Multiple police shot in Dallas protest

If deadly force requires an immediate threat then there wouldn't be time to come up with a plan on how to use deadly force.

Now you've just crossed over into silliness. Even if the guy had dozens of hostages and started killing them, the police would still take time to come up with a plan. The expected number of deaths caused by the killer might only rise linearly with time, while the expected number of deaths caused by police action might drop exponentially with time. For example, if everybody rushes in willy nilly, maybe half the hostages are killed and half a dozen police officers. After an hour of planning, maybe two hostages are executed, but the attack can be implemented with zero police casualties and only a couple more fatalities among the hostages.

This wasn't precisely a hostage situation, but it was similar in that every minute the guy remained alive meant additional risk that he could injure or kill somebody.
 
If deadly force requires an immediate threat then there wouldn't be time to come up with a plan on how to use deadly force.

You're kind of parsing it wrong.

The police must determine the absent arrest the subject poses an immediate threat of death or serious injury and that deadly force is necessary to effect arrest.

To me it seems facially apparent that, in the view of a reasonably prudent and cautious person similarly situated as the decision maker, this idiot would pose an immediate risk of death or serious injury if allowed to escape. Certainly people are free to articulate why this perception was unreasonable.

As mentioned previously I think given the circumstances as reported, the DPD was required to basically articulate surrender instructions and that's about it.
 
Last edited:
You're kind of parsing it wrong.

The police must determine the absent arrest the subject poses an immediate threat of death or serious injury and that deadly force is necessary to effect arrest.

To me it seems facially apparent that, in the view of a reasonably prudent and cautious person similarly situated as the decision maker, this idiot would pose an immediate risk of death or serious injury if allowed to escape. Certainly people are free to articulate why this perception was unreasonable.

As mentioned previously I think given the circumstances as reported, the DPD was required to basically articulate surrender instructions and that's about it.

But while negotiating, they would not be under the impression that deadly force is required for arrest so deadly force would not be allowed at that time?
 
I'm sure Dallas police are reading this thread just kicking themselves right now, knowing they just woulda coulda shoulda Something Different that would please you, personally, Mr Random Monday Morning Quarterback On The Internet.

In fact they will probably just log in and post a question next time "hey, Internet, should we continue negotiating with this guy who claims to have bombs, or what?"

Yeah, they could have shot him in the leg.

Or shot his gun out of his hand.

Works in all the movies.

:blackcat:
 
Is there really nothing from the police on why they went in when they did and used a bomb?
 
I'm sure Dallas police are reading this thread just kicking themselves right now, knowing they just woulda coulda shoulda Something Different that would please you, personally, Mr Random Monday Morning Quarterback On The Internet.

In fact they will probably just log in and post a question next time "hey, Internet, should we continue negotiating with this guy who claims to have bombs, or what?"

Snark aside, I do expect the police to take a good look at what happened and see where improvements might be made. I'd be surprised if they didn't spend considerable effort doing so themselves.

There's a right way to do it. Criticism doesn't have to be about laying blame but can be about seeking improvement. We are not necessarily faulting the cops by exploring other options or asking questions about what happened. An automatic leap to a defensive posture is counterproductive.
 
Snark aside, I do expect the police to take a good look at what happened and see where improvements might be made. I'd be surprised if they didn't spend considerable effort doing so themselves.

There's a right way to do it. Criticism doesn't have to be about laying blame but can be about seeking improvement. We are not necessarily faulting the cops by exploring other options or asking questions about what happened. An automatic leap to a defensive posture is counterproductive.

Besides, what else are we going to talk about?
 
But while negotiating, they would not be under the impression that deadly force is required for arrest so deadly force would not be allowed at that time?

No.

While negotiating, they very well could determine that deadly force would be necessary to effect arrest.
 
Is there really nothing from the police on why they went in when they did and used a bomb?

The police chief said he would take the same action again and asked the police rigging the bomb to avoid destroying the structure. I took that to convey to try to limit the charge to whatever was necessary to kill this moron.
 
No.

While negotiating, they very well could determine that deadly force would be necessary to effect arrest.

That isn't what I said. I agree that negotiating can lead to that conclusion. I'm asking if deadly force is warranted when the begin negotiating, while negotiating and believing negotiating will work.
 
If deadly force requires an immediate threat then there wouldn't be time to come up with a plan on how to use deadly force.

That makes no sense. Are you saying that, if you're pinned down by a sniper and cannot kill him immediately, instead thinking about a plan for a few minutes and then implementing it, you somehow the threat wasn't immediate?
 
But while negotiating, they would not be under the impression that deadly force is required for arrest so deadly force would not be allowed at that time?

This isn't invective, so just kind of clear your mind and think about the question.

If required to predict what would happen had this idiot escaped, would you include further shootings as an immediate and very real possibility?

If asked by police (your forum name aside) to go retrieve this idiot in the garage, would you have perceived it as likely that you would have been shot?
 
No.

While negotiating, they very well could determine that deadly force would be necessary to effect arrest.

Which is why they were negotiating with him in the first place. I don't get why Bob doesn't understand this. They were in a situation where deadly force was going to be necessary unless they could talk him into just giving up. They did not have an immediate need to kill him without negotiation because he was no longer a direct threat while holed up, but any attempt to approach him had a high probability of being deadly.

After realizing he could not be reasoned with, there was really not another reasonable option, and frankly the solution the cops chose was really smart. The only other possible non-lethal option I can think of would have been to simply wait longer. Perhaps hunger, thirst, or tiredness would have eventually gotten the better of him, but at that point it would be a tossup as to whether he would surrender or come out guns blazing, putting more people in danger.
 
That isn't what I said. I agree that negotiating can lead to that conclusion. I'm asking if deadly force is warranted when the begin negotiating, while negotiating and believing negotiating will work.

No, if they conclude that force is not necessary to effect arrest then they lack the condition of necessity.
 
Which is why they were negotiating with him in the first place. I don't get why Bob doesn't understand this. They were in a situation where deadly force was going to be necessary unless they could talk him into just giving up. They did not have an immediate need to kill him without negotiation because he was no longer a direct threat while holed up, but any attempt to approach him had a high probability of being deadly.

After realizing he could not be reasoned with, there was really not another reasonable option, and frankly the solution the cops chose was really smart. The only other possible non-lethal option I can think of would have been to simply wait longer. Perhaps hunger, thirst, or tiredness would have eventually gotten the better of him, but at that point it would be a tossup as to whether he would surrender or come out guns blazing, putting more people in danger.

My problem is with people who feel deadly force was authorized that whole time of those two hours.
 
That makes no sense. Are you saying that, if you're pinned down by a sniper and cannot kill him immediately, instead thinking about a plan for a few minutes and then implementing it, you somehow the threat wasn't immediate?

Correct. Following the Orlando shooting, and a lot of discussion about SWAT tactics, a situation with active shooting at people requires immediate entry with no planning.
 
Is there really nothing from the police on why they went in when they did and used a bomb?

Yes. He went into it in depth on CNN on Sunday.

2 Hours of negotiating resulted in being mocked and being asked for more fodder.

The chief asked SWAT to come up with something to end it. "Be creative if you have to" was the order.

So they did. The rest was an Earth Shattering Kaboom!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom