[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

Trying to wrap my head around the idea that no one discusses the moral question surrounding the Allied bomber campaigns in general, let alone Dresden. It has been quite a hot topic for some time among documentary makers and historians.

Here in Canada there was a major documentary called "The Valour and the Horror" which detailed the futility and the human costs of the Allied bomber campaigns. It caused a huge stir when the Legion began a national protest campaign against it. Of course, it's only 15 years old so it might be a little too new for some. The History channel and the BBC have similar programs. It would be fair to say you can find dozens of articles in Jstor. A quick search of Amazon revealed several books and dvd's dealing with the subject, most specifically addressing Dresden.

Is it easy to not find something you aren't looking for?
 
Trying to wrap my head around the idea that no one discusses the moral question surrounding the Allied bomber campaigns in general, let alone Dresden. It has been quite a hot topic for some time among documentary makers and historians.

Then obviously it's not 'no one', right?

Anyway, using troofer logic, what evidence do we have that Dresden wasn't a Nazi false flag operation?

:eek:
 
Last edited:
Nothing like a thread like this to remind me of something to be thankful for on Thanksgiving Day. I've said this before, but I don't think it can be said too often.

I am thankful that our fathers and grandfathers, mothers and grandmothers, Americans and Brits and Russians and Candadians and countless others, fought and suffered and sacrificed to fight the Nazi ideology. I'm thankful that they were able to exploit its blindness and its weakness. I'm thankful that they battered it into what it remains today: a twisted impotent wisp of hatred; the stupidest, ugliest, and most useless ideology of a century notable for stupid, ugly, useless ideologies; a bad joke in bad taste; a handy source of stock villains for adventure stories (useful because no one is offended when the heroes shoot them on sight without hesitation or compassion); an icon of mental illness and of failure and of absolutely nothing else.

I'm thankful that they shot the people who were fighting for Nazi ideals. I'm thankful that they bombed them. I'm thankful that they strafed them in their camps and burned them in their bunkers and bayoneted them in their trenches and garotted them at their guard posts and starved them in Stalingrad and sank them in the depths of the Atlantic. I'm thankful that they hung them by the neck in Nuremberg. At great cost to themselves, they did what they could and what was necessary to take the Nazis' power away forever, and I'm thankful for their many sacrifices and thankful for their success.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
And yet, even with OWH's quote, you're still completely wrong. That is to be expected coming from a position of willful ignorance such as your own.


And here, as just one example out of fifty, is the California Penal Code Section 403:

403. Every person who, without authority of law, willfully disturbs
or breaks up any assembly or meeting that is not unlawful in its
character, other than an assembly or meeting referred to in Section
302 of the Penal Code or Section 18340 of the Elections Code, is
guilty of a misdemeanor.


See? There is no requirement that the threat of "fire" be taken seriously. There is no requirement of actual harm.

You are wrong.


So esquire, Oliver Wendall Holmes is wrong in what he stated in a Supreme court decision because the California code trumps the Supreme court.
:boxedin:

Good to know.
 
The thing about deniers is that they don't necessarily deny the events

http://www.denialism.com/2007/03/what-is-denialism.html

"the employment of rhetorical tactics to give the appearance of argument or legitimate debate, when in actuality there is none."

This presumes that anyone arguing that the Nazis killed 4 million Jews is a denier.

This is strange.

The Jewish population decreased in Europe by 6 million and we know for a certainty that a number did emigrate to the US and Israel.

Are you stating that to state these facts one is a denier?

Your implication is that facts are irrelevant to this particular talk, and a maligning characterization of the presenter of facts is appropriate.

What is the reasoning here?
 
I'm thankful that they shot the people who were fighting for Nazi ideals. I'm thankful that they bombed them. I'm thankful that they strafed them in their camps and burned them in their bunkers and bayoneted them in their trenches and garotted them at their guard posts and starved them in Stalingrad and sank them in the depths of the Atlantic. I'm thankful that they hung them by the neck in Nuremberg. At great cost to themselves, they did what they could and what was necessary to take the Nazis' power away forever, and I'm thankful for their many sacrifices and thankful for their success.

Myriad, with all respects returned, this part is just plain wrong, in generalizing each and every German that fought -and died- in the war, as fighting for Nazi ideals.

I know this thread isn't about that, but I thought it needed to be said.
 
Myriad, with all respects returned, this part is just plain wrong, in generalizing each and every German that fought -and died- in the war, as fighting for Nazi ideals.

Indeed, many of the victims of the allied campaign were entirely innocent. Many of them had no choice. That doesn't mean that Myriad is wrong though. They weren't killed to punish them - they were killed to end an evil.

I know this thread isn't about that, but I thought it needed to be said.

Part of the issue to do with Holocaust discussions is the extent to which the deaths of Jews differ from other deaths. It's not morally obvious.
 
How come we never hear about any American soldiers describing the carnage they witnessed in the wake of the firebombing of Dresden in February, 1945?
The number of casualties at Dresden was a fluke due to the occurrence of a firestorm. Firestorms were very rare events, with perhaps just half a dozen occuring during the entire war. Had a firestorm not occurred, the casualties at Dresden would have been no worse than any similar raid on other German cities.

The attack on Dresden was a completely ordinary Bomber Command raid. It is only the results that were extraordinary.

Trying to wrap my head around the idea that no one discusses the moral question surrounding the Allied bomber campaigns in general, let alone Dresden.
It's a topic I'm always willing to discuss. I find there are a lot of misunderstandings and misconceptions surrounding the subject.

Here in Canada there was a major documentary called "The Valour and the Horror" which detailed the futility and the human costs of the Allied bomber campaigns. It caused a huge stir when the Legion began a national protest campaign against it.
I remember watching that series. Personally, I felt many of the veterans' objections to that program vis-a-vis it presenting information out-of-context and incompletely were entirely justified.
 
Last edited:
The Jews have had a static population for 60 years?

So, in 1930 Jews were 9% of the world population, 6% of the world population in 1950, and today Jews are 2% of the world population.

What is your explanation for the decrease in percentage of Jews between 1950 and 2005?

Did they go to Mars?

What happened to the Jews?
Here is the answer from the experts.
http://www.ihr.org/jhr/v07/v07p375_Desjardins.html
 
So esquire, Oliver Wendall Holmes is wrong in what he stated in a Supreme court decision because the California code trumps the Supreme court.


Once again, you deliberately misread a post and then try to get a poster to back up a statement he never made. It is a very tiring and very ineffective debate tactic.

I never said OWH was wrong. OWH was a genius. I said you were wrong. You personally. You said this:

You can only be punished for yelling fire in a crowded theater IF your yelling is taken as serious and there is actual harm done as a direct result of your yelling.


It is an incorrect statement. As I showed you with just one state's law, there is no requirement that you be taken seriously or cause actual harm. It's not surprising that you were wrong as all you did was make up a rule out of thin air after having done no research whatsoever. You're bound to make mistakes when you have no idea what you're talking about.

In any case, you're wrong for many more reasons. Here is what Holmes actually wrote here:

The most stringent protection of free speech would not protect a man falsely shouting fire in a theater and causing a panic. [...] The question in every case is whether the words used are used in such circumstances and are of such a nature as to create a clear and present danger that they will bring about the substantive evils that Congress has a right to prevent.

So, all Holmes said was that fire could not be shouted "falsely." He never said anything about people needing to take the threat of fire seriously or of anyone suffering actual harm. The test you made up out of your imagination has nothing to do with what Holmes said.

But there's an even more important reason why California law doesn't disagree with Holmes: The case in which he said it had nothing to do with shouting things in theaters. The case of Shenck v. US was about a man convicted of circulating fliers against the draft in World War I. Everything Holmes said about fires in theaters was dicta. It was just words that he wrote to support his opinion that Congress could criminalize the act of telling people to resist the draft.

California isn't violating the Supreme Court's opinion because the Supreme Court's opinion only applies to the case it's hearing and similar cases. The Supreme Court cannot just start making rules about things that are not in dispute. So, nothing said in the case of a man with World War I fliers could ever actually bind any state about their shouting in public laws in any case.

Two points remain: First, the concept of dicta is so well understood, so open, and so obvious that it is amazing to me that you failed to apprehend this point. Anyone who did even a moment's research would see that Holmes could not have been talking about actual yelling in actual theaters. You clearly have no understanding of the facts or concepts about which you spoke.

Second, this is a case where the SCt found it was constitutional to convict someone of a crime for doing nothing but handing out pamphlets to draftees during a time of war. There's pretty much no question that the Court's opinion was reversed by Brandenburg v. OhioWP. Imagine Vietnam without "Alice's Restaurant," a song that had pretty much the same theme as Schenck's pamphlets. Considering how strident you've been in your defense of free speech in this and other threads, it is astonishing to me that you would cite Schenck with approval.

Perhaps you were utterly ignorant of the facts of Schenck and you spoke without giving your comments any thought whatsoever. Perhaps that's it.
 
Last edited:
You can only be punished for yelling fire in a crowded theater IF your yelling is taken as serious and there is actual harm done as a direct result of your yelling.

The most stringent protection of free speech would not protect a man falsely shouting fire in a theater and causing a panic. [...] The question in every case is whether the words used are used in such circumstances and are of such a nature as to create a clear and present danger that they will bring about the substantive evils that Congress has a right to prevent.


Esquire, you can parse all you want but the fact remains that simply yelling fire in a crowded theater is free speech according to Oliver Wendall Holmes. Ohh, and I agree with Oliver and not you.
 
You can only be punished for yelling fire in a crowded theater IF your yelling is taken as serious and there is actual harm done as a direct result of your yelling.

The most stringent protection of free speech would not protect a man falsely shouting fire in a theater and causing a panic. [...] The question in every case is whether the words used are used in such circumstances and are of such a nature as to create a clear and present danger that they will bring about the substantive evils that Congress has a right to prevent.


Esquire, you can parse all you want but the fact remains that simply yelling fire in a crowded theater is free speech according to Oliver Wendall Holmes. Ohh, and I agree with Oliver and not you.



Here's something else often attributed (wrongly) to Oliver Wendel Holmes: A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds.

I have explained why Holmes' statement cannot actually bind any state in any way regarding its criminal laws of fire yelling. I have explained why Holmes' statement does not actually imply your made up test. I have shown state law that contradicts your made-up test. Please cite any evidence at all that your made-up test is actually the law in any state in the country.

Also, your last paragraph contradicts everything else you said. Your last paragraph says that "simply yelling fire in a crowded theater is free speech," but Holmes said you cannot falsely shout fire. So which do you believe? Do you believe Holmes who limits speech only to times when the theater is on fire (like you say you do) or do you belive yourself that you can yell fire any time at all so long as it does not cause actual harm? Can you even tell the difference?

Hint: You can't. Reason: You're wrong. Result: Stop talking about topics on which you know nothing. Attenuated Result: The world becomes a better and smarter place for your silence.
 
Last edited:
Myriad, with all respects returned, this part is just plain wrong, in generalizing each and every German that fought -and died- in the war, as fighting for Nazi ideals.

I know this thread isn't about that, but I thought it needed to be said.

Bell I agree, many German's fought with honour and dignity, and respect for civilian population, and disagreed with the final solution or were unaware of it. Most of the german military senior hierarchy wanted to engage in terms after the success of Overlord.

It does a dis service to Germans who signed up to the army that they were idealogical Nazis.
 
You can only be punished for yelling fire in a crowded theater IF your yelling is taken as serious and there is actual harm done as a direct result of your yelling.

That's a pathetic arguement. Yelling fire, or doing anything that has the potential to create a panic displays callous and wanton disregard for the public safety, and perhaps the intent to cause harm, and is, thus, of concern to the state for reasons of public safety.

By your definition, drunken driving would be of no concern to the state until you have harmed someone. You're talking through your belly button on this one.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom