[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

With all due respect, Jerome, the link is the content. Also, I will give Gravy a pass here, as I think that Holocaust deniers and racists are worthy of nothing but contempt. However, if the poster feels offended, he/she can always report the offending remark.

I would contend that it would be proper to draw something from the link to evidence a claim.

The insults are just tasteless.
 
Do you think OJ was innocent or guilty? Are some rulings incorrect? Yes.

Indeed, but not this one as any review of the evidence will show...

Finally Irving gripped the small podium in front of him and challenged Robert Jan to go to Auschwitz "with a trowel and clean away the gravel and find a reinforced concrete hole". If the holes were found Irving proclaimed "I would happily abandon my action immediately... It would drive such a hole through my case that I would have no possible chance of defending it any further"

Between the closure of the case and the appeal...

Harry Mazal, an engineer and expert in Computer Science carefully examined the remains of the roof of Crema 2. Using computer modelling and mathematical analysis they found what they believe to be 3 of the 4 holes. Van Pelt asked a professional engineer to review these findings. He found them so compelling that they were appended to Van Pelts 2nd report and submitted to the court of appeal.

David Irving subsequently withdrew, before review, both of the documents he had submitted as the basis of his appeal...

He lost, he lost fair and square on the basis that his own evidence was found to be flawed not to say engineered...

From the QC's summing up...

"Irving's treatment of the historical evidence is so perverse and egregious that it is difficult to accept that it is inadvertance on his part.....<snip> He has deliberately skewed the evidence to bring it in line with his political beliefs"

To put this into context a judge attended a dinner near the end of the trial which Lipstadt happened to be at, he gave her a warning...

"Do not anticipate a rousing condemnation of Irving from Charles Gray. British judges practice judicial restraint. A judge who believes a witness lied will say 'I did not find this witness helpful' Everyone at the Law Courts knows this is judicial shorthand for 'He's a liar'. THe judge however is not going to say so..."

That's how damning this verdict was, a total and utter refutation of everything Irving had launched the case for. He was proved to be a liar, a charlatan and a poor historian...
 
Fourth time, kageki:

http://www.nizkor.org/

Will you stop being an ignorant baby, and try to be a rational adult? Can you?

What exactly is the point of just linking the entirety of the site? I've read the articles on there and I don't find some of them persuasive especially on the contentious issues. Gravy why is it so hard for you to debate the specific issues?

Was it 6 million? Isn't the conservative estimate 5-6 million?

Would you have a problem if I said that 5 million Jews died in the Holocaust and not 6 million? 3 million?
 
What exactly is the point of just linking the entirety of the site? I've read the articles on there and I don't find some of them persuasive especially on the contentious issues. Gravy why is it so hard for you to debate the specific issues?
Yeah, it's too much to ask that you get informed about the subject you're whining about.

I gave you the link to the 66 IHR questions that Nizkor answered, and asked you to present your case as to specifically what they get wrong.

I guess you can't, and you're just here to whine. That's sad.
 
Last edited:
Was it 6 million? Isn't the conservative estimate 5-6 million?

Yes, that's the accepted (and historically supported) range of estimates, although most of the estimates are at the higher end of that range. Anywhere reasonably close is fine by me.


Would you have a problem if I said that 5 million Jews died in the Holocaust and not 6 million?

A problem? No. I might have a suspicion, though. Why are you deliberately cherry-picking from the lower end of the range? (Similarly, what is "conservative" about 5 million instead of 6 million? Why is it "conservative" to minimize deaths? Who or what are you trying to "conserve," and against what are you protecting it?)

3 million?

Given that that's somewhere between 50-60% of the accepted figures, I would say that that's not a very good estimate. No, I'd say that's a very bad estimate. If you really knew nothing about the Holocaust, I might be willing to consider a mis-statement of that magnitude to be a correctable error borne of ignorance. But that's obviously not the case. You're obviously familiar with the more traditional number of 6 million. On what basis do you reject 6 million and prefer 3?
 
Say, did any of the resident Holocaust deniers ever answer my question about if the Holocaust didn't happen does that make the Nazis a swell bunch who were just misunderstood?
 
Say, did any of the resident Holocaust deniers ever answer my question about if the Holocaust didn't happen does that make the Nazis a swell bunch who were just misunderstood?

I think that was the limited number of posts where they tried to claim that Poland "had it coming to them", to coin a phrase. :rolleyes:
 
A problem? No. I might have a suspicion, though. Why are you deliberately cherry-picking from the lower end of the range?

Why are you deliberately cherry-picking from the higher end of the range? How about 5.5 million dead?

If it's perfectly ok to use the higher estimate of 6 million then I don't see any reason why I can't say 5 million when I believe that is a more factual number.

Is nizkor the only valid source for the figure or where do you get your source from?


(Similarly, what is "conservative" about 5 million instead of 6 million? Why is it "conservative" to minimize deaths? Who or what are you trying to "conserve," and against what are you protecting it?)

Are you people seriously that afraid to be labeled a neo-Nazi that you would go this far to appease the Holocaust survivors? You well know what a "conservative estimate" is supposed to mean. There is always a "conservative" estimate and a higher estimate.

I don't think any scholar would point out something silly like that in my use of the word "conservative estimate".
 
I was in Saudi for a while. I'm familiar with the views espoused by some in those parts of the world. It saddens me. But then their views on religion and appropriate punishments also worry me. Fortunately it seems geographically restricted.

Perhaps our little anti-semites should emmigrate?

I see from the recent case where a rape victim was sentenced to be flogged that it hasn't changed much since I was there. One side effect is that I'm never likely to refer to the USA as a police state run by religious fundamentalists.
 
Well, it IS fundamentally wrong, because it's a tu quoque, basically.

When it's used as an excuse - which it often is, for example on this thread - then it's fundamentally wrong.

However, if someone is claiming that what the Nazis did was unprecedented and totally unique in human history, then it's legitimate to point out a long list of atrocities, committed for many different reasons.

This is not a harmful thing to do. The way to learn from the Nazis is not to hive them off into a seperate compartment of history. What they did is being done still. In 1945 it might have seemed that racial strife had been brought to an end, and the big struggle would be between economic models. That's not what's happened. There are mini-Nazis all over the world, killing their neighbours.
 
Why are you deliberately cherry-picking from the higher end of the range? How about 5.5 million dead?

If it's perfectly ok to use the higher estimate of 6 million then I don't see any reason why I can't say 5 million when I believe that is a more factual number.

Is nizkor the only valid source for the figure or where do you get your source from?


Are you people seriously that afraid to be labeled a neo-Nazi that you would go this far to appease the Holocaust survivors? You well know what a "conservative estimate" is supposed to mean. There is always a "conservative" estimate and a higher estimate.

I don't think any scholar would point out something silly like that in my use of the word "conservative estimate".

How many people were killed in the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki in the Empire of Japan?
 
Oh, BTW, I take it that those of you who think Poland provoked Hitler are entirely cool with the invasion and occupation of Iraq, right?
 
Well the conversation veered in that direction, but when you think about it is highly relevant.

What the European colonists did does not seem any different from what the Nazis did, but Nazis are evil and the colonists generally regarded as the great discoverers of the US.

People naturally are hesitant accepting that around 40 million Native Americans were exterminated by the colonists. If it is ok to question those numbers then why is it illegal in some places to question the Holocaust numbers?

By comparing these 2 events it more then illustrates the ridiculous bias in the discussion that occurs about the Holocaust.



Did I ever say the Nazis weren't these horrible, baby-eating monsters? I just want to know what is more accurate. 1 million or 6 million?

1 million dead in the Holocaust.

Kageki - you have my permission to use my shorter summary of your "position"

By best guess at the moment is that it's the following:

"Your" ancestors killed millions of people which means that killing millions of people isn't unusual and since today you aren't consumed by guilt about what your ancestors did it means you don't really think genocide is that bad, so even though the Nazi's didn't kill millions of people, you hypocritically think the Nazi's are terrible and evil because they killed millions of people, which they didn't, but Jews smell.
 
When it's used as an excuse - which it often is, for example on this thread - then it's fundamentally wrong.

However, if someone is claiming that what the Nazis did was unprecedented and totally unique in human history, then it's legitimate to point out a long list of atrocities, committed for many different reasons.

This is not a harmful thing to do. The way to learn from the Nazis is not to hive them off into a seperate compartment of history. What they did is being done still. In 1945 it might have seemed that racial strife had been brought to an end, and the big struggle would be between economic models. That's not what's happened. There are mini-Nazis all over the world, killing their neighbours.

Only as long as the comparisons you are making are in fact apple to apple and not apple to pear. For example the Nazi's (as far as I am) aware were the first group to "industrialise" their attempt at genocide.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom