[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

By best guess at the moment is that it's the following:

"Your" ancestors killed millions of people which means that killing millions of people isn't unusual and since today you aren't consumed by guilt about what your ancestors did it means you don't really think genocide is that bad, so even though the Nazi's didn't kill millions of people, you hypocritically think the Nazi's are terrible and evil because they killed millions of people, which they didn't, but Jews smell.

Yeah, I think that sums it up, quite nicely.
 
Why are we suddenly talking about Native Americans ? Let's get back on topic, folks.

It's relevant in the sense that there are three ways to deny the Holocaust. We've seen all three on this thread.

The first is to just say that it didn't happen. This is clearly the silliest. The evidence is overwhelming that regardless of details, the Nazis killed many millions of people due to their race.

The second is to refuse to deny the holocaust, but to concentrate on minor issues and say that one isn't denying anything. This can be addressed by repeatedly stressing the big picture and ignoring the side issues. Does it matter whether it was six million or five million? Clearly it matters, but saying it was five million doesn't exonerate the Nazis.

The third form of denial is to say, yes the Nazis did terrible things, but the Russians were as bad, the Americans dropped the atom bomb, and the British burned Dresden. Aren't they all the same? This is a difficult one to counter, since it's not fundamentally wrong. Ultimately, it's a matter of personal judgement to say that the Nazi extermination of millions on racist grounds is in a different category from what the Allies did in trying to end the war and save the people that the Nazis were trying to murder.
 
Elementary tool used to influence others to disregard content which you can not counter.

Do you really think those on this forum fall for such playground tactics?

Maybe you should present your wears at nickelodeon.com
What, and ruin your gig? Wouldn't think of intruding on your territory!
But thanks for thinking of me!
 
Ironically, Schinler's List is on digital here in the UK this evening.

Doubltess our little anti-semites will hand-wave it away as propoganda, fabrication, or a combination of both.

The irony, as I've said before, is that it doesn't really matter what these fellows think. The Holocaust is accepted as fact in most of the world. Europe (especially Europe), the Americas, and Antipodes. It's taught in school. It's covered extensively in libraries and other learning resources.

In contrast, our little friends are hounded (rightly) for their racist, anti-semetic views. They are (rightly) denied a mouthpiece in mainstream publicaiton. They have no hold in the academic world. They are, in fact, illegal in several countries.

So I don't really think it matters what they say. Few people listen, fewer still care. That the Nazi apologists, the anti-semites, and the racists continue to hold their views is nothing more than a damning indictment on the hatred, small-mindedness, and sheer ignorance of people. That's about it.

Moreover they apparently hide behind the freedom of expression set out in the US constitution. They can't prove their assertions about the Holocaust being a fake, so they need a system which tolerates this rubbish. They want to wage war on other races, and live in a system which appears reluctant to fetter such actions. Oh, these clowns in the BNP would give their eye-teeth to be able to spout the same claptrap in public.

For one, I'm 100% glad to be in a country where the law acts to prevent the worst of their bile being played out on the public stage. And frankly I don't care if they don't like it. They can always come over and complain. I can't want to see what happens to them.......
 
Last edited:
Elementary tool used to influence others to disregard content which you can not counter.

Cut down by me so I can ask.

Are you stating that JimBenArm is an "elementary tool..."? or that he uses... never mind.
 
Last edited:
But there's a part of the world where their view is not only accepted, but dominant, and where they not only have a hold in academia, but are the only viewpoint permitted.
I was in Saudi for a while. I'm familiar with the views espoused by some in those parts of the world. It saddens me. But then their views on religion and appropriate punishments also worry me. Fortunately it seems geographically restricted.

Perhaps our little anti-semites should emmigrate?
 
Last edited:
There are certain things, in the presence of which, one should only close the curtains and tiptoe silently away.
 
For one, I'm 100% glad to be in a country where the law acts to prevent the worst of their bile being played out on the public stage. And frankly I don't care if they don't like it. They can always come over and complain. I can't want to see what happens to them.......

One should be careful of happiness with legal presidents set which curtail speech.
 
One should be careful of happiness with legal presidents set which curtail speech.


Your ignorance of the law, and the protection of human rights in the UK, is quite spectacular. Tell me, do you research everything quite so well, or is this just a temporary blip on the horizon?
 
Anything more about Holocaust denial? Atrain disappeared quite a while ago; Magz merely hopped in and out; Kageki seems to have disappeared, too, though it may have something to do with time zones. What we are left with is JdG's failure to spellcheck. (Or since "president" is spelled correctly, maybe his crime was to rely on a spellcheck program rather than a dictionary. Any librarian could have told him not to do that.) So it goes.

I'm still wondering how the guys down at the beer hall, or at Joe Goebbels' Bar'n'Grill, took to Kageki, who says he is of Japanese ancestry. K, would you respond?
 
Just as an aside, I thought that this quote from the judgment against Irving was rather appropriate in the context of the current discussion:

It is not difficult to discern a pattern to the activities and attitudes to which I have alluded in the preceding paragraph. Over the past fifteen years or so, Irving appears to have become more active politically than was previously the case. He speaks regularly at political or quasi-political meetings in Germany, the United States, Canada and the New World. The content of his speeches and interviews often displays a distinctly pro-Nazi and anti-Jewish bias. He makes surprising and often unfounded assertions about the Nazi regime which tend to exonerate the Nazis for the appalling atrocities which they inflicted on the Jews. He is content to mix with neo-fascists and appears to share many of their racist and anti-semitic prejudices. The picture of Irving which emerges from the evidence of his extra-curricular activities reveals him to be a right-wing pro-Nazi polemicist. In my view the Defendants have established that Irving has a political agenda. It is one which, it is legitimate to infer, disposes him, where he deems it necessary, to manipulate the historical record in order to make it conform with his political beliefs.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom