[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

I like to seriously start collecting all these stories since everyone seems to know a survivor.

What did your grandfather say exactly? What did they exactly witness?

Sure the Nazis did seem to round up the Jews and seemed to use them mostly for forced labor to produce goods during the war.

Nazis seemed to be rather elaborate with their executions at camp. Going so far as to disguise a gas chamber as showers and have 12 orchestras throughout the camps which mainly consisted of Jewish prisoners only to fool the prisoners about the executions?

Again why did they bother to delouse and tattoo the prisoners only to execute them?

As for the Jews, the Transfer Agreement between the Nazis and Zionists seem to reveal the main plan for Jews was to deport them eventually to Palestine.

Poppycock. You aren't even up to Atrain's level. Please check your cheat sheets! Don't you have any, well, self-respect? Don't you want to make a good showing? Don't you want to make converts?

Yes, I've met survivors, and I've seen the numbers. No close relations though there were some among my European cousins, who moved after the war to Israel. Most survivors, and most WW2 vets are dead now, of course. Remember -- last year? -- the guy who tried to kidnap Eli Wiesel in a hotel and force him to reveal the "truth"?

Edit: I believe the man who was tattooed #1 is, or was till recently, still alive in Poland and active in Auschwitz survivors activities -- a Polish Christian, not a Jew. How do you feel about the 100 thousand or so Polish Christians who were killed at Auschwitz, by the way?
 
Last edited:
...snip...

Oh yeah, he's right about one thing. The Nazis regarded the British as their racial cousins and were very annoyed that, with some exceptions (certain aristocratic families, and street fascists gathered around Mosley -- though he modelled himself more on Mussolini), the British were singularly uninterested. See Gerwin Strobl, "The Germanic Isle," a very good book.

It's a sad fact that until quite late on Hitler had the support of many influential British people, infamously the owner of the Daily Mail supported Hitler until Britain declared war with Germany.

In 1933 he published this editorial in his newspaper

I urge all British young men and women to study closely the progress of the Nazi regime in Germany. They must not be misled by the misrepresentations of its opponents. The most spiteful distracters of the Nazis are to be found in precisely the same sections of the British public and press as are most vehement in their praises of the Soviet regime in Russia.

They have started a clamorous campaign of denunciation against what they call "Nazi atrocities" which, as anyone who visits Germany quickly discovers for himself, consists merely of a few isolated acts of violence such as are inevitable among a nation half as big again as ours, but which have been generalized, multiplied and exaggerated to give the impression that Nazi rule is a bloodthirsty tyranny.

The German nation, moreover, was rapidly falling under the control of its alien elements. In the last days of the pre-Hitler regime there were twenty times as many Jewish Government officials in Germany as had existed before the war. Israelites of international attachments were insinuating themselves into key positions in the German administrative machine. Three German Ministers only had direct relations with the Press, but in each case the official responsible for conveying news and interpreting policy to the public was a Jew.
 
I like to seriously start collecting all these stories since everyone seems to know a survivor.

What did your grandfather say exactly? What did they exactly witness?

he is dead

Sure the Nazis did seem to round up the Jews and seemed to use them mostly for forced labor to produce goods during the war.

Nazis seemed to be rather elaborate with their executions at camp. Going so far as to disguise a gas chamber as showers and have 12 orchestras throughout the camps which mainly consisted of Jewish prisoners only to fool the prisoners about the executions?

Again why did they bother to delouse and tattoo the prisoners only to execute them?

Why not research it from an openminded point of view? Instead of asking stupid uniformed questions.

As for the Jews, the Transfer Agreement between the Nazis and Zionists seem to reveal the main plan for Jews was to deport them eventually to Palestine.

What was left of them perhaps?

My grandfather was a british soldier who served nearly all the war in a german POW camp. He said they were the most evil scum he had ever seen. His word is good enough for me.
 
I like to seriously start collecting all these stories since everyone seems to know a survivor.


No need to. These people have already started collecting eyewitness testimonies for you. Of course, they've only managed to to film 50,657 of them, so that might not be sufficient proof for you.
 
It's a sad fact that until quite late on Hitler had the support of many influential British people, infamously the owner of the Daily Mail supported Hitler until Britain declared war with Germany.

In 1933 he published this editorial in his newspaper

This is a bit off topic but there was a woman MP who was part of this group. Naturally she did not get along with Winston Churchill. She once told him "Sir, if you were my husband I would put poison in your tea". Chruchill being master of one liners replied "Madam, if I were your husband I would drink it." :D
 
Is it me or does anyone else have the sneaking suspicion that one of our holocaust deniers has a new profile?
 
My grandfather was a british soldier who served nearly all the war in a german POW camp. He said they were the most evil scum he had ever seen. His word is good enough for me.

My father-in-law was captured in early 1945, near Strasbourg, a 20 year old Jewish kid from Detroit; company medic. He was shipped to a POW camp where the oldtimers were British captured in 1940 or 1941. And of course the prisoners basically ran the inner workings of the camp; standard procedure. The British oldtimers made sure that no Jewish soldiers were ever sent out on work details, because typically they were "shot while trying to escape." He never talked about his experiences till I became his first son-in-law (no sons, 4 daughters), in 1978. But I always felt they had helped keep him alive, and his family is grateful.

And then, of course, there was the day the American air force bombed the POW camp and almost killed him ...
 
There is some truth to that as some of the deniers are white nationalists and sometimes gush about Hitler which is both wrong and biased, but the truth is also much murkier.

Isn't it also reasonable to say the Allied and the Jews attempt to make the Nazis more vile then they really were? Therefore have bias too?

Many of the allegations of Jewish survivors seem grossly exaggerated or completely fabricated. Burning babies alive? Did the Nazis really do that?

Why did the Nazis delouse prisoners with Zyklon B to stop the spread of typhus only to kill them later with the same gas? Some of it doesn't add up.

Closer analysis does seem to reveal that the Nazis weren't as evil as the Allied like us to believe, but still nowhere from innocent either. They did believe in purifying the Aryan race for instance and for the record considered Britain their Aryan cousins.

There shouldn't be some "intent" or bias. Only what really happened.

wie es eigentlich gewesen war...;)

But that's precisely how it is within history, which is the only yardstick worth applying here. The field of research into the Third Reich, WWII and the Holocaust is one of the most internationalised there is; Germans, Americans, Brits, pretty much all other European nationalities, all checking each others' work and rectifying inevitable national biases.

All this scholarship shows that the Nazis were more murderous than any other regime in European history, more murderous than Stalin (yes, fact fans, Dolfy pips Uncle Joe to the post there) and more widely murderous than anyone else, too. This gives about 25+ countries in modern Europe an especially good reason to remember Dolfy. Most particularly in Eastern Europe, where the Nazis ran amok murdering millions of Poles, Belarusians, Ukrainians and Russians.

As for the warmed-over denier canards

1) burning babies alive: there are multiple eyewitness accounts to this effect. By standards dating back to the Romans, we can conclude that this was probably the case, on rare occasions. Funnily enough this is not a detail that is regularly mentioned in conventional history books, since it's simply gross.

It's also utterly peripheral to the real issue, which is how the SS organised mass murder on a routine basis, since this was an exceptional event, not the norm. The witness evidence says that this happened for a certain period in 1944, number of times unknown, because there were difficulties (shortages of gas, space in the gas chamber, too few people arriving to be gassed economically).

Frankly, whether or not that detail happened is irrelevant. At best, you have a possible embellishment, not a key detail whose possible falsity (note, possible, since all you're doing is bringing argument to personal incredulity to the table here) would negate the totality of a witness account.

2) The 'doesn't add up' wiffle about Zyklon and delousing is pure ignorance of the circumstances. The SS got the inspiration for one kind of gas chambers from the T4 euthanasia program, and indeed transferred experienced personnel from German euthanasia institutes to Poland, to run death-camps such as Belzec, Treblinka and Sobibor. So this had nothing to do with delousing at all.

Second, delousing facilities never used Zyklon B on people, because, duuuh, it's incredibly lethal. HCN was used to kill lice in clothing; people would be separated from their clothing and then sent via a separate route into showers, then reunited with their freshly deloused clothing afterwards. This happened to millions of people, including Wehrmacht soldiers, Ostarbeiter, other foreign workers, and KZ inmates.

The inspiration to use Zyklon B at Auschwitz most certainly originated from its use as a delousing agent, but that speaks to the logic of the development, not to its 'not adding up'. Furthermore, Zyklon B was first used to kill people in an experiment on Soviet commissars and sick Polish camp inmates. These people had to die, the Auschwitz camp staff thought they'd try something different that was potentially less messy than mass shootings (which tend to grind an Uebermensch down after a while, they found).

:boggled:

Anyway, time for you to put your cards on the table: what are the sources for your so far unsourced hearsay opinions?
 
Hello. Very interesting thread here.

These are great questions that have crossed my mind as well as I started looking more into our history. In many ways though it is a strange question that shows the incredible force of social conformity. You ask these questions simply because it is unfashionable to even hint that the Nazi regime could possibly have not been evil incarnate.

"Evil incarnate" is a rather strange term. The typical sheep following Hitler probably had no immediate intention of committing evil, but the over-all design was about as evil as a "human" gorvernment can become. And being evil was by no means a disqualification for membershipp in even the innermost circles of power in the party. Ultimately, many of the actions of the party and of the state they created were unspeakably evil. Mass exterminations and enslavement of entire peoples are just not defensible.

The point is that you shouldn't be asking these questions just to see what opinion or answer is acceptable.

"Hitler was not as bad as he is made out to be" is not an acceptable answer among civilized human beings. He was about as evil as any major world leader has ever been. Stalin is a distant third, right after Pol Pot.

Germany suffered a crushing defeat in WWI. Hitler blamed the Jews for the loss (there is some truth in this)

I would say that the defeat was more a result of the hubris of the German leadership. The Jews may not have supported the war effort as much as the ethnic Germans would have liked, but, then, the war was not really a good idea to begin with.

Hitler felt the Treaty of Versaille was unfair. Most of Europe felt the same. Germany also lost some territory as a consequence.

- Hitler wanted revenge from WWI. Hitler wanted to rebuild and rearm Germany and to regain the lost territory.

Half-point for the first part. The treaty sucked and was driven by the baser instincts of the victors. Life is hard. Deal with it. As for the lost territory, it was taken by force of arms to begin with, so that does not justify taking more by force of arms. Hitler's vision was of Germany taking what the Germans felt they deserved, but they clearly deserved none of it, especially in the Steppes.

Hitler hated Communism. His plans for the east were to mainly stop the Soviet Communists.

That's another half-truth. His plans for the east mostly involved making it a supply of wheat, harvested by Russian and Ukrainian and Polish peons, for the German tables.

Poles were killing Germans living in Poland. Hitler wanted to defend them.

I have seen no indication of this other than in sources totally apologetic for the Nazis. There were actually a few false-flag operations staged to make it appear to be true to justify the invasion.

Hitler wanted to regain the lost territory to Poland.

And he had no right to do so. The Polish people had just been freed from a couple centuries of oppression by non-Polish nations.

Hitler only invaded Poland after making a non-aggression pact with the Soviets. They made a deal to split up Poland between them. The Soviets also invaded Poland from the east.[/QUOTE}

Stalin signed the non-aggression treaty mostly to allow himself time to build up the Red Army. Much Soviet equipment used in the initial battles was manufactured in Germany or with steel imported from Germany. Germany needed the wheat that they got in exchange to feed their armies on the western front.

Hitler did not think the British and also the French were going to attack Germany when he invaded Poland. The British were appeasing Hitler up to that point. The British made a secret pact to defend Poland if Germany were to attack Poland. This is what made Poles cocky and were openly taunting Germany prior to the invasion.

There is nothing wrong with a newly-liberated nation taking pride in their national identity as long as they stay within their own boarders. There was never any chance of a successful polish invasion and occupation of Germany. Thus, there was nothing defensive about the invasion.

While this is not meant to justify the Nazis, it is a good start in illustrating that we have not been told the whole story. I can discuss this further, but I'll leave it at that for now since this thread is about the Holocaust.

We have been told all of what we need to know about the Germany rationale for the war. They were wrong. Their rationale does nothing to make those who would paint Hitler in a less malignant light any less evil.
 
Last edited:
Isn't it also reasonable to say the Allied and the Jews attempt to make the Nazis more vile then they really were? Therefore have bias too?
No, NAZIs did it. You have been exposed to stupid ideas and you are actually letting your ignorance show.

If you want to make up cute ideas about NAZIs and other murdering scum, have at it. It just makes you look like a dumb as dirt NeoNAZI idiot.
 
wie es eigentlich gewesen war...;)

But that's precisely how it is within history, which is the only yardstick worth applying here. The field of research into the Third Reich, WWII and the Holocaust is one of the most internationalised there is; Germans, Americans, Brits, pretty much all other European nationalities, all checking each others' work and rectifying inevitable national biases.

All this scholarship shows that the Nazis were more murderous than any other regime in European history, more murderous than Stalin (yes, fact fans, Dolfy pips Uncle Joe to the post there) and more widely murderous than anyone else, too. This gives about 25+ countries in modern Europe an especially good reason to remember Dolfy. Most particularly in Eastern Europe, where the Nazis ran amok murdering millions of Poles, Belarusians, Ukrainians and Russians.

As for the warmed-over denier canards

1) burning babies alive: there are multiple eyewitness accounts to this effect. By standards dating back to the Romans, we can conclude that this was probably the case, on rare occasions. Funnily enough this is not a detail that is regularly mentioned in conventional history books, since it's simply gross.

It's also utterly peripheral to the real issue, which is how the SS organised mass murder on a routine basis, since this was an exceptional event, not the norm. The witness evidence says that this happened for a certain period in 1944, number of times unknown, because there were difficulties (shortages of gas, space in the gas chamber, too few people arriving to be gassed economically).

Frankly, whether or not that detail happened is irrelevant. At best, you have a possible embellishment, not a key detail whose possible falsity (note, possible, since all you're doing is bringing argument to personal incredulity to the table here) would negate the totality of a witness account.

2) The 'doesn't add up' wiffle about Zyklon and delousing is pure ignorance of the circumstances. The SS got the inspiration for one kind of gas chambers from the T4 euthanasia program, and indeed transferred experienced personnel from German euthanasia institutes to Poland, to run death-camps such as Belzec, Treblinka and Sobibor. So this had nothing to do with delousing at all.

Second, delousing facilities never used Zyklon B on people, because, duuuh, it's incredibly lethal. HCN was used to kill lice in clothing; people would be separated from their clothing and then sent via a separate route into showers, then reunited with their freshly deloused clothing afterwards. This happened to millions of people, including Wehrmacht soldiers, Ostarbeiter, other foreign workers, and KZ inmates.

The inspiration to use Zyklon B at Auschwitz most certainly originated from its use as a delousing agent, but that speaks to the logic of the development, not to its 'not adding up'. Furthermore, Zyklon B was first used to kill people in an experiment on Soviet commissars and sick Polish camp inmates. These people had to die, the Auschwitz camp staff thought they'd try something different that was potentially less messy than mass shootings (which tend to grind an Uebermensch down after a while, they found).

:boggled:

Anyway, time for you to put your cards on the table: what are the sources for your so far unsourced hearsay opinions?

No I don't believe that is precise history. History is largely dependent on interpretation with possible false evidence and hearsay. Ironing out the real details is precisely what historians do and what discussions are for.

Nazis more murderous then Stalin and anyone else? Really? I haven't heard that anywhere when the figures seems to show otherwise. Are you not biased?


Possible embelisment or gross exaggeration? It is pertinent to know these exact details as it's quite relevant on getting an accurate portrayal of the Nazis or shall I say Germans?



So which is it? Was Zyklon B used to kill humans or not? You seem to be contradicting yourself.

The scenario you described is probably exactly what happened. They were never sent to the showers disguised as gas chambers to be killed. They were sent to the showers... You do realize you are contradicting witness testimonies?

Why did they still bother to delouse prisoners?

Records seem to indicate that there weren't enough Zyklon B gas for mass executions. Since they had VX nerve gas lying around, why didn't they use that instead?

Lastly, I do believe the revisionists have a point where they say it was impossible to carry out mass extermination using gas given the conditions explained by witness testimonies.

If the gas is so lethal then Sonderkommandos would have needed full body suits which they didn't.
 
How can there be any question about how evil the Nazis were? They're so evil that when they opened the Ark of the Covenant, it melted their ******* heads! Seriously, glowing holy-ghost-assassins flew out of God's own humidor and melted the Nazis' heads. God's judgment, right there. End of story.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Is it me or does anyone else have the sneaking suspicion that one of our holocaust deniers has a new profile?

What difference does it make? They all have the same indoctrination, the same heroes, the same links, the same lies.
 
The delousing process consisted of shaving off every bit of hair and a hot shower. This was done to keep the healthy persons capable of performing useful labor alive long enough to starve to death and to prevent a pandemic of typhus in the German factories where they were sent to be worked to death. It was more for the well-being of the Germans than for that of their prisoners/slaves. Those not deemed capable of working had to be disposed of somehow.

The Nazis were not at all hesitant to kill off Germans who didn't measure up to minimal standards of mental competancy. Why then, should they have any reservations against killing individuals they considered "a race, but not a human race" when they were ecconomicly useless and a strain on resources?

Look again at the pictures of the Jewish corpses and the survivors. Not a one of them seems to have an ounce of body fat to spare. That takes prolonged starvation. Clearly, there was more than adequate food available to keep the German people and Allied POWs alive, but not the Jews. That there were still ethnic Germans being born proves that there was food available, despite the ravages of war. Below a certain percentage of body fat, women stop ovulating. The Germans weren't so mal-nourished that they could not have kept the internees alive ...had they given a rat's about jewish lives.
 
No I don't believe that is precise history. History is largely dependent on interpretation with possible false evidence and hearsay. Ironing out the real details is precisely what historians do and what discussions are for.

The "real details" have long been established. You are displaying the woo-ful tendency to confuse part with whole, detail with totality and periphery with centre.

Nazis more murderous then Stalin and anyone else? Really? I haven't heard that anywhere when the figures seems to show otherwise. Are you not biased?

No, I'm not biased since I read both Russian and German, have studied both sets of documents pertaining to the bodycounts and have formed a reasoned conclusion based on these documents that the Stalinist regime murdered fewer people than the Nazi regime.

Possible embelisment or gross exaggeration? It is pertinent to know these exact details as it's quite relevant on getting an accurate portrayal of the Nazis or shall I say Germans?

No, in this case you should say the Auschwitz SS, a tiny minority of 'Nazis' and an even tinier minority of Germans. You're betraying your own biases by conflating an entire people with the activities of small minorities in uniform, acting under orders and while drunk on racist ideology.

An embellishment is an exaggeration, by the way. What you have not done is established that this is either.
So which is it? Was Zyklon B used to kill humans or not? You seem to be contradicting yourself.

No, I am not contradicting myself because you are falling for an either/or fallacy and trying to pretend that things must be solely one or the other. There are many dual-purpose devices and phenomena in the world. An axe can be used either to chop down wood or to knock someone's head off. Likewise the chemicals that make up fertiliser can be used either to fertilise agricultural land or to form the basis for a bomb.

The scenario you described is probably exactly what happened. They were never sent to the showers disguised as gas chambers to be killed. They were sent to the showers...

OK, so now it all comes out. You're a denier. Please inform us all which revisionists you derived this nonsense from. Leuchter? Rudolf? Faurisson? Tell us so we can have a good laugh.

You do realize you are contradicting witness testimonies?

Waaait a minute, a moment ago you were trying to poison the well and cast doubt on witness testimonies because of a peripheral detail mentioned by some witnesses in one camp regarding one moment of time... and now you have the cheek to claim *I* am contradicting witness testimonies?

Why did they still bother to delouse prisoners?

The selection principle is where almost all deniers fall down. The logic was very simple. If you were arbeitsfaehig (fit for work) then you were selected for work and entered into Auschwitz. If you were arbeitsunfaehig (unfit for work) then you were selected for immediate extermination.

The bigger question is: why would a cynical totalitarian regime not kill those it deemed to be unfit for work and without any possibility of becoming fit for work, such as the elderly and small children, the crippled and chronically sick?

While in the camp, those selected for work received (poor) rations, (poor) access to medical care, (poor) access to sanitation, including delousing of their clothing.

Were any of these inmates to become arbeitsunfaehig, they would be selected for the gas chamber and killed. Then new arrivals would replace them. Human life and what Marx called labour power were cheap, indeed had been devalued.

This is so well known as to beggar belief that not one denier I have ever encountered grasps the simple utiliarian logic of the system.

Records seem to indicate that there weren't enough Zyklon B gas for mass executions.

No, records indicate there was in fact more than sufficient HCN for this person. Read Robert Van Pelt's report for the Irving trial which is online, he discusses this among other themes.

Since they had VX nerve gas lying around, why didn't they use that instead?

Where to start? How many ways can we count the woo here?

Firstly, nerve gas was developed by the German Armed Forces and was a military chemical weapon. The SS did not have access to sarin and tabun.

Second, nerve gas, unlike cyanide, requires full noddy-suit protection and is lethal through the skin. It is super-toxic, and remains so for much longer than other chemical weapons of the WWI generation (which thus includes HCN). Traces of nerve gas which find their way to the undersides of fences can remain poisonous for a very long time.

Third, the SS had easy access to cyanide. Why mess with something that they found worked?

By the way, how many people do you think that we, the normal sane non-revisionists, think were murdered using Zyklon B as opposed to other means?

Lastly, I do believe the revisionists have a point where they say it was impossible to carry out mass extermination using gas given the conditions explained by witness testimonies.

No, they don't. Leuchter doesn't, Lueftl doesn't, Faurisson doesn't, Rudolf doesn't, and nor do any of the other [rule10]holes

If the gas is so lethal then Sonderkommandos would have needed full body suits which they didn't.

That would apply to nerve gas, which you just tried to argue was somehow superior to cyanide - 'why didn't they use that instead?'

DOOOOOOOHHHH!

OSHA publishes a neat little chart showing how many ppm of cyanide is lethal and how many can be tolerated for short periods. Guess what, simply opening the doors of a gas chamber and letting natural air circulation remove the gas, while wearing a gas mask and no other protection, is quite sufficient.

Otherwise, you're now arguing that every time anyone conducted a HCN fumigation in a delousing chamber, that they required special protection over and above a gas mask. Guess what? they didn't need such protection. Otherwise not one delousing of clothing could ever have taken place. There is no functional difference between a delousing and a gassing for those carrying it out.

So that's your argument screwed.
 
Hello. Very interesting thread here.

These are great questions that have crossed my mind as well as I started looking more into our history. In many ways though it is a strange question that shows the incredible force of social conformity. You ask these questions simply because it is unfashionable to even hint that the Nazi regime could possibly have not been evil incarnate.

The point is that you shouldn't be asking these questions just to see what opinion or answer is acceptable. If you are truly interested in finding out the answer then the only recourse is to do research yourself, but since they are good questions in the context of this discussion I can add a little to it.

Sorry people, I left this onscreen too long and others shredded this summary already
I can't post any links yet so a quick summary regarding pre-WWII conditions:

- Germany suffered a crushing defeat in WWI. Hitler blamed the Jews for the loss (there is some truth in this)

- Hitler felt the Treaty of Versaille was unfair. Most of Europe felt the same. Germany also lost some territory as a consequence.

- Hitler wanted revenge from WWI. Hitler wanted to rebuild and rearm Germany and to regain the lost territory.

- Hitler hated Communism. His plans for the east were to mainly stop the Soviet Communists.

Invasion of Poland

- Poles were killing Germans living in Poland. Hitler wanted to defend them.

- Hitler wanted to regain the lost territory to Poland.

- Hitler only invaded Poland after making a non-aggression pact with the Soviets. They made a deal to split up Poland between them. The Soviets also invaded Poland from the east.

- Hitler did not think the British and also the French were going to attack Germany when he invaded Poland. The British were appeasing Hitler up to that point. The British made a secret pact to defend Poland if Germany were to attack Poland. This is what made Poles cocky and were openly taunting Germany prior to the invasion.


While this is not meant to justify the Nazis, it is a good start in illustrating that we have not been told the whole story. I can discuss this further, but I'll leave it at that for now since this thread is about the Holocaust.


Your summary is appalling.

There is no truth to the Jews being to blame for Germany's loss in WWI. The German General staff had conned the Kaiser right to the end, and simply walked away from the whole thing in November 1918.

Hitler felt the treaty was unfair, welcome to losing a world war. Take time to examine the conditions that Germany forced Russia to accept in the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk in 1917.

Germany lost very little territory due to Versailles. Alsace-Lorraine was returned to the French and Danzig went to Poland. Their few colonies were insignificant. Other than that is was some tiny slivers to the Czechs and Poles. By European standards that's pretty minute, especially when the scope of the war is considered. Austria-Hungary fared much worse. By the time of Poland, Hitler had regained all the territories except Alsace-Lorraine and Danzig.

Hitler looked east for "lebensraum", it didn't matter what nation was there. Hitler hated communism true, he also hated democracy.

Poland

Hitler had been formenting dissent in Danzig for some time. Poland was next on his hit list. The Poles attempted to negotiate a solution but Hitler, as per usual, upped the ante any time an agreement was close.

A port city is what he wanted back, hardly an excuse for war.

The attack on Poland was inevitable, regardless of the treaty with the Soviet Union, it was simply gravy (no pun intended).

Hitler was warned that Britain and France would likely go to war over Poland. He decided to follow the advice of the rather stupid Foreign Minister Von Ribbentrop on the matter. Appeasement was long over, and Britain and France had been agressively rearming at this point. Secret pact? Their guarantee of Polish sovereignty made all the papers, and Chamberlain reminded Hitler of it several times. The Polish government was certainly disliked within Europe, once again hardly a reason for war.

You would fail a first year World History course with this kind of stuff, let alone any class that goes into depth on Nazi Germany. I really advise you to do some serious reading, you are not in a position to discuss this currently.
 
Last edited:
No I don't believe that is precise history. History is largely dependent on interpretation with possible false evidence and hearsay. Ironing out the real details is precisely what historians do and what discussions are for.

...snip...

Yes it is indeed what historians do however after many decades of extensive research the consensus is pretty clear about the atrocities of WWII, at best there is still discussion about very small details and interpretations of motives not actions.
 
This is a bit off topic but there was a woman MP who was part of this group. Naturally she did not get along with Winston Churchill. She once told him "Sir, if you were my husband I would put poison in your tea". Chruchill being master of one liners replied "Madam, if I were your husband I would drink it." :D

Ah, yes, Lady Astor, right? I didn't know until now the root of their dislike for each other. And she was the butt of some of Churchill's best jokes:

L.A.: You, sir, are quite drunk.

W.C.: And you, madam, are quite ugly. However, by morning, I shall be quite sober.
 
The delousing process consisted of shaving off every bit of hair and a hot shower. This was done to keep the healthy persons capable of performing useful labor alive long enough to starve to death and to prevent a pandemic of typhus in the German factories where they were sent to be worked to death. It was more for the well-being of the Germans than for that of their prisoners/slaves. Those not deemed capable of working had to be disposed of somehow.

The Nazis were not at all hesitant to kill off Germans who didn't measure up to minimal standards of mental competancy. Why then, should they have any reservations against killing individuals they considered "a race, but not a human race" when they were ecconomicly useless and a strain on resources?

Look again at the pictures of the Jewish corpses and the survivors. Not a one of them seems to have an ounce of body fat to spare. That takes prolonged starvation. Clearly, there was more than adequate food available to keep the German people and Allied POWs alive, but not the Jews. That there were still ethnic Germans being born proves that there was food available, despite the ravages of war. Below a certain percentage of body fat, women stop ovulating. The Germans weren't so mal-nourished that they could not have kept the internees alive ...had they given a rat's about jewish lives.

First this illustrates that the Jews were not entirely exclusive to the Holocaust. The Nazis got rid of anyone they deemed undesirable. Not just because you were a Jew.

But did they really want to work and starve them to death? Your comments also slightly disprove the official story that it was a death camp. It was primarily a labor camp to produce goods necessary during war.

How do you know exactly those corpses were all Jews to begin with? The camps were ravaged with disease like Typhus and there was massive food shortages and resources due to the Allied bombing campaign. It does seem to make sense the Germans would rather save themselves first before anyone else when there were not enough food to go around to everyone.

Oh but they also saved the Allied POWs??


I am not allowed yet to post links, but this testimony comes from the Nuremburg trial (Nuremberg document NO-1523.)

SS chief Heinrich Himmler, who was ultimately in charge of the concentration camp system, was so concerned about the high death rate due to disease that he issued an emphatically worded order in December 1942 to improve the nutrition of the inmates and take all necessary measures to reduce the death rate.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom