Bolded Part
[gnome]
Mein Gott, man! Do you realize that that would mean they killed 75 people per hour, 7 days a week, 365 days a year for two years! Do you have any idea of the logistics involved in that.... while fighting a losing battle against five different soviet armies! It boggles the mind that some people just believe anything. [/gnome off]
Actual holocaust deniers are beyond hope. I respond to them, admittedly with a certain passion, so that people stumbling across their filth will see it pegged for what it is. I'm more interested in the pseudo serious and neo-libertarians who are tip-toeing up to the edge of Denialism and hungrily peering in the window. Some of those might actually still be save-able.
AT and MaGZ are just lightweight bigots, IMHO. Note that Nick Terry doesn't even bother to drop more than a passing note. I'd bet that if Mr. Terry sees a serious or credentialed Denier in here, he'd be on 'em like white on rice.
No bet, but my standards for what might count as 'serious or credentialed' are pretty darn high now. The Skeptics Society Forum has a playpen for 2-4 deniers who are largely not worth debating, as the regular denizens can manage them quite well, and they are incredibly repetitive and boring.
A-Train and MaGZ are indulging in the usual antisemitic fallacies (
argumentum ad judaeorum? I forget my O-Level Latin knowledge of declensions. We do need this named precisely as there are many forms of CT woo that appeal to the magic powers of teh Joooz) and are thus essentially immune to reasoned argument. Quarantining them is easily done as neither seems inclined to post more than a few lines of a drive-by than make a sustained argument.
Likewise those who engage in HD/'scepticism' for trolling purposes. JdG has racked up nearly 1700 posts in what can't be more than 2 months here (join date: Oct 2007) and so it's small wonder he cannot manage more than one-liners of elliptical and cryptic relevance to anything that might be under discussion.
Apropos the Crimea, JdG seems to be indulging in another classic fallacy, argumentum ad ignorantium, combined with an argument to personal incredulity. Ignorance is no defense in a matter of historical or scientific argument. Before you can apply your personal scepticism, you have to know what the evidence is. The straight up answer to any debate over what happened to the Crimean Jews is to send JdG to the library, and probably also to language classes, to read the dissertations now published as books of Andrej Angrick and Norbert Kunz, two German historians who have respectively worked on Einsatzgruppe D (who carried out the mass shootings in the Crimea with support from the German Army and some local collaborators), and German occupation policy in the Crimea. I could also recommend some Russian-language material too.
No doubt JdG was blithely unaware that such books existed, or if he was, he has been pretending that their existence doesn't matter. He might perhaps demand, (1) an English-language work, (2) a source on the internet, (2) that his discussion partners do the reading for him. (1) through (2) exist, i.e. one can recommend Hilberg's classic study and therein one will find quite a bit of discussion of the Crimea on a few pages, likewise a lot of discussion of Otto Ohlendorf, the commander of Einsatzgruppe D. I bet one could find a fair few things through semi-competent Googling.
(2) and (3) are typical troll behaviour, i.e. a wilful refusal to consider the possibility that real knowledge and science, including historical knowledge and science, are not reducible to political and philosophical opinion, and have to be worked at.
This applies to the languages needed to get to the starting-line of direct knowledge of the evidence concerning the Holocaust. Engineers, physicists and architects need a mastery of maths, physics and other sciences which is potentially there in anyone who actually stayed awake