No I don't believe that is precise history. History is largely dependent on interpretation with possible false evidence and hearsay. Ironing out the real details is precisely what historians do and what discussions are for.
The "real details" have long been established. You are displaying the woo-ful tendency to confuse part with whole, detail with totality and periphery with centre.
Nazis more murderous then Stalin and anyone else? Really? I haven't heard that anywhere when the figures seems to show otherwise. Are you not biased?
No, I'm not biased since I read both Russian and German, have studied both sets of documents pertaining to the bodycounts and have formed a reasoned conclusion based on these documents that the Stalinist regime murdered fewer people than the Nazi regime.
Possible embelisment or gross exaggeration? It is pertinent to know these exact details as it's quite relevant on getting an accurate portrayal of the Nazis or shall I say Germans?
No, in this case you should say the Auschwitz SS, a tiny minority of 'Nazis' and an even tinier minority of Germans. You're betraying your own biases by conflating an entire people with the activities of small minorities in uniform, acting under orders and while drunk on racist ideology.
An embellishment is an exaggeration, by the way. What you have not done is established that this is either.
So which is it? Was Zyklon B used to kill humans or not? You seem to be contradicting yourself.
No, I am not contradicting myself because you are falling for an either/or fallacy and trying to pretend that things must be solely one or the other. There are many dual-purpose devices and phenomena in the world. An axe can be used
either to chop down wood
or to knock someone's head off. Likewise the chemicals that make up fertiliser can be used
either to fertilise agricultural land or to form the basis
for a bomb.
The scenario you described is probably exactly what happened. They were never sent to the showers disguised as gas chambers to be killed. They were sent to the showers...
OK, so now it all comes out. You're a denier. Please inform us all which revisionists you derived this nonsense from. Leuchter? Rudolf? Faurisson? Tell us so we can have a good laugh.
You do realize you are contradicting witness testimonies?
Waaait a minute, a moment ago you were trying to poison the well and cast doubt on witness testimonies because of a peripheral detail mentioned by some witnesses in one camp regarding one moment of time... and now you have the cheek to claim *I* am contradicting witness testimonies?
Why did they still bother to delouse prisoners?
The selection principle is where almost all deniers fall down. The logic was very simple. If you were arbeitsfaehig (fit for work) then you were selected for work and entered into Auschwitz. If you were arbeitsunfaehig (unfit for work) then you were selected for immediate extermination.
The bigger question is: why would a cynical totalitarian regime
not kill those it deemed to be unfit for work and without any possibility of becoming fit for work, such as the elderly and small children, the crippled and chronically sick?
While in the camp, those selected for work received (poor) rations, (poor) access to medical care, (poor) access to sanitation, including delousing of their clothing.
Were any of these inmates to become arbeitsunfaehig, they would be selected for the gas chamber and killed. Then new arrivals would replace them. Human life and what Marx called
labour power were cheap, indeed had been devalued.
This is so well known as to beggar belief that not one denier I have ever encountered grasps the simple utiliarian logic of the system.
Records seem to indicate that there weren't enough Zyklon B gas for mass executions.
No, records indicate there was in fact more than sufficient HCN for this person. Read Robert Van Pelt's report for the Irving trial which is online, he discusses this among other themes.
Since they had VX nerve gas lying around, why didn't they use that instead?
Where to start? How many ways can we count the woo here?
Firstly, nerve gas was developed by the German Armed Forces and was a military chemical weapon. The SS
did not have access to sarin and tabun.
Second, nerve gas, unlike cyanide, requires full noddy-suit protection and is lethal through the skin. It is super-toxic, and remains so for much longer than other chemical weapons of the WWI generation (which thus includes HCN). Traces of nerve gas which find their way to the undersides of fences can remain poisonous for a very long time.
Third, the SS had easy access to cyanide. Why mess with something that they found worked?
By the way, how many people do you think that we, the normal sane non-revisionists, think were murdered using Zyklon B as opposed to other means?
Lastly, I do believe the revisionists have a point where they say it was impossible to carry out mass extermination using gas given the conditions explained by witness testimonies.
No, they don't. Leuchter doesn't, Lueftl doesn't, Faurisson doesn't, Rudolf doesn't, and nor do any of the other [rule10]holes
If the gas is so lethal then Sonderkommandos would have needed full body suits which they didn't.
That would apply to nerve gas, which you just tried to argue was somehow superior to cyanide - 'why didn't they use that instead?'
DOOOOOOOHHHH!
OSHA publishes a neat little chart showing how many ppm of cyanide is lethal and how many can be tolerated for short periods. Guess what, simply opening the doors of a gas chamber and letting natural air circulation remove the gas, while wearing a gas mask and no other protection, is quite sufficient.
Otherwise, you're now arguing that every time anyone conducted a HCN fumigation in a delousing chamber, that they required special protection over and above a gas mask. Guess what? they didn't need such protection. Otherwise
not one delousing of clothing could ever have taken place. There is no functional difference between a delousing and a gassing for those carrying it out.
So that's your argument screwed.