[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

Nah, the British used it in the Battle of Britain.

Wrong Radar.
RadarMASH.jpg
 
Shouldn't the usual radar be "RADAR?" As an acronym for Radio Detection and Ranging.

In that case it should be RaDaR, but anyway, it wasn't RADAR, it was CARROTS ;)

(now there is a real propaganda myth which has taken hold in the public mind...)
 
What the Japanese and German aggression had in common was that both nations saw themselves as the rightful rulers over a major portion of the world, and took steps to set themselves up as such. The deaths of the indigenous peoples was of little consequence, because they were lesser sorts of folk than the people of the invading nations.

Why, for instance, had the Japanese any territorial interest in China or Korea?

I won't even excuse our involvement in Iraq, given that the PNAC manifesto states that we should use our status as a military power to maintain "mastery" over events in the region. That idea should have died with Hitler.
 
How clever Elizabeth! It's amazing that this real fleet traveling from across the planet was never detected by the US radar system when even Australia warned the US about the Japanese fleet heading to Pearl Harbor? I guess the US never did anything to provoke Japan into attacking?

You've obviously never heard of George Elliot, Joseph Lockard or Kermit Tyler, since you're laboring under the delusion that the USA had a comprehensive early-warning radar network in operation in December 1941.

In fact, they didn't. The equipment was still relatively crude and cranky, operators were still being trained and the USA was a long way from grasping the lessons the British had learned about how to make radar part of an integrated air-defense system.

In fact, the Japanese attack was picked up by an SCR-270 radar set when it was still about 130 miles away, but the only officer at the information center to which the operators reported the contact dismissed it.

The first SR-270's became functional in July, 1941 and by November Bergquist only had a small team established and a set of four SCR-270-B's stationed around Oahu with one unit in reserve. They were placed on the central north shore (Haleiwa), Opana Point (northern tip), in the northwest at the highest point- Mount Kaala, and one in the southeast corner at Koko Head. However there was no real communications system or reporting chain set up. At one point the operators of one of the sets were instructed to phone in reports from a local gas station some distance down the road. By explicit order by General Short, the radar stations were to only be operated for four hours per day and to shut down by 7AM each day.
Unit s/n 012 was at Opana Point, Hawaii on the morning of the seventh of December, 1941 manned by two privates, Elliot and Joseph Lockard. That morning the set was supposed to be shut down, but the soldiers decided to get in additional training time in since the truck scheduled to take them to breakfast was late in arriving. At 7:02 they saw the Japanese aircraft approaching Oahu at a distance of 130 miles and Lockard telephoned the information center at Fort Shafter and reported "Large number of planes coming in from the north, three points east". The operator taking his report passed on the information repeating that the operator emphasized he had never seen anything like it, and it was an "an awful big flight."

From that point on the sighting was ignored. The report was passed on to an untrained officer who had arrived only a week earlier. He thought they had detected a flight of B-17s arriving that morning from the US. There were only six B-17s in the group, so this did not account for the large size of the plot. But the officer had little grasp of the technology and the B-17's had no IFF (Identification Friend or Foe) system, nor any alternative procedure for identifying distant friendlies as the British had developed during the Battle of Britain. The raid on Pearl Harbor started 55 minutes later, and signaled the United States' formal entry into World War II.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SCR-270_radar

And the testimony of (Lieutenant at the time of Pearl Harbor) Kermit Tyler, the officer who blew the call:

Colonel TYLER. Just as a matter of interest, I saw this lad who was keeping the historical record. There is a record made of every plot that comes into the station, and I had not [1099] yet observed that activity, so I went over to see what he was doing, and it happened to be just about 7 o'clock, or roughly thereabout; and he had these plots out probably 130 miles, which I looked at, and there were other plots on the board at that time. It was just about 7, or a little bit after, I think, and then, right at 7 o'clock, all the people who were in the information center, except the telephone operator, folded up their equipment and left. There were just the operator and myself again; and about 7:15, the radar operator from Opana called the telephone operator to say that he had a larger plot than he had ever seen before, on his 'scope, and the telephone operator relayed the call to me; so I took the call, and, inasmuch as I had no means of identifying friendly plots from enemy, nor was I led to believe that there would be any occasion to do so, I told him not to worry about it.

And the next warning I had was about 5 after 8, when we received a call that there was an attack on.

23. General FRANK. What did you assume this was that was coming in? It might have been what?

Colonel TYLER. As far as I was concerned, it could. I thought it most probable that it would be the B-17's which were coming from the mainland.
The testimony of Tyler, Elliot and Lockard can all be found here.

Your argument is remarkably reminiscent of the shinola troofers routinely spread about NORAD and US air defenses on 9/11- and about as well-informed.

I mentioned that to illustrate the total lack of empathy that exists in the world in discussing history. Clearly your statement seems to be exemplary of that. You're saying they deserved to suffer?
Apportioning an appropriate share of responsibility to the lunatic militarists who thought that Japan could conquer, rob and rape its way out of its economic problems doesn't constitute saying that the ordinary people of Japan deserved to suffer.

It must be a great feeling to know when the US does anything it's because they are "liberating" countries. I guess building military bases in foreign countries is for their "protection".
And finally we come to the crux of the biscuit- your ideological motivation to minimize or deny the well-documented crimes of the Nazis and the Imperial Japanese forces. This is a non sequitur; no matter how badly the US gummint has behaved, it doesn't change what happened in Europe and Asia between 1937 and 1945.
 
[reasonable, cut out for clarity..]

Der Untergang is undeniably pop culture, but its better pop culture than most. And much more accessible to the average person than the reading necessary for in depth understanding.

I agree completely. But when people start referring to 'Der Untergang' when talking about Hitler, or 'Schindler's List' when talking about the holocaust we have a real problem.

Some people do not feel the need to research further, because the history/reality has been explained to them in an easily digestible package.
And the portrait of Hitler or Schindler in the movies, is as inaccurate as my personal description of 9/11 or my memories from the court of king Nero.

What happened in Europe during the Nazi regime is impossible to describe. Dry historical facts does not even begin to give justice to the people that suffered this plague on humanity.

Fortunately, we do not need an explanation or justice. We do not need an apology for Nazism and Hitler. We do not need some interpretation of their wrongdoings, of their wants and needs.

We do not need an explanation. Any explanation is bound to belittle the terror of nazism.

Nazism does not have a human face. Hitler was not human.

This is not denial.

But to accept Hitler as human or Nazism as 'normal' human behaviour is to invite MaGZ and friends into our society.

It is simply just not acceptable. 'Der Untergang' wants me to accept Hitler, and i say 'No!' Still, my eyes are open!
 
1. Prior to the Pearl Harbor attack, US radar technology had never been proven in battle.
2. Even so, the Pearl Harbor radar detected the Japanese force about an hour away.
3. Since none of the officers were trained in how to use the radar effectively, they didn't respond.

Anyway, I see where this is going. Standard Japanese WW2 revisionism. It wasn't the Empire's fault that they attacked the US and were humiliated in return. The US devil made them do it! The US made it so easy to attack, how could Japan not follow through?


Read the Vaillant-Couturier testimony.

This is one of the biggest problem I have when it comes down to discussing history.

When it's the perspective from the Japanese side it's "revisionism", but when it's the word of the US government it's "official". Similiarly anything from the German government is all "Nazi propaganda" and therefore unreliable. Do you ever think there is US and British propaganda?

Do you honestly believe Pearl Harbor was a "surprise"? The US despite being the dominant country in this world sure seems to have a lot of "oops" moments. I just find it hard to believe that Japan really thought they had a chance to take over the US or if that even was the intention.

That "humiliation" involved the unnecessary use of not 1 but 2 nuclear bombs that wiped 2 major cities off the map when the US had already bombed the crap out of Japan with conventional bombs. Can you picture the entire manhattan island with no buildings standing?

It's not really about laying the guilt trip for Japan though. The Japanese sincerely want the effects and use of nuclear bombs to be exposed for the sake of world peace and for the US to stop covering it up. If Americans are still boasting about using it again or that Japan deserved to be nuked then we still have a long ways to go.
 
Do you honestly believe Pearl Harbor was a "surprise"? The US despite being the dominant country in this world sure seems to have a lot of "oops" moments. I just find it hard to believe that Japan really thought they had a chance to take over the US or if that even was the intention.

With all due respect, the biggest issue many on this forum have is those who debate primarily from a position of personal incredulity.

My momma always told me beware of a sentence that starts with 'I just find it hard to believe...'.

And if you think that on Dec 7, 1941 the US was 'the dominant country in this world' then you aren't paying attention. If you have any compelling evidence Pearl Harbor wasn't a surprise then I would be interested in hearing it.
 
Last edited:
Bell said:
Alas, he was. Which tells a lot about the capabilities of the human race.
Well, obviously Hitler was a human being.
Now you just need to demonstrate that Hitler was human!
This may get lost in translation, but in my native language there is a huge difference between the two.
 
Last edited:
What the Japanese and German aggression had in common was that both nations saw themselves as the rightful rulers over a major portion of the world, and took steps to set themselves up as such. The deaths of the indigenous peoples was of little consequence, because they were lesser sorts of folk than the people of the invading nations.

Why, for instance, had the Japanese any territorial interest in China or Korea?

I won't even excuse our involvement in Iraq, given that the PNAC manifesto states that we should use our status as a military power to maintain "mastery" over events in the region. That idea should have died with Hitler.

I appreciate you at least recognizing what the US is doing today, but you see the British and the US colony has a much longer history of colonization that continues to modern times. How many Native Americans were slaughtered do you think to make way for the white Europeans? The genocide of Native Americans that added up to what 10,20 million?

If it weren't for Germany or Japan then you would have Britain and US ruling over territories... which they do. Those over 300 military bases the US has all over the world is off course to help "defend" that nation.

China had made some ridiculous claim in the past that Japan should be returned to China because it was once part of mainland China. They also seem to have their eyes set on Taiwan. Our entire world history consists of on-going territorial conquest. It is hardly unique. Not that I'm defending imperialism which is why I strongly oppose this war in Iraq.

Maybe you can ween yourself off of Allied propaganda a little bit though.
 
Well, obviously Hitler was a human being.
Now you just need to demonstrate that Hitler was human!
This may get lost in translation, but in my native language there is a huge difference between the two.

Sadly we're not talking in your native language or I might find it easier to understand what you are trying to say.
 
Do you honestly believe Pearl Harbor was a "surprise"? The US despite being the dominant country in this world sure seems to have a lot of "oops" moments.

Personal incredulity is not an argument. However, if you really wanna know, my opinion is that their striking first at Pearl Harbor rather than in the Phillipines probably was a surprise- at least to the American brass.

I just find it hard to believe that Japan really thought they had a chance to take over the US or if that even was the intention.

It almost certainly wasn't. Their Pacific strategy appears to have been first to strike a crippling blow to US naval power in the Pacific and then to glom as wide an expanse of the Pacific as possible and create a defensive perimeter.

The idea was that with a diminished Navy, the USA would negotiate a peace rather than fight their way all the way to Japan. The territories seized in the central Pacific would serve two purposes: to deter the USA from fighting through such vast distances, and as bargaining chips which could be given back in exchange for what the militarists really wanted- Allied acquiescence in Japan's seizure of resource-producing areas in East and Southeast Asia.

They utterly blew that strategy at Pearl Harbor. After that, no American administration could possibly have negotiated a peace, especially one favorable to Japan, without being skinned alive by the American public.

That they failed to destroy any carriers, or the machine shops and repair facilities, or the 4.5 million barrels of fuel oil at Pearl, while losing 27 pilots from a Navy which only graduated 100 pilots per year, didn't help them much either.
 
With all due respect, the biggest issue many on this forum have is those who debate primarily from a position of personal incredulity.

My momma always told me beware of a sentence that starts with 'I just find it hard to believe...'.

And if you think that on Dec 7, 1941 the US was 'the dominant country in this world' then you aren't paying attention. If you have any compelling evidence Pearl Harbor wasn't a surprise then I would be interested in hearing it.

You call your mother, momma? Are you in grade school?

That's funny you try to minimize the strength of the US now, but openly boast about humiliiating the japs and nazis.

I'm sure you're smart enough to know about the controversy over Pearl Harbor and know where to look. I've never heard of a country that managed to secretly invade a country without them knowing it. Has a "surprise" invasion of another country ever happened anytime else?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom