[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

It doesn't mean the Holocaust hasn't happened the way it did.

Too much BS to respond to here.

Again, because you hate the state of Israel you want to diminish the Holocaust.

It's an odd case of:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post_hoc_ergo_propter_hoc

"The state of Israel is wrong,
the Holocaust was used to create the State of Israel.
Therefore the Holocaust was wrong."

The Holocaust happened the way it did, and Israel is there to stay.

Good bye creep.

You certainly have a fascination with assumption and conjecture don't you?

But what if the Holocaust was exaggerated? What if the Nazis didn't gas Jews in gas chambers and burned them alive in ovens?

If it is true these stories were fabricated then that is great indignity to the German people who also suffer from the burden of the Holocaust and the Nazis even today. Did the Nazis still kill Jews? Yes it appears to be so, but the extermination camps really appears to be for what it is. A concentration camp for labor to produce goods. The extermination camps were really crematoriums that burned dead bodies to help stop the spread of typhus. Many people died in the war for a variety of reasons.

None of this matters off course. Even if the Holocaust did happen that way it did, it still is not justification for the colonization and creation of Israel.
 
You certainly have a fascination with assumption and conjecture don't you?

But what if the Holocaust was exaggerated? What if the Nazis didn't gas Jews in gas chambers and burned them alive in ovens?

If it is true these stories were fabricated then that is great indignity to the German people who also suffer from the burden of the Holocaust and the Nazis even today. Did the Nazis still kill Jews? Yes it appears to be so, but the extermination camps really appears to be for what it is. A concentration camp for labor to produce goods. The extermination camps were really crematoriums that burned dead bodies to help stop the spread of typhus. Many people died in the war for a variety of reasons.

None of this matters off course. Even if the Holocaust did happen that way it did, it still is not justification for the colonization and creation of Israel.

Marvelous post! Read the first line, then read the three paragraphs of your own conjecture. What if... what if... if it is true... appears to be... even if...

You are Your posts are totally factless. It's really amazing.
 
Oh, where to begin? This thread has grown so much since I left for work this evening.

Hitler wanted Germany to be the one and only super-power, and for all non-Germans to be subjects to the Germanic peoples. There just was no place for the Jews in this scheme. He didn't even consider them fully human. There was no intent to re-settle the Jews in Palestine. If he said that, it was entirely a ruse. He made sure that his borders were sealed so that the Jews could not escape and save him the trouble of confining them awaiting transfer.

Hitler thought, at the outset, that America and Britain would fall into line with him before the invasion of France. When they didn't, he thought that Britain would capitulate easily, there being such a large fascist movement in Britain, especially among influential citizens, to include at least a cousin of Neville Chamberlain"s. I sometimes wonder wheter Neville himself might have been a closet Nazi.

Dunkirk taught him otherwise.

Hitler was also kind of useless in planning strategic moves. His foolishness, in the end, was a blessing to the world. It was really stupid of him to have left a major logistics center on his flank.

He was not interested in just wiping out Communism. He thought that the wheat fields of the Steppes should belong to the Herrenvolk. It's in Mein Kampf.

The "sliver" of Czechoslovakia that he wanted was also the source of most of the resources for the Czech industries and the only defensible boundary within Europe where his expansion could have been stopped. Chamberlain should burn in hell for stabbing the most vibrant democracy in Europe in the back.

In case anyone is still wondering, I am not Jewish. My ancestors were English, French and Polish, with perhaps a bit of Cherokee many generations back.

Betray my race? That is an absurd concept to begin with.

It's like this. If you have descendants, your blood line is not extinct.

There have been two "pure" races in the history of mankind, the Tasmanians and the Neanderthalers. See what they amounted to? Only by breeding out were any remnant of them preserved. There is still some speculation that the only reason there are white people in the world is that the far eastern populations of Neanderthalers doinked African immigrants. The DNA tests are still inconclusive, in my opinion. I think the most telling test would be on the Predmosti remains. They look more Neanderthal than African to me, but are still clearly H. sapiens sapiens.

Just being white does not, in and of itself, make anyone special or more deserving of a bigger share of the world's resources.

And Pierce and Matthews were not great men. They were morons, and the world is better off without them.

As for those who hope to fulfill their dreams, they are welcome to the pointy ends of a few rounds of 7.62X54R should they get froggy.
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Sealion

It existed but was postponed indefinitely.

"Following swift victory in the Battle of France, Germany believed the war in the west was won. However, the United Kingdom refused peace talks. "


It seems you are determined to cling to the incredibly stupid notion that Hitler actually wanted peace. You are afraid to read Kershaw so I will bring Kershaw to you. I know the detailed explanation from one of the finest historians (imagine that, consulting a historian on history) on the subject of Nazi Germany will have little effect on you, but it should illuminate the weakness of your viewpoint for others.

http://books.google.com/books?id=9S...ts=i9wfZGnM6_&sig=uHs-yVtv9afDtjXEWks--h-DKfs

A few hundred pages of far greater depth than anything you have presented. I would suggest you read the entire thing but you have made it obvious that a few lines from some hack internet site is the best you can do. Once again, leave history alone and stick to your anti-semitism.
 
It is not disputed, it is a fact. You want to dispute it because you want to diminish the horror, in order to invalidate the state of Israel.

I want to dispute it because it seems it may not have been possible or make sense that the Nazis specifically would use Zyklon B to exterminate mass amounts of people.



Contradictory testimonies do seem to exist. That nothing that bad ever happened other then how wartime conditions are like.

I still wonder why the Nazis even bothered to delouse the prisoners with Zyklon B which is what it is made for, only to use the same gas to kill the prisoners instead?

The Nazis did have an interest in keeping the prisoners alive so they could be put to work in the labor camps. It does seem that the Nazis had a need for manpower so it would actually make sense to keep more prisoners alive.




Was it technically and logistically possible to have carried out mass executions in gas chambers specifically using Zyklon B given the conditions of the environment and the process described by witness testimonies?

A highly lethal gas that can be absorbed through the skin, but was designed as granules to be slow release and could not have achieved temperatures high enough for the gas to evaporate given the location.

That given these conditions it is not be possible that prisoners would die in minutes upon release, but instead would take much longer or possibly not even die at all because the gas would be ineffective in that cold, damp environment?

Since the dead bodies would continue to emit the lethal gas it absorbed, body disposal would be an incredibly dangerous if not lethal task. It appears that it neither seems logistically possible to kill that many people using Zyklon B gas or practical to use gas for mass extermination.

Disposing of even one person that died from gassing requires the body to be scrubbed down thoroughly before it is safe to handle it again.

It makes me wonder if Zyklon B could have even been used for mass extermination?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zyklon_B
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Zyklon_B
 
WHOA! That pretzel logic makes my head hurt.

I still wonder why the Nazis even bothered to delouse the prisoners with Zyklon B which is what it is made for, only to use the same gas to kill the prisoners instead?

To save ammo, once the have separated the Arbeitsfaehig from the Arbeitsunfaehig.

The Nazis did have an interest in keeping the prisoners alive so they could be put to work in the labor camps. It does seem that the Nazis had a need for manpower so it would actually make sense to keep more prisoners alive.

It made some sense to keep the Abreitsfaehig alive as long as they remained in that status, but they were not, apparently, considered worth the effort of providing well for their continued well-being.

Was it technically and logistically possible to have carried out mass executions in gas chambers specifically using Zyklon B given the conditions of the environment and the process described by witness testimonies?

A highly lethal gas that can be absorbed through the skin, but was designed as granules to be slow release and could not have achieved temperatures high enough for the gas to evaporate given the location.

Of course it was.


Disposing of even one person that died from gassing requires the body to be scrubbed down thoroughly before it is safe to handle it again.

What gives you that idea?

You know, don't you, thatr Zyclon B was also used to delouse clothing? Not how persistant a residue could it leave and still be safe to use for that purpose?

And how can a dead body release a lethal dose of the stuff if it only absorbs enough to kill the individual? It really makes no sense.

Using Zyclon B was good logistics, because it gets two uses out of one commodity, saving the trouble of ordering and transporting several in smaller quantities.

Now, as for your blather about its being ineffectual in that environment, how, pray tell, would it be on any use against lice if cannot disperse into a gas that the inefficient respiratory apparatus on an insect could inhale?
 
It seems you are determined to cling to the incredibly stupid notion that Hitler actually wanted peace. You are afraid to read Kershaw so I will bring Kershaw to you. I know the detailed explanation from one of the finest historians (imagine that, consulting a historian on history) on the subject of Nazi Germany will have little effect on you, but it should illuminate the weakness of your viewpoint for others.

http://books.google.com/books?id=9S...ts=i9wfZGnM6_&sig=uHs-yVtv9afDtjXEWks--h-DKfs

A few hundred pages of far greater depth than anything you have presented. I would suggest you read the entire thing but you have made it obvious that a few lines from some hack internet site is the best you can do. Once again, leave history alone and stick to your anti-semitism.

So this Ian Kershaw guy is quite the hero for you huh?

It seems the contents of his books are controversial. Aren't there more then one historian out there?

Now you have a problem with wikipedia? You know it is widely accepted and does contain links to various sources and I merely provide it for reference. Wikipedia is quite biased to mainstream views and about Jews anyways. You should be welcoming them.
 
It seems the contents of his books are controversial. Aren't there more then one historian out there?

Yes, there are. And the vast majority of them consider Hitler to have been a deranged and perverted little git who inflicted some of the greatest evils ever perpetrated against humanity.

Stalin, at least, was sympathetic to those who actively participated in the building of the society he envisioned. He did not exclude entire categories by accident of birth. Unfortunately, he was not competant to really carry out the designs of Marx and Engels. He was too much into himself. He had a distorted vison of the world, but that vision was grounded in a lot more realistic principles than was Naziism.

Pol Pot probably had more in common with Hitler. He would have been considered a very close second, had he had as many people under his jurisdiction, and his vision was more of a halucination.
 
So this Ian Kershaw guy is quite the hero for you huh?

It seems the contents of his books are controversial. Aren't there more then one historian out there?

Now you have a problem with wikipedia? You know it is widely accepted and does contain links to various sources and I merely provide it for reference. Wikipedia is quite biased to mainstream views and about Jews anyways. You should be welcoming them.

Controversial? By who, never mind you never seem to mention those sorts of things. He is regarded as one of the greatest historians alive and his biography of Hitler is considered the definitive work, replacing Bullock's (you seem to forget I have mentioned him, no surprise, I have seen your limited comprehension in action) biography. Should I bother to list his awards and work up to his knighthood? Yeah very controversial. Not at all like the crap you spout. I have also cited Ambrose, we are now up to 3 historians, to your zero. I could add Watt and Greenberg but what's the point. It's not like you would actually read real history, it won't support your hatred. And it would be difficult to find a student of the period who doesn't regard Kershaw as someone to emulate. His scholarship is awe-inspiring, and reminds me how trivial my knowledge is. Imagine where you would place on that scale.

Wikipedia is a joke in any university I have attended or worked in. I have never been in a history department that would allow it's use as a source. There goes the idea that it is widely accepted. This is easy enough to confirm, drop by a local university history department and ask them. While you're are it, you might repeat your "summary" to them, Historians enjoy a good laugh. I am quite done being the least bit courteous to you, you are not trying to learn, nor are you seeking the truth. You are simply trying to justify your racism, and are far out of your league here. You have repeatedly shown how ignorant you are of the basics, once again referring to that infantile summary of yours. It's time to invoke the slaughter rule.
 
Last edited:
You know, don't you, thatr Zyclon B was also used to delouse clothing? Not how persistant a residue could it leave and still be safe to use for that purpose?

And how can a dead body release a lethal dose of the stuff if it only absorbs enough to kill the individual? It really makes no sense.

I would assume that clothing do not absorb gas as opposed to a dead body.

How do you know that a body can't absorb more gas? It only requires a small amount for it to be lethal so it really doesn't matter how much gas the bodies can really absorb.

Using Zyclon B was good logistics, because it gets two uses out of one commodity, saving the trouble of ordering and transporting several in smaller quantities.

Now, as for your blather about its being ineffectual in that environment, how, pray tell, would it be on any use against lice if cannot disperse into a gas that the inefficient respiratory apparatus on an insect could inhale?

From what I understand, it would require that the ambient temperature needs to be high enough to meet the point where the Zyklon B granules would evaporate for it to be effective. Larger amounts are required to kill pests then humans.

I would imagine the Nazis knew how to properly use Zyklon B for it's purpose. To delouse prisoners in an effort to stop typhus which it seems they had frequently done and for any new prisoners that entered the camps.
 
Yes, there are. And the vast majority of them consider Hitler to have been a deranged and perverted little git who inflicted some of the greatest evils ever perpetrated against humanity.

Stalin, at least, was sympathetic to those who actively participated in the building of the society he envisioned. He did not exclude entire categories by accident of birth. Unfortunately, he was not competant to really carry out the designs of Marx and Engels. He was too much into himself. He had a distorted vison of the world, but that vision was grounded in a lot more realistic principles than was Naziism.

Pol Pot probably had more in common with Hitler. He would have been considered a very close second, had he had as many people under his jurisdiction, and his vision was more of a halucination.

You're actually defending Stalin and Communists? Wow. You don't find a problem with that? You sound like you're almost drooling over Stalin. Do you support China too?

Just wondering if it would be appropriate to call you a Communist from now.
 
From what I understand, it would require that the ambient temperature needs to be high enough to meet the point where the Zyklon B granules would evaporate for it to be effective. Larger amounts are required to kill pests then humans.

I would imagine the Nazis knew how to properly use Zyklon B for it's purpose. To delouse prisoners in an effort to stop typhus which it seems they had frequently done and for any new prisoners that entered the camps.

(emphasis added)

In other words, they were using Zyklon B to delouse prisoners, and for delousing, you need dosages that are lethal to humans. :dig:
 
WARNING! these videos contain disturbing images.


These videos are from the world at war episode "genocide" and include numerous eyewitness accounts from jews and germans.

genocide 1
the warsaw ghetto.
http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=3-o6jvWXPCQ

genocide 2
transportation to camps.
http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=xxchZq_IBLY

genocide 3
inside the camps.
http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=frlgTIWYzz4

genocide 4
the horror comes to an end.
http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=VABMeV_KvFw


Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.
George Santayana (1863-1952)
 
You're actually defending Stalin and Communists? Wow. You don't find a problem with that? You sound like you're almost drooling over Stalin. Do you support China too?

Just wondering if it would be appropriate to call you a Communist from now.

Not defending Stalin, as much as I am saying that Hitler was many times more the monster. Stalin was too self-centered to really build a sound socialist state. And he was militarily inept. Had he not rehabilitated Zhukov, we would all have been screwed. It is more a testament to the fighting abilities and courage of the Russian soldier and the brilliance of some of their weapons designers that they were able to hold off the Germans and turn the tide of battle. Those qualified field commanders who managed to survive the purges made the real difference. Stalin was actually in the way a lot in the lead-up to the war.

No, I do not defend the kind of communism practiced in China, either, but it was an improvement over what the Japanese did to China and Korea.

I'm actually a Democrat, but a bit left of FDR.
 
Not defending Stalin, as much as I am saying that Hitler was many times more the monster. Stalin was too self-centered to really build a sound socialist state. And he was militarily inept. Had he not rehabilitated Zhukov, we would all have been screwed. It is more a testament to the fighting abilities and courage of the Russian soldier and the brilliance of some of their weapons designers that they were able to hold off the Germans and turn the tide of battle. Those qualified field commanders who managed to survive the purges made the real difference. Stalin was actually in the way a lot in the lead-up to the war.

No, I do not defend the kind of communism practiced in China, either, but it was an improvement over what the Japanese did to China and Korea.

I'm actually a Democrat, but a bit left of FDR.

You mentioned Stalin and sympathize in the same sentence. I'm not sure how much more sappy you can get. The brave Communist, Bolshevik soldiers? Hitler was also fighting on two fronts.

You did just try to defend what China is doing still to this day.What does the Japanese have to do with what China is doing to their own people?

Wow I had no idea some people really support communism. Why don't you go live in China then?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom