More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

...
...I am getting ready to drop the big big bomb on you folks, and I predict that many of you will be singing another tune. Some of you have suggested that 99.9% of scientists don't believe in homeopathy, as though this is proof of something because it wasn't too long ago that 99.9% of physicians believed in bloodletting and mercury and on and on and on (and "scientists" have been not only the biggest promoters of allopathic medicine but also their best "PR" persons).

....

I was scrolling through this thread because he was pulling the "water is like a CD-rom" bit on Orac's blog, when I noticed this statement.

Did he drop a bomb? Did I miss it? If he did, what was it? Because I don't really see anyone "singing another tune."
 
I suppose I deserved that, considering that they have not posted mine yet.


Ah, yes, you have to try to dumb yourself down a bit.
Some of us don't have a lot of trouble with that. :D
 
Last edited:
I wonder if Dana is pleased with the result of his puffing of the Roy paper? That is, a letter to Homoeopathy, signed by four PhDs, pointing out what crap it is!

I'm not saying it was only Dana that sparked that off, because other homoeopaths were doing much the same thing, but he certainly contributed to our decision to take such a keen interest in the thing.

Rolfe.
 
Medical News Today has just published an adapted version of the press release mentioned in post # 1089:


For those interested, if you click on the link and scroll down the page you'll find a box where you can submit a rating regarding “How interesting was this article?”. And further down the page there’s a link for “Write an opinion of this article”.

Blatant publicity masquerading as information.

The rating system on that page is really silly: not only can you pretend to be a healthcare professional, you can vote as many times as you like. You just need to refresh the page. At the moment there are 48 votes from healthcare professionals and 47 votes from members of the public. I wonder how many people have really voted...
 
Congrats Linda!

How about this response though:

I am a medical practitioner since 1961 and a Homeopath since 1990 I decided I needed an extra tool and discovered this effective system of Medicine with a wealth of writings and experiece extending back now two centuries.

It is challenging as one knows if explores and understands the nature and origin of the disturbance and match it to a remedy in the right potency {that is succussed and diluted enough to match the energy of the disturbance ] that one can establish deep healing. This occurs often enough to keep one persisting.

Sometimes a better mind is needed and I wish I had a specialist with the necessary intellect to refer to. One needs to be a detective to tie threads together. As well as challenging it is enormous fun. A homeopath should be part of every Medical Team.


:boggled:
 
Is this you DeeTee?

Homeopathy has been so comprehensively debunked recently that its proponents seem ready to do anything to regain a vestige of credibility. So we are subjected to the unedifying spectacle of Mr Ullman promoting his book, which appears to be little more than a straw-grasping exercise. How is the knowledge that a "famous person used homeopathy a long time ago" meant to provide evidence for its efficacy? Famous people have also studied their horoscopes, had their fortunes told with crystal balls and believed that fairies lived at the bottom of the garden. Does the fact that they were famous mean all these things were true?

150 years ago, homeopathy was a "new" and, in comparison to the conventional medical therapies of the time, a gentle approach to the treatment of illness. The fact that people tried it out is hardly surprising. Today it has been firmly put in its place as an anachronistic irrelevance, in which no credible scientist has any belief, because there is no evidence it achieve anything better than a placebo can. The fact that homeopathy has found more modern proponents in such scientific juggernauts and luminaries as David Beckham and Tony Blair should serve as a red flag that it is complete and utter nonsense. Tony Blair has a track record of cognitive credulity, which ranges from a delusion that crystals in Mexican pyramids can energise his karma to fevered imaginings that Iraq posessed WMD.
 
Is this you DeeTee?
:)
Zat's me!

Is this you BJ, sowing seeds of destruction in the woo camp?
posted by Liz Brenton on 19 Dec 2007 at 10:11 am
I am interested in all alternative therapies and find most of them work much better than traditional medicine. I am currently using Tarot Cards to cure my flu. Last time it worked, within a few days I started to feel better.

It will always be the case that traditional medicine will look at tarot cards, homeopathy, astrology, etc. with hate - for they threaten their income.
:biggrin:
I find Tarot Cards are very effective for constipation - showing a woo the death card can make them cr*p their pants.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, I wasn't sure how to take that post either.
A completely woo woo or a cynic. :D


"I am interested in all alternative therapies and find most of them work much better than traditional medicine.

I am currently using Tarot Cards to cure my flu."


Classic. :D
 
Last edited:
Mr. Monkey,
You pointed me to this email of yours. So what?

By the way, I would really hate to be wasting my time with this. I have paid real money, £28.43 to be precise, to download this paper and I would not be happy to be attempting to discuss its contents with a bullsh!tter who has not read the paper, but just tries to bluff his way using abstracts and second-hand quotations. So, simple question, what is the penultimate word on page 823?

Hmmm. You've chosen to select one study of Elia of the many that he has done and that he has had published in various respected scientific journals. You seemed to pick reference #4 below. Its results find, "Thus, in 83% of the preparations the procedure of successive dilutions and succussions modified the physico-chemcial properties of water. In 50% of the samples the heat is in excess; in 35% of the samples pH was higher and in 38% of the samples the electrical conductivity was higher too." (p. 821).

Now, are you going to tell us that ALL of the below journals are really "homeopathic journals" and not serious scientific publications?

[1] V. Elia, M. Niccoli, Ann. New York Acad. Sci, 879 (1999) 241.
[2] V. Elia, M. Niccoli, J. Therm. Analysis and Calorimetry, 61 (2000) 527.
[3] V. Elia and M. Niccoli, J. of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry, 75 (2004) 815.
[4] V.Elia, S.Baiano, I.Duro, E.Napoli, M. Niccoli, L.Nonatelli, Homeopathy, 93 (2004) 144-150.
[5] V.Elia, E.Napoli, M. Niccoli, L.Nonatelli, A. Ramaglia & E.Ventimiglia, J. of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry, 78 (2004) 331.
[6] V. Elia, M. Marchese, M. Montanino, E. Napoli, M. Niccoli, L. Nonatelli, A. Ramaglia, J. Sol. Chem.,34 (2005) 947.
 
Mr. Monkey,
You pointed me to this email of yours. So what?



Hmmm. You've chosen to select one study of Elia of the many that he has done and that he has had published in various respected scientific journals. You seemed to pick reference #4 below. Its results find, "Thus, in 83% of the preparations the procedure of successive dilutions and succussions modified the physico-chemcial properties of water. In 50% of the samples the heat is in excess; in 35% of the samples pH was higher and in 38% of the samples the electrical conductivity was higher too." (p. 821).

Now, are you going to tell us that ALL of the below journals are really "homeopathic journals" and not serious scientific publications?

[1] V. Elia, M. Niccoli, Ann. New York Acad. Sci, 879 (1999) 241.
[2] V. Elia, M. Niccoli, J. Therm. Analysis and Calorimetry, 61 (2000) 527.
[3] V. Elia and M. Niccoli, J. of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry, 75 (2004) 815.
[4] V.Elia, S.Baiano, I.Duro, E.Napoli, M. Niccoli, L.Nonatelli, Homeopathy, 93 (2004) 144-150.
[5] V.Elia, E.Napoli, M. Niccoli, L.Nonatelli, A. Ramaglia & E.Ventimiglia, J. of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry, 78 (2004) 331.
[6] V. Elia, M. Marchese, M. Montanino, E. Napoli, M. Niccoli, L. Nonatelli, A. Ramaglia, J. Sol. Chem.,34 (2005) 947.

I note that you have not answered the specific question I asked as a check to ensure you had read the full text of the paper you cited.

Please answer that question. I am not going to go any further unless you can show you are not a bullsh!tter who is just regurgitating the abstracts of papers he has not read.

If your next post does not answer the question correctly I shall draw the obvious inference.

I also note you have failed to answer the more substantive question, which does rather get more to the heart of the matter;

"What is your opinion of the statistical methods used? "
 
Are we really talking about reference #4?
That has page numbers 144-150.
Does Dana mean #3?
 
Last edited:
Are we really talking about reference #4?
That has page numbers 144-150.
Does Dana mean #3?

I'm going to put some links in, since I went looking for the full texts. I have access to all except the first.

[1] Vittorio Elia and Marcella Niccoli. Thermodynamics of Extremely Diluted Aqueous Solutions. Ann. NY. Acad. Sci. 879 (1) 241-248 (1999)
[2] V. Elia and M. Niccoli. New Physico-chemical Properties of Water Induced by Mechanical Treatments. A calorimetric study at 25°C. J. Therm. Anal. Calorim. 61 (2) 527-537 (2000)
[3] V. Elia and M. Niccoli. New Physico-Chemical Properties of Extremely Diluted Aqueous Solutions. J. Therm. Anal. Calorim. 75 (3) 815-836 (2004)
[4] V. Elia, S. Baiano, I. Duro, E. Napoli, M. Niccoli, and L. Nonatelli. Permanent physico-chemical properties of extremely diluted aqueous solutions of homeopathic medicines. Homeopathy 93 (3) 144-150 (2004)
[5] V. Elia, E. Napoli, M. Niccoli, L. Nonatelli, A. Ramaglia, and E. Ventimiglia. New Physico-Chemical Properties of Extremely Diluted Aqueous Solutions - A calorimetric and conductivity study at 25°C. J. Therm. Anal. Calorim. 78 (1) 331-342 (2004)
[6] V. Elia, M. Marchese, M. Montanino, E. Napoli, M. Niccoli, L. Nonatelli, and A. Ramaglia. Hydrohysteretic Phenomena of "Extremely Diluted Solutions" Induced by Mechanical Treatments: A Calorimetric and Conductometric Study at 25°C. J. Solution Chem. 34 (8) 947-960 (2005)

And some newer ones:

V. Elia, L. Elia, P. Cacace, E. Napoli, M. Niccoli, and F. Savarese. "Extremely diluted solutions" as multi-variable systems - A study of calorimetric and conductometric behaviour as a function of the parameter time. J. Therm. Anal. Calorim. 84 (2) 317-323 (2006)

V. Elia, E. Napoli, and R. Germano. The "Memory of Water": an almost deciphered enigma. Dissipative structures in extremely dilute aqueous solutions. Homeopathy 96 (3) 163-169 (2007) (see this)

V. Elia, L. Elia, M. Marchese, M. Montanino, E. Napoli, M. Niccoli, L. Nonatelli, and F. Savarese. Interaction of "extremely dilute solutions" with aqueous solutions of hydrochloric acid and sodium hydroxide: A calorimetric study at 298K. J. Mol. Liq. 130 (1-3) 15-20 (2007)

V. Elia, L. Elia, M. Montanino, E. Napoli, M. Niccoli, and L. Nonatelli. Conductometric studies of the serially diluted and agitated solutions on an anomalous effect that depends on the dilution process. J. Mol. Liq. 135 (1-3) 158-165 (2007)
 
Even Gully does not seem to have been entirely convinced about the merits of homoeopathy. From here: He "might be induced to try" homoeopathy to "subdue a passing but troublesome symptom"? Hardly a resounding endorsement of a "holistic" therapy.

BY THE WAY...I HAVE A COPY OF GULLY'S 1846 BOOK, AND THERE IS NO REFERENCE TO THAT STATEMENT ON PAGE 83...AND THE BOOK ENDS ON PAGE 405, SO ANOTHER PERSON'S STATEMENT ABOUT PAGE 500+ IS DUBIOUS TOO.


In the 1856 edition you link to from your website, the statement in question appears on page 48.

And the 1846 edition catalogued here has 692 pages.
 
In the 1856 edition you link to from your website, the statement in question appears on page 48.

And the 1846 edition catalogued here has 692 pages.
Perhaps the remaining 287 pages just appear to be "blank" in Dana's copy. However, I am sure they contain the memory of words, and if he looks carefully he will find they are a far more effective commentary on homeopathy than the pages with less diluted, visible text that preceded them.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom