[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

I'm sure that even you can see the inherrent absurdity of that point.

You failed to display any grasp of freedom of speech issue in the UK. Don't complain when I point it out to you.

You have made zero declarations about freedom of speech in the UK. You have disputed nothing I have stated. You have only declared that I know not what I say.


Let us start over and have a conversation.

You may begin with the current issues of free speech in the UK concerning Holocaust denial.
 
- 6 million seems incorrect.

"Seems" how ?

It seems to be much less then that so I would like to determine what a more factual number would be to use. 5 million? 1 million? Why don't we stop with the charade and keep saying it's 6 million?

Because you just CLAIM it's not 6 million. Would you mind backing that up ?

- There never was a specific plan to exterminate Jews. The Final Solution seems to indicate it was about deportation.

http://www.ess.uwe.ac.uk/GENOCIDE/browning1.htm

- There never was any extermination camp. Nazis did not burn people alive in ovens. Only dead bodies cremated. Nazis never exterminated mass amounts of Jews in gas chambers. Nazis never shipped these people to the camps only to exterminate them in droves in a factory. They were labor and relocation camps.

And how can you tell, since you ignore the very people who LIVED in those camps ?

The Holocaust pertaining to the Jewish people seem to be largely exaggerated with fabricated elements and not even 6 million either. The Nazis did seem to have a greater plan for racial purity, but it was never just about the Jews.

And how does that make them less of the monsters that they were ?
 
Then explain why David Irving lost his court case, eh?

Cases like this are interesting. It's really the only time historical revisionists and conspiracy theorists' evidence sees a legitimate courtroom environment. It's a rare event.

I wish it happened more often. I see evidence that is accepted blindly by conspiracy theorists that would NEVER survive formal scrutiny all the time on this and other forums.

It's one thing to throw out unsubstantiated claims on an internet forum; it's quite another to expose them to expert scrutiny in a formal trial environment.
 
Anyway, you still haven't answered my question: how is this relevant ?

Well the conversation veered in that direction, but when you think about it is highly relevant.

What the European colonists did does not seem any different from what the Nazis did, but Nazis are evil and the colonists generally regarded as the great discoverers of the US.

People naturally are hesitant accepting that around 40 million Native Americans were exterminated by the colonists. If it is ok to question those numbers then why is it illegal in some places to question the Holocaust numbers?

By comparing these 2 events it more then illustrates the ridiculous bias in the discussion that occurs about the Holocaust.

And 1 million wouldn't be horrible enough to call the Nazis monsters ?

Did I ever say the Nazis weren't these horrible, baby-eating monsters? I just want to know what is more accurate. 1 million or 6 million?

1 million dead in the Holocaust.
 
Do you think OJ was innocent or guilty? Are some rulings incorrect? Yes.

If the gloves don't fit, you must acquit.

oj.jpg
 
- 6 million seems incorrect. It seems to be much less then that so I would like to determine what a more factual number would be to use. 5 million? 1 million? Why don't we stop with the charade and keep saying it's 6 million?

Because six million seems to be the number that best fits the historical evidence.

- There never was a specific plan to exterminate Jews.

A single specific plan, no. There were several. For example, Operation Reinhard, the plan to operate three extermination camps in Poland.

The Final Solution seems to indicate it was about deportation.

Only superficially.


- There never was any extermination camp.

There were three : Belzec, Treblinka, and Sobibor.

Nazis did not burn people alive in ovens.

This is true. They burned people alive in ditches instead.

Only dead bodies cremated.

We have testimony from the soldiers and officers responsible for setting the ditches on fire.

Nazis never exterminated mass amounts of Jews in gas chambers.

Treblinka alone had ten gas chambers with a capacity of something like five thousand people a day. Again, we have statements from the people responsible for constructing and running them (see, in particular, Erich Bauer, the so-called Gasmeister of Sobibor, who estimated that 350,000 Jews had been gassed at Sobibor alone, and that Sobibor had the smallest body count among the three camps.

Estimates for deaths at those three camps alone run to between 1.5 and 2 million Jews.


Nazis never shipped these people to the camps only to exterminate them in droves in a factory.

We have train records; more than 500,000 Jews were shipped to Belzec alone. If they were relocation camps, where were they relocated to (and how? Not by train.) If they were labor camps, what were they laboring on (and how did the product of their labor leave the camps? Not by train). I can even be more precise than that; the surviving records document at least 519,392, of which no more than five are known to have survived.

They were labor and relocation camps.

What kind of "labor" kills 500,000 people in a year and a half?
 
Did I ever say the Nazis weren't these horrible, baby-eating monsters? I just want to know what is more accurate. 1 million or 6 million?

1 million dead in the Holocaust.

1.7 million dead in Treblinka, Sobibor, and Belzec alone -- just three camps and a year and a half out of the total might of the German Reich -- suggests that six million is more accurate. 1 million is highly inaccurate even if no Jew died elsewhere in the Reich at all between 1935-1945, which of course is preposterous.
 
Well the conversation veered in that direction, but when you think about it is highly relevant.

What the European colonists did does not seem any different from what the Nazis did, but Nazis are evil and the colonists generally regarded as the great discoverers of the US.

Theres that "seem" again. When did the colonists round up the natives and kill them again?

People naturally are hesitant accepting that around 40 million Native Americans were exterminated by the colonists. If it is ok to question those numbers then why is it illegal in some places to question the Holocaust numbers?

Is it illegal where you live?


Did I ever say the Nazis weren't these horrible, baby-eating monsters? I just want to know what is more accurate. 1 million or 6 million?

1 million dead in the Holocaust.

And you can back up your number?
 
1.7 million dead in Treblinka, Sobibor, and Belzec alone -- just three camps and a year and a half out of the total might of the German Reich -- suggests that six million is more accurate. 1 million is highly inaccurate even if no Jew died elsewhere in the Reich at all between 1935-1945, which of course is preposterous.

How many of them were Jews? How did they exactly die? Are those numbers even accurate?

Maybe you all can start providing sources to prove your claim that 6 million Jews were systematically killed.
 
How many of them were Jews?

Those numbers are estimates for Jewish deaths. So, all of them.

How did they exactly die?

In the gas chambers, for the most part. The procedure is well-documented. Although it's not clear how relevant this question is. If the Germans had decided to machine-gun them instead, would they be less dead?

Are those numbers even accurate?

To the best available historical evidence, yes. They're "estimates," which implies a certain amount of guesswork. But on the other hand, we know of 500,000 Jews that went into Belzec and died there.


Maybe you all can start providing sources to prove your claim that 6 million Jews were systematically killed.

Start with Yitzhak Arad, The Operation Reinhard Death Camps. If you want something web-accessible, start at www.holocaust-history.org and work from there.
 

Lying About Hitler (Richard Evans) is another good source. It covers most of the general details and specifically refutes many of the lies told in the name of Holocaust denial. (It is, of course, a book-version of Evans' expert report at the Irving trial. So if you think the Irving case was mis-decided, perhaps you can also point to the errors of fact in the fairly damning expert report....)
 
With all due respect, Jerome, the link is the content. Also, I will give Gravy a pass here, as I think that Holocaust deniers and racists are worthy of nothing but contempt. However, if the poster feels offended, he/she can always report the offending remark.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom