[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

Only as long as the comparisons you are making are in fact apple to apple and not apple to pear. For example the Nazi's (as far as I am) aware were the first group to "industrialise" their attempt at genocide.

Exactly. It's a tricky business to compare the different atrocities of the twentieth century, and there's considerable scope for the likes of Kageki to throw in random horrors out of history and to imply that the Nazis weren't so special after all. To show that what they did was unique and uniquely reprehensible, it's necessary to show that not only did they kill many millions of people, they did so in an organised, planned way using the full resources of a modern state.

It's a reasonable thing to compare what they did with the other mass exterminations of the twentieth century, and the extent to which Stalin's actions are apples or pears is a matter of judgement.
 
Exactly. It's a tricky business to compare the different atrocities of the twentieth century, and there's considerable scope for the likes of Kageki to throw in random horrors out of history and to imply that the Nazis weren't so special after all. To show that what they did was unique and uniquely reprehensible, it's necessary to show that not only did they kill many millions of people, they did so in an organised, planned way using the full resources of a modern state.

It's a reasonable thing to compare what they did with the other mass exterminations of the twentieth century, and the extent to which Stalin's actions are apples or pears is a matter of judgement.

Nazis didn't have a death factory. That is the crux of the Holocaust debate and the sole reason why Nazis are considered so evil.

Even without a death factory, it's pretty clear the Nazis did kill many people not unlike any other country during war.

It turns out it's not even unique because the colonists did exactly the same thing to Native Americans and killed more. 100 million dead.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_history_of_American_indigenous_peoples
Historian David Stannard is of the opinion that the indigenous peoples of America (including Hawaii[16]) were the victims of a "Euro-American genocidal war."[17] While conceding that the majority of the indigenous peoples fell victim to the ravages of European disease, he estimates that almost 100 million died in what he calls the American Holocaust.[18] Stannard's perspective has been joined by Kirkpatrick Sale, Ben Kiernan, Lenore A. Stiffarm, and Phil Lane, Jr., among others; the perspective has been further refined by Ward Churchill, who has said that "it was precisely malice, not nature, that did the deed."[17] -- the Europeans chose to spread diseases.

Off course this notion of an American Holocaust and targeted genocide is contested. Not a surprise as it would would lose the raison d'etre to demonize Nazis. Nazis are the most convenient scapegoats of history.

Germans never had a death factory. Maybe people should be reminded that the original neo-Nazi, racist, sick bastards are Germans and they bring up good points.

No gas chambers. No ovens. Not even close to 6 million.
 
The derail in regards to Iraq has been moved, pelase keep to the topic under discussion.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Darat
 
Nazis didn't have a death factory. That is the crux of the Holocaust debate and the sole reason why Nazis are considered so evil.

Even without a death factory, it's pretty clear the Nazis did kill many people not unlike any other country during war.

It turns out it's not even unique because the colonists did exactly the same thing to Native Americans and killed more. 100 million dead.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_history_of_American_indigenous_peoples


Off course this notion of an American Holocaust and targeted genocide is contested. Not a surprise as it would would lose the raison d'etre to demonize Nazis. Nazis are the most convenient scapegoats of history.

Germans never had a death factory. Maybe people should be reminded that the original neo-Nazi, racist, sick bastards are Germans and they bring up good points.

No gas chambers. No ovens. Not even close to 6 million.

kageki - using this would be a lot quicker for you:


By best guess at the moment is that it's the following:

"Your" ancestors killed millions of people which means that killing millions of people isn't unusual and since today you aren't consumed by guilt about what your ancestors did it means you don't really think genocide is that bad, so even though the Nazi's didn't kill millions of people, you hypocritically think the Nazi's are terrible and evil because they killed millions of people, which they didn't, but Jews smell.
 
Nazis didn't have a death factory. That is the crux of the Holocaust debate and the sole reason why Nazis are considered so evil.

Even without a death factory, it's pretty clear the Nazis did kill many people not unlike any other country during war.

It turns out it's not even unique because the colonists did exactly the same thing to Native Americans and killed more. 100 million dead.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Populat...genous_peoples
Actually, it's a stupid and idiotic comparison only someone who failed history would use. The problem being that some of the Indians died out of stupidity and not malice. The number you are citing does not make that distinction and if you bothered to read wikipedia it looks like it was pulled out of someones behind.
 
Originally Posted by Darat View Post
By best guess at the moment is that it's the following:

"Your" ancestors killed millions of people which means that killing millions of people isn't unusual and since today you aren't consumed by guilt about what your ancestors did it means you don't really think genocide is that bad, so even though the Nazi's didn't kill millions of people, you hypocritically think the Nazi's are terrible and evil because they killed millions of people, which they didn't, but Jews smell.

What? Nazis did kill millions. No one is denying that so there is no hypocrisy.

What is being specifically disputed is whether they had "industrialized" killing factories or that 6 million Jews really died. Were they really extermination camps or was it just labor camps?

I'm starting to think that was all made up. They were probably decent camps too.
 
...snip..

I'm starting to think that was all made up. They were probably decent camps too.

You are now lying.

There is nothing in the evidence presented in this thread by other Members that casts any doubt on whether "it" happened therefore you are obviously lying and you had already decided that it "was all made up", or for whatever reason, you wish to deny "it" happened.

Why you have decided to promote lies and nonsense is of course only known to yourself however you have served a useful function in this thread in that anyone following it will have quickly understand how your bigoted and hate filled statements can easily be shown to be lies.
 
Last edited:
Actually, it's a stupid and idiotic comparison only someone who failed history would use. The problem being that some of the Indians died out of stupidity and not malice. The number you are citing does not make that distinction and if you bothered to read wikipedia it looks like it was pulled out of someones behind.

Oh now they died out of stupidity? That's a pretty bold statement with nothing to back it up although a few historians seem to disagree with you. You care to tell some Native Americans that? Maybe not the 100 million, but 40 million at least.

Do I sniff denial in the worst degree? It's a perfect comparison to the Holocaust.

Bunch of white folks from Europe who massacred anyone not white as them. I fail to see how that is any different from Nazi racial ideology. Indeed the literature seems to indicate the Europeans were pursuing something like that.

So no Nazis were not unique in their pursuit in any way. No death factories either.
 
What the European colonists did does not seem any different from what the Nazis did, but Nazis are evil and the colonists generally regarded as the great discoverers of the US.

Again, how is that relevant ? We're not talking about the colonists.

People naturally are hesitant accepting that around 40 million Native Americans were exterminated by the colonists. If it is ok to question those numbers then why is it illegal in some places to question the Holocaust numbers?

I don't really care. Start another thread if you want to.

Did I ever say the Nazis weren't these horrible, baby-eating monsters? I just want to know what is more accurate. 1 million or 6 million?

1 million dead in the Holocaust.

Evidence, please.
 
Whilst there may be some legitimate reasons to discuss other examples of large scale exterminations and/or genocides, this thread is about what the thread title says it is: "The Holocaust never happened!" ensure your discussions are directly relevant to the thread topic.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Darat
 
How many of them were Jews? How did they exactly die? Are those numbers even accurate?

Maybe you all can start providing sources to prove your claim that 6 million Jews were systematically killed.

How is the testimony of people who were there, on both sides of the fence, not enough ?
 
You are now lying.

There is nothing in the evidence presented in this thread by other Members that casts any doubt on whether "it" happened therefore you are obviously lying and you had already decided that it "was all made up", or for whatever reason, you wish to deny "it" happened.

Why you have decided to promote lies and nonsense is of course only known to yourself however you have served a useful function in this thread in that anyone following it will have quickly understand how your bigoted and hate filled statements can easily be shown to be lies.

My decision is not final off course, but that is my inclination based on analysis.

What lie? That the Holocaust never happened?

http://www.adelaideinstitute.org/Auschwitz/truth.htm

The testimonies admit the Nazi doctors helped elders. Why would they have orchestras and swimming pools just to kill them? It's stated inmates had access to them.
 
Why are you deliberately cherry-picking from the higher end of the range? How about 5.5 million dead?

If it's perfectly ok to use the higher estimate of 6 million then I don't see any reason why I can't say 5 million when I believe that is a more factual number.

Boo-hoo, tu quoque, man!! Tu quoque!

Are you people seriously that afraid to be labeled a neo-Nazi that you would go this far to appease the Holocaust survivors?

And there we have it. Next you'll claim we're all on the Jews' payroll.

Nazis didn't have a death factory.

Three gas chambers in ONE champ ? How do you call that ?

It turns out it's not even unique because the colonists did exactly the same thing to Native Americans and killed more. 100 million dead.

It's 100, now ?

Nazis are the most convenient scapegoats of history.

Yeah, I mean, give Hitler a break! He just wanted to be an artist!

No gas chambers. No ovens. Not even close to 6 million.

No gravity, no sun, no oxygen. It's all a conspiracy!
 
My decision is not final off course, but that is my inclination based on analysis.

What lie? That the Holocaust never happened?

http://www.adelaideinstitute.org/Auschwitz/truth.htm

The testimonies admit the Nazi doctors helped elders. Why would they have orchestras and swimming pools just to kill them? It's stated inmates had access to them.


I clearly indicated which of your statements I was mentioning i.e:

"..I'm starting to think that was all made up... "

Many of your other statements and assertions in this thread are also lies in that they are factually incorrect and you are making them in an attempt to deceive people.
 
How is the testimony of people who were there, on both sides of the fence, not enough ?

Because they don't talk about exterminations. Only a few it seems talk specifically about gas chambers and ovens.

Don't tell me about burning pits either. Dead or alive. It is doubtful whether that is even possible as it's being hotly debated on the skeptics forum.

You have some testimonies that are faked. Some forced. Some biased like this French resistance member championed by Holocaust promoters. If you like to continue tossing out this general claim about testimonies then let's start breaking it down.

Where is the evidence? Are there any examinations being done today on the concentration camps?
 
Last edited:
Kageki,

I have loitered here long enough reading your indignant posts.
As far as I am aware no Germans took the "we were just delousing people" or "there were NO ovens and NO gas chambers" when brought to justice at nuremburg or since.

Instead (and I'm no historian) they mostly relied on the "I was just following orders" or "I knew nothing about that".


Do you not think that it makes you look silly that you, with the benefit of fifty years of hindsight and the accumulated works of historians, interest groups and academics are now trying to argue a case that the perpetrators themselves (and anyone else in the intervening period) has not?

It would help prop up your preposterous case if they did.

It is a testament to you and your argument that I have been a quiet watcher here (for a year or more) through realistice, Killtown and Max Photon and yet you get me to finally get off my backside, not that you wil get any of those references mind you I have a suspicion that you don't read much.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom