[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

Ridicule yes, although to be honest the type of people I've seen that try and deny the Holocaust probably aren't too concerned about how ridiculous they look.

That is the thing that intrigues me. If one is to conclude based on evidence that 5 million were murdered, one is claimed a DENIER. I see nothing like this in the study of any other aspect of history.
 
I know I have not participated in this thread, but I must say, Jerome, it is not the number. If you say that 5 million died, not 6 million, that is not being a denier. Being a denier is more akin to... well, to use a crappy analogy: a truther isn't someone who says that no one died on 9/11. A truther is someone who says it was a CD, or space beams, or indestructible Israelites, or something equally silly.
 
That is the thing that intrigues me. If one is to conclude based on evidence that 5 million were murdered, one is claimed a DENIER. I see nothing like this in the study of any other aspect of history.

You are not commenting on what I actually posted, constructing and argument for someone else and then arguing against that is known as a "strawman".
 
Excuse me, where did I "admit" something I did not actually say?

Reported.

Are you kidding?

The conversation you entered was the reasoning behind there not being anyone "serious" disputing the claim of 6 million. I proposed ridicule as the reasoning behind this and you agree with this assessment.

I was complementing you on your honesty.

:confused:
 
You are not commenting on what I actually posted, constructing and argument for someone else and then arguing against that is known as a "strawman".

I was not making an argument against what you wrote. I was commenting on my thinking initiated by what you wrote.

Everything is not an argument. Maybe I am confused. I am attempting to have conversation.
 
That is the thing that intrigues me. If one is to conclude based on evidence that 5 million were murdered, one is claimed a DENIER. I see nothing like this in the study of any other aspect of history.

Given your comment I apologise for misconstruing this post originally.

I do not see what you claim. There have been many debates between historians over the decades over exactly how many people (of whatever group) were exterminated and depending on their own classifications many respected historians have different figures for different groups. In a sad way it does not matter if there were 5 or 6 million people exterminated the magnitude doesn't change.

What is ridiculed and yes is even against the law in a very few countries is the claim that mass extermination of millions of people did not happen.
 
I know I have not participated in this thread, but I must say, Jerome, it is not the number. If you say that 5 million died, not 6 million, that is not being a denier.

This is what I find unusual about this subject. Any thought or evidence that seems to dispute any aspect of the holocaust is retorted with claims of denier and other sorts of name-calling, and then is extrapolated into the desire of the denier wanting to destroy Israel and/or Jews.

Leftysergeant gave an honest answer in that he believes that the subject is so important that any question of the facts could lead to a resurgence of the ideals of the Nazis.
 
Why do you respond to a question about the gassing with an example of forced abortions?

I'm not. I'm suggesting you read up on the subject.

You're the one who's saying the Nazis weren't all that bad. So, how about those newborn babies ?

The specific event being questioned is the gas chambers. Were there really gas chambers?

Aside from people who weren't there, no one seems to dispute that.

Heck, even the Nazis admitted to it.

No one ever seems to have actually seen the prisoners die.

Seeing them die would've meant being in the "showers" with them, would it not ?

Only that they were lined up naked to be entered into the showers and heard screams.

So, what ? You think the water was too cold ?

You're just a Nazi apologist, now.

We are also told that the gas chambers were disguised to look like showers so they can fool the prisoners when they were really going to gas them.

We also know that the Nazis did use Zyklon B gas to delouse prisoners.

It just seems rather elaborate on the part of the Nazis that they would go that far just to execute prisoners in gas chambers. They had orchestras?

This is an argument from personal incredulity. Do you have any actual evidence that puts the "official" version in question ?
 
Are you kidding?

No, I'm not. This isn't the first time you've misrepresented someone else's argument on this thread. Darat saw that you had twisted my words straight away, see above.

The conversation you entered was the reasoning behind there not being anyone "serious" disputing the claim of 6 million. I proposed ridicule as the reasoning behind this and you agree with this assessment.

SDC was in fact referring to the murder of 'approx' six million and millions of others. It seems you think that the Six Million figure is either sacred or taboo, which it is not, otherwise Raul Hilberg (who calculated 5.1 million in 1961 and stuck by it until his death this summer) would be excoriated as a 'denier' instead of lauded and elevated to the AAAS and invited to sit on the USHMC, etc etc etc.

Clearly, if you are unfamiliar with Raul Hilberg's estimate then you don't know very much about this subject, and would benefit from reading his standard work The Destruction of European Jews.

Now be off with you.
 
This is what I find unusual about this subject. Any thought or evidence that seems to dispute any aspect of the holocaust is retorted with claims of denier and other sorts of name-calling, and then is extrapolated into the desire of the denier wanting to destroy Israel and/or Jews.

Leftysergeant gave an honest answer in that he believes that the subject is so important that any question of the facts could lead to a resurgence of the ideals of the Nazis.


Well, also, you have to look at some of the facts that deniers debate. I mean only 300,000 Jews dead? Cyanide can't kill people? (Yes, I have heard that before, though not online, so I can't give a link, sorry.) And some other really outrageous things should get someone rightfully branded as a denier. I know that sometimes the person honestly doesn't know any better, but still.
 
Well, also, you have to look at some of the facts that deniers debate. I mean only 300,000 Jews dead? Cyanide can't kill people? (Yes, I have heard that before, though not online, so I can't give a link, sorry.) And some other really outrageous things should get someone rightfully branded as a denier. I know that sometimes the person honestly doesn't know any better, but still.

Well; without a internet link to your personal conversations, I can not believe a word you say.;)

Seriously, I am certain that you have heard the claims you describe. I do agree that ridiculous claims should be ridiculed. I think this should go both ways. If I remember correctly the lamp shade and soap stories have been debunked.
 
It wasn't addressed to me, but heck, let's go through this. You have 3 questions. Here are the answers.

The hate is from you, Magz.

"Decedent" means someone who is dead. (Deceased, get it? de·ce·dent (dhttp://img.tfd.com/hm/GIF/ibreve.gif-shttp://img.tfd.com/hm/GIF/emacr.gifdhttp://img.tfd.com/hm/GIF/prime.gifnt)
n. Law A dead person.) This question makes no sense.


You are closer to a Stalinist than anyone else I hear on this list.

Lefty, sorry. I interrupted. I should back down. I got carried away.

Are you having a good time in discussing this topic?
 
Isn't this the same in the US? Many people say the Nazis could not have been possible without the backing of influential people abroad.

Hitler was also Time's Man of the Year.

That is usually a leftist argument made here in America. The story goes with the claim that American bankers helped finance the rise of Hitler. No doubt there were banking agreements with Germany before Hitler but I just don’t see any Americans being sympathic to Hitler other that Henry Ford. There was just too much anti-Hitler propaganda in America in the 1930's for most people think independently.
 
Last edited:
There was just too much anti-Hitler propaganda in America in the 1930's for most people think independently.

Does pro-hitler propaganda allow people to think independently?

In your world, perhaps nothing should ever be reported or stated lest it conflicts with our independence of thought?

Is this what you do? Just make any old crap up and believe it because you're an independent thinker?

Except, of course, your thoughts on any subject are not really original, are they, because you get them all from far right websites, don't you?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom