[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

It's amazing that this real fleet traveling from across the planet was never detected by the US radar system...
Uh, radars at Pearl Harbor were capable of detecting warships hundreds of miles away?

when even Australia warned the US about the Japanese fleet heading to Pearl Harbor?
Uh, how does Australia warn the U.S. about a fleet which took a northern route well outside of normal shipping lanes, a route often plagued by bad weather, and a route that was a couple of thousand miles away from Australia?

I guess the US never did anything to provoke Japan into attacking?
And what was it in response to that the U.S. slapped a trade embargo on Japan? Oh, yes, its brutal occupation of China. An occupation which consisted of things like the infamous Rape of Nanking.
 
You call your mother, momma? Are you in grade school?

That's funny you try to minimize the strength of the US now, but openly boast about humiliiating the japs and nazis.

I'm sure you're smart enough to know about the controversy over Pearl Harbor and know where to look. I've never heard of a country that managed to secretly invade a country without them knowing it. Has a "surprise" invasion of another country ever happened anytime else?

What in the world are you talking about?
 
Sadly we're not talking in your native language or I might find it easier to understand what you are trying to say.

Tarrou is saying that allthough Hitler was human, he did not act in a human (humane) way. But lot's of people didn't or do not, but Hitler took it as far as one could.

My point is that allthough Hitler allowed for all those atrocities, he was still a human being. Humans ARE capable of doing those evil things.
 
I agree completely. But when people start referring to 'Der Untergang' when talking about Hitler, or 'Schindler's List' when talking about the holocaust we have a real problem.

Some people do not feel the need to research further, because the history/reality has been explained to them in an easily digestible package.
And the portrait of Hitler or Schindler in the movies, is as inaccurate as my personal description of 9/11 or my memories from the court of king Nero.

What happened in Europe during the Nazi regime is impossible to describe. Dry historical facts does not even begin to give justice to the people that suffered this plague on humanity.

Fortunately, we do not need an explanation or justice. We do not need an apology for Nazism and Hitler. We do not need some interpretation of their wrongdoings, of their wants and needs.

We do not need an explanation. Any explanation is bound to belittle the terror of nazism.

Nazism does not have a human face. Hitler was not human.

This is not denial.

But to accept Hitler as human or Nazism as 'normal' human behaviour is to invite MaGZ and friends into our society.

It is simply just not acceptable. 'Der Untergang' wants me to accept Hitler, and i say 'No!' Still, my eyes are open!

Some believe that Hitler was not human but superhuman; or at least a superhuman personality.

http://www.theneworder.org/hitler_phenom/hitler_lives.html
 
Sadly we're not talking in your native language or I might find it easier to understand what you are trying to say.
Sorry! :boxedin:

What I am trying to say is this:

1. Hitler was a human being [sic].
2. To analyze hitler as a 'normal human being' is futile and dangerous.
3. 'Der untergang' portraits Hitler as a human being just like you and me.

Hitler was not a normal human being. Nazi-germany was not just 'another empire'. Nazi punks are not just 'misinformered youngsters'.

ETA: Thanks Bell! humane it is! My first translation award goes to you! (1 beer in Copenhagen - come and get it!)
 
Last edited:
Tarrou is saying that allthough Hitler was human, he did not act in a human (humane) way. But lot's of people didn't or do not, but Hitler took it as far as one could.

My point is that allthough Hitler allowed for all those atrocities, he was still a human being. Humans ARE capable of doing those evil things.

Hitler was hardly the sole "inhuman" leader bred by the circumstances of that strange time in European history. Ante Pavelić was at least as bad as Hitler, though he had nowhere near as much power and influence.
 
Well, obviously Hitler was a human being.
Now you just need to demonstrate that Hitler was human!
This may get lost in translation, but in my native language there is a huge difference between the two.

So, what is your native language? Do you read right to left?
 
I appreciate you at least recognizing what the US is doing today, but you see the British and the US colony has a much longer history of colonization that continues to modern times. How many Native Americans were slaughtered do you think to make way for the white Europeans? The genocide of Native Americans that added up to what 10,20 million?

I think the number of Indians in North America at the time of the White conquest was the same number of Indians that are alive today.
 
You call your mother, momma? Are you in grade school?

That's funny you try to minimize the strength of the US now, but openly boast about humiliiating the japs and nazis.

I'm sure you're smart enough to know about the controversy over Pearl Harbor and know where to look. I've never heard of a country that managed to secretly invade a country without them knowing it. Has a "surprise" invasion of another country ever happened anytime else?

Nice try to avoid my question by insulting me, but please, this is not some conspiracy forum. Explain to me exactly how 'I just don't believe' and 'I've never heard' is a legitimate debate tactic.

What you are going to get here is rational, intelligent treatment of the subject. If you are going to keep up with folks here, arguments from incredulity and insults will get you nowhere. SHOW SOME EVIDENCE
 
Last edited:
How clever Elizabeth! It's amazing that this real fleet traveling from across the planet was never detected by the US radar system when even Australia warned the US about the Japanese fleet heading to Pearl Harbor? I guess the US never did anything to provoke Japan into attacking?

You can't have it both ways. First you said the U.S. was "duped" into joining the war; now they were the ones doing the duping? And you seem to have a thing about countries "provoking" other countries into attacking. What were the Allies doing, jumping around going "Nyah, nyah, nyah" and thumbing their noses?


Which they did. Which also doesn't mean the Nazis gassed a ton of Jews in gas chambers alive.

Where did the bodies come from that were thrown into the crematoria?


I mentioned that to illustrate the total lack of empathy that exists in the world in discussing history. Clearly your statement seems to be exemplary of that. You're saying they deserved to suffer?

Please don't attribute things to me that I never said. I did not say your parents deserved to suffer. I said their sufferings should be laid at the feet of the Japanese warlords who took their country to war.


Do you honestly believe Pearl Harbor was a "surprise"? The US despite being the dominant country in this world sure seems to have a lot of "oops" moments. I just find it hard to believe that Japan really thought they had a chance to take over the US or if that even was the intention.

The U.S. was not a superpower in 1941. When the war was over, because so much of the European and Asian infrastructure had been destroyed, there was an economic and military vacuum. Due to its distance from the fighting, the U.S. was isolated from the destruction, and, because of its involvement in the war, already in manufacturing mode. Conditions combined to create a niche into which the U.S. fit very well.

And the intention of the Japanese in World War II was not to "take over the U.S." It was to cripple and demoralize us so that we would have neither the means nor the will to interfere with the Japanese campaign of Asian conquest.


That "humiliation" involved the unnecessary use of not 1 but 2 nuclear bombs that wiped 2 major cities off the map when the US had already bombed the crap out of Japan with conventional bombs. Can you picture the entire manhattan island with no buildings standing?

It's not really about laying the guilt trip for Japan though. The Japanese sincerely want the effects and use of nuclear bombs to be exposed for the sake of world peace and for the US to stop covering it up. If Americans are still boasting about using it again or that Japan deserved to be nuked then we still have a long ways to go.

It was WAR, infant. And not war that the U.S. started, either. A judgment was made that a quick and decisive end to combat in the Pacific was necessary, and the bomb was dropped.

The results were horrific. Consider that nuclear weapons had never been deployed against a populated area. I truly believe that, before Hiroshima and Nagasaki, no one could conceive of the effects of an atomic weapon on living creatures. Of course they knew there would be a huge explosion and a flash and a shock wave, but they hadn't actually seen the aftermath. Yes, the first and only time that nuclear weapons were used, they were used by the U.S. However, you will note that we haven't used them since.

As far as just desserts are concerned, what had the people in Hawaii done to "deserve" the rain of bombs on December 7, 1941? What had the Korean "comfort women" done to "deserve" their gang rapes? What had the civilian population of Nanjing done to "deserve" looting, arson, torture, rape and murder? I suppose all those people had been "provoking" the Japanese. You speak as if the country of Japan had not been actively waging war on the rest of the world for years. Did they "deserve" to be the target of atomic weapons? Maybe not, but they certainly had to be stopped.
 
An invasion of the Japanese mainland, as an alternative to the atomic bombs, would have killed more Japanese than both bombs put together.
 

Oh I see Marie-Claude Vaillant-Couturier another darling of Holocaust promoters who was a member of the French resistance.

The French, who got their asses kicked by the Germans. She possibly didn't have a bone to pick with the Germans including some of her seemingly exaggerated claims and ambiguous descriptions of the gassing.

This testimony is based on this same French resistance woman who was detained as a political prisoner describing the conditions of the camp towards the end of the war?

http://www.hdot.org/trial/judgement/05.022
http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marie-Claude_Vaillant-Couturier


I still don't get the impression that mass gassing had occurred to kill Jews. According to Vaillant-Couturier they were gassing everyone without any qualifications. Gassing everyone to disinfect them?



MME. VAILLANT-COUTURIER: At Auschwitz there was a brothel for the SS and also one for the male internees of the staff, who were called "Kapo." Moreover, when the SS needed servants,

The Kapo were prison guards picked by the SS and mostly consisted of Jewish men. The Jewish Kapos had access to brothels and were often more brutal then the SS.

http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/Holocaust/kapos.html
 
He's implying that you're an Israeli, and hence a Jew. You might want to consider putting him on ignore. He's a nasty piece of work.

Heh, I missed that! I kind of like when people embarass themselves in public though, so I'll keep my mouse pointer away from the ignore button for now.:)
 
Kegeki you have A LOT of more evidence to ignore before this thing is over. Do you think that it's simply Marie-Claude Vaillant-Couturier's word against yours?
 
Tarrou is saying that allthough Hitler was human, he did not act in a human (humane) way. But lot's of people didn't or do not, but Hitler took it as far as one could.

My point is that allthough Hitler allowed for all those atrocities, he was still a human being. Humans ARE capable of doing those evil things.


I have a theory that there are some creatures that look human but are not. Hitler, Stalin, Pol Pot, Ceaucescu, Ted Bundy, Charles Manson and Jeffrey Dahmer fit this category. They are not human, and, unless and until our understanding of the way the brain works is increased by orders of magnitude, nothing you can do will make them human. They are not, and should be kept away from others that they could harm.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom