[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

:eek: Christopher Columbus killed 6 million American Natives between 1650 and 1990! That murderous old devil!

-Gumboot

Well I don't think Columbus was around by then was he? Maybe you forgot the 40 million in 1492 to 8 million in 1650?

Way to remain in denial about the ethnic cleansing of Native Americans. But you see Columbus was a good old chap! Apparently Native Americans would disagree with you Gumboot. Do you have the courage to say your praises about Columbus to a Native American's face?

http://www.hartford-hwp.com/archives/41/385.html
 
About the Irving trial: first, assume my ignorance of the English legal system.

I had always heard that the burden is very much on the defendant in a libel/ slander trial. In the US, the general saying (which is probably incomplete or only accurate to some degree) is that the truth, in these cases, is a sure defense. If I say Fred chops puppies for breakfast, and he sues me, but it turns out that he does chop etc., he's not going to win his case.

I was honestly surprised when he lost the English case. There is no question that rude things had been said publicly about him, by Lipstadt as well as others. Did the decision break precedent in some way, or is it just my failure to understand?
 
Last edited:
Well I don't think Columbus was around by then was he? Maybe you forgot the 40 million in 1492 to 8 million in 1650?

Way to remain in denial about the ethnic cleansing of Native Americans. But you see Columbus was a good old chap! Apparently Native Americans would disagree with you Gumboot. Do you have the courage to say your praises about Columbus to a Native American's face?

http://www.hartford-hwp.com/archives/41/385.html

He's back! He's bad!

He's leading the fight for Native American rights...???

Yo, K. What about the Holocaust? You know, the one in Europe in 1938-45 (generally considered as the defining dates: Kristallnacht to VE day.)
 
About the Irving trial: first, assume my ignorance of the English legal system.

I had always heard that the burden is very much on the defendant in a libel/ slander trial. In the US, the general saying (which is probably incomplete or only accurate to some degree) is that the truth, in these cases, is a sure defense. If I say Fred chops puppies for breakfast, and he sues me, but it turns out that he does chop etc., he's not going to win his case.

I was honestly surprised when he lost the English case. There is no question that rude things had been said publicly about him, by Lipstadt as well as others. Did the decision break precedent in some way, or is it just my failure to understand?


Correct, however it is your failure to understand the English legal system but also the wider case that is of note here.

For a start, Irving was not the defendant. He was the Pursuer. Irving sued Dr. Lipstadt and her British publisher, Penguin Books Ltd., for libel, saying his reputation as an historian was defamed. The suit was filed in England, where libel laws favour the plaintiff.

Irving represented himself.

Judge Gray found that Irving had "for his own ideological reasons persistently and deliberately misrepresented and manipulated historical evidence" in order to portray Hitler "in an unwarrantedly favourable light" particularly in his treatment of the Jews. Irving had "significantly" misrepresented, misconstrued, omitted, mistranslated, misread and applied double standards to the historical evidence in order to achieve his ideological presentation of history.

Judge Gray also found that Irving was an "active Holocaust denier; that he is anti-semite and racist, and that he associates with right-wing extremists who promote neo-Nazism".

Irving's appeal was dismissed.
 
Last edited:
I just have a problem when unsupportable numbers are thrown about willy nilly; and to question those numbers one is called names as a counter.

Well estimated numbers have been reached between scholars apparently. Yeah thinking how the great country of the USA was founded by the systematic slaughter that resulted in about 40 million Native Americans dead is definitely hard to wrap your head around.

Is the 6 million supported for the Holocaust? Why not 5 million? I'm thinking it's actually 1 million or less.
 
Well estimated numbers have been reached between scholars apparently. Yeah thinking how the great country of the USA was founded by the systematic slaughter that resulted in about 40 million Native Americans dead is definitely hard to wrap your head around.

I see hyperbole and appeal to emotion has been honed to a fine art here.
 
I note with some amusement that you have veered away from the kicking you're getting on Holocaust Denial.

Let me make life easy for you.

The genocide, whether deliberate or otherwise, of the natives in the Americas following European contact is a tragedy. No matter whether 100 thousand or a million died, it is a matter of great import and regret. All of us should be shamed by it.

However no-one is suggesting that the deaths occured, and that a considerable proportion of the populations fell victim to (for example) imported diseases and general deprivation. No-one is suggesting that it was a massive plot orchestrated by the Native Americans. There are laws to prevent (or at least try to prevent) genocide.

Now, unless you're suggesting that this in some way exonerates the perpetrators of all subsequent murders, get back to the point at hand.
 
Aye, well, you're playing free and easy with interpretation of fact so there's no reason to assume that your approach to grammar would be any better.....
 
Your ignorance of the law, and the protection of human rights in the UK, is quite spectacular. Tell me, do you research everything quite so well, or is this just a temporary blip on the horizon?

Nice job at not responding to the content and attacking the knowledge base of the poster.
 
The third form of denial is to say, yes the Nazis did terrible things, but the Russians were as bad, the Americans dropped the atom bomb, and the British burned Dresden. Aren't they all the same? This is a difficult one to counter, since it's not fundamentally wrong. Ultimately, it's a matter of personal judgement to say that the Nazi extermination of millions on racist grounds is in a different category from what the Allies did in trying to end the war and save the people that the Nazis were trying to murder.

Well, it IS fundamentally wrong, because it's a tu quoque, basically.
 
Well I don't think Columbus was around by then was he? Maybe you forgot the 40 million in 1492 to 8 million in 1650?

Way to remain in denial about the ethnic cleansing of Native Americans. But you see Columbus was a good old chap! Apparently Native Americans would disagree with you Gumboot. Do you have the courage to say your praises about Columbus to a Native American's face?

http://www.hartford-hwp.com/archives/41/385.html

Who's "praising Columbus" ? And if somebody's praising him, it's surely not for murder.

Anyway, you still haven't answered my question: how is this relevant ?

Is the 6 million supported for the Holocaust? Why not 5 million? I'm thinking it's actually 1 million or less.

And 1 million wouldn't be horrible enough to call the Nazis monsters ?
 
He's back! He's bad!

He's leading the fight for Native American rights...???

Yo, K. What about the Holocaust? You know, the one in Europe in 1938-45 (generally considered as the defining dates: Kristallnacht to VE day.)

Is there anything wrong in standing up for the Native Americans?

What about the Holocaust? The ethnic cleansing of Native Americans completely dwarfs that, but let's try to get to the bottom of the Holocaust.


- 6 million seems incorrect. It seems to be much less then that so I would like to determine what a more factual number would be to use. 5 million? 1 million? Why don't we stop with the charade and keep saying it's 6 million?

- There never was a specific plan to exterminate Jews. The Final Solution seems to indicate it was about deportation.

- There never was any extermination camp. Nazis did not burn people alive in ovens. Only dead bodies cremated. Nazis never exterminated mass amounts of Jews in gas chambers. Nazis never shipped these people to the camps only to exterminate them in droves in a factory. They were labor and relocation camps.

The Holocaust pertaining to the Jewish people seem to be largely exaggerated with fabricated elements and not even 6 million either. The Nazis did seem to have a greater plan for racial purity, but it was never just about the Jews.
 
Nice job at not responding to the content and attacking the knowledge base of the poster.

I'm sure that even you can see the inherrent absurdity of that point.

You failed to display any grasp of freedom of speech issue in the UK. Don't complain when I point it out to you.
 
Is there anything wrong in standing up for the Native Americans?

What about the Holocaust? The ethnic cleansing of Native Americans completely dwarfs that, but let's try to get to the bottom of the Holocaust.


- 6 million seems incorrect. It seems to be much less then that so I would like to determine what a more factual number would be to use. 5 million? 1 million? Why don't we stop with the charade and keep saying it's 6 million?

- There never was a specific plan to exterminate Jews. The Final Solution seems to indicate it was about deportation.

- There never was any extermination camp. Nazis did not burn people alive in ovens. Only dead bodies cremated. Nazis never exterminated mass amounts of Jews in gas chambers. Nazis never shipped these people to the camps only to exterminate them in droves in a factory. They were labor and relocation camps.

The Holocaust pertaining to the Jewish people seem to be largely exaggerated with fabricated elements and not even 6 million either. The Nazis did seem to have a greater plan for racial purity, but it was never just about the Jews.

Then explain why David Irving lost his court case, eh?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom