Multiple police shot in Dallas protest

You're kidding, right? He was telling them he was going to kill them the whole time. He said he had bombs all over the place and still had hundreds of rounds left. You can bet they all wanted to take him alive so they could question him, but he just wasn't going to cooperate, and he could have executed some kind of suicide attack at any time. This was a no-brainer.

Them what took so long?
 
You're kidding, right? He was telling them he was going to kill them the whole time. He said he had bombs all over the place and still had hundreds of rounds left. You can bet they all wanted to take him alive so they could question him, but he just wasn't going to cooperate, and he could have executed some kind of suicide attack at any time. This was a no-brainer.

Yeah...one guy surrounded by hundreds of cops with full body armor, barricades and unlimited weapons.....Ohhhhh that is so ScArEy! (make me almost want to pee in my pants when I think about it!)
 
Good evening. At the time the decision was made to use lethal force to end the confrontation, the police acted in a manner they felt was the best option to stop further harm. At that time, the police in communication with the suspect, but it doesn't sound like it was a negotiation. The suspect would only talk to a black police officer. The suspect told them that more people will be injured. He told them that there were bombs right there. He told them that there are other bombs elsewhere. He asked about how many he got and seemed proud of that. He was singing to them. He was in a.position that could not be approached without putting more people at risk. All this going on while the police where still trying to sort out how many shooters there were. They were dealing with multiple people walking around with long rifles, and bullet proof vest, exercising their right to do so. It's likely this lead the multiple reports of multiple shooters. They didn't know if the suspect was in communication with other possible shooters. Under those conditions I could see why the police decided to remove this guy from the equation.
 
Underlying my thinking on this is the idea: the citizenry gets to decide how they want to be policed. We should listen to the experts, but it's up to us to decide.

This means the Monday morning quarterbacking isn't merely about finding "gotchas" (although it can be), but an effort to understand and criticize and alter policies we deem inappropriate.

And the duty of oversight goes beyond talk about threats and safety. If we decide that cops shouldn't shoot fleeing felons, then the cops shouldn't shoot fleeing felons - no matter what justification is offered up. This is because we are both the beneficiaries and the victims of police practices. If what we want makes the job more dangerous, then that becomes the case.

I don't yet know how I feel about this case and the robo-bomb. All that's happened so far is the "pay attention" button has been pushed.
 
Yeah...one guy surrounded by hundreds of cops with full body armor, barricades and unlimited weapons.....Ohhhhh that is so ScArEy! (make me almost want to pee in my pants when I think about it!)

He still had bullets and was actively taking shots at them. Their kevlar vests may as well be cardboard against the rifle he was using. He also claimed that he had multiple IED's in the area ready to detonate. I agree with the decision for them to stop this guy from killing more people.

The guy wanted to die, he got his wish.
 
Just to avoid confusion, when I assert a requirement to negotiate surrender I'm not meaning that the police were required to offer or accept the demand for any concessions. I assert that they were probably required to articulate some very basic surrender instructions. All of this assuming the circumstances as reported -- suspect contained, open communication and a time requirement for effecting an alternate plan.
 
I don't care what they used.

My problem is that if they could negotiate for 2 hours, deadly force should not be authorized in that time. If deadly force is authorized, it should be a situation where spending time negotiating presents great risk to the people.

Baloney.

They had him surrounded, Just wait him out.

Gawd ****in' Damn...is is that hard to figure out?

Them what took so long?

Yeah...one guy surrounded by hundreds of cops with full body armor, barricades and unlimited weapons.....Ohhhhh that is so ScArEy! (make me almost want to pee in my pants when I think about it!)

People have some odd ideas here.

Why not take him out earlier? Because they were negotiating.

Why did they kill him rather than continue to negotiate, or use non-violent means? Because he stopped negotiating, and started shooting again.

Was he really a threat? After all, they had him surrounded. But he had already shot 12 cops, who are, after all, trained to deal with shooters. Plus, there may have been other shooters, he may have been ready to detonate bombs.

He ended negotiations, not the cops. He started shooting again. They had 12 people down already. How many more do they have to risk before people catch on that this guy was much more dangerous than the average joe?
 
People have some odd ideas here.

Why not take him out earlier? Because they were negotiating.

Why did they kill him rather than continue to negotiate, or use non-violent means? Because he stopped negotiating, and started shooting again.

Was he really a threat? After all, they had him surrounded. But he had already shot 12 cops, who are, after all, trained to deal with shooters. Plus, there may have been other shooters, he may have been ready to detonate bombs.

He ended negotiations, not the cops. He started shooting again. They had 12 people down already. How many more do they have to risk before people catch on that this guy was much more dangerous than the average joe?

You seem to be the first to suggest he started shooting again. Nobody on either side seems to have said that so I must have missed that.
 
You seem to be the first to suggest he started shooting again. Nobody on either side seems to have said that so I must have missed that.

It is late and I need to get my kids to bed. If nobody else has posted a source by morning, I'll see if I can find one then. I am pretty sure I read that after a period of negotiation, he started shooting again.
 
Seriously? Is that true? At what range?

Within a city block, an unreinforced kevlar vest will offer very minimal protection to intermediate and large rifle rounds. For common rounds, think other than .22. What's important is the relationship between the surface area of the round (the caliber) and the muzzle velocity imparted.

For instance, the 9mm Luger -- a popular handgun round -- has a muzzle velocity ~1100 fps.

A .30-06 rifle is .30 caliber (~8mm) round adopted by the army in 1906. A popular hunting load develops a muzzle velocity around 2,900 fps.

That's 2,800 lbs of energy at the muzzle for the '06 vs the ~400 ft lbs for the 9mm handgun. The same .30-06 round will still carry well over 400 ft lbs at 1000 yards.
 
Within a city block, an unreinforced kevlar vest will offer very minimal protection to intermediate and large rifle rounds. For common rounds, think other than .22. What's important is the relationship between the surface area of the round (the caliber) and the muzzle velocity imparted.

For instance, the 9mm Luger -- a popular handgun round -- has a muzzle velocity ~1100 fps.

A .30-06 rifle is .30 caliber (~8mm) round adopted by the army in 1906. A popular hunting load develops a muzzle velocity around 2,900 fps.

That's 2,800 lbs of energy at the muzzle for the '06 vs the ~400 ft lbs for the 9mm handgun. The same .30-06 round will still carry well over 400 ft lbs at 1000 yards.

Okay; thanks. How many fps can a Kevlar jacket protect against? Say, with no more damage than extensive bruises or maybe a broken rib?
 
Okay; thanks. How many fps can a Kevlar jacket protect against? Say, with no more damage than extensive bruises or maybe a broken rib?

They are not measured exactly that way, but a Kevlar vest can stop a powerful pistol round which go less than 1500 fps. The 7.62x39 used goes 2400 fps.
 
But if deadly force was allowed at that time, why are they allowed to endanger others by dragging it out?

You know, sometimes I wonder if people are just messing with me, and this one is a tough call. It just seems so unlikely that others don't understand what went down here. But, I do solve problems for a living, and that often requires pulling together a bunch of data, getting the big picture, and proceeding from there. So, it probably went something like this:

It boils down to two things:
1.) He was an imminent threat to public safety and that threat needed to be neutralized.
2.) It was entirely possible he was part of a cell, and the best way to find out was to keep him alive and get information from him.

Further, if they could negotiate a surrender, both goals could be accomplished, but they would have accept the inherent risks of leaving an active shooter in play for a while.

After weighing things for a while, they decide to negotiate, and start urgent, parallel investigations of the three suspects they had arrested. As the clock ticks and the information flows -- including data from the crime scene, it now becomes less and less likely any of the three were involved, and the cops consider the emerging probability the guy holed up in the parking garage is the only shooter. That tilts the scales away from needing to capture him alive and toward neutralizing the continued threat to public safety, and the decision is made to neutralize the threat.
 
You know, sometimes I wonder if people are just messing with me, and this one is a tough call. It just seems so unlikely that others don't understand what went down here. But, I do solve problems for a living, and that often requires pulling together a bunch of data, getting the big picture, and proceeding from there. So, it probably went something like this:

It boils down to two things:
1.) He was an imminent threat to public safety and that threat needed to be neutralized.
2.) It was entirely possible he was part of a cell, and the best way to find out was to keep him alive and get information from him.

Further, if they could negotiate a surrender, both goals could be accomplished, but they would have accept the inherent risks of leaving an active shooter in play for a while.

After weighing things for a while, they decide to negotiate, and start urgent, parallel investigations of the three suspects they had arrested. As the clock ticks and the information flows -- including data from the crime scene, it now becomes less and less likely any of the three were involved, and the cops consider the emerging probability the guy holed up in the parking garage is the only shooter. That tilts the scales away from needing to capture him alive and toward neutralizing the continued threat to public safety, and the decision is made to neutralize the threat.

That makes sense.

My take is cops are idiots unequipped to mentally handle the situation and should have the procedure spelled out for them before hand.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom