Multiple police shot in Dallas protest

I would expect so. He was armed the entire time. He was a threat the entire time.

Just saw this report on the siege that followed the shootings, I'd say they did the best of a bad job.

During negotiations that lasted about two hours, Johnson insisted that he would speak only with an African American police negotiator, Brown said. “And he just basically lied to us, playing games, laughing at us, singing, asking how many did he get and that he wanted to kill some more and that there were bombs there.”

http://www.msn.com/en-au/news/world...yptic-messages-in-blood/ar-BBu9ArR?li=AAgfIYZ
 
I don't understand how you can have a situation where you can negotiate for five hours while having the option for deadly force that entire time. Either the threat is being exaggerated, or the negotiating is extremely unwise and unnecessarily puts the public at risk.

Cops are too stupid to have that level of discretion.

They negotiated for two hours, not five. Read the article linked to in the post previous to this one.

Also from that article:

Brown said Johnson was in a position where officers would have had to expose themselves to “grave danger” to get a shot at him. Therefore, he said, he approved a hastily conceived plan to detonate a bomb near the gunman and would “do it again if presented with the same circumstances.”

The article also points out that they used explosives, but not an actual pre-manufactured bomb. They did not have a previous plan to use such a device, and came up with the plan on the spot.
 
In a short, with lighting just right? Sure. Not often. Did you see the size of it?
Interesting that you had that short so quick.

I notice the link I posted now goes to a more discreet video. I wonder if someone decided not to give pointers on how to shoot 100 rounds in 50 seconds or whatever he did. I tried linking to another address but I can't get the video to show.

I just Googled conceal AR-15 on person or something like that. If someone says it's impossible I look for a counterexample.
 
They negotiated for two hours, not five. Read the article linked to in the post previous to this one.

Also from that article:



The article also points out that they used explosives, but not an actual pre-manufactured bomb. They did not have a previous plan to use such a device, and came up with the plan on the spot.

I don't care what they used.

My problem is that if they could negotiate for 2 hours, deadly force should not be authorized in that time. If deadly force is authorized, it should be a situation where spending time negotiating presents great risk to the people.
 
I don't care what they used.

My problem is that if they could negotiate for 2 hours, deadly force should not be authorized in that time. If deadly force is authorized, it should be a situation where spending time negotiating presents great risk to the people.

If, after those 2 hours, they came to the conclusion that the gunman was not going to allow himself to be taken alive, then it was reasonable to kill him. He was clearly a very dangerous fellow. Maybe they could have waited for him to deteriorate mentally and physically from stress, fatigue, and hunger, and thereby increase the chances of taking him alive without undue risk to police officers, but it was also the case that the longer they waited, the greater the risk that he might escape. They also didn't know whether or not he had accomplices who might try to extricate him from his position.

The bottom line is I don't see the decision to kill him to be unreasonable at all under the circumstances.
 
The Dallas police chief also sought to explain initial confusion that resulted in the arrests of three “suspects” who turned out not to be involved in the shooting.

He said 20 to 30 people, some of them wearing camouflage, showed up at the peaceful Black Lives Matter protest carrying AR-15 rifles and such items as gas masks, ammunition gear and bulletproof vests. “Doesn’t make sense to us,” he said, “but that’s their right in Texas,” where people can legally carry long firearms in public.

Yeeeeehhhhhaaaaawwww
 
Last edited:
If, after those 2 hours, they came to the conclusion that the gunman was not going to allow himself to be taken alive, then it was reasonable to kill him. He was clearly a very dangerous fellow. Maybe they could have waited for him to deteriorate mentally and physically from stress, fatigue, and hunger, and thereby increase the chances of taking him alive without undue risk to police officers, but it was also the case that the longer they waited, the greater the risk that he might escape. They also didn't know whether or not he had accomplices who might try to extricate him from his position.

The bottom line is I don't see the decision to kill him to be unreasonable at all under the circumstances.

Are you speculating on the procedure or is it the defined procedure? I am most interested in the formal guidance on navigating this situation and if there is or is not good information to make changes.

As I said, cops are too dumb to be put in charge here.
 
The kind of layman terms threshold to use (non-custodial) lethal force to effect arrest is that the force be necessary to effect arrest and that the person poses an immediate threat of death or serious injury absent arrest.

I guess people are free to articulate why this idiot wasn't an immediate threat. That will be a hard sell.

IMO, the only rational question is what feature made the use of lethal force unnecessary -- or, flipping the question, what option other than lethal force was available?
 
The kind of layman terms threshold to use (non-custodial) lethal force to effect arrest is that the force be necessary to effect arrest and that the person poses an immediate threat of death or serious injury absent arrest.

I guess people are free to articulate why this idiot wasn't an immediate threat. That will be a hard sell.

IMO, the only rational question is what feature made the use of lethal force unnecessary -- or, flipping the question, what option other than lethal force was available?


Maybe they should have killed him sooner. Should the decision have been made 10 minutes earlier? 2 hours earlier?
 
Are you speculating on the procedure or is it the defined procedure? I am most interested in the formal guidance on navigating this situation and if there is or is not good information to make changes.

I have no idea what the procedure is. I'm just going by what I think makes sense. Also, in the action movies I've seen, cornered criminals have an amazing ability to escape from sticky situations. See, for example, the Joker in the Dark Knight movie.

As I said, cops are too dumb to be put in charge here.

Cops are about average intelligence, from the studies I've seen. I think a person with average intelligence, who spends years studying and thinking about (and perhaps even experiencing) these types of situations, is well equipped to make the necessary decisions. Like I said, their plan strikes me as reasonable enough that I see no point in second guessing it.
 
Maybe they should have killed him sooner. Should the decision have been made 10 minutes earlier? 2 hours earlier?

At some point the decision maker realized the guy was prepared to die. It might have taken 2 hours for that realization to filter up the chain of command.
 
Cops are about average intelligence, from the studies I've seen. I think a person with average intelligence, who spends years studying and thinking about (and perhaps even experiencing) these types of situations, is well equipped to make the necessary decisions. t.

I disagree.
 
At some point the decision maker realized the guy was prepared to die. It might have taken 2 hours for that realization to filter up the chain of command.

If deadly force was necessary it probably shouldn't have to involve the chain of command.
 
I disagree.

Should it be some nobody in a case this high profile?

The higher the profile, the more there should be a procedure to adhere to that results in the same decision whether a nobody or a chief.

If there is a life threatening situation, waiting on the chain of command increases the risk.
 
Last edited:
I see it as no different from a soldier clearing out an entrenched enemy with a grenade. A bit scary that it came to that, but I won't second guess the decision.

That isn't the question here. No one is debating the method here. The question is how did the soldier's decision to throw the grenade get made.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom