Neanderthals & humans interbred

Schrodinger's Cat

Unregistered
Joined
Feb 11, 2010
Messages
3,456
For years, one of the biggest debates in physical anthropology has been whether or not neandertals and humans interbred. But a new article in Science magazine discusses how gene sequencing from neandertals shows that they DID in fact interbreed, and that "Eurasian humans inherited a small amount, about 1-4%, of their genes from the extinct sibling species."

here's a link to the science magazine page:'

http://www.sciencemag.org/special/neandertal/feature/index.html

as well as a summation of findings from USA today:

http://www.usatoday.com/tech/science/discoveries/2010-05-06-neanderthal07_ST_N.htm

The science website is great and has a lot of information and interactive features.

I look forward to National Geographic magazine's coverage of this story.
 
Really appreciated you posting this Cat. Saved me the time of Googling for these links, which I will post elsewhere and credit you as the source. Thanks! :)

I heard about this on the BBC this afternoon, and have long awaited such verification for the claims of Milford Wolpoff over 2 decades ago. In his Race and Human Evolution, he made a very convincing argument for interbreeding between our ancestors and neandertals, though it was rejected by most paleoanthropoligists for many years after. Certainly this isn't a field for those looking for quick proofs.
 
Either spelling and either pronunciation --Neanderthal or Neandertal -- is correct.

This study appears to corroborate the mainstream opinion on the question, and provides a welcome, and hopefully definitive, conclusion after decades of speculation.
 
This is a rather small change in the expectation of neadertal influence on sapiens (from 0 to 1-3% of Eurasians), but the difference is rather earth shaking, especially on what it will do on the lunatic fringe, which already believes in huge neadertal genetic contributions in Germans (one theory I heard of), for instance. It's easier to just tell them that they are simply mistaken, but, of course, the truth is the truth, and science grows.

It is very interesting, and from my point of view, sort of welcome. I think we all need some red-headed genes in our background. :D
 
This study appears to corroborate the mainstream opinion on the question, and provides a welcome, and hopefully definitive, conclusion after decades of speculation.

Maybe, and maybe not. There still is another 40% of their genome to be pieced together and mapped; further surprises are possibler.
 
Hmmm, 1-4% seems like a very significant contribution, isn't it? Since all humans are only about 1% different?
 
Hmmm, 1-4% seems like a very significant contribution, isn't it? Since all humans are only about 1% different?

No, this isn't a percentage of DNA. This is the percentage of the population that has (some amount? of) the neandertal genes.
 
No, this isn't a percentage of DNA. This is the percentage of the population that has (some amount? of) the neandertal genes.

It's neither a percentage of DNA, or of population. It's "an average 1% to 4% of their genes".
 
That must have led to some awkward moments as Thorg introduced his new girlfriend in the local pub.
 
That must have led to some awkward moments as Thorg introduced his new girlfriend in the local pub.
I was tempted to say that this finding explains New Zealanders, but thought better about making such an uncharitable remark.
 
There may be a hundred named authors of that paper, but I am proud to say my father is one of them :)
 
Neanderthal Cro Magnon interbreeding

http://my.att.net/s/editorial.dll?b...atid=0&eetype=article&render=y&ac=0&ck=&ch=ne

Ok this scientist says we did. On the science channel the scientists said we didn't. After seeing reconstructions of Neanderthal women I can see why we didn't but perhaps on occassion some Cro magnon hunters would have sex with a Neanderthal woman in exchange for food or whatever just to be macho. I thought the genetic differences were too great for any interbreeding?
 
That is very cool.

Because I don't know enough about DNA research and genes and so forth, I'll ask a dumb question.

Is there a way to know yet what contributions these Neandertal genes made? In other words, were Eurasian humans taller, shorter, stronger, weaker, disease resistant, etc. (probably in some extremely subtle ways) because they had these genes?

I'm curious what difference there would be in a person with 1-4% of these genes, compared to a person who had none. What would we have been like if our distance ancestors hadn't interbred?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom