Multiple police shot in Dallas protest

While I do not subscribe to the NRA theory, your sarcasm is noted. It may have been a different story, if he had been in the open. He was not.

Open carry and armed citizens is supposed to stop this kind of thing, it did not.
 
Open carry and armed citizens is supposed to stop this kind of thing, it did not.

Nobody ever claimed that it was an automatic solution. Just that the chances of successful intervention were greater when armed. The actual tactical situation will always dictate the result.

You are misrepresenting an argument to make a point that is not proven one way or another by this particular incident.
 
Is the issue that he was killed, or is the issue that he was killed with a bomb rather than a bullet?

I think it's the bomb v. bullet bit. There's a kind of callousness to it. It's hard to make a logical case, since dead is dead, but we do think of some ways of killing (nerve gas, radiation poisoning) as being worse than others. It can't be that they are worse for the dead person, so it must be they are worse for the killer.

And let's not forget - this happened in Texas. An arrest will end up getting this guy the death penalty anyhow. Texas is one of those places where death row still means death, eventually. Justice doesn't demand he gets killed now.
 
I still don't see how this is any different than using a sniper. There are Rules of Engagement for using snipers, and it sounds as if those same rules were followed for this, except that he was not in a location where a sniper could get a bead on him.


I'm curious... How many non-hostage situations have warranted a sniper?
 
While I do not subscribe to the NRA theory, your sarcasm is noted. It may have been a different story, if he had been in the open. He was not.

So the point is...as long as bad guys with guns don't enact any kind of element of surprise, or use tactics to their advantage, good guys with guns will stop that **** all day long?
 
Nobody ever claimed that it was an automatic solution. Just that the chances of successful intervention were greater when armed. The actual tactical situation will always dictate the result.

You are misrepresenting an argument to make a point that is not proven one way or another by this particular incident.

Or by any incident. There is no evidence to support the notion that an armed public is safer from mass shootings.
 
Open carry and armed citizens is supposed to stop this kind of thing, it did not.

You do realize that if any of the other people there with guns had even acted like they were going to start shooting at anyone, the police -or yet another armed citizen- would've immediately began firing back at them, right?

It's my understanding when this thing started they believed there were multiple shooters, so the only prudent thing a person with a gun could do was take themselves out of the fray. If they attempted to "help" they might just as easily mistake another armed citizen who was also trying to help for one of the perpetrators.

It doesn't necessarily mean an armed populace is useless (although I'm not convinced it would be any real help in any circumstance) but in this case there was only room for more error. The chance of any random citizen actually making the situation better was very slim; but the chance of getting dead trying was very high.
 
I have no sympathy for the dead sniper. According to what has been reported, he wasn't going to stop until he was dead and he was still a danger.
I find using a bomb a bit unnerving. Now that the precedent has been set, using bombs in the future will be all that much easier. A line has been crossed and I am not sure I am comfortable with it. As has been said, dead is dead and the end result would be the same with several different methods. This action was very personal for the police involved and it is possible other solutions were overlooked. I don't know.

Hopefully it will be reviewed by other parties with less personal attachment.
 
I don't see the debate over using a bomb to kill the shooter as showing sympathy for the murderer. I see it as a question of the police deciding they can act as judge, jury, and executioner after only a brief (two hour) standoff. At this time I don't have enough information say the police were wrong in their use of the bomb, but I am questioning if it was right. Had they truly exhausted all options? Or were they in a mode of "let's kill this (multiple expletives deleted) because he killed a dozen of us"? That's revenge, not justice.

Understandable, but the society we live in leaves justice to the courts and revenge to the Mafia.

For the families of the murdered and wounded officers, and the potential for more killings, that brief two hour standoff is a lifetime. The police did what they felt was right thing to prevent future killings. Only my opinion, I fully support their actions.
 
I'm curious... How many non-hostage situations have warranted a sniper?

It depends what you mean by non hostage. An active shooter situation, where police know the criminal has the intent and ability to endanger more lives can justify a sniper. Charles Whitman would be one example. In this case, the criminal was armed, declaring he would kill more people, well within weapon range of innocent people, taking pot shots at police and claiming to have planted bombs.
 
Wow, some people seem really invested in insisting that a mass murderer actively continuing his crimes and threatening to set off multiple bombs any minute is no threat at all to the police or the public. After all, if he's "surrounded" his bullets and bombs can't hurt anyone, right?

The following questions are for those who insist the murderer did not need to be stopped as soon as possible:

You just went pass the biggest blow to the police position. If he should have been stopped as soon as possible, why wait 2 hours?
 
I still don't see how this is any different than using a sniper. There are Rules of Engagement for using snipers, and it sounds as if those same rules were followed for this, except that he was not in a location where a sniper could get a bead on him.

Is the issue that he was killed, or is the issue that he was killed with a bomb rather than a bullet?

I don't care about the method. I am solely focused on the use of force and if they acted inappropriately by taking too long.
 
You just went pass the biggest blow to the police position. If he should have been stopped as soon as possible, why wait 2 hours?

I don't know the specifics but I wouldn't be at all surprised that after the police found themselves in a standoff with a madman in a college building where they couldn't get shooters into position without extreme risk, it took some time to come up another option. Using a remote controlled robot to deliver c4 to a shooter had never been done before and I expect it took a while to imagine, a while to convince decision makers it was a viable option and a while rig up.
 
Last edited:
I don't know the specifics but I wouldn't be at all surprised that after the police found themselves in a standoff with a madman in a college building where they couldn't get shooters into position without extreme risk, it took some time to come up another option. Using a remote controlled robot to deliver c4 to a shooter had never been done before and I expect it took a while to imagine, a while to convince decision makers it was a viable option and a while rig up.

The problem is a case where deadly force is supposedly necessary but can be approached so leisurely. If the situation is so severe, then waiting 2 hours is irresponsible. They need to respond with the resources they have on hand.
 
The problem is a case where deadly force is supposedly necessary but can be approached so leisurely. If the situation is so severe, then waiting 2 hours is irresponsible. They need to respond with the resources they have on hand.

Why don't you take the initiative and contact the Dallas Police Chief and ask for an explanation?
 
The problem is a case where deadly force is supposedly necessary but can be approached so leisurely. If the situation is so severe, then waiting 2 hours is irresponsible. They need to respond with the resources they have on hand.

This makes the assumption that using the robot was made and they waited 2 hours to deploy it. They were willing to use deadly force from minute zero while engaging the shooter and providing him with the option to surrender.

C4, which is used to detonate suspicious object, and a bomb robot can be found on a SWAT team in most large cities. It was a resource they had on hand.
 
The problem is a case where deadly force is supposedly necessary but can be approached so leisurely. If the situation is so severe, then waiting 2 hours is irresponsible. They need to respond with the resources they have on hand.

Without being privy to the decision making process and the minute to minute info available to the officers we can only speculate but one possibility is that they chose the lesser of two evils. While the shooter was in the building, taking potshots at the officers but not shooting randomly out a window, they may have been willing to hold off on a suicidal charge and accept some risk to their own officers as a tradeoff for coming up with a safer method of approaching the shooter.
 
This makes the assumption that using the robot was made and they waited 2 hours to deploy it. They were willing to use deadly force from minute zero while engaging the shooter and providing him with the option to surrender.

C4, which is used to detonate suspicious object, and a bomb robot can be found on a SWAT team in most large cities. It was a resource they had on hand.

My point is they should not have those options. A deadly force situation should compel the use of deadly force. If there is an option to negotiate, simply reaching a limit on willingness to negotiate shouldn't matter.

Now, if someone suggests the situation legitimately changed,that would matter.
 
This makes the assumption that using the robot was made and they waited 2 hours to deploy it. They were willing to use deadly force from minute zero while engaging the shooter and providing him with the option to surrender.

C4, which is used to detonate suspicious object, and a bomb robot can be found on a SWAT team in most large cities. It was a resource they had on hand.

Chief said about 15 minutes between his directive to "be creative if you have to" to the result of the bomb robot.

He went to a Press Conference, and that's what they came up with when he returned.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom