tsig
a carbon based life-form
- Joined
- Nov 25, 2005
- Messages
- 39,049
How do you define Holocaust denier?
If I said the Nazis killed only 4 million Jews would that fall into the category of denier?
How many do you have to kill to be a murderer?
How do you define Holocaust denier?
If I said the Nazis killed only 4 million Jews would that fall into the category of denier?
Trying to wrap my head around the idea that no one discusses the moral question surrounding the Allied bomber campaigns in general, let alone Dresden. It has been quite a hot topic for some time among documentary makers and historians.
How do you define Holocaust denier?
If I said the Nazis killed only 4 million Jews would that fall into the category of denier?
And yet, even with OWH's quote, you're still completely wrong. That is to be expected coming from a position of willful ignorance such as your own.
And here, as just one example out of fifty, is the California Penal Code Section 403:
403. Every person who, without authority of law, willfully disturbs
or breaks up any assembly or meeting that is not unlawful in its
character, other than an assembly or meeting referred to in Section
302 of the Penal Code or Section 18340 of the Elections Code, is
guilty of a misdemeanor.
See? There is no requirement that the threat of "fire" be taken seriously. There is no requirement of actual harm.
You are wrong.

How many do you have to kill to be a murderer?
The thing about deniers is that they don't necessarily deny the events
http://www.denialism.com/2007/03/what-is-denialism.html
"the employment of rhetorical tactics to give the appearance of argument or legitimate debate, when in actuality there is none."
Yeah, sorry - that was my fault, and then I had a problem removing mine![]()
I'm thankful that they shot the people who were fighting for Nazi ideals. I'm thankful that they bombed them. I'm thankful that they strafed them in their camps and burned them in their bunkers and bayoneted them in their trenches and garotted them at their guard posts and starved them in Stalingrad and sank them in the depths of the Atlantic. I'm thankful that they hung them by the neck in Nuremberg. At great cost to themselves, they did what they could and what was necessary to take the Nazis' power away forever, and I'm thankful for their many sacrifices and thankful for their success.
Myriad, with all respects returned, this part is just plain wrong, in generalizing each and every German that fought -and died- in the war, as fighting for Nazi ideals.
I know this thread isn't about that, but I thought it needed to be said.
The number of casualties at Dresden was a fluke due to the occurrence of a firestorm. Firestorms were very rare events, with perhaps just half a dozen occuring during the entire war. Had a firestorm not occurred, the casualties at Dresden would have been no worse than any similar raid on other German cities.How come we never hear about any American soldiers describing the carnage they witnessed in the wake of the firebombing of Dresden in February, 1945?
It's a topic I'm always willing to discuss. I find there are a lot of misunderstandings and misconceptions surrounding the subject.Trying to wrap my head around the idea that no one discusses the moral question surrounding the Allied bomber campaigns in general, let alone Dresden.
I remember watching that series. Personally, I felt many of the veterans' objections to that program vis-a-vis it presenting information out-of-context and incompletely were entirely justified.Here in Canada there was a major documentary called "The Valour and the Horror" which detailed the futility and the human costs of the Allied bomber campaigns. It caused a huge stir when the Legion began a national protest campaign against it.
The Jews have had a static population for 60 years?
So, in 1930 Jews were 9% of the world population, 6% of the world population in 1950, and today Jews are 2% of the world population.
What is your explanation for the decrease in percentage of Jews between 1950 and 2005?
Did they go to Mars?
So esquire, Oliver Wendall Holmes is wrong in what he stated in a Supreme court decision because the California code trumps the Supreme court.
You can only be punished for yelling fire in a crowded theater IF your yelling is taken as serious and there is actual harm done as a direct result of your yelling.
You can only be punished for yelling fire in a crowded theater IF your yelling is taken as serious and there is actual harm done as a direct result of your yelling.
The most stringent protection of free speech would not protect a man falsely shouting fire in a theater and causing a panic. [...] The question in every case is whether the words used are used in such circumstances and are of such a nature as to create a clear and present danger that they will bring about the substantive evils that Congress has a right to prevent.
Esquire, you can parse all you want but the fact remains that simply yelling fire in a crowded theater is free speech according to Oliver Wendall Holmes. Ohh, and I agree with Oliver and not you.
A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds.
Myriad, with all respects returned, this part is just plain wrong, in generalizing each and every German that fought -and died- in the war, as fighting for Nazi ideals.
I know this thread isn't about that, but I thought it needed to be said.
You can only be punished for yelling fire in a crowded theater IF your yelling is taken as serious and there is actual harm done as a direct result of your yelling.