[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

Darn that UK! Were just like the Poles in your mind; "taunting" Hitler by refusing to surrender?

Didn't you know that hundreds of thousands of British people would regularly congregate on the White Cliffs of Dover and shout "nah-nah we ain't surrendering" just to taunt the Germans?

If we hadn't done that I'm sure Germany and its allies would never, ever have killed or harmed a single British person so all those deaths of British (and Commonwealth allies) people were entirely the responsibility of the British because they would not surrender.

What could have been more provocative than not surrendering to an aggressor?
 
Himmler’s first interview with an American journalist.
http://www.ihr.org/jhr/v18/v18n5p50_Stoddard.html

Evil Himmler said:
For centuries, that region and others in eastern Europe have been chronically disturbed by jarring minorities hopelessly mixed up with one another. What we are now trying to do is to separate these quarreling elements in just, constructive fashion.

There is no "just" way to uproot and exile ethnic groups.
 
Wow I had no idea some people really support communism. Why don't you go live in China then?


You've never been there have you?

I have earlier this year and it was wonderful, a huge and expanding economy and wonderful people who love to learn things from the west. Huge skyscrapers and getting more and more like Hong Kong everyday. My company (fron the US) are making huge money over there at the moment, very far from communism.

Not the big red machine you obviously think it is. Every post you have made so far has been full of ignorance and deficient in facts.

You must try harder.
 
BTW why is it so incredulous that I am Japanese? I was born in Japan from two very Japanese parents. It's as simple as that.

We'll not go into the atrocities committed by your lot during the war then eh?

Probably find you are just as in denial about them as you are about the nazi's

I wondered why you seemed to have a soft spot for them. Cozy bedfellows in the war atrocities game perhaps?
 
You think I'm not Japanese because that would mean I'm non-Aryan? By definition I guess it would mean I'm non-Aryan. So what?

What's an Aryan and who is not considered an Aryan or a non-Aryan?

BTW why is it so incredulous that I am Japanese? I was born in Japan from two very Japanese parents. It's as simple as that.

Watch the extra negatives, young person. Too many negatives make sentences, in English, really hard to parse. In Slavic languages, by contrast, you can toss negatives in by the ton without ambiguity.

You are the one, I gather, who is concerned about Aryans vs non-Aryans. Those who were agitated on the topic (like the Nazis) were very clear that Aryans did not include East Asians of any variety. I have some vague idea that the Japanese were declared "honorary Aryans" for the duration of the war, by the Germans... Something to do with the Ainu people of the northern island.

What do the self-proclaimed "Aryans" say when an individual of Japanese extraction (as I gather you are) stops by the club and says, "Hey guys, how are ya doin'?"

"Aryan", as a group of people (ethnic group, race, tribe, fan club, whatever you want), does not exist. What does exist is a linguistic distinction; though the word "Aryan" is no longer used, as "Indo-European" is preferred for the large language family.

Nuts. You see how messy it gets with English-language negatives? You've got me thinking about it and I get muddled. Coffee... need more coffee...
 
Please remember that the Holocaust came before Israel which completely invalidates your statement.

Unholy mother of Hell! You're so ignorant it syphons my own knowledge!

It turns out the Zionists really did plan out this whole Israel thing including the issue of how to get Jews to move there all based on a whacky religious tale that tells of G-d giving Eretz Israel to the Chosen Ones and trying to rebuild the Temple of Solomon.

Well, if I had any doubt that you were an anti-semite, they're gone, now!

Many people feel the Holocaust serves as a perfect justification for the creation of the state of Israel that was arbitrarily decided between a couple Zionists and the British on foreign territory with indigenous people living on it who have been under brutal occupation of said state with a racist policy against non-Jews since then.

Actually, it had been in discussion for a few decades before the war. Don't you read anything ?

But what if the Holocaust was exaggerated? What if the Nazis didn't gas Jews in gas chambers and burned them alive in ovens?

Then that would imply the most massive creation of fake evidence in the history of mankind. Do you know of Occam's Razor ?

The extermination camps were really crematoriums that burned dead bodies to help stop the spread of typhus.

Not according to everyone who lived in those horrific camps.
 
So this Ian Kershaw guy is quite the hero for you huh?

Ad Hominem.

It seems the contents of his books are controversial. Aren't there more then one historian out there?

Yes. Most of them disagree with you.

You're actually defending Stalin and Communists? Wow. You don't find a problem with that?

Nice dodge. Please, make every effort NOT to adress his points.

Just wondering if it would be appropriate to call you a Communist from now.

Well, you seem to be fond of labeling, so go right ahead.

Wow I had no idea some people really support communism.

Then you haven't been out of your basement, much.
 
Kageki said:
It was called resettlement and they did have plans to resettle the Jewish population to Palestine. Why do you spend so much effort to transport people only to kill them?

:rolleyes:

One of the survivors to appear on the section about the camps talks about the gassing. Did he actually witness them die?

Maybe you should read Marie Claude Vaillant-Couturier's testimony at Nuremberg. It's quite... educational. According to her testimony, Jewish babies were drowned as soon as they were born.
 
Something of a side note, but I think relevant. It's frequently said that while old ex-communists are almost impossible to shut up about their past beliefs and affiliations, old nazis are almost completely silent about theirs. (Now that I think of it, this was frequently said when I was in graduate school, which was a while ago. Ooof.)

Hitler's architect and party boy Speer was an exception, in terms of telling his story, but it's come to be recognized that Speer and historical truth did not spend much time together.
 
We'll not go into the atrocities committed by your lot during the war then eh?

Probably find you are just as in denial about them as you are about the nazi's

I wondered why you seemed to have a soft spot for them. Cozy bedfellows in the war atrocities game perhaps?

Since this thread is about the Holocaust there should be no need to get into it in the first place.

Well if soft spot as in it was simply my country then yes. funk what is your nationality?

Do you also recall that Japan was ultimately decimated by the US? Would you like to know the stories of my parent's childhood in a ravaged, post-WWII Japan or would you even care?

My American friend used to explain to me from a documentary he saw on Discovery about how the Japanese tossed babies on bayonettes and other acts of atrocities with a gleeful smile. Yeah they were sick. How can I deny it happened? I am however interested to know exactly what happened.

Would you also like to talk about the genocide of Native Americans or the Indian Removal Act?
 
Since this thread is about the Holocaust there should be no need to get into it in the first place.

...snip...

If atrocities carried out by other participants in WWII have no place in this discussion what relevance was there to you binging up China and Burma today to the discussion?
 
Maybe you should read Marie Claude Vaillant-Couturier's testimony at Nuremberg. It's quite... educational. According to her testimony, Jewish babies were drowned as soon as they were born.


Why do you respond to a question about the gassing with an example of forced abortions?


The specific event being questioned is the gas chambers. Were there really gas chambers?

The only thing we see is a gas chamber that was made by the Soviets. The rest is witness testimonies and forensic evidence that is hotly contested.

No one ever seems to have actually seen the prisoners die. Only that they were lined up naked to be entered into the showers and heard screams. Not much is talked about how they got rid of the bodies afterwards which resulted from the use of a lethal gas. Is there any difficulties in moving large amounts of dead bodies that remain to exude the lethal gas that it absorbed?

http://www.adelaideinstitute.org/Auschwitz/truth.htm

Are we to believe that all these facilities at Auschwitz were just for Nazis? They even had 16 orchestras, but we are told the Nazis played classical music which consisted mostly of Jewish prisoners so they can fool the prisoners when they were really going to be gassed.

We are also told that the gas chambers were disguised to look like showers so they can fool the prisoners when they were really going to gas them.

We also know that the Nazis did use Zyklon B gas to delouse prisoners.

It just seems rather elaborate on the part of the Nazis that they would go that far just to execute prisoners in gas chambers. They had orchestras?

http://www.cympm.com/orkest.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Girl_orchestra_of_Auschwitz
http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/Holocaust/auschwitz_orch.html
auschwitz_orch.jpg

Prisoners' orchestra during a Sunday concert for the SS-men in Auschwitz.
The orchestra was probably conducted by the inmate Franciszek Nierychlo
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom