[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

Are you sure about that? Do you mean Germans could not start businesses on their own. No retail stores or small machine shops, no produce stands or cafes to be started on their own for their own livelihood. It just does not sound likely to me.

Major industries are highly regulated by the government. It is one of the main tenets of Fascism.
 
You have got to be kidding me. The US was duped into entering the war by Hitler, you do know he declared war on them and not vice versa? As for elaborating on Hitler's offer of peace (not land, PEACE, unless you count his guarantee of the Empire, and you shouldn't) after the fall of Poland, and then of France, would you have believed him? Hitler was well aware than Germany was not prepared for a long term war, and eventually he would have to turn east for his lebensraum. Look up how Hitler felt about the concept of a 2 front war. Hence his "peace' offer.

No what exactly happened? I've been pretty occupied by this headline that said:

Judea Declares War On Germany
http://www.biblestudysite.com/judeawar.htm
http://www.wintersonnenwende.com/scriptorium/english/archives/articles/jdecwar.html


Are you sure Hitler didn't offer to give all the land back and just wanted it back to pre-WWI boundaries?

This clearly illustrates that Hitler had no desires to invade Britain or the US as he considered them Aryan cousins.

Any additional sources regarding Hitler's peace offer would be appreciated.
 
Hundreds of thousands were killed by Lithuanians, Latvians, Ukrainians and Romanian troops killed some 360,000. But yeah, the vast majority were killed by Nazis.

Also, some number emigrated to America and Israel. Some number died as many civilians died in the war. Some number died fighting in the war.
 
No what exactly happened? I've been pretty occupied by this headline that said:

Judea Declares War On Germany
http://www.biblestudysite.com/judeawar.htm
http://www.wintersonnenwende.com/scriptorium/english/archives/articles/jdecwar.html


Are you sure Hitler didn't offer to give all the land back and just wanted it back to pre-WWI boundaries?

This clearly illustrates that Hitler had no desires to invade Britain or the US as he considered them Aryan cousins.

Any additional sources regarding Hitler's peace offer would be appreciated.


Yes, I am not surprised that those headlines would fascinate you. Does the armband get ever get tight?

As for sources, I gave you your assignment, this is also covered by Kershaw and Bullock. Odd, they don't seem to think Hitler was being honest.

Really now, others have pointed out that your arguments fall into the neo-nazi nonsense more than they do any search for history. Why not simply give up the facade and admit you have something against Jews. I could care less about that, it's the butchering of history I find offensive.
 
The only country National Socialist Germany wanted to destroy was the Soviet Union. To get there you have to go through Poland.
Then please explain the conquering of Belgium, Holland, Denmark, Norway, Luxemburg, and France, as well as the attempted conquering of Britain. All of these nations were on Germany's western front. Poland, Russia, etc., are on the eastern front. Couldn't anyone in the Nazi regime read a map?
 
Last edited:
Then please explain the conquering of Belgium, Holland, Denmark, Norway, Luxemburg, and France, as well as the attempted conquering of Britain. All of these nations were on the western front.

Well, If you want to get to the Soviet Union by way of Alaska, one way would be to work your way west from Europe and across the USA and Alaska until you conquered Siberia.

Simple. ;)
 
Last edited:
Also, some number emigrated to America and Israel. Some number died as many civilians died in the war. Some number died fighting in the war.

You have to narrow that down some, only German Jews managed to emigrate in any numbers. I have mentioned before that the western nations raised some major obstacles to jewish immigration (Canada was among the worst). People seem to have the idea that the Nazi policy against Jews was a static affair. This couldn't be further from the truth. The Nazi attitude would change and evolve because of many reasons, most importantly being the huge number of Jews in the captured territories, and the influence of radical elements within the Nazi government. There is no question that there were elements within the German government that were loathe to pursue some of the more aggressive parts of Jewish policy. Some of the (smarter) members of the government recognized the contributions from Jews within the society (Schacht for example), some were even humane in their concerns. Sadly these people were not among those closest to Hitler, who could be influenced on such matters (i.e. campaign to euthanize the handicapped in the 1930s). This is not to say the anti-Jewish campaign could have been stopped, it was much too central to Hitler's basic tenets and propaganda. but perhaps it might have been blunted.
 
Then please explain the conquering of Belgium, Holland, Denmark, Norway, Luxemburg, and France, as well as the attempted conquering of Britain. All of these nations were on Germany's western front. Poland, Russia, etc., are on the eastern front. Couldn't anyone in the Nazi regime read a map?

Ouch you have my beloved Lacey's picture and now I have to quibble with you. The conquering of the west was simply the logical move. There was no way that Britain and France could back down at this point, their public would never have allowed it. Hitler had proven that he could not be trusted under any circumstances. France could actually have won the war rather easily had it simply invaded (unbelievably crappy leadership) anytime in 1939 or early 1940. Instead they gave Germany all the time it needed to shift the troops from Poland to Norway, and then to the western front. They have to take Belgium and Holland because the Maginot line would have forced an ugly frontal assault. It was Guderian who really wrote these plans, I think he could read a map.

I know you wrote this as a reply to the silly contention of Hitler wanting peace but I am in full out discussion mode, and this is more interesting to me than nitpicking tiny details in the Holocaust.
 
No, the Holocaust is being debated by deniers because they want Isreal to disappear. Denialism is the appearance of a debate where there is none, to further a political cause.

http://www.denialism.com/2007/03/what-is-denialism.html

If it wasn't for your hatred of Israel, there wouldn't be a debate about the Holocaust.

Please remember that the Holocaust came before Israel which completely invalidates your statement.



Balfour Declaration in 1917
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balfour_Declaration_of_1917

"the British government supported Zionist plans for a National home for the Jewish people within Palestine‎ "


Transfer Agrreement

http://www.transferagreement.com/

" The Transfer Agreement is Edwin Black's compelling, award-winning story of a negotiated arrangement in 1933 between Zionist organizations and the Nazis to transfer some 50,000 Jews, and $100 million of their assets, to Jewish Palestine in exchange for stopping the worldwide Jewish-led boycott threatening to topple the Hitler regime in its first year."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greater_Israel
http://www.biblestudysite.com/judeawar.htm
http://www.jewsagainstzionism.com


It turns out the Zionists really did plan out this whole Israel thing including the issue of how to get Jews to move there all based on a whacky religious tale that tells of G-d giving Eretz Israel to the Chosen Ones and trying to rebuild the Temple of Solomon.

Certainly not to say that the Israeli government has not done anything wrong ever right? What about the Palestinians?

http://www.btselem.org/index.asp
 
Yes, I am not surprised that those headlines would fascinate you. Does the armband get ever get tight?

As for sources, I gave you your assignment, this is also covered by Kershaw and Bullock. Odd, they don't seem to think Hitler was being honest.

Really now, others have pointed out that your arguments fall into the neo-nazi nonsense more than they do any search for history. Why not simply give up the facade and admit you have something against Jews. I could care less about that, it's the butchering of history I find offensive.

Would you happen to know the exact name and conditions of this peace offer? I really like to see some sources on this since I am having a hard time finding any. Since you seem to know a lot about it you must have some sources you can provide?
 
Please remember that the Holocaust came before Israel which completely invalidates your statement.

It is you who has it backwards pal.

As you posted, the state of Israel was a project well before the Holocaust happened. So you trying to invalidate or diminish the Holocaust in order to discredit Israel is a dead end.
 
Last edited:
Would you happen to know the exact name and conditions of this peace offer? I really like to see some sources on this since I am having a hard time finding any. Since you seem to know a lot about it you must have some sources you can provide?


There was no formal offer. Hitler had extended peace feelers through other officials after Poland, notably Goring (he had a network that ran through Scandinavian diplomats). After the fall of France, Hitler made the advance in a Reichstag speech. If Britain conceded Europe and arranged to have the former German colonies returned, Hitler would magnanimously recognize the British Empire. As Kershaw and Bullock both note, this generous offer came almost immediately after he was told that Operation Sea Lion was a virtual impossibility.
 
It is you who has it backwards pal.

As you posted, the state of Israel was a project well before the Holocaust happened. So you trying to invalidate or diminish the Holocaust in order to discredit Israel is a dead end.

The state of Israel physically did not exist before the Holocaust right?

Many people feel the Holocaust serves as a perfect justification for the creation of the state of Israel that was arbitrarily decided between a couple Zionists and the British on foreign territory with indigenous people living on it who have been under brutal occupation of said state with a racist policy against non-Jews since then.

My first and foremost purpose in this discussion is to find out exactly what occurred during the Holocaust.
 
Transfer Agrreement

http://www.transferagreement.com/

" The Transfer Agreement is Edwin Black's compelling, award-winning story of a negotiated arrangement in 1933 between Zionist organizations and the Nazis to transfer some 50,000 Jews, and $100 million of their assets, to Jewish Palestine in exchange for stopping the worldwide Jewish-led boycott threatening to topple the Hitler regime in its first year."


You might want to actually read this book before you assume it buttresses you ideals. It doesn't.
 
Many people feel the Holocaust serves as a perfect justification for the creation of the state of Israel

It doesn't mean the Holocaust hasn't happened the way it did.

that was arbitrarily decided between a couple Zionists and the British on foreign territory with indigenous people living on it who have been under brutal occupation of said state with a racist policy against non-Jews since then.
Too much BS to respond to here.

My first and foremost purpose in this discussion is to find out exactly what occurred during the Holocaust.
Again, because you hate the state of Israel you want to diminish the Holocaust.

It's an odd case of:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post_hoc_ergo_propter_hoc

"The state of Israel is wrong,
the Holocaust was used to create the State of Israel.
Therefore the story of the Holocaust is wrong."

The Holocaust happened the way it did, and Israel is there to stay.

Good bye creep.
 
Last edited:
There were about 6 million Jews missing from Europe at the end of the war.

Are you contending that all 6 million were murdered by the Nazis?

This is an argument from ignorance and incredulity.

To properly answer this question, you need to show that your number of 'about 6 million Jews missing' is correct.

To do this you need to look at the population of Jews in Europe before and after World War II. You have done this already.

Then you need to see if the definition of 'Jew' and 'European' was the same in both the before and after surveys. Then you need to see if the methodology behind the surveys was comparable.

Only then can you be confident that you have a handle on the number of Jews in Europe before and after World War II.

Next you need to consider that the Jewish population wasn't static. People were being born, changing their religion and dying of natural causes. So you need to account for these factors

Only then can you properly understand how many Jews were missing from Europe.

Now you can start to investigate why these Jews might be missing. To do this you need to study deaths in combat, deaths at the hands of the nazis and those who fled overseas.

This clearly illustrates that Hitler had no desires to invade Britain.

. It also does not seem that Hitler wanted global conquest nor even had the desire to topple England as he viewed their cooperation as necessary.

The plan to invade was called Operation Sealion. It existed. Deal.
 
Last edited:
Ouch you have my beloved Lacey's picture and now I have to quibble with you.
Given the first part of your reply, I'll let you quibble without complaint. :D

I know you wrote this as a reply to the silly contention of Hitler wanting peace but I am in full out discussion mode, and this is more interesting to me than nitpicking tiny details in the Holocaust.
Well, it was more of a reply to the idea that if Germany wanted to get Russia first and foremost, then it went in the wrong direction for over a year.

The plan to invade was called Operation Sealion. It existed. Deal.
There were also some fairly detailed plans as to how the occupation of Britain would be conducted.

That said, the prospects for Germany actually being able to successfully conduct a seaborne invasion of Britain were quite low. They just didn't have the proper equipment or experience to do the job right even if they had won the Battle of Britain (winning that was also unlikely).
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom