[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

Is that true? 5 million dead in 3 years sounds like the Holocaust to me.

I really wonder how many Native Americans actually died as a consequence of a brutal takeover by Europeans? I heard a Native American fellow on the radio the other day mentioning there was 40 million at the the time of conquest down to under a million. I also like to know if that is true.

How many did Columbus bring with him?

5 million killed in 3 years is over 4,500 per day every day.

How many bullets did he bring with him?
 
Have you even seen the movie ? It depicts Hitler as a maniac psychopath.

I have seen the movie. And i agree that the picture it paints of Hitler is far from positive.

But: In the recent weeks I have seen a 6-part documentary about the holocaust as well.

That very documentary got me thinking about 'Der Untergang', and i stand firm in my belief that Hitler's last days are only a matter for historians - not a matter for film makers, regardless of what kind of emotions they want to evoke in me.

Any attempt to 'humanize' Adolf Hitler will always imply some kind of apology, and the terror of the Nazi regime is beyond forgiveness
(thus spoke a student of Albert Camus :boxedin:)

My biggest concern with 'Der untergang' is its claim to be authentic.
There is nothing authentic about the movie. It shows a demoralised, pityful, manic psychopath, which in my opinion is dishonest at best. If the movie should have been made at all (which it in my opinion shouldn't have), it should have captured his 'career' all the way from the rise to power to the final apocalypse.

But again: I do not want to understand Hitler. He was a very insignificant character, placed on the world scene more by chance than by reckoning it seems.

I would like to understand his followers, the men and women in Waffen-SS, the common people enamoured by nazism, and the people carrying wood to the ovens. I would like to understand MaGZ. As I grow older my understanding grows, but I am still essentially mystified .

Don't get me wrong: I think 'Der Untergang' is a great movie. I just don't think it does any service to students of history, nor to the victims of the Nazi era.
 
You mean "Downfall" ? I own it on DVD. It's a very, very good movie. I especially like how completely detached from reality Hitler was.

It's a good movie to watch in a marathon, just after "Saving Private Ryan" and before "Nuremberg".
Belz's Summertime Feelgood Film Festival?
 
Read up on diseases such as smallpox. They killed far more Native Americans than bullets ever did.

You have evidence that Columbus; in 1493, intentionally spread smallpox?

I have no dispute that Columbus did come to the Americas to move out and kill the natives; but killing 5 million in 3 years is a ridiculous claim on its face which brings into question the validity of the presenter.
 
You have evidence that Columbus; in 1493, intentionally spread smallpox?

I have no dispute that Columbus did come to the Americas to move out and kill the natives; but killing 5 million in 3 years is a ridiculous claim on its face which brings into question the validity of the presenter.


Why would it have to be intentional? You should read Jared Diamond's Guns, Germs, and Steel for examples of how American populations (not just natives of the Carribean) were decimated by introduced diseases. It is well known how the Native Hawai'ian population crashed after contact with Western explorers.

I have seen many different numbers for the Carib and Taino populations pre-contact, and how they fared after Columbus returned as governor. I am not necessarily agreeing with the number the poster presented, but I completely disagree with your argument from incredulity that such a number is inconceivable. I am also refuting your argument that a genocide has to be accomplished using "bullets".

I recommend that you read history before commenting on it.
 
So, you're a Pearl Harbor CTer, after all ? Is there ANY revisionist history you don't buy into ?

I believe in one conspiracy theory as you believe in another conspiracy theory.

"Magic" cables

http://www.ihr.org/jhr/v04/v04p467_Greaves.html

US had broken Japanese codes. The US knew what the Japanese were up to and their capabilities. FDR knew about Pearl Harbor and let it happen.

http://whatreallyhappened.com/pearl/www.geocities.com/Pentagon/6315/pearl.html

Germany's declaration of war

Germany only declared war after Japan out of obligation to the Tripartite Pact. Germany never had intentions of declaring war on America by itself.

Japan's Intent

What exactly were the ambitions and the intent of Japan?

http://www.ihr.org/jhr/v04/v04p467_Greaves.html

A number of Japan's intercepts were translated and circulated on November 26th. Perhaps the most informative was one sent on November 14, from Tokyo to Hong Kong and eleven other Chinese cities. It read in part:

Though the Imperial Government hopes for great things from the Japan-American negotiations, they do not permit optimism for the future. Should the negotiations collapse, the international situation in which the Empire will find herself will be one of tremendous crisis. Accompanying this, the Empire's foreign policy as it has been decided by the cabinet ... is:

a. We will completely destroy British and American power in China.

b. We will take over all enemy concessions and enemy important rights and interests (customs and minerals, etc.) in China....

We will cope with a world war on a long-time scale. Should our reserves for total war and our future military strength wane, we have decided to reinforce them from the whole Far Eastern area. This has become the whole fundamental policy of the Empire....

Please keep absolutely quiet the existence of these decisions and the fact that they have been transmitted to you.

The "official" explanation is only one side of the argument. What were the British and the US doing at this time?

Again nothing to indicate they had any desire to attack the US which makes the story about Pearl Harbor that much more odd. Japan was fighting with Russia too and was against Communism.
 
Why would it have to be intentional? You should read Jared Diamond's Guns, Germs, and Steel for examples of how American populations (not just natives of the Carribean) were decimated by introduced diseases. It is well known how the Native Hawai'ian population crashed after contact with Western explorers.

I have seen many different numbers for the Carib and Taino populations pre-contact, and how they fared after Columbus returned as governor. I am not necessarily agreeing with the number the poster presented, but I completely disagree with your argument from incredulity that such a number is inconceivable. I am also refuting your argument that a genocide has to be accomplished using "bullets".

I recommend that you read history before commenting on it.


From the text we are talking about:
In 1493, when Columbus returned to the Hispaniola, he quickly implemented policies of slavery and mass extermination of the Taino population of the Caribbean. Within three years, five million were dead. Las Casas, the primary historian of the Columbian era, writes of many accounts of the horrors that the Spanish colonists inflicted upon the indigenous population: hanging them en mass, hacking their children into pieces to be used as dog feed, and other horrid cruelties. The works of Las Casas are often omitted from popular American history books and courses because Columbus is considered a hero by many, even today.


Can you find any implication in this text that the 5 million deaths were not intentional?
 
I doubt that many here, except a few hared-core racists would disagree with the position that the extermination of some native tribes and their removal from their lands was an atrocity. Hopefully, we are moving beyond justifying it on the grounds of Manifest Destiny. I would hope that we at least learned that much from WWII.

Some people here, however, are immune to such education.
 
I doubt that many here, except a few hared-core racists would disagree with the position that the extermination of some native tribes and their removal from their lands was an atrocity. Hopefully, we are moving beyond justifying it on the grounds of Manifest Destiny. I would hope that we at least learned that much from WWII.

Some people here, however, are immune to such education.


Yep, those people just landed on "Ignore".
 
US had broken Japanese codes. The US knew what the Japanese were up to and their capabilities. FDR knew about Pearl Harbor and let it happen.

They knew something was coming. The naval officer who was mostly running the show just did a lot of stupid things, expecting more a guerilla operation at the outset of hostilities.

QUOTE]http://whatreallyhappened.com/pearl/www.geocities.com/Pentagon/6315/pearl.html[/QUOTE]

Decent people do not generally take kindly to what that site is selling. They're kind of Nazi.

Germany only declared war after Japan out of obligation to the Tripartite Pact. Germany never had intentions of declaring war on America by itself.

Actually, the Nazis believed up until the last that we would come over to their side once they had secured Europe.

What exactly were the ambitions and the intent of Japan?

To control all the resources of Asia for the ecconomic benefit of the Japanese Empire. The rest of Asia would be tributory states.
 
US had broken Japanese codes.
The US had broken several Japanese codes. None of them happened to be the code that the Japanese military used to plan Pearl Harbor. (Please, give your ancestors a little credit. They weren't completely incompetent.)
 
How many did Columbus bring with him?

5 million killed in 3 years is over 4,500 per day every day.

How many bullets did he bring with him?

I think a lot of people died from cruel forced labor and also from disease. How about just chopping heads off with a sword? Did the Tainos even have weapons? Don't forget the time period we're talking here.

Just curious how does that work out with 6 million Jews that died in the Holocaust?
 
Last edited:
The US knew what the Japanese were up to and their capabilities.
From reading the Japanese diplomatic messages it was known war was imminent. Any time diplomats are instructed to destroy their code books, it's pretty obvious what's coming.

What wasn't known was where the war would start.

The Pearl Harbor strike wasn't even the original Japanese war plan; it was adopted only at the insistence of Admiral Yamamoto.

FDR knew about Pearl Harbor and let it happen.
Incorrect.

Germany only declared war after Japan out of obligation to the Tripartite Pact.
Not quite. The terms of the pact only required the members to come to the defence of another member should that member be attacked. Since Japan initiated the hostilities, Germany was not obligated to declare war on the United States.

Japan was fighting with Russia too and was against Communism.
Japan signed a non-aggression pact with Russia in April of 1941. The two nations had fought battles in 1938-39. But the Japanese were soundly defeated in the Battle of Khalkin Gol, taking away the lesson that the Russians could be fierce and determined foes. This was something that Germany had yet to learn.
 
Last edited:
You have evidence that Columbus; in 1493, intentionally spread smallpox?

I have no dispute that Columbus did come to the Americas to move out and kill the natives; but killing 5 million in 3 years is a ridiculous claim on its face which brings into question the validity of the presenter.

Well this is straight from the horse's mouth. Las Casas says 3 million.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taíno

Bartolomé de Las Casas wrote (1561) in his multivolume History of the Indies: [26]

There were 60,000 people living on this island [when I arrived in 1508], including the Indians; so that from 1494 to 1508, over three million people had perished from war, slavery and the mines. Who in future generations will believe this?

Notice on wikipedia it says the figure is hotly contested. You wonder why it's ok to debate those numbers, but not the Holocaust. Was it really 6 million?

At the minimum we should be saying 5 million for the Holocaust. Stephen Walt even suggested 3 million or lower.


Native American ethnocide

50 million Native Americans in 1492
8 million in 1650
2 million in 1990

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_history_of_American_indigenous_peoples
http://www.census.gov/population/socdemo/race/indian/ailang1.txt

Why do we still honor Christopher Columbus as the great discover of America when he was a mass murderer? Do Native Americans have a right to protest about that?

http://www.hartford-hwp.com/archives/41/385.html

Columbus kidnapped , enslaved, and murdered the Arawak people. He ruled with severe discipline ordering the cutting off of ears or nose as punishment for minor crimes.

When the Arawaks fought back, Columbus used the excuse to wage war. On March 24th, 1495 Columbus set out to conquer the Arawaks. With 20 hunting dogs, horses, and guns Columbus set upon the Arawaks, tearing them up with dogs and mowing them down with volleys of bullets, and running them over with horses. Reporting back to Queen Isabel of Spain, Columbus boasted In the name of the holy trinity, we can send from here all the slaves that Brazil will hold. The Spaniards hunted Indians for sport and murdered them for dog food.
 
wikipedia? a source that can easily be edited by revisionists?

Notice on wikipedia it says the figure is hotly contested. You wonder why it's ok to debate those numbers, but not the Holocaust. Was it really 6 million?

Hotly contested by those handful of deniers on the left side of the bell curve for intelligence doesn't count, Sorry.. are you going to do a bit of research beyond trying to reinforce your racism?

http://www.nizkor.org/

[SIZE=-1]66 Questions & Answers About the Holocaust[/SIZE]

 
Hotly contested by those handful of deniers on the left side of the bell curve for intelligence doesn't count, Sorry.. are you going to do a bit of research beyond trying to reinforce your racism?

http://www.nizkor.org/

[SIZE=-1]66 Questions & Answers About the Holocaust[/SIZE]

You do realize I was referring to the hotly contested numbers of how many Columbus slaughtered?

In a rational world your reaction and comments should not even exist.

I say it's 5 million or less. To be more accurate an estimate of 5-6 million dead in the Jewish Holocaust. After all the total dead in the Holocaust is 11 million.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom