[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

That's a pathetic arguement. Yelling fire, or doing anything that has the potential to create a panic displays callous and wanton disregard for the public safety, and perhaps the intent to cause harm, and is, thus, of concern to the state for reasons of public safety.

By your definition, drunken driving would be of no concern to the state until you have harmed someone. You're talking through your belly button on this one.

I will continue to take the side of Oliver Wendall Holmes, the man who wrote the words in a supreme court case.

You can choose to think Holmes is pathetic if you like. It is still a free thought country.
 
The most important words here are "clear and present danger."

There is clear and present danger that encouraging acceptance of Holocaust denial and acceptance of Naziism as just another political position will eventually result in acceptance of mass murder, a la Kevin Barret's dreams of a blood purge of non-twoofers.
 
The most important words here are "clear and present danger."

There is clear and present danger that encouraging acceptance of Holocaust denial and acceptance of Naziism as just another political position will eventually result in acceptance of mass murder, a la Kevin Barret's dreams of a blood purge of non-twoofers.

Which part of National Socialism is a "clear and present danger"?

Fascism?

Socialism?

Nationalism?

Militarism?

Eugenics?

Antisemitism?
 
I will continue to take the side of Oliver Wendall Holmes, the man who wrote the words in a supreme court case.

You can choose to think Holmes is pathetic if you like. It is still a free thought country.


So, do you agree with Holmes' ruling that it should be criminal for a person to pass out anti-enlistment fliers to recently drafted soldiers in a time of war?

Do you believe that a case about passing out fliers can actually bind the states in the manner in which they decide when actual theater patrons may or may not alert those around them to the threat of fire?

Do you believe that the case in which Holmes made the statement is still good law?

Have you done any research on Schenck v. US at all? How about Blackburn?

Have you ever taken a course at any college at any time in Constitutional Law?

Have you ever read a book about the First Amendment?

Do you agree that it should be illegal to protest a war?

Can you define the "clear and present danger" test?

Do you believe that the "clear and present danger" test is still good law?

Have you ever protested a war?

Have you ever been tested for trisomy 21?

Put the following events in order:
World War I
Everything That's Happened Since World War I

In fifty words or less, describe where you think you are right now.

Now dance.
 
Which part of National Socialism is a "clear and present danger"?

Fascism?

Socialism?

Nationalism?

Militarism?

Eugenics?

Antisemitism?

All of it, though it is not really a form of socialism.

Minimizing the evil that they intended is dispicible. The deaths of the Jews did not just happen. The Nazis wanted them gone, and dead was as good a form of gone as any. They had, quite simply, no right as humans to have done what they did. They are evil and apologizing for them is an evil act. The only sub-humans involved in WWII were the Nazi ideolouges.
 
Bell I agree, many German's fought with honour and dignity, and respect for civilian population, and disagreed with the final solution or were unaware of it. Most of the german military senior hierarchy wanted to engage in terms after the success of Overlord.


That's true.

It does a dis service to Germans who signed up to the army that they were idealogical Nazis.


But I didn't say that. I said they were fighting for Nazi ideals. Which they were, in a manner that has nothing to do with what they did or didn't believe in personally. The result of their fighting, if successful, would not have been honor, dignity, and respect for the civilian population. It would have been the establishment of Nazi rule based on Nazi principles and goals, just as it was in every place they were successful.

I'm sorry they had to be destroyed. I'm glad they were destroyed.

I'm glad that today's Nazis are such an embarrassing joke that they don't have to be destroyed. I hope it stays that way, for their sakes as well as mine.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
All of it, though it is not really a form of socialism.

Just called itself and practiced socialism, but never mind that.

Minimizing the evil that they intended is dispicible. The deaths of the Jews did not just happen. The Nazis wanted them gone, and dead was as good a form of gone as any. They had, quite simply, no right as humans to have done what they did. They are evil and apologizing for them is an evil act. The only sub-humans involved in WWII were the Nazi ideolouges.

When you wrote the bolded above, did you mean that if it is a historical fact based on evidence that the Nazis killed 5 million Jews; that to state this fact, as it minimizes their atrocities, is despicable?
 
1. By your math that is a murder every 1 minute and 36 seconds 24 hours a day for 60 days straight.

2. With your logistics experience are you testifying this is logistically possible under the circumstances of the Crimea during war?



3. Name-calling?

(numbers added by me)

1. How long does it take to pull a trigger? Why gosh, you could kill ten people in one minute, and then have a 16 minute break, by your math. Or maybe you could line up, say twenty or thirty at a time. I think I read that they might have done that in certain areas (sarcastic smiley of your choice). Then you could kill a couple of hundred in an hour, and even have time to sleep. Jerome! Jerome! Jerome! It was World War II! (It was in all the papers at the time.) In many an action or battle, dozens or hundreds of people were killed within spans of minutes.

2. Once again you're evidencing complete lack of knowledge of the battle for the Crimea in '41. The Germans controlled all of the Crimea except for Sebastopol by October 31. The Russians landed a big ol' army/force in the area around Kersh a couple of months later, but the Germans whupped them real good, so essentially the only fighting in the Crimea in the time in question was the siege of Sebastapol. (Hint: Maps are your friend. Look at a map of the Crimea and get an idea of how much area was under their control.)


3. Yep. Your behavior is that of a troll so I say you're a troll. You're the Monty Python "argument sketch". No facts, just counterpoint. And when you take a chance on actually citing something factual, you quite often fail miserably as in this example. You called a fellow poster, in so many words, a liar. If you were an adult, you'd just apologize for the apparent mistake. (I think you misread the post and didn't see the 1942 date on the communique, but instead of admitting it, you're continuing to throw smoke grenades to cover your retreat, hoping someone will think you've won. You haven't, that sort of sophistry rarely plays here.)

I'm quite sure the mods watch any thread on the holocaust because tempers snap and accusations fly. If calling you a troll is an offence to the rules, I can I can live with the warning, but I frankly don't think it merits one. If it walks like a duck, talks like a duck, craps like a duck, and is constantly seen in the company of other ducks.....
 
Last edited:
(numbers added by me)

I will have to defer to your expressed skills of logistics and thus your account of the logistical ability of the Germans to scour the country side of the Crimea during the battles with the Russians and kill 50,000 people of a particular race in 60 days.



BTW: The memos you seem to be defending have yet to be sourced.

Do you normally take things written on the forums at face value, or just when you like what is said?
 
Just called itself and practiced socialism, but never mind that.



When you wrote the bolded above, did you mean that if it is a historical fact based on evidence that the Nazis killed 5 million Jews; that to state this fact, as it minimizes their atrocities, is despicable?

I am saying that disputing the numbers killed and stating that some of them just happened is to minimize the fact that the Nazis were an infection needed to be stopped by any means available and that those who do not now recognize them as evil may be contermplating further evil.

That there are still people in the world who do not consider the Nazis the greatest evil ever to rise is one of the reasons I own firearms and am preparted to use them without remorse.

There is no lower form of life passing for human than a Nazi.
 
I'm thankful that they shot the people who were fighting for Nazi ideals.

One post I bet you wish you'd thought more about.

It is still a free thought country.

One of the few left. That's why Stormfront have a radio show.

________________________________


Isn't it about time Holocaust denial was left to tag-teams from Stormfront to come over for Remembrance Day debates? Or cage matches, if they'd rather.


One thing I find ironic. Many vehement Holocaust denier deniers don't seem to hold the same of level of revulsion towards the atrocities their own country is actively committing right now.
 
I am saying that disputing the numbers killed and stating that some of them just happened is to minimize the fact that the Nazis were an infection needed to be stopped by any means available and that those who do not now recognize them as evil may be contermplating further evil.

By any means necessary if the subject is deemed important enough.

I agree with your sentiment. I disagree that facts should be hidden. When facts are hidden and then found it promotes ideas of romanticism of the vile.
 
That there are still people in the world who do not consider the Nazis the greatest evil ever to rise is one of the reasons I own firearms and am preparted to use them without remorse.

I've just read that a few times and I'm a little concerned for my safety. As I read it, your biggest concern is people who do not believe that the Nazis were the greatest evil ever and you'd have to include me in your target group. That the target is at the end of a gun disturbs me, especially when said gun has been purchased with me specifically in mind!

There is no lower form of life passing for human than a Nazi.

Given the vehemence you reserve for people who don't agree with you, you could chalk me up in the group that disagrees with that statement as well.
 
A theoretical question for those participants of this thread denying the Holocaust:

Let's for the moment say the Holocaust didn't happen. What then does that mean we should think about the Nazi regime? Should it still be reviled for waging war on its neighbouring nations? Should it still be considered a grotesque entity for the brutal manner in which it occupied the nations it subjugated? Should the SS and Gestapo still be regarded as horrible and repugnant organizations? Is it still moral and correct for the Allies to have defeated the Third Reich?
 
I'm sometimes amazed that Holocaust Deniers exist.

For crying out loud, the Einsatzgruppen shot some 1.5 M Jews before the death camps even opened!

To question the exact total of Jews killed is justified, IMO, in the interest of historical accuracy. But claiming that there was no organized, systematic campaign of genocide directed at the Jews by the Nazis??? That takes serious mental issues.

It speaks volumes that so many Holocaust Deniers have joined the 9/11 twoof movement.
 
A theoretical question for those participants of this thread denying the Holocaust:

Let's for the moment say the Holocaust didn't happen. What then does that mean we should think about the Nazi regime? Should it still be reviled for waging war on its neighbouring nations? Should it still be considered a grotesque entity for the brutal manner in which it occupied the nations it subjugated? Should the SS and Gestapo still be regarded as horrible and repugnant organizations? Is it still moral and correct for the Allies to have defeated the Third Reich?


I think their argument is more of a tortured form of antisemitism. They're stick with this logical proof that makes no sense but they have to try to make all of the premises true because it's all they've got:

1. Jews benefitted a great deal from world sympathy after the Holocaust.
2. But the Holocaust wasn't as bad as it was made out to be.
3. If the Jews knew this, they are liars who deserve to have all of the benefits taken away from them.
4. If the Jews didn't know this, they are now trying to cover it up which makes them liars who deserve to have all of the benefits taken away from them.
5. If the Jews didn't know this and aren't covering it up because they still don't really understand it, the harsh truth compels us to take away all of the benefits they've gotten because they never deserved them anyway.

All of this rests upon the supressed premises that: 1) Jewish advances since World War II are due to some sort of social guilt and not due to a generally increasing worldwide tolerance for religious diversity; and 2) that Jews have advanced far more than people realize and now run the world or something equally nuts.

Scratch a Holocaust denier, find a racist.
 
I'm sometimes amazed that Holocaust Deniers exist.

For crying out loud, the Einsatzgruppen shot some 1.5 M Jews before the death camps even opened!

To question the exact total of Jews killed is justified, IMO, in the interest of historical accuracy. But claiming that there was no organized, systematic campaign of genocide directed at the Jews by the Nazis??? That takes serious mental issues.

It speaks volumes that so many Holocaust Deniers have joined the 9/11 twoof movement.

Bolded Part

[gnome]
Mein Gott, man! Do you realize that that would mean they killed 75 people per hour, 7 days a week, 365 days a year for two years! Do you have any idea of the logistics involved in that.... while fighting a losing battle against five different soviet armies! It boggles the mind that some people just believe anything. [/gnome off]

Actual holocaust deniers are beyond hope. I respond to them, admittedly with a certain passion, so that people stumbling across their filth will see it pegged for what it is. I'm more interested in the pseudo serious and neo-libertarians who are tip-toeing up to the edge of Denialism and hungrily peering in the window. Some of those might actually still be save-able.

AT and MaGZ are just lightweight bigots, IMHO. Note that Nick Terry doesn't even bother to drop more than a passing note. I'd bet that if Mr. Terry sees a serious or credentialed Denier in here, he'd be on 'em like white on rice.
 
I will have to defer to your expressed skills of logistics and thus your account of the logistical ability of the Germans to scour the country side of the Crimea during the battles with the Russians and kill 50,000 people of a particular race in 60 days.



BTW: The memos you seem to be defending have yet to be sourced.

Do you normally take things written on the forums at face value, or just when you like what is said?

Jerome... try this again real slowly...

There
was
no
huge
battleground
in
the
Crimea
except
for
the
siege
of
Sevastopol.

Stop making that silly argument. The Germans had free run of the entire peninsula, including control of Yalta, just like in the rest of the Ukraine. And, as mentioned when the Russians put a huge force into Kersh, the Germans captured the whole damned bunch, so that area was only a battleground for a couple of weeks near the end of '41.
 
Trying to wrap my head around the idea that no one discusses the moral question surrounding the Allied bomber campaigns in general, let alone Dresden. It has been quite a hot topic for some time among documentary makers and historians.

...snip...

It's been discussed on the Forum many, many times. However its got nowt to do with the Holocaust.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom