Neanderthals & humans interbred

So, so far,

We have Homo sapiens arising in Africa, modern African races are largely descended from this stock and show no neanderthal influence - they're pure H. sapiens. A few lineages left Africa and fairly early on crossbred with H. neanderthalensis, producing a bunch of neanderthal half-breeds from which the rest of humanity is descended. And in the process they picked up genes which made their brains bigger than the pure H. sapiens lineages.

Is it just me, or is this likely to upset ... just about everybody?
I'm ignorant of all of this ..... but is this an accurate summary? And the only thing I would assume just from the links and this thread is that "half-breed" is a misnomer. I'm understanding that the Neanderthal genes were "breed out" to where their influence became nill. Correct?
 
So finally we have an answer as to how Neanderthal managed to hang on in the area of our largest dispersal from Africa without us wiping them out immediately. I always wondered at that. Surely if it was us that wiped out Neanderthal the last place they were known to exist should have been the first place they became extinct in. So they survived through cooperation with the newcomers while the rest of the Neanderthals in Eurasia became extinct without our presence.
:D
awesome
 
I'm ignorant of all of this ..... but is this an accurate summary? And the only thing I would assume just from the links and this thread is that "half-breed" is a misnomer. I'm understanding that the Neanderthal genes were "breed out" to where their influence became nill. Correct?

Genetics doesnt work like that, we picked up a few new genes that assisted our survival from a close sub species that had developed them over a long period. In effect it was a leg up for us. A genetic short cut that made us more fit to survive in the new harsh conditions, no one as of yet can say what these genes did as far as I know. Half breed is definitely a misnomer. I would imagine the cultural exchange was also more than helpful. New weapons, new clothes and hmmm, new types of lice.
http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/tag/neanderthals/
Armed with little direct evidence, scientists had previously estimated that clothing originated anywhere from around 1 million to 40,000 years ago.
An earlier analysis of mitochondrial DNA from the two modern types of lice indicated that body lice evolved from head lice only about 70,000 years ago. Because body lice thrive in the folds of clothing, they likely appeared not long after clothes were invented, many scientists believe.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neanderthal
The first proto-Neanderthal traits appeared in Europe as early as 600,000–350,000 years ago. Current (as of 2010) genetic evidence suggests interbreeding took place with Homo sapiens during the period of some 80,000 to 50,000 years ago, and it is now believed that humans of Eurasian descent are anywhere between 1% and 4% Neanderthal.
So Neanderthals invented clothing that supported lice populations, whereas when we lived in sunny africa such clothing was unneccesary and then when we met, we took their clothing technology and the lice came for free

;)
 
Last edited:
So Neanderthals invented clothing that supported lice populations, whereas when we lived in sunny africa such clothing was unneccesary and then when we met, we took their clothing technology and the lice came for free

;)
Same ****, different day:

The population of Old World peoples in the Americas grew steadily, while the number of the indigenous people plummeted. Old World diseases such as smallpox, influenza, bubonic plague and pneumonic plagues devastated the previously isolated Native Americans. Conflict and outright warfare with European newcomers and other American tribes reduced populations and disrupted traditional society. The extent and causes of the decline have long been a subject of academic debate, along with its possible characterization as a genocide or democide.

In one disputed incident, British soldiers in North America were said to have discussed intentionally infecting native people as part of a war effort. During Pontiac's Rebellion in 1763, a number of Native Americans launched a widespread war against British soldiers and settlers to drive the British out of the Great Lakes region. In what is now western Pennsylvania, Native Americans (primarily Delawares) laid siege to Fort Pitt on June 22, 1763. Surrounded and isolated, William Trent, the commander of Fort Pitt gave representatives of the besieging Delawares two blankets and a handkerchief from the Pittsburgh smallpox hospital, "out of our regard to them", when the two Delaware men came to talk to him.[22] Letters exist between two other British officers, Jeffrey Amherst and Henry Bouquet, that explicitly advocate the idea of using smallpox-infested blankets to kill Indians.[22] Historians disagree as to whether Trent acted with the intent expressed by Bouquet and Amherst.

Whatever Trent's intent, a number of recent scholars consider doubtful the evidence connecting his gift of blankets to the smallpox outbreak. These scholars believe that the disease was most likely spread by native warriors returning from attacks on infected white settlements.[23] In other words, while some officers expressed the desire to use biological warfare, smallpox was so widespread and so easy to catch that there were other opportunities for Native Americans to be infected.
Rule of thumb ---- keep fashion trends to yourself.
 
That seems like a pretty bold assumption. What sort of "cooperation" are you picturing here?

Neanderthal extinction rest of world 60,000bce
Neanderthal extinction in heavily occupied near east homo sapiens territory 30,000bce

do the math
:p

and what type of cooperation ?
dude, between 1 and 4% of our entire genetic make up is directly inherited from the Neanderthals, that didn't happen from sticking it up each others poopers
:D
 
Last edited:
As I understand it, the only population of modern humans now known to have bred with neanderthals was the one that left Africa via the Middle East and went on to populate Eurasia and Australasia. Neanderthal genes are not present in humans from sub-Saharan Africa, so I suppose the answer to your question is: 'not much'.
(bold added)

I think this part is wrong.

There were several, independent, 'out of Africa' migrations of H. sapiens.

At least one of those migrations seems to have taken a 'coastal' route around the (southern) shores of Asia (those shores are now under several dozen - hundred? - metres of water); the living descendants of those migrants include the Australian aborigines (well, some of them; there may have been several later migrations into Australia) and natives of the Andaman Islands.

Perhaps some future forensic genetics might turn up Neaderthal genes in these southern, early migrants, which would make the case curiouser, more complicated, and interesting.

New Zealand? Nah, the natives there come from what we today call East Asia, Taiwan to be exact.
 
I'm not buying it. They've got no way to define some genes as human genes and some as Neanderthal genes, the amount of our DNA that they're claiming is from Neanderthals is greater than the amount that has previously been said to vary between one modern human race and another, and a handful of earlier genetic studies contradict it, including not only a direct comparison between the two groups but also some assessments of the modern population's diversity which found that we lack genes dating back to within the right time frame.
You're right about the bolded part, since Neanderthals are humans.

There is a difference between modern "races" of a certain percent. There is also a difference between an average representative of modern humans and Neanderthals. What's the problem? If blacks have no Neanderthal and all other races do, that accounts for some of the difference between modern "races", no?
 
(bold added)

I think this part is wrong.

There were several, independent, 'out of Africa' migrations of H. sapiens.

At least one of those migrations seems to have taken a 'coastal' route around the (southern) shores of Asia (those shores are now under several dozen - hundred? - metres of water); the living descendants of those migrants include the Australian aborigines (well, some of them; there may have been several later migrations into Australia) and natives of the Andaman Islands.

Perhaps some future forensic genetics might turn up Neaderthal genes in these southern, early migrants, which would make the case curiouser, more complicated, and interesting.

New Zealand? Nah, the natives there come from what we today call East Asia, Taiwan to be exact.
Wouldn't it be awesome if it turned out that the migration happened out of Australia? A large segment went to Africa, a smaller segment went to east Asia, and then everything else came out of Africa later?
 
If blacks have no Neanderthal and all other races do, that accounts for some of the difference between modern "races", no?

Not really, the largest genetic variance between two groups of humans is between east and west Africans which represents the longest split since uniformity.

The modern races for all intents and purposes don't actually exist and the small differences that you are probably remarking on is caused by just a handful of genes. Take the light colouration of European skin, this is caused by a single gene (SLC24A5) which is responsible for between 25 and 38% of skin pigmentation variation between Black African and White European humans. There is only one race of humans on this planet
Us
;)
 
...this study states 1-4% of Eurasian DNA comes from Neandertals. ....
this study say that Eurasians inherited 1-4% of their genes from neandertals.


You seem to be confusing % of genes and % of DNA. They are not the same thing, and very unlikely to produce identical figures.
 
I'm ignorant of all of this ..... but is this an accurate summary? And the only thing I would assume just from the links and this thread is that "half-breed" is a misnomer. I'm understanding that the Neanderthal genes were "breed out" to where their influence became nill. Correct?

Why do you think it's a misnomer? In what way do the individuals described not fit the definition?
 
Trent Wray said:
And the only thing I would assume just from the links and this thread is that "half-breed" is a misnomer. I'm understanding that the Neanderthal genes were "breed out" to where their influence became nill. Correct?
Why do you think it's a misnomer? In what way do the individuals described not fit the definition?

Well, it is true that they're not exactly "half-breed" since their ancestry is less than half Neandertal, but in the spirit of trying "to upset ... just about everybody" as sphenisc wrote, we clearly need a one drop rule concerning Neandertals.
 
Well, it is true that they're not exactly "half-breed" since their ancestry is less than half Neandertal, but in the spirit of trying "to upset ... just about everybody" as sphenisc wrote, we clearly need a one drop rule concerning Neandertals.

Clearly my original post has been misread, the individuals I called half-breeds were half neanderthal.
 
That seems like a pretty bold assumption. What sort of "cooperation" are you picturing here?
I picture Cro Magnon and Neanderthals hunting together and sharing food and mates. We learned from the Neanderthals and they learned from us.. We had the technology and they had the brawn. I picture a neanderthal as the perfect bodyguard.

I think there would have ben more interbreeding had the neanderthals been more attractive. Their facial features and primitive ways were probably a turnoff even in those ancient days.
 
(bold added)

I think this part is wrong.

There were several, independent, 'out of Africa' migrations of H. sapiens.

At least one of those migrations seems to have taken a 'coastal' route around the (southern) shores of Asia (those shores are now under several dozen - hundred? - metres of water); the living descendants of those migrants include the Australian aborigines (well, some of them; there may have been several later migrations into Australia) and natives of the Andaman Islands.

Perhaps some future forensic genetics might turn up Neaderthal genes in these southern, early migrants, which would make the case curiouser, more complicated, and interesting.

New Zealand? Nah, the natives there come from what we today call East Asia, Taiwan to be exact.

Hi DRD, what evidence is there for dispersal that is separated enough in time to warrant a multiple migration model?

In the case of the Bering land bridge there is a clear period of time where humans were able to easily use small boats to traverse the Bering land bridge, so that is one clear event. Apart from the artic people who used living on the ice sheet.

So while there are obviously many times at which homo sapiens sapiens would have migrated out of Africa the dispersal rates are considered to be almost continuous and contiguous. The rate of distribution seems to have been fairly even. Some anthropologists have theorized for a long time that the ice sheets are what provided geographic separation and allowed for the separation of homo sapiens neanderthalis from homo sapiens sapiens in Europe. In the middle east there are samples that are morphologically mixed through ~150,000 BP, and the dates for the arising of gracile homo sapiens (with the cranial vault and lack of eye ridges and the occipital bump) vary around ~80,000 BP.

The dispersal of gracile homo sap sapienes seems to have been wide spread and continuous in terms of migration. With the biggest leap having been to Australia at around ~40,000 BP although that is a somewhat controversial date, and many exist.

For everyone in the thread:

Homo sapiens is the genus name.

Homo sapiens sapiens is the species name as is Homo sapiens neanderthalis.
 
I picture Cro Magnon and Neanderthals hunting together and sharing food and mates. We learned from the Neanderthals and they learned from us.. We had the technology and they had the brawn. I picture a neanderthal as the perfect bodyguard.

I think there would have ben more interbreeding had the neanderthals been more attractive. Their facial features and primitive ways were probably a turnoff even in those ancient days.

Considering that most humans don't need beer goggles to have sex with unattractive people that seems unlikely.
 
I picture Cro Magnon and Neanderthals hunting together and sharing food and mates. We learned from the Neanderthals and they learned from us.. We had the technology and they had the brawn. I picture a neanderthal as the perfect bodyguard.

Cro Magnon was just that community of homo sapiens that were the first into Europe around 35,000 years ago. The term is often confused amongst non professionals as a seperate species. Thesedays scientifically they are referred to as "European Early Modern Humans" (or EEMH), instead of "Cro-Magnon".

;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom