[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

The point is that you shouldn't be asking these questions just to see what opinion or answer is acceptable.
The reason for asking the questions I did is because it often seems to me that the reason for denying the Holocaust is that it is an attempt to somehow make Hitler and the Nazi regime seem more palatable and less vile.

I wanted to know if the resident deniers here had that intent.
 
Hello. Very interesting thread here.

These are great questions that have crossed my mind as well as I started looking more into our history. In many ways though it is a strange question that shows the incredible force of social conformity. You ask these questions simply because it is unfashionable to even hint that the Nazi regime could possibly have not been evil incarnate.

The point is that you shouldn't be asking these questions just to see what opinion or answer is acceptable. If you are truly interested in finding out the answer then the only recourse is to do research yourself, but since they are good questions in the context of this discussion I can add a little to it.


I can't post any links yet so a quick summary regarding pre-WWII conditions:

- Germany suffered a crushing defeat in WWI. Hitler blamed the Jews for the loss (there is some truth in this)

- Hitler felt the Treaty of Versaille was unfair. Most of Europe felt the same. Germany also lost some territory as a consequence.

- Hitler wanted revenge from WWI. Hitler wanted to rebuild and rearm Germany and to regain the lost territory.

- Hitler hated Communism. His plans for the east were to mainly stop the Soviet Communists.

Invasion of Poland

- Poles were killing Germans living in Poland. Hitler wanted to defend them.

- Hitler wanted to regain the lost territory to Poland.

- Hitler only invaded Poland after making a non-aggression pact with the Soviets. They made a deal to split up Poland between them. The Soviets also invaded Poland from the east.

- Hitler did not think the British and also the French were going to attack Germany when he invaded Poland. The British were appeasing Hitler up to that point. The British made a secret pact to defend Poland if Germany were to attack Poland. This is what made Poles cocky and were openly taunting Germany prior to the invasion.


While this is not meant to justify the Nazis, it is a good start in illustrating that we have not been told the whole story. I can discuss this further, but I'll leave it at that for now since this thread is about the Holocaust.

Pfeh. Standard disingenuous Holocaust denier openers; just like the truther version, "Hey, I'm just asking questions." Here are a couple of comments. I'll comment on the points on which you are wrong. (No question that Germany felt wronged by Versailles, and some others felt so as well -- English popular opinion leaned to that side.)

You say: "there is some truth" in the Dolchstoss (stab in the back), by the Jews, legend of Germany's defeat in 1918. Nope. Wrong. No truth at all. Read some books, and I don't mean the likes o' Butz. Right now I'm reading Winkler's big book on Weimar Germany, a standard work.

You say: Hitler's main idea in the "wild east" was to stop communism. That was a factor, sure. So was Lebensraum, living room, the dream of creating a vast German colonial empire in the region. Poles, Czechs -- ooohh, did he hate Slavs! -- Russians, and others, were to be culturally "beheaded" (educated and upper classes destroyed) and enslaved, Roma/ Gypsies to be killed, etc.

You say: Poles were killing Germans. Nope. Wrong. Untrue.

You say: Poles were "cocky" and "openly taunting." Nope. Unless, "No, we aren't going to surrender" qualifies as that. And Britain's and France's guarantees to Poland were public knowledge -- they had to be, to be effective. While France had been allied with Poland for years, Britain gave up officially on appeasement after March 1939, when Hitler broke his promises (for the umpteenth time) and marched into rump (sic!) Czechoslovakia. Oh, you forgot to claim that the Czechs had been killing the Sudeten Germans. Come on, look at your cheat sheets! Do I have to remind you of everything?

Heck, are the Poles not allowed to be "cocky"? Any rule about that? Jeszcze Polska nie zginela, and I don't mean that in a nice way.

Crikey. What a lousy pack of ... incorrect statements.
 
Invasion of Poland

- Poles were killing Germans living in Poland. Hitler wanted to defend them.

- Hitler wanted to regain the lost territory to Poland.

- Hitler only invaded Poland after making a non-aggression pact with the Soviets. They made a deal to split up Poland between them. The Soviets also invaded Poland from the east.

- Hitler did not think the British and also the French were going to attack Germany when he invaded Poland. The British were appeasing Hitler up to that point. The British made a secret pact to defend Poland if Germany were to attack Poland. This is what made Poles cocky and were openly taunting Germany prior to the invasion.


While this is not meant to justify the Nazis, it is a good start in illustrating that we have not been told the whole story. I can discuss this further, but I'll leave it at that for now since this thread is about the Holocaust.

Well it sounds like you are trying to do just that, justifying the invasion of Poland. Do you anything to back up your claims? I find it hard to believe that the Poles, with small army and obsolete air force compared to the Germans would taunt anyone. Speaking of the whole story did you know that Polish Army was still using calvary when the Germans invaded?

Is this one of your sources?

< http://judicial-inc.biz/Broomberg.htm >
 
Well it sounds like you are trying to do just that, justifying the invasion of Poland. Do you anything to back up your claims? I find it hard to believe that the Poles, with small army and obsolete air force compared to the Germans would taunt anyone. Speaking of the whole story did you know that Polish Army was still using calvary when the Germans invaded?

Is this one of your sources?

< http://judicial-inc.biz/Broomberg.htm >

I'll disagree on some of this. In fact, the Polish state was overconfident, as things proved, concerning its military preparation; though of course the French and British guarantees added to their confidence. The general view was that the French, in particular, could beat Germany. Relative to the actual, eventual balance of forces, with the Germans in the west and the Sovs in the east, Poland gave a far better showing than is often recognized. And in the war as a whole, the 4th-largest-Allied armed forces were the Polish one -- though distributed (by 1943-44) between British and Soviet leadership.

Co nam przemoc obca wziela, szabla odbierzymy, you know.
 
Hello.

- Poles were killing Germans living in Poland. Hitler wanted to defend them.
These Germans the Poles were killing were known as the German Army, which invaded and occupied Poland and systematically slaughtered its civilian population.
 
The reason for asking the questions I did is because it often seems to me that the reason for denying the Holocaust is that it is an attempt to somehow make Hitler and the Nazi regime seem more palatable and less vile.

I wanted to know if the resident deniers here had that intent.

There is some truth to that as some of the deniers are white nationalists and sometimes gush about Hitler which is both wrong and biased, but the truth is also much murkier.

Isn't it also reasonable to say the Allied and the Jews attempt to make the Nazis more vile then they really were? Therefore have bias too?

Many of the allegations of Jewish survivors seem grossly exaggerated or completely fabricated. Burning babies alive? Did the Nazis really do that?

Why did the Nazis delouse prisoners with Zyklon B to stop the spread of typhus only to kill them later with the same gas? Some of it doesn't add up.

Closer analysis does seem to reveal that the Nazis weren't as evil as the Allied like us to believe, but still nowhere from innocent either. They did believe in purifying the Aryan race for instance and for the record considered Britain their Aryan cousins.

There shouldn't be some "intent" or bias. Only what really happened.
 
I'll disagree on some of this. In fact, the Polish state was overconfident, as things proved, concerning its military preparation; though of course the French and British guarantees added to their confidence. The general view was that the French, in particular, could beat Germany. Relative to the actual, eventual balance of forces, with the Germans in the west and the Sovs in the east, Poland gave a far better showing than is often recognized. And in the war as a whole, the 4th-largest-Allied armed forces were the Polish one -- though distributed (by 1943-44) between British and Soviet leadership.

Co nam przemoc obca wziela, szabla odbierzymy, you know.

There is a difference between being overconfident and taunting a potential foe.
 
My word, what an inauspicious beginning, Kageki. I don't think more than eleven words you posted were true. Have you studied World War II at all? I mean, have you studied anything not written by David Irving?


- Germany suffered a crushing defeat in WWI. Hitler blamed the Jews for the loss (there is some truth in this)


I have no doubt Hitler blamed the Jews for losing WWI. I have no doubt Hitler blamed the Jews for rain, sour milk and meteor showers. However, what truth is there that "the Jews" caused Germany to lose WWI? What truth is there that "the Jews" even acted as a cohesive bloc? And which Jews are you talking about - American, German, Polish? Why would Hitler blame the Polish Jews for Germany's inability to fight a two-front war?


Hitler felt the Treaty of Versaille was unfair. Most of Europe felt the same. Germany also lost some territory as a consequence.


I'm sure he felt everything that wasn't perfect for Germany was unfair. That was kind of his thing.


- Hitler wanted revenge from WWI. Hitler wanted to rebuild and rearm Germany and to regain the lost territory.


Revenge against whom? The mythical "Jews" who somehow caused Germany to lose by hoping really hard? Germany started a simultanious two-front war for, basically, no reason. Why is that anyone's fault but Germany's?


Hitler hated Communism. His plans for the east were to mainly stop the Soviet Communists.


If by "stop Soviet Communists" you mean "kill every man, woman and child from the German/Polish border to the Pacific Ocean," I agree with you. Somehow on his way to rid the world of Communism, he managed to kill eleven million civilians and set up death camps to liquidate the entire Jewish population of Poland. If Communism was his main goal, he sure wasted a lot of resources before getting at it.


Poles were killing Germans living in Poland. Hitler wanted to defend them.


I thought Hitler wanted to get through Poland to wipe out Soviet Communists. Which one was it?


Hitler wanted to regain the lost territory to Poland.


And some other choice pieces of real estate as well.


Hitler only invaded Poland after making a non-aggression pact with the Soviets. They made a deal to split up Poland between them. The Soviets also invaded Poland from the east.


Um, what? Didn't you say Hitler was trying to wipe out Societ Communism? Why would the fact that Germany and Russia made a deal to split Poland be any defense of the German invasion of Poland if Hitler's plan was to race through Poland and stab the Russians in the back as quickly as possible?


Hitler did not think the British and also the French were going to attack Germany when he invaded Poland. The British were appeasing Hitler up to that point. The British made a secret pact to defend Poland if Germany were to attack Poland. This is what made Poles cocky and were openly taunting Germany prior to the invasion.


Have you been drinking?


I can discuss this further.


Not intelligently, you can't.
 
Last edited:
Isn't it also reasonable to say the Allied and the Jews attempt to make the Nazis more vile then they really were? Therefore have bias too?
No.

Closer analysis does seem to reveal that the Nazis weren't as evil as the Allied like us to believe, but still nowhere from innocent either.
No. Closer analysis reveals that the Nazis were more evil than any history book can convey.

Link not safe for work: http://hatemonitor.csusb.edu/images/dartmouth/DachauBodiesApril_45.jpg

Time to get informed, kageki. http://www.nizkor.org/
 
Last edited:
There is some truth to that as some of the deniers are white nationalists and sometimes gush about Hitler which is both wrong and biased, but the truth is also much murkier.

Isn't it also reasonable to say the Allied and the Jews attempt to make the Nazis more vile then they really were? Therefore have bias too?

Many of the allegations of Jewish survivors seem grossly exaggerated or completely fabricated. Burning babies alive? Did the Nazis really do that?

Why did the Nazis delouse prisoners with Zyklon B to stop the spread of typhus only to kill them later with the same gas? Some of it doesn't add up.

Closer analysis does seem to reveal that the Nazis weren't as evil as the Allied like us to believe, but still nowhere from innocent either. They did believe in purifying the Aryan race for instance and for the record considered Britain their Aryan cousins.

There shouldn't be some "intent" or bias. Only what really happened.

What about the ones from the German survivors who admitted it all?

So my grandfather was lying then?
 
There is some truth to that as some of the deniers are white nationalists and sometimes gush about Hitler which is both wrong and biased, but the truth is also much murkier.

Isn't it also reasonable to say the Allied and the Jews attempt to make the Nazis more vile then they really were? Therefore have bias too?

Many of the allegations of Jewish survivors seem grossly exaggerated or completely fabricated. Burning babies alive? Did the Nazis really do that?

Why did the Nazis delouse prisoners with Zyklon B to stop the spread of typhus only to kill them later with the same gas? Some of it doesn't add up.

Closer analysis does seem to reveal that the Nazis weren't as evil as the Allied like us to believe, but still nowhere from innocent either. They did believe in purifying the Aryan race for instance and for the record considered Britain their Aryan cousins.

There shouldn't be some "intent" or bias. Only what really happened.

Gather 'round, folks! Many of those present are experts on the standard, sidling, crab-wise approach that truthers like to employ; "I'm just asking questions;" "Shouldn't we all be unbiased;" and so on and so forth which you all know well.

Well, we are now seeing the standard, sidling, crab-wise approach of the Holocaust denier types. The "truth is murkier...;" could the Nazis really have used Zyklon-B for killing when it could also be used for lice (which was, incidentally, a standard Nazi image of the Jews). Etc. etc.

I've often wondered. Do Holocaust deniers work from particular scripts? Do they draw on the same Web sites or books? Do they know that Hitler's last nephews live in obscurity (or did till recently, at least) in the greater NY area?

Oh yeah, he's right about one thing. The Nazis regarded the British as their racial cousins and were very annoyed that, with some exceptions (certain aristocratic families, and street fascists gathered around Mosley -- though he modelled himself more on Mussolini), the British were singularly uninterested. See Gerwin Strobl, "The Germanic Isle," a very good book.
 
Last edited:
There is a difference between being overconfident and taunting a potential foe.

"Poland wants war with Germany and Germany will not be able to avoid it even if she wants to." He threatened to overrun Germany in three days.

Rydz Smigly

?
 
"Poland wants war with Germany and Germany will not be able to avoid it even if she wants to." He threatened to overrun Germany in three days.

Rydz Smigly

?

Source please. And if you have a source that is not from some hate monger web site does this justify the Germans invading Poland?
 
What about the ones from the German survivors who admitted it all?

So my grandfather was lying then?

I like to seriously start collecting all these stories since everyone seems to know a survivor.

What did your grandfather say exactly? What did they exactly witness?

Sure the Nazis did seem to round up the Jews and seemed to use them mostly for forced labor to produce goods during the war.

Nazis seemed to be rather elaborate with their executions at camp. Going so far as to disguise a gas chamber as showers and have 12 orchestras throughout the camps which mainly consisted of Jewish prisoners only to fool the prisoners about the executions?

Again why did they bother to delouse and tattoo the prisoners only to execute them?

As for the Jews, the Transfer Agreement between the Nazis and Zionists seem to reveal the main plan for Jews was to deport them eventually to Palestine.
 
"Poland wants war with Germany and Germany will not be able to avoid it even if she wants to." He threatened to overrun Germany in three days.

Rydz Smigly

?

Source it, please. And in the original -- which could be Polish or French, that being the standard diplomatic language of the day. My French is mediocre, but I can translate the Polish fine if you will only provide it. Actually, I'll take the German, too. R-S was in the Polish Legion in WWI, which fought in the Austro-Hungarian army, so he probably spoke at least some German.

Alternatively, you can provide a reputable historian, who is not David Irving. I loved how, in the little poem he would recite to his daughter(s?), he rhymed "Aryan," and "Rastafarian." Don't you? Or do you think it was just a leeeeeeettle bit over the top?

And so what, anyhow? It was the Germans who invaded Poland. Edward Rydz-Smigly (also known, honest to god, as Edward Smigly-Rydz), was far from the brightest bulb in the box despite his leadership of the Polish state.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom