Multiple police shot in Dallas protest

There were a lot of good guys with guns on scene. Look how it worked out. Surprise, surprise, completely different than in wet fantasies of gun nutjob whackos.

You mean nobody jumped into the air in slow motion as their trenchcoat billowed behind them and doves started taking flight as they shot two pistols and twirled in midair?
 
Why not bring the building down? After all, there were officers in surgery that didn't make it.

Certainly the fact that this idiot shot 11 police officers was a consideration kind of functionally required by the decision maker in determining the immediacy of threat. It sounds like an emotional argument, but in this case it's also kind of a constitutional or legal argument. Don't bring the building down sounds like a good force limiter here. I'm assuming they have cleared the parking structure, which seemed to have been reported at the time.
 
Wow, some people seem really invested in insisting that a mass murderer actively continuing his crimes and threatening to set off multiple bombs any minute is no threat at all to the police or the public. After all, if he's "surrounded" his bullets and bombs can't hurt anyone, right?

The following questions are for those who insist the murderer did not need to be stopped as soon as possible: How much risk should the police have to assume to to try to take him alive when he has proven he will not cooperate with that plan? How long do you leave him unmolested when he can burst from cover at any second, shooting wildly and every single shot he fires can kill someone? Why at the time he makes it do you refuse to believe his claim he can detonate bombs that can kill many people while out of your sight? Do you understand that "body armour" does not mean "magical shield that makes you invulnerable and immune to gunshots"? Do you realize that bullets fired randomly from any rifle can travel great distances, punch through windows or walls and kill innocent people?Do you realize the murderer was communicating with police and insisting he would murder more people? Do you understand that every second the murderer was free and armed he represented an immediate and continuing threat to innocent lives whether the police could see him or not? Should the police be obligated to value the murderers life more highly than their own or innocent members of the public? How many more people should have had their lives endangered to preserve the murderer's?
 
Wow, some people seem really invested in insisting that a mass murderer actively continuing his crimes and threatening to set off multiple bombs any minute is no threat at all to the police or the public. After all, if he's "surrounded" his bullets and bombs can't hurt anyone, right?

The following questions are for those who insist the murderer did not need to be stopped as soon as possible: How much risk should the police have to assume to to try to take him alive when he has proven he will not cooperate with that plan? How long do you leave him unmolested when he can burst from cover at any second, shooting wildly and every single shot he fires can kill someone? Why at the time he makes it do you refuse to believe his claim he can detonate bombs that can kill many people while out of your sight? Do you understand that "body armour" does not mean "magical shield that makes you invulnerable and immune to gunshots"? Do you realize that bullets fired randomly from any rifle can travel great distances, punch through windows or walls and kill innocent people?Do you realize the murderer was communicating with police and insisting he would murder more people? Do you understand that every second the murderer was free and armed he represented an immediate and continuing threat to innocent lives whether the police could see him or not? Should the police be obligated to value the murderers life more highly than their own or innocent members of the public? How many more people should have had their lives endangered to preserve the murderer's?

That's a powerful picture you've drawn there. Is there much in it to distinguish it from other barricaded gunman scenarios? I only ask because this is the first time I've heard of a bomb being used in this way.

It's either an innovation for an old problem or there's something unique here. I grant the unique thing might be, "We had the robot handy and it seemed like a good idea to use it."

In fact, that's quite believable. You get the robot ready to send it in and have a look-around, and then someone suggests, "Hey, remember those bombs we have in the truck? If anyone needs blowing up, this rat **** does."
 
Certainly the fact that this idiot shot 11 police officers was a consideration kind of functionally required by the decision maker in determining the immediacy of threat. It sounds like an emotional argument, but in this case it's also kind of a constitutional or legal argument. Don't bring the building down sounds like a good force limiter here. I'm assuming they have cleared the parking structure, which seemed to have been reported at the time.

That's an important nuance, the idea of a force limiter. It gets us away from the unrealistic "get this guy at all costs." There are choices being made.
 
There were a lot of good guys with guns on scene. Look how it worked out. Surprise, surprise, completely different than in wet fantasies of gun nutjob whackos.

It also didn't work out the other way...there was no wild firefight.

However, I suspect that most of the good guys with guns did not have ammo handy, and thus could not do much except get mistaken for the shooter.
 
Thank goodness they did, since someone actually was shooting at them...

It's relatively cheap to buy body armor if it's legal where you live.
Is wearing body armour not a constitutional right? I thought it would be a feature of the equipment of every "well-regulated militia" by now.
 
Is wearing body armour not a constitutional right? I thought it would be a feature of the equipment of every "well-regulated militia" by now.

I already ate...

Usually you'd hear the idea that someone who wanted to wear body armor was paranoid.

This time though, there actually was a shooter, and with the trend in protests towards violence, I can see why people might have worn it if they owned it.

I am still at a loss as to how the shooter was a sniper, though. The only kill I saw was a close up ambush?
 
That's a powerful picture you've drawn there. Is there much in it to distinguish it from other barricaded gunman scenarios? I only ask because this is the first time I've heard of a bomb being used in this way.

It's either an innovation for an old problem or there's something unique here. I grant the unique thing might be, "We had the robot handy and it seemed like a good idea to use it."

In fact, that's quite believable. You get the robot ready to send it in and have a look-around, and then someone suggests, "Hey, remember those bombs we have in the truck? If anyone needs blowing up, this rat **** does."

The highlighted part is a very good and fair question that I had not thought of. My first reaction is: it depends. I suppose that a lethal option is a lethal option. If it's considered necessary to immediately completely disable a criminal I don't think there is any moral difference between a disablement (which includes the unfortunate side effect of causing instant death) caused by a robot and the disablement caused by sniper firing a bullet into the criminal's brain.

I guess the decision would have to depend on the same sort of threat assessment the sniper uses. The only justification for taking a life is to save another or others. If a criminal was barricaded in a bank vault with no hostages, no sightlines outside and no line of retreat then preemptively killing him would certainly not be justified. If a distraught father was in his house threatening to stab his kids it might be justifed but it would require careful judgement of the risk to the kids by the on scene officers and negotiater ( More to follow, going home now)
 
A pair of research studies on the racial disparities in police shootings. On the surface, they appear to be contradict each other, but I have not had time to do more than skim either one.

A Multi-Level Bayesian Analysis of Racial Bias in Police Shootings at the County-Level in the United States, 2011–2014

The results provide evidence of a significant bias in the killing of unarmed black Americans relative to unarmed white Americans, in that the probability of being {black, unarmed, and shot by police} is about 3.49 times the probability of being {white, unarmed, and shot by police} on average. Furthermore, the results of multi-level modeling show that there exists significant heterogeneity across counties in the extent of racial bias in police shootings, with some counties showing relative risk ratios of 20 to 1 or more.



An Empirical Analysis of Racial Differences in Police Use of Force

This paper explores racial differences in police use of force. On non-lethal uses of force, blacks and Hispanics are more than fifty percent more likely to experience some form of force in interactions with police. Adding controls that account for important context and civilian behavior reduces, but cannot fully explain, these disparities. On the most extreme use of force – officer-involved shootings – we find no racial differences in either the raw data or when contextual factors are taken into account.
 
Texas is open-carry and a large proportion of the people there have guns. How did a mass shooting happen in such a place that should be safe from such gun violence, according to NRA theory?
 
Texas is open-carry and a large proportion of the people there have guns. How did a mass shooting happen in such a place that should be safe from such gun violence, according to NRA theory?

While I do not subscribe to the NRA theory, your sarcasm is noted. It may have been a different story, if he had been in the open. He was not.
 
I find all this sympathy for a mass murderer to be a bit much.
I don't see the debate over using a bomb to kill the shooter as showing sympathy for the murderer. I see it as a question of the police deciding they can act as judge, jury, and executioner after only a brief (two hour) standoff.

At this time I don't have enough information say the police were wrong in their use of the bomb, but I am questioning if it was right. Had they truly exhausted all options? Or were they in a mode of "let's kill this (multiple expletives deleted) because he killed a dozen of us"? That's revenge, not justice.

Understandable, but the society we live in leaves justice to the courts and revenge to the Mafia.
 
I don't see the debate over using a bomb to kill the shooter as showing sympathy for the murderer. I see it as a question of the police deciding they can act as judge, jury, and executioner after only a brief (two hour) standoff.

At this time I don't have enough information say the police were wrong in their use of the bomb, but I am questioning if it was right. Had they truly exhausted all options? Or were they in a mode of "let's kill this (multiple expletives deleted) because he killed a dozen of us"? That's revenge, not justice.

Understandable, but the society we live in leaves justice to the courts and revenge to the Mafia.

I still don't see how this is any different than using a sniper. There are Rules of Engagement for using snipers, and it sounds as if those same rules were followed for this, except that he was not in a location where a sniper could get a bead on him.

Is the issue that he was killed, or is the issue that he was killed with a bomb rather than a bullet?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom