Neanderthals & humans interbred

Clearly my original post has been misread, the individuals I called half-breeds were half neanderthal.

Yep, I read it again, you said it very plainly. We're descended from the true one-half-breeds. Don't know how I misread that.

I still love your original post, though, because it's so true. As the new information stands now, it really does kinda shake things up.
 
This quote made me chuckle
Professor Svante Paabo Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology said:
Neanderthals are not totally extinct, in some of us they live on - a little bit

All that brain power and no access to a dictionary
:D
 
Hi DRD, what evidence is there for dispersal that is separated enough in time to warrant a multiple migration model?
It's pretty well-established, I think, and comes from genetic anthropology. In a nutshell, the conclusions rest on detailed analyses of the distributions of human haplotypes. I came across this first in a book whose name I no longer recall, but the ideas are outlined in this webpage.

In the case of the Bering land bridge there is a clear period of time where humans were able to easily use small boats to traverse the Bering land bridge, so that is one clear event. Apart from the artic people who used living on the ice sheet.

So while there are obviously many times at which homo sapiens sapiens would have migrated out of Africa the dispersal rates are considered to be almost continuous and contiguous. The rate of distribution seems to have been fairly even. Some anthropologists have theorized for a long time that the ice sheets are what provided geographic separation and allowed for the separation of homo sapiens neanderthalis from homo sapiens sapiens in Europe. In the middle east there are samples that are morphologically mixed through ~150,000 BP, and the dates for the arising of gracile homo sapiens (with the cranial vault and lack of eye ridges and the occipital bump) vary around ~80,000 BP.

The dispersal of gracile homo sap sapienes seems to have been wide spread and continuous in terms of migration. With the biggest leap having been to Australia at around ~40,000 BP although that is a somewhat controversial date, and many exist.
I think it's fair to say that the physical anthropological data is not sufficiently fine-grained to tell whether migrations were discontinuous, and if so, how many there were.

For everyone in the thread:

Homo sapiens is the genus name.

Homo sapiens sapiens is the species name as is Homo sapiens neanderthalis.
This is, yet again, a good example of the limitations of the current taxonomic conventions.

Even for animals the definition of a species - based on infertile interbreeding, ultimately - is shaky (check out ring species, for example); for plants - where quite distinct species (judged by traditional, as well as genetic, markers) often produce very viable hybrids - it's considerably more problematic.
 
It's pretty well-established, I think, and comes from genetic anthropology. In a nutshell, the conclusions rest on detailed analyses of the distributions of human haplotypes. I came across this first in a book whose name I no longer recall, but the ideas are outlined in this webpage.
Sure:
There is also the error of deriving dispersion from surviving genomes solely, there has to be multiple tracks and unfortunately most technologies fade away at 14,000 BP due to preservation.

I will have to read more of the supporting research there are some rather broad and unsupported claims on that particular page:
The first modern humans to leave Africa about 120,000 years ago, during a interglacial optimum, went into the Levant but disappeared by 90,000 years ago when this area became a desert.
That is rather broad, as there is no particular reason to assign 'modern' humans a status of 120,000BP, it is possible but that is not the best way to state it in the least.

The best evidence and it is rather scant is 80,000 BP, more that is still very sparse at 60,000 BP.

I will have to check but I do not think that there is any consensus that modern homo sapiens sapiens diverged at 120,000 BP, again the data is rather inconclusive and that is a very broad statement and not very carefully couched.
[/quote]


I think it's fair to say that the physical anthropological data is not sufficiently fine-grained to tell whether migrations were discontinuous, and if so, how many there were.
[/quote]
Exactly, so the 'second migration' does seem to be related to ice age maxima and minima. And it may also be related to what?
Survival of humans using domestication and proto agriculture as opposed to actual migration, so it could be a mix of technology spearding out of north africa, where some belief agriculture developed.

So the 'wave' out of africa may represent less of a migration and more the dominance of survival in agricultural societies. Which are interelated.

I have to read the sources to see how great that divergence is as well.
This is, yet again, a good example of the limitations of the current taxonomic conventions.

Even for animals the definition of a species - based on infertile interbreeding, ultimately - is shaky (check out ring species, for example); for plants - where quite distinct species (judged by traditional, as well as genetic, markers) often produce very viable hybrids - it's considerably more problematic.


Oh sure, I was being pedantic for sure.


But people currently should refer to
sapiens sapiens and sapiens neanderthalis
rather than
homo sapiens and homo neanderthalis.

Time will tell, as more samples are found and analyzed, we also have to be very carfeul drawing conclusions for less than twenty type samples as well. When the samples get up into the hundreds the confidence levels will rise. I have to check but i am fairly certain we are talking about less than twenty of neanderthalis. (For DNA sequence)
 
This quote made me chuckle
Professor Svante Paabo Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology said:
Neanderthals are not totally extinct, in some of us they live on - a little bit
All that brain power and no access to a dictionary
:D

What would a dictionary have told him?
 
Wouldn't it be awesome if it turned out that the migration happened out of Australia? A large segment went to Africa, a smaller segment went to east Asia, and then everything else came out of Africa later?

Spencer Wells has demonstrated in the Genographic Project that haplogroup L is present in Africa, India and Australia. In addition, haplogroup M is always present with L everywhere except for some of Africa. That demonstrates that the earlier L occurred in Africa alone, and the later M occurred within the subgroup that later sent a part of itself to Australia. All aborigiinal Australians have L and M. There is collateral archaeological evidence that man didn't see Australia until about 70,000 years ago.
 
For everyone in the thread:

Homo sapiens is the genus name.

Homo sapiens sapiens is the species name as is Homo sapiens neanderthalis.

I've never seen these definitions before. According wiki and other sources I've used (tolweb.org for one) the binomial nomenclatureWP defines a species, while the trinomenWP defines a subspecies. Neadertal manWP was long thought to have been a subspecies of sapiens, but has more lately been recognized as a separate species, Homo neandertalensis.

Note that such a designation does not rule out interbreeding between sapiens and neadertalensis. It simply says that they did not interbreed for an interval. When a later removal of a geographic barrier (or perhaps social/behavioral barrier) between them, they could, to at least a small extent, interbreed then. Such a thing could happen if, for example, camels and llamas, obviously now separate species, for some reason began occupying a common geographical area. The camaWP has proven that there is not (yet) a biological barrier.
 
Last edited:
What would a dictionary have told him?

That being extinct means you don't live on. The word itself is derived from the latin word for "dying out", "extinctus" and was originally coined to describe what happens to a fire when you put water on it.

btw, youre a towel
:D
 
Last edited:
I think there would have ben more interbreeding had the neanderthals been more attractive. Their facial features and primitive ways were probably a turnoff even in those ancient days.

That's one heck of a lot of projection of your inclinations on those poor innocent "savages". I imagine that our learned sexual gaming played a lot less of a large part of their lives than they do for moderns.
 
But people currently should refer to
sapiens sapiens and sapiens neanderthalis
rather than
homo sapiens and homo neanderthalis.

The one is no more applicable than the other. As it states in sphensic's reference, anthro students are moving to specieshood for neandertalensis, if only to give it what they consider the proper emphasis in cultural studies. At any rate, the two are at least equally acceptable. I've seen Homo neaderlalensis in a large number of formal papers.

Time will tell, as more samples are found and analyzed, we also have to be very careful drawing conclusions for less than twenty type samples as well. When the samples get up into the hundreds the confidence levels will rise. I have to check but i am fairly certain we are talking about less than twenty of neanderthalis. (For DNA sequence)
For DNA sequencing, there are samples from five individuals. I think there may be as many as 50 neandertal individuals identified, including those in Iran and the Caucasus.
 
Last edited:
I've never seen these definitions before. According wiki and other sources I've used (tolweb.org for one) the binomial nomenclatureWP defines a species, while the trinomenWP defines a subspecies. Neadertal manWP was long thought to have been a subspecies of sapiens, but has more lately been recognized as a separate species, Homo neandertalensis.

I wondered about that too.

There are subgenuses, but for animals, I thought it would be: Genus (subgenus) species. So a three-rank name without parentheses would be Genus species subspecies.

So isn't Homo always the genus? Sapiens or neadertalensis would either be referring to the species or subspecies, depending on whether it's immediately after Homo or the third word of the name.
 
I wondered about that too.

There are subgenuses, but for animals, I thought it would be: Genus (subgenus) species. So a three-rank name without parentheses would be Genus species subspecies.

So isn't Homo always the genus? Sapiens or neadertalensis would either be referring to the species or subspecies, depending on whether it's immediately after Homo or the third word of the name.

A subgenus is just another class rung, like subfamily or supraclass or infraorder. Biology is trying to shake all that 7 layer-stuff off, leaving only species and clade as valid categories.

Yes, Homo is a genus - AFAIK, you have it right.
 
This Wikipedia page gives a bit more detail on early human migrations, and lots of references. It's not a field (of science) I am particularly familiar with, so I cannot say what size the grain of salt you need is.

The main evidence listed here seems to be from mitochondrial haplogroups; I'm pretty sure similar studies have been done with Y chromosome haplogroups, and that they are broadly consistent with the early divergence of the ancestors of Australian aborigines (at least the first such) and ancestors of today's Europeans (well, the first H. sapiens migrants into Europe anyway, or at least the ones which left ancestors alive today), either in East Africa (modern day Ethiopia or Eritrea) of Middle East.
 
Last edited:
If modern HSS is 1-4% HSN, just how much different was there between the pre-interbreeding sub-species anyhow? We must have been about 98% genetically similar to even interbreed. So, the 1-4% figure sounds like plenty to make a full-Neanderthal. One in a billion means dozens out there now?

Based on that guesstimation, it is entirely possible that we can currently make a throw-back, an entirely Neanderthal. That would explain my brother.;) Or, seriously, another pair of siblings that I know. The Mom and Dad appear normal, Dad is an engineer. The sons are both tall, hairy, broad nose, deep voice, and last I heard residing in the Patton State Mental Hospital for the Criminally Insane. Rape and other Violence.
 
Rape and other Violence.

I've been wondering why so many are assuming that the interbreeding means cooperation between Hss and Hsn. Maybe it's similar to why we assume that extraterrestrials will be friendly and benevolent. Just as likely is that there was a little angry love making between the tribes.

Or let's assume that the interbreeding was mostly consensual. Is it really a stretch to imagine a physical attraction between a female Hss and a male Hsn? If the male Hsn was brutish maybe that was a turn-on for the female Hss. You see plenty of such pairings in modern society, ugly guy + beautiful woman. Not so much the other way around though. Brutish looking females are seldom much of a turn-on for males of the sp. So I'm wondering if the genetic evidence can indicate whether there was a gender specific factor contributing to the mixing.
 
Or let's assume that the interbreeding was mostly consensual. Is it really a stretch to imagine a physical attraction between a female Hss and a male Hsn? If the male Hsn was brutish maybe that was a turn-on for the female Hss. You see plenty of such pairings in modern society, ugly guy + beautiful woman. Not so much the other way around though. Brutish looking females are seldom much of a turn-on for males of the sp. So I'm wondering if the genetic evidence can indicate whether there was a gender specific factor contributing to the mixing.

I think youre falling into the trap there of judging a different culture by your own cultural standards. If you take a look at some of the earliest female figurines produced by Homo Sapiens the first thing you'll notice is that they aren't catwalk models
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venus_figurines
A more primitve society is more likely to think wide hips and large pendulous breasts are beautiful than an attractive face, the former will propogate the species by assisting childbirth, the latter gives no such evolutionary advantage.

When it comes down to it, imagining that our distant ancestors would be attracted to the gracile female form is to forget that about 90% of our own ancestors were by our own standards pretty awful looking women. Black teeth, body odour, skin disease, high infant mortality, venerial diseases, poor education. Would you date someone like that ?

Most of your ancestors did
:D
 
The Neanderthal side, no doubt. ;)

I was talking about the women of the last few hundred years. By comparison to our own, Neanderthal women were extremely healthy and well adapted to their environment.

;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom