Neanderthals & humans interbred

By the way, prehistoric humans tried to interbreed with gorillas too. Here is proof. The hair lice that human beings have mostly in their scalp is different from the lice human beings sometimes have in their personal regions. Yet this is the same lice that gorillas have all over their bodies. We have to have gotten it from trying to mate with gorillas eons ago.

If I was to bet, I would say that mixing with the neanderthals was not their idea.

I don't see that as being absolute proof. Isn't it equally plausible that the humans killed the gorilla and the lice jumped ship while the gorilla was being butchered?

Or maybe the human sat on a toilet seat recently occupied by an infected gorilla.
 
Why do you think it's a misnomer? In what way do the individuals described not fit the definition?
Sorry I had forgotten to check up on my few posts in this thread.

I was assuming it was a misnomer due to the way I was interpreting what you were trying to convey by "halfbreed", as were some of the other posters. No worries though.

---------------

So is there any way to tell what cognitive consequences would result from interbreeding with the N's? ;) Obviously there will be physical attributes / characteristics ...
 
Last edited:
I wonder how they can tell the difference between identical genes because we share a common ancestor and genes because of interbreeding.

A clue: they aren't identical. They differ in non-functional stretches of the proteins, indicating difference s in the genes. This is a common way to track genes and genetic history; there is a long history of using the protein cytochrome C - it is estimated that there are more possible varieties of cytochrome C than there have ever been individuals on Earth, from bacteria to us.

By the way, prehistoric humans tried to interbreed with gorillas too. Here is proof. The hair lice that human beings have mostly in their scalp is different from the lice human beings sometimes have in their personal regions. Yet this is the same lice that gorillas have all over their bodies. We have to have gotten it from trying to mate with gorillas eons ago.

That's a pretty long, not to say salacious, step in logic there. All the scientists say is that the lice are the same. It isn't like lice can't move on their own.

If I was to bet, I would say that mixing with the neanderthals was not their idea.

Bill, animals have been doing it for at least 2.5 billion years. You mean they couldn't find a priest to make it all cool? What is it with the air from Puget Sound?

You can say that some wimpy Cro-Magnon might be man enough? http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencet...The-face-Neanderthal-woman-revealed-time.html
 
Apparently the news media left out the conclusions from the studies which suggested there were alternative explanations for the findings. Interbreeding was one of several possible explanations.

Ancient Sex Scandals: Did We Get It On With Neandertals?

So, the blogger is decrying the tendency to look at the salacious, after using that title line? :)

Science Blogs are your friends. :D

OK, I'll bite - so what exactly are the other mechanisms that can explain how genes that match the Neandertal genome (I assume) made it into the sapiens genome? Could it be that they didn't mix, but that they are the same by coincidence? I presume we were separated long enough to have encountered, separately, some amount of marker mutation that would make it unlikely? Was it Bill's lice? Was it some kind of genius virus, or a parallel transfer across a commonly used spear? What other possibilities are there besides "getting it on"?
 
So, the blogger is decrying the tendency to look at the salacious, after using that title line? :)



OK, I'll bite - so what exactly are the other mechanisms that can explain how genes that match the Neandertal genome (I assume) made it into the sapiens genome? Could it be that they didn't mix, but that they are the same by coincidence? I presume we were separated long enough to have encountered, separately, some amount of marker mutation that would make it unlikely? Was it Bill's lice? Was it some kind of genius virus, or a parallel transfer across a commonly used spear? What other possibilities are there besides "getting it on"?
The answer is obvious .... both Neanderthals and sapiens were banging gorillas. Either that, or copulating with lice. :confused:
 
I read (for the first time - don't know how I missed it) the Nat Geo article that leads on from the Wilma description. It is very interesting and said several things I hadn't known.

The article came out in last month, in April. It was therefore written a couple of months ago, before this latest news aqbout Neadertals becomae known. The purveyor of the news, Paablo Svante, is also the person who, several yaers back, is the one that did a the initial study on Neadertal mDNA and declared the Neandertal and sapiens had been totally separated for 700,000 years. So we don't apparently have a difference of opinion here, but rather a shift due to increases in evidence.

The article highlights a group of nine Neandertal individuals in a cave in Spain. They were apparently killed and eaten by other humans - the arm bones and skulls were cracked open violently. Soon after the feast the ground they were left on collapsed into the cavern below, burying the bones before the scavengers could get them. They died 43,000 years ago, while they were in the process of being squeezed against the Med by approaching glaciers and cold weather.

http://ngm.nationalgeographic.com/2008/10/neanderthals/hall-text
 
The answer is obvious .... both Neanderthals and sapiens were banging gorillas. Either that, or copulating with lice. :confused:

I guess it really comes down to who was putting the bite on whom. A three-way that only a louse could love. Etc, etc, adn.
 
...

OK, I'll bite - so what exactly are the other mechanisms that can explain how genes that match the Neandertal genome (I assume) made it into the sapiens genome? ...
The 'blogger' cited this piece from this blogger in Discover magazine:
While working on this post, I contacted two experts who have been critical of some earlier studies on hominin interbreeding, Laurence Excoffier of the University of Bern and Nick Barton of the University of Edinburgh. Both scientist gave the Neanderthal genome paper high marks and agree in particular that the interbreeding hypothesis is a good one. But they do think some alternative hypotheses have to be tested. For example, interbreeding is not the only way that some living humans might have ended up with Neanderthal-like pieces of DNA. Cast your mind back 500,000 years, before the populations of humans and Neanderthals had diverged. Imagine that those ancestral Africans were not trading genes freely. Instead imagine that some kind of barrier emerged to keep some gene variants in one part of Africa and other variants in another part.
Now imagine that the ancestors of Neanderthals leave Africa, and then much later the ancestors of Europeans and Asians leave Africa. It’s possible that both sets of immigrants came from the same part of Africa. They might have both taken some gene variants with them did not exist in other parts of Africa. Today, some living Africans still lack those variants. This scenario could lead to Europeans and Asians with Neanderthal-like pieces of DNA without a single hybrid baby ever being born.

Science Blogs is a network of exchange of scientific information by way of the blogger system of information exchange.
 
Auel.

There did seem to be a lot going on sexually in those books.
No TV back then of course.

There's a potential in this finding for racism- isn't there always? - but it's one I'll find amusing to watch for.
If Africans are indeed the "pure racial stock" and we Euro-white-trash are the byblows of a few drunken hunting parties, I wonder who will be keener to sweep the whole sordid business under the cave carpet?
 
Amid all the debate, just wanted to interject that isn't it wonderful how much we have come to understand genetics, and how much more we will continue to discover? It just has so many implications not only in terms of improving human health, but in helping us try to understand the world around us, and ourselves.


Did anyone see the short national geographic article this month which talked about efforts to create a catalog of genetic barcodes for species? They talk about it on their website as well

http://blogs.nationalgeographic.com/blogs/admin/mt-search.cgi?tag=STRs&blog_id=48

Interesting stuff!
 
...the story of a cave bear named "Clanof"?
Well, there was no Paddington back then either.
They're actually quite well researched books, albeit wildly speculative and a bit silly. Two people, who happen to be sort of Aryan blue-eyed blondes, basically create medecine, agriculture and the military-industrial complex between them, while having loads of graphically described nookie every fifty pages.
I've read worse.:D
 
I guess it really comes down to who was putting the bite on whom. A three-way that only a louse could love. Etc, etc, adn.

Speculation: Those lice may have also migrated from killed Gorillas. From what I remember lice tend to migrate rather fast from dead hosts. What if they went from dead Gorilla to sufficiently close live hunter?
 
Speculation: Those lice may have also migrated from killed Gorillas. From what I remember lice tend to migrate rather fast from dead hosts. What if they went from dead Gorilla to sufficiently close live hunter?

...or dropped on them from trees after a nectar break, or they infested a frisky sheep, or came from USPS in a package with stick-on stamps and a pencilled in address, or were caught from the fallout of a bug-bomb. All perfectly valid theories. Trent just likes it the traditional, churchy way.

[PS: for those slow on the uptake, it is obvious that we need not have tried to rape a gorilla in order to have contracted lice from them, even public hair lice, should some of those lice have been so inclined. Lice, over time, are pretty non-discriminatory.]
 
That's a racist slur!
Lice are fine, upstanding arthropods.
Not their fault if you don't scrub hard enough.
 
...the story of a cave bear named "Clanof"?
:):)I blame the screen reader for making it sound as if I'd put in the space!
Well, there was no Paddington back then either.
They're actually quite well researched books, albeit wildly speculative and a bit silly. Two people, who happen to be sort of Aryan blue-eyed blondes, basically create medecine, agriculture and the military-industrial complex between them, while having loads of graphically described nookie every fifty pages.
I've read worse.:D
Yes!! But in the first book she had to mate with the neanderthal type and produced a son, whose name I forget. I started listening to the last book, but quickly gave up, dipped in here and there and at the very end.
 
:):)I blame the screen reader for making it sound as if I'd put in the space!

Yes!! But in the first book she had to mate with the neanderthal type and produced a son, whose name I forget. I started listening to the last book, but quickly gave up, dipped in here and there and at the very end.

Dag? Dog? Doug? Something like that? I don't have the novels to check.

Palaeoanthropology has moved on a lot since the first book, but Auel did her research at the time. I understand she's working on at least one more in the series. The explanations of people's names and roles gets a bit tedious in the later stories - and Jondalar and Ayla between them seem to be well on the way to inventing the Dewey Decimal System and geostationary satellites. It's kinda hokey, but fun!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom