[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

Are you having reading comprehension problems? I did not say Stalin was a great leader. Just not as wack as Hitler. And yes, it was the military virtue of the Russian soldier, more than Stalin's military skills that enabled them to defeat the Germans.

And the Chinese Communists were at least trying to rebuild China for the benfit of the Chinese, rather than for the Japanese.

What Japan did to China and Korea was inexcusable.
 
Not defending Stalin, as much as I am saying that Hitler was many times more the monster. Stalin was too self-centered to really build a sound socialist state. And he was militarily inept. Had he not rehabilitated Zhukov, we would all have been screwed. It is more a testament to the fighting abilities and courage of the Russian soldier and the brilliance of some of their weapons designers that they were able to hold off the Germans and turn the tide of battle. Those qualified field commanders who managed to survive the purges made the real difference. Stalin was actually in the way a lot in the lead-up to the war.

No, I do not defend the kind of communism practiced in China, either, but it was an improvement over what the Japanese did to China and Korea.

I'm actually a Democrat, but a bit left of FDR.

There is a series of documentaries called Scorched Earth - they spend a lot of time examining the tide of war in the East and what factors led to the change of fortune for the Soviets

One point made, was the average Russian saw it as just a war - The germans would come, the germans would go - Most Russians supported Stalin cause he was the only tyrannt that spoke Russian

However as the war entered its second year - a lot of the propaganda being spewed by the Soviet government about the way the NAZIs were behaving started to become confimed by suvivors filtering back from the front. The Russian people began to realise just what was at stake, not only their country being conqured, but all possibilty that the people themselves would be exterminated.

Apparently there was a famous speech at the time in which Stalin began. "My fellow brother and sister comrades" The Russians suddenly realised how deep in the poo they really where - Stalin had never spoken on personal terms up to that point. Half joking, it was said nearly half the country had a stroke on hearing that.
 
WARNING! these videos contain disturbing images.


These videos are from the world at war episode "genocide" and include numerous eyewitness accounts from jews and germans.

genocide 1
the warsaw ghetto.
http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=3-o6jvWXPCQ

genocide 2
transportation to camps.
http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=xxchZq_IBLY

genocide 3
inside the camps.
http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=frlgTIWYzz4

genocide 4
the horror comes to an end.
http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=VABMeV_KvFw


Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.
George Santayana (1863-1952)


It was called resettlement and they did have plans to resettle the Jewish population to Palestine. Why do you spend so much effort to transport people only to kill them?

The "inside the camps" one includes a British propaganda officer. I call that biased. To their credit they did show a clip of German "propaganda" that shows prisoners attending to their gardens inside the camp.


Gassings

One of the survivors to appear on the section about the camps talks about the gassing. Did he actually witness them die? Did the prisoners scream when the showers were turned on? Did he witness how they disposed of the bodies?

Burning pits

The last survivor is simply labeled as a "Hungarian Jew" who presumably speaks in Hungarian. I suppose all you need to know is that he is a Jew. Don't they have names? What was he really talking about?

Were there really burning pits of bodies and is it even possible?

What does that blurry picture of questionable nature really show? If it did happen were they not burning bodies of people that had already died?

It seem it is actually difficult to burn many bodies in a large pit and would certainly require large amounts of fuel which was a scarce commodity. If it is even true about this melted fat being scooped on top of the pile, would it even help to continue the burning?

"I understand that the Auschwitz-Birkenau complex was built on a swamp.
Even with drainage ditches, the water is still very close to the surface. This
condition would make it difficult to dig burning pits as described in the literature.

There seems to be a conflict between the earths natural forces and Holocaust sources. "

http://www.skepticforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=39&t=9026
 
What was it about your parental upbringing that led you and your siblings to betray your race?


1706046ea08bbb122f.jpg
 
But it was only part of Czechoslovakia right? The land that was lost? Austria does seem like it was a straight take over though.

How was it really inside Germany? Hitler might have hated non-Aryans, but he also seem to have taken good care of his people.

Well, it's in response to my post, so I'll reply.

Hitler took over all of Bohemia and Moravia, the two western parts, by March 1939. Slovakia was made into a German puppet state. The eastern chunk, variously known but nowadays recognized as a western slice of Ukraine centered on Uzhgorod (Russian translit.), went to Hungary.

You know, you could look this stuff up. Even Wiki Wacky Pedia may have simple stuff like this right.

I don't think you're Japanese, by the way. That would mean you are non-Aryan by any "definition."

Inside Germany... Yep, Germans did pretty well, for a while. What's a "non-Aryan"? Are Czechs and Poles and Russians "non-Aryan"? He hated them like poison. Almost as much as he hated the Jews, but he didn't have any respect for their brains, so they could wait a bit, and then live in slavery to the Germans.
 
I'll pass on such suffocating details for now. I see nizkor and I see zionist propaganda.



So it seems gassing by Zyklon B is not even technically possible. Einsatzgruppen is admittedly poorly documented. What does that word even mean? What did they really do and how many did they kill?



Why is that?

What makes the Jews more enduring when more Slavs died and is documented that 40 million were planned to be executed? However it is disputed that the same could be said about the Jews and it turns out it's possibly not even close to 6 million.

Why don't we ever read about everyone else?



They absolutely use it for political reasons. The Israelis still ask for money from the Germans, Swiss and have even accused the Vatican. It's our tax money building those museums.

What do you think Israel is about?

The Holocaust is debated precisely because of the weight of the subject and it's massive consequences.


Holy god. You refuse to be "suffocated" and then you refer to Zyklon B?? Do you understand irony?

Gassing by Zyklon B is entirely possible. Where did you decide it wasn't?

Einsatzgruppen -- come on, can't you look anything up? Means essentially "special assignment teams." They were really, really good at their jobs.

Modern Germany, to its credit, has recognized its special responsibility. They also pay non-Jewish surviving slave laborers, by the way. Including those wily Slavs.

Your statements are beyond belief. Barely minor league.
 
That is only so because we are told that Jews were gassed in gas chambers and shoved into ovens which is what is being disputed.

Well I like to know then what really happened in the the US. Were they not forced into labor and such as was the case in Germany?

No, the murder of approx 6 mln Jews and many millions of non-Jews is not disputed by anyone serious.

I'll defer to others about the detention of the Japanese-Americans. Not my province.
 
I admit that the holocaust happened.

I admit Jews were a major if not the major victim.

I debate the total number hideously murdered.

What does that make me?

I can't resist.
Edited by Darat: 
Breach of Rule 12 removed.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Are you having reading comprehension problems? I did not say Stalin was a great leader. Just not as wack as Hitler. And yes, it was the military virtue of the Russian soldier, more than Stalin's military skills that enabled them to defeat the Germans.

And the Chinese Communists were at least trying to rebuild China for the benfit of the Chinese, rather than for the Japanese.

What Japan did to China and Korea was inexcusable.

This is where I differ with you greatly. I think Stalin was as sick as Hitler. Communists were sick bastards who shortly after became mortal enemies of the US.

Why would the Chinese try to do something for the Japanese? What kind of logic is that in an attempt to defend China? How well do you think China has done today with their Communist ideals?

Any atrocities are inexcusable. Why don't you go tell the Chinese to stop persecuting the monks in Burma that is happening today?
 
Some of the German allies were Slavs: the Bulgarians for example. Slavs were recruited into the Waffen SS.

Cut down by me to the Waffen SS. Yep, they were. Some hated Stalin and the Sovs more than anything else (Russians and Sovs of many sorts). Others thought they could gain independence (Ukraine) but were bitterly disappointed by the Germans' treatment of them. Others were just glad to get out of the Germans' prison camps in which millions of Soviet soldiers died.

Interestingly, many of the Waffen SS Slavic conscripts or volunteers ended up fighting the US-UK-Canadian-Polish forces in France. Whaddaya know.

Waffen SS is the military branch of the SS, by the way, not responsible for the death camps. I figure Magzie is going to use "Waffen SS" existence to "prove" that the SS as a whole wasn't involved in the death camps.
 
...snip...

Any atrocities are inexcusable. Why don't you go tell the Chinese to stop persecuting the monks in Burma that is happening today?

Er Burma is not China, China does not control the government of Burma, the persecution of opponents to the current military government in Burma are persecuted by fellow Burmese.
 
Oh right, Bulgaria. Magz and Kag, you'll love this bit. While the Germans' Bulgarian allies helped round up and deport to Auschwitz the Greek Jews, they protected their own (Bulgarian) Jews. Isn't that annoying? Don't you feel like calling up King Boris and giving him a piece of your mind?
 
Any atrocities are inexcusable. Why don't you go tell the Chinese to stop persecuting the monks in Burma that is happening today?

Cut by me to this last bit. Eh? The Chinese are in Burma whoops, Myanmar?

Edit: ach, too late.
 
Last edited:
I thought British servicemen were treated fairly well in the POW camps. At least they were not keep out in the open as Eisenhower did with the German prisoners he held at the end of the war.

See Other Losses by James Bacque.

Unfortunately my grandfather is not here to put you straight but in any case you may take my word for it or you could take the word of the germans who admitted the very things you deny

You won't though because there is something wrong inside your head
 
I don't think you're Japanese, by the way. That would mean you are non-Aryan by any "definition."

Inside Germany... Yep, Germans did pretty well, for a while. What's a "non-Aryan"? Are Czechs and Poles and Russians "non-Aryan"? He hated them like poison. Almost as much as he hated the Jews, but he didn't have any respect for their brains, so they could wait a bit, and then live in slavery to the Germans.

You think I'm not Japanese because that would mean I'm non-Aryan? By definition I guess it would mean I'm non-Aryan. So what?

What's an Aryan and who is not considered an Aryan or a non-Aryan?

BTW why is it so incredulous that I am Japanese? I was born in Japan from two very Japanese parents. It's as simple as that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom