Multiple police shot in Dallas protest

My point is they should not have those options. A deadly force situation should compel the use of deadly force. If there is an option to negotiate, simply reaching a limit on willingness to negotiate shouldn't matter.

Now, if someone suggests the situation legitimately changed,that would matter.

It did change. They went from negotiating to realizing that negotiating wasn't going to work, after the perp laughed, asked how many he got, started singing, asked if he was going to have a chance to get more.... etc..etc..etc...

Those delicate conversations take time.
 
It did change. They went from negotiating to realizing that negotiating wasn't going to work, after the perp laughed, asked how many he got, started singing, asked if he was going to have a chance to get more.... etc..etc..etc...

Those delicate conversations take time.

That should have zero impact on the deadly force decision making.
 
It did change. They went from negotiating to realizing that negotiating wasn't going to work, after the perp laughed, asked how many he got, started singing, asked if he was going to have a chance to get more.... etc..etc..etc...

Those delicate conversations take time.

Were they allowed to kill him while he was still negotiating?
 
I don't see the debate over using a bomb to kill the shooter as showing sympathy for the murderer. I see it as a question of the police deciding they can act as judge, jury, and executioner after only a brief (two hour) standoff.

I don't get that. If they had shot him dead, would we be having this discussion? Would they not have "acted as judge, jury and executioner"? What's so different now? And how long do cops have to wait while people are shooting at them before they respond in kind?
 
I have no sympathy for the dead sniper. According to what has been reported, he wasn't going to stop until he was dead and he was still a danger.
I find using a bomb a bit unnerving. Now that the precedent has been set, using bombs in the future will be all that much easier. A line has been crossed and I am not sure I am comfortable with it.

That is a very good answer to my previous post. Thank you.
 
"Allowed"? I dunno. Probably. It's up to the Chief, not me.

Except that it is not. Deadly force has an objective reasonableness standard and an immediate danger requirement.

If they can go an hour and a half, then a other 15, I call into question their whole sense of immediate danger. They are not using deadly force to stop an immediate threat, they are keeping deadly force ready to use at their leisure.
 
I don't get that. If they had shot him dead, would we be having this discussion? Would they not have "acted as judge, jury and executioner"? What's so different now? And how long do cops have to wait while people are shooting at them before they respond in kind?

How long do cops have to wait?

Deadly force situations normally don't permit waiting. The fact they can wait at all brings their judgement of deadly force into question.
 
I have no sympathy for the dead sniper. According to what has been reported, he wasn't going to stop until he was dead and he was still a danger.
I find using a bomb a bit unnerving. Now that the precedent has been set, using bombs in the future will be all that much easier. A line has been crossed and I am not sure I am comfortable with it. As has been said, dead is dead and the end result would be the same with several different methods. This action was very personal for the police involved and it is possible other solutions were overlooked. I don't know.

Hopefully it will be reviewed by other parties with less personal attachment.

The mobile bomb was a method of ending the threat without providing the shooter the opportunity to realize his one and only goal of increasing his bodycount. It was an intelligent tactic.
 
That should have zero impact on the deadly force decision making.

I'm sure Dallas police are reading this thread just kicking themselves right now, knowing they just woulda coulda shoulda Something Different that would please you, personally, Mr Random Monday Morning Quarterback On The Internet.

In fact they will probably just log in and post a question next time "hey, Internet, should we continue negotiating with this guy who claims to have bombs, or what?"
 
How long do cops have to wait?

Deadly force situations normally don't permit waiting. The fact they can wait at all brings their judgement of deadly force into question.

Yes, I'm sure you have All Teh Informations sitting there in your chair, and fully and completely comprehend the entire strategic environment and what tactical decisions should be made. The police really missed the boat not asking You what to do.
 
I'm sure Dallas police are reading this thread just kicking themselves right now, knowing they just woulda coulda shoulda Something Different that would please you, personally, Mr Random Monday Morning Quarterback On The Internet.

In fact they will probably just log in and post a question next time "hey, Internet, should we continue negotiating with this guy who claims to have bombs, or what?"

All I ask is the family brings a suit and we can have a court adjudicate if they acted properly.
 
Except that it is not. Deadly force has an objective reasonableness standard and an immediate danger requirement.

If they can go an hour and a half, then a other 15, I call into question their whole sense of immediate danger. They are not using deadly force to stop an immediate threat, they are keeping deadly force ready to use at their leisure.

And I care....

why?
 
That should have zero impact on the deadly force decision making.

If it affects the current threat level the shooter is perceived to have, it does make a difference.

You are right that the use of deadly force requires immediacy of threat and I can totally understand why the length of the standoff makes you question that immediacy. Again, the only justification for taking a human life is if it is the only option to save another life or lives.

All I'm saying is that for all of us that weren't there at this stage we don't have enough information to draw any conclusions. It seems reasonable enough to me that the police on the scene could well have acted as they did in good faith and in the public interest. I can imagine multple scenarios that support that view and to me personally it seems the most likely possibility. Central to my thinking is that the perceived threat level of the shooter could change from moment to moment.

Of course I could be completely wrong about that. The police may have decided to execute the criminal in cold blood, not caring if he was a current risk to anyone. I think that's unlikely but some of the other posters here are insisting on it.

Either way it's still too early for us to have any firm information.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom