Multiple police shot in Dallas protest

This guy wanted to die. Another suicide by mass shooting, but this time armed police officers were the target. He was probably expecting to be shot to death and was disappointed when that fantasy blew up in his face.....
 
I see it as no different from a soldier clearing out an entrenched enemy with a grenade. A bit scary that it came to that, but I won't second guess the decision.

Cops aren't at war and don't have the same powers as soldiers
 
Maybe they should have killed him sooner. Should the decision have been made 10 minutes earlier? 2 hours earlier?

That really doesn't articulate lack of necessity or immediacy, though.

Assuming the situation as reported, I think that the time required to deploy a killbot and the existing avenue of communication probably required some level of effort negotiating surrender before a reasonably cautious and prudent person would consider lethal force necessary to prevent death or great bodily injury. The amount of time spent on this effort is dependent on the time it takes to ready the alternate plan and the time it takes the responsible party to conclude necessity.

I really don't see the point of a shot clock over changes in circumstance.
 
That really doesn't articulate lack of necessity or immediacy, though.

Assuming the situation as reported, I think that the time required to deploy a killbot and the existing avenue of communication probably required some level of effort negotiating surrender before a reasonably cautious and prudent person would consider lethal force necessary to prevent death or great bodily injury. The amount of time spent on this effort is dependent on the time it takes to ready the alternate plan and the time it takes the responsible party to conclude necessity.

I really don't see the point of a shot clock over changes in circumstance.

I like the name

Coming to a station near you
 
That really doesn't articulate lack of necessity or immediacy, though.

Assuming the situation as reported, I think that the time required to deploy a killbot and the existing avenue of communication probably required some level of effort negotiating surrender before a reasonably cautious and prudent person would consider lethal force necessary to prevent death or great bodily injury. The amount of time spent on this effort is dependent on the time it takes to ready the alternate plan and the time it takes the responsible party to conclude necessity.

I really don't see the point of a shot clock over changes in circumstance.

I think it's meant to show the situation was stable, not volatile.

It's much easier to forgive the use of deadly force in extremis, less so when it's deliberative. It's like how we think of first and second degree murder as different crimes - the planning element.

Does the guy get a chance to surrender to the robot?
 
I have no idea what the procedure is. I'm just going by what I think makes sense. Also, in the action movies I've seen, cornered criminals have an amazing ability to escape from sticky situations. See, for example, the Joker in the Dark Knight movie.



Cops are about average intelligence, from the studies I've seen. I think a person with average intelligence, who spends years studying and thinking about (and perhaps even experiencing) these types of situations, is well equipped to make the necessary decisions. Like I said, their plan strikes me as reasonable enough that I see no point in second guessing it.

Baloney.

They had him surrounded, Just wait him out.

Gawd ****in' Damn...is is that hard to figure out?
 
This easily met the tests necessary to use deadly force to neutralize a threat.

1. Does the person have the ABILITY to inflict great bodily harm or death on yourself or another person or persons?
2. Does the person have the INTENT to inflict great bodily harm or death on yourself or another person or persons?
3. Are you or others in JEOPARDY of immediate death or great bodily harm?

I would say all three tests were satisfied, and that means anyone can use deadly force to neutralize the threat, civilian or cop. This is straight from the conceal carry course that was put together by the state.
 
I think it's meant to show the situation was stable, not volatile.

I think the relative stability status quo required an offer of surrender. I also think the status quo was not sustainable or tolerable. So the question becomes what force would be necessary to disrupt that existing situation.

Does the guy get a chance to surrender to the robot?

Not necessarily. Once a conclusion is achieved that the use of lethal force is necessary, the mechanism is simply tactics.
 
Last edited:
I think the relative stability status quo required an offer of surrender. I also think the status quo was not sustainable or tolerable. So the question becomes what force would be necessary to disrupt that existing situation.



No necessarily. Once a conclusion is achieved that the use of lethal force is necessary, the mechanism is simply tactics.

An amazing use of the English Language. Sounds like Government-Speak.
 
This easily met the tests necessary to use deadly force to neutralize a threat.

1. Does the person have the ABILITY to inflict great bodily harm or death on yourself or another person or persons?
2. Does the person have the INTENT to inflict great bodily harm or death on yourself or another person or persons?
3. Are you or others in JEOPARDY of immediate death or great bodily harm?

I would say all three tests were satisfied, and that means anyone can use deadly force to neutralize the threat, civilian or cop. This is straight from the conceal carry course that was put together by the state.

Who was he going to kill? He was trapped
 
The policeman who had to retrieve him. That's discounting the threat of escape or his threat of bombs.

They weren't too worried for two hours

They should have just waited him out

At least over night till he would of calmed down and come off whatever weird **** he was strung out on
 
Who was he going to kill? He was trapped

You're kidding, right? He was telling them he was going to kill them the whole time. He said he had bombs all over the place and still had hundreds of rounds left. You can bet they all wanted to take him alive so they could question him, but he just wasn't going to cooperate, and he could have executed some kind of suicide attack at any time. This was a no-brainer.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom