Do you think OJ was innocent or guilty? Are some rulings incorrect? Yes.
Indeed, but not this one as any review of the evidence will show...
Finally Irving gripped the small podium in front of him and challenged Robert Jan to go to Auschwitz "with a trowel and clean away the gravel and find a reinforced concrete hole". If the holes were found Irving proclaimed "I would happily abandon my action immediately... It would drive such a hole through my case that I would have no possible chance of defending it any further"
Between the closure of the case and the appeal...
Harry Mazal, an engineer and expert in Computer Science carefully examined the remains of the roof of Crema 2. Using computer modelling and mathematical analysis they found what they believe to be 3 of the 4 holes. Van Pelt asked a professional engineer to review these findings. He found them so compelling that they were appended to Van Pelts 2nd report and submitted to the court of appeal.
David Irving subsequently withdrew, before review, both of the documents he had submitted as the basis of his appeal...
He lost, he lost fair and square on the basis that his own evidence was found to be flawed not to say engineered...
From the QC's summing up...
"Irving's treatment of the historical evidence is so perverse and egregious that it is difficult to accept that it is inadvertance on his part.....<snip> He has deliberately skewed the evidence to bring it in line with his political beliefs"
To put this into context a judge attended a dinner near the end of the trial which Lipstadt happened to be at, he gave her a warning...
"Do not anticipate a rousing condemnation of Irving from Charles Gray. British judges practice judicial restraint. A judge who believes a witness lied will say 'I did not find this witness helpful' Everyone at the Law Courts knows this is judicial shorthand for 'He's a liar'. THe judge however is not going to say so..."
That's how damning this verdict was, a total and utter refutation of everything Irving had launched the case for. He was proved to be a liar, a charlatan and a poor historian...