[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

What do you think of John Toland's book on Hitler?

Kind of depends on what level you want to regard it. It is well written, and reasonably accurate. It would be a decent lightweight primer for those who want a taste without the heavy scholarship. Solid pop culture biography, which is what it was intended to be.

On a scholarly level it would be kind of a poor choice. Kershaw and Bullock are certainly better, if not as engaging to read. Toran is not a historian, he does not purport to be a historian, nor does he concentrate on Nazi Germany as a writer. It would be unreasonable to expect the same level of analysis as you would from a historian on the period. The interviews are very valuable but are accepted at face value. It's age now also counts a bit against it, a lot of new work has been produced since. I would put him in the same boat as Shirer, certainly a work of some value but not something I'd rely on solely or primarily.
 
Hitler did leave us his last political testament.


Yeah, he wrote a suicide note.

In which he lied.

How pathetic is that, telling lies in your suicide note? You'd think a suicide note would be one of the few circumstances that one can be completely honest with oneself and the world without concern for the consequences. But he lied anyhow.

What a putz.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
I wanted war with Germany before that, but couldn't get the Methodists to back me. The Lutherans were going to, but they were too involved with the Dakota Border War. If the Episcopilians hadn't stepped in, and brokered the DMZ between North and South Dakota, who knows what might have happened? We'd all be ice fishing and eating lutefisk!

I like lutefish.
 
Enough is enough?

Having read as much of this thread as I could stomach, why do all of the intelligent members of this board still debate MaGZ?

I am probably not the first to suggest this, but would it not be wise to
ignore him in pityful silence?

Is he not clearly beyond any sort of reasoning/help?
 
Has Japan come to grips with their wartime atrocities in China yet? Korea? Burma? The Phillippines? Everyplace else they attempted to bring into the "Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere"? The atrocities they committed on POW's? Or does Japanese history still skip over that part of history?

The Japanese have that big atomic alibi. While they've eschewed their evil ways, they haven't quite been able to do what the Germans did, and accept that they were evil.
 
Why do you respond to a question about the gassing with an example of forced abortions?

The specific event being questioned is the gas chambers. Were there really gas chambers?
Why did you reply without reading the testimony you were advised to read? Is it a tremendous problem for you to type (Vaillant-Couturier testimony) into Google?

The only thing we see is a gas chamber that was made by the Soviets. The rest is witness testimonies and forensic evidence that is hotly contested.
It's hotly contested by unqualified charlatans.

Not much is talked about how they got rid of the bodies afterwards which resulted from the use of a lethal gas.
Plenty has been said about it. Mme. Vaillant-Couturier's testimony, for example.

Is there any difficulties in moving large amounts of dead bodies that remain to exude the lethal gas that it absorbed?
No difficulties at all if you have the proper equipment.

They even had 16 orchestras, but we are told the Nazis played classical music which consisted mostly of Jewish prisoners so they can fool the prisoners when they were really going to be gassed.

We are also told that the gas chambers were disguised to look like showers so they can fool the prisoners when they were really going to gas them.

We also know that the Nazis did use Zyklon B gas to delouse prisoners.
We also know that by 1942, SS general Harald Turner was so familiar with "delousing" as a euphemism for murder, that he used it jokingly in one of his letters.

It just seems rather elaborate on the part of the Nazis that they would go that far just to execute prisoners in gas chambers.
Yes, it was a very elaborate. Your point?
 
Yeah, he wrote a suicide note.

In which he lied.

How pathetic is that, telling lies in your suicide note? You'd think a suicide note would be one of the few circumstances that one can be completely honest with oneself and the world without concern for the consequences. But he lied anyhow.

What a putz.

Respectfully,
Myriad

Well it was more than a note. It was his dictated political testament. Beyond that I certainly agree with your other assessment. He lied in much of it, or presented what was left of his delusion. In many ways it's like Mein Kampf, rambling, often non-sensical, and predicting a future that is even mor eludicrous now than it was then.
For those interested there was a brilliant film call Der Untertag made about Hitler's last 10 days. Won a few awards a couple of years ago. It is largely drawn from testimony of Hitler's private secretary. Incredibly well done film, best watched in the German with subtitles. (And I am very bitchy about historical movies, I can count the ones I like on one hand, and before any foolish questions, no I didn't care for Schindler's List).
 
Well it was more than a note. It was his dictated political testament. Beyond that I certainly agree with your other assessment. He lied in much of it, or presented what was left of his delusion. In many ways it's like Mein Kampf, rambling, often non-sensical, and predicting a future that is even mor eludicrous now than it was then.
For those interested there was a brilliant film call Der Untertag made about Hitler's last 10 days. Won a few awards a couple of years ago. It is largely drawn from testimony of Hitler's private secretary. Incredibly well done film, best watched in the German with subtitles. (And I am very bitchy about historical movies, I can count the ones I like on one hand, and before any foolish questions, no I didn't care for Schindler's List).

The problem with 'Der Untergang' and for that matter 'Schindler's List' is that they deal with events too close to our collective past.

The thought that present or future generations of youth are going to grow up with all of their knowledge of Hitler and the holocaust derived from movies, makes me very sad.

(recently a poll here in Denmark showed that a growing number of people below the age of eighteen, had doubts that the holocaust ever happened (still a small number, mind you). Their source? Tha Intarwebs!! - If young people are that gullible, surely they will understand a movie as 'Der Untergang' as a documentary about an impotent weak personality, rather than the dramatization of the last days of a monster?)
 
If you think what your implication here is true, than would the above post mean you are baiting?

Just for once, could you please make a clear, declarative, positive statement? This is twisted to the point of incomprehensibility.
 
The problem with 'Der Untergang' and for that matter 'Schindler's List' is that they deal with events too close to our collective past.

The thought that present or future generations of youth are going to grow up with all of their knowledge of Hitler and the holocaust derived from movies, makes me very sad.

(recently a poll here in Denmark showed that a growing number of people below the age of eighteen, had doubts that the holocaust ever happened (still a small number, mind you). Their source? Tha Intarwebs!! - If young people are that gullible, surely they will understand a movie as 'Der Untergang' as a documentary about an impotent weak personality, rather than the dramatization of the last days of a monster?)

The first part of I realy don't understand, you don't seem to want to question the actual history presented, but rather some odd qualifier that, frankly, makes little sense to me.

I hate to shock you but future generations will not learn history from movies, they don't learn it at all now. And the youth market is decidely unfriendly to this sort of film, no rap sound track and all. It appears more plausible that the youth gravitate to youtube videos I need only point at some of the posts by our closet neo-nazis as proof. To learn the subject requires considerable reading, real reading. Not from Wikipedia or some insignificant web page but rather the books and journal articles from real historians, not to mention a healthy dose of direct document examination. As someone who has done a hell of a lot more reading that most on the subject, and still realizes what a minor command I have of it, I find it silly to think the general public will ever have a real grasp. It would be like expecting them to learn gall bladder surgery on their own.
History has often been compared to science. Among the arts it has the highest requirements for empirical proof. It tracks its theories and their evolutions. The history of slavery, the history of Native relations, the history of the rise and fall of empires (unabashed Kennedy fan) and many other fields amply demonstrate this notion.

Der Untergang is undeniably pop culture, but its better pop culture than most. And much more accessible to the average person than the reading necessary for in depth understanding.
 
Last edited:
So those Japanese planes over Pearl Harbor were...what, holograms?

How clever Elizabeth! It's amazing that this real fleet traveling from across the planet was never detected by the US radar system when even Australia warned the US about the Japanese fleet heading to Pearl Harbor? I guess the US never did anything to provoke Japan into attacking?

I believe the ovens were crematoria used for disposing of the bodies after the murders.

Which they did. Which also doesn't mean the Nazis gassed a ton of Jews in gas chambers alive.

Frankly, I think the suffering of your parents can be laid squarely at the feet of the warlords who signed on for the Axis cause. And I doubt if they cared much at all.

I mentioned that to illustrate the total lack of empathy that exists in the world in discussing history. Clearly your statement seems to be exemplary of that. You're saying they deserved to suffer?

It must be a great feeling to know when the US does anything it's because they are "liberating" countries. I guess building military bases in foreign countries is for their "protection".
 
It's amazing that this real fleet traveling from across the planet was never detected by the US radar system when even Australia warned the US about the Japanese fleet heading to Pearl Harbor?
1. Prior to the Pearl Harbor attack, US radar technology had never been proven in battle.
2. Even so, the Pearl Harbor radar detected the Japanese force about an hour away.
3. Since none of the officers were trained in how to use the radar effectively, they didn't respond.

Anyway, I see where this is going. Standard Japanese WW2 revisionism. It wasn't the Empire's fault that they attacked the US and were humiliated in return. The US devil made them do it! The US made it so easy to attack, how could Japan not follow through?

Which also doesn't mean the Nazis gassed a ton of Jews in gas chambers alive.
Read the Vaillant-Couturier testimony.
 
Last edited:
1. Prior to the Pearl Harbor attack, US radar technology had never been proven in battle.
2. Even so, the Pearl Harbor radar detected the Japanese force about an hour away.
3. Since none of the officers were trained in how to use the radar effectively, they didn't respond.

Anyway, I see where this is going. Standard Japanese WW2 revisionism. It wasn't the Empire's fault that they attacked the US and were humiliated in return. The US devil made them do it!


Read the Vaillant-Couturier testimony.

Heh its kageki, the slaughter rule is in effect. I think he has a rule that he must put at least one really stupid thing in each post. I loved the part about the "American radar system", which was actually a truck sitting on Hawaii. He has absolutely no clue what the state of American radar development was at the time, but he's going to comment on it anyway. I wonder if he even knows what the strategic thinking of the Japanse was at the time.
 
I thought Radar was introduced in the Korean war? :confused:
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom