[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

I think I can answer this. According to Jewish Law, when a Jewish man marries a non-Jew, offspring are not Jews. Based on a 54 percent figure
http://judaism.about.com/od/jewishhumor/f/jewry_usa.htm
at least one quarter of the population growth vanishes, based on using Jewish Law to determine who is Jewish.


Well, Robinson, I'd disagree with you slightly. The Jewish mother thing certainly is a "rule" in most branches of Judaism. However, it's not an enforced rule. There's a good reason for this: Nobody really wants to enforce it. As a people, we don't have the luxury of excluding anybody. If you live like a Jew and call yourself a Jew, we're pretty much going to accept that you're a Jew and count you as one. It's a self-defining demographic. Jews are counted by statisticians as anyone who answers yes to the question, "Are you Jewish?" Also, anyone who hears that question and runs away.

Now, there may be some highly religious sects who disagree but even they would just have the "non-Jew" convert - a process that would be trivially easy for any "non-Jew" who considers himself a Jewish member of such a religious sect.


You can only be punished for yelling fire in a crowded theater IF your yelling is taken as serious and there is actual harm done as a direct result of your yelling.


Once again, you are completely wrong about a matter of law. Your statement is false. Don't ask me for evidence, do your own research before just blithering ignorantly.


By your math that is a murder every 1 minute and 36 seconds 24 hours a day for 60 days straight.

With your logistics experience are you testifying this is logistically possible under the circumstances of the Crimea during war?


We know that it was logically possible because it happened. Fact is proof of possibility.



Was every single Jew that was no longer in Europe murdered?
That is the crux. If the European population of Jews dropped by 6 million and not all 6 million were murdered than the 6 million figure is incorrect.


Okay, so now I see your disgusting little jog around logic. All you want to prove is that less than six million Jews were murdered by the Nazis. You think that knocking down that fact somehow brings all claims about the Holocaust tumbling to the ground.

You're a filthy, ignorant fool. Read a book.


Second of all,

How come we never hear about any American soldiers describing the carnage they witnessed in the wake of the firebombing of Dresden in February, 1945?


I certainly never heard about it first hand from an American POW who was there. I only read about it second hand in the Cliff's Notes.

ETA: I'm kidding. Slaughterhouse Five kicks ass.
 
Hey, come on. It's patently unfair to use historical facts when debating Holocaust deniers.

It's also patently unfair to use the term 'debate' when describing discussions with Holocaust deniers. It's actually more like trying to keep a straight face during their idiotic diatribes.
 
The fact remains that the number of Jews who immigrated to Israel, the USA, and other places after WW2 in no way accounts for the missing 6 million Jews.

For example, before WW2 there were between 3.3 million and 2.8 million Jews in Poland. After the war there were 300,000 left. Most of them moved to Israel. Where did the missing Jews go?

Nazis can never answer this question.
 
That is the crux. If the European population of Jews dropped by 6 million and not all 6 million were murdered than the 6 million figure is incorrect.

Of course the figure is incorrect. Does anyone think exactly six million were killed? It would be a surprisingly round number. That's yet another strawman. Suppose that close analysis reveals that "only" five million Jews were killed, the rest being due to natural wastage. How does that change our attitude to the event?

However, all else being equal, populations remain static. Deaths are balanced by births. It should also be possible to allow for the death rates suffered by the non-Jewish civilian populations. When this is done, it turns out that vast numbers of Jews must have been deliberately disposed of.
 
The fact remains that the number of Jews who immigrated to Israel, the USA, and other places after WW2 in no way accounts for the missing 6 million Jews.

For example, before WW2 there were between 3.3 million and 2.8 million Jews in Poland. After the war there were 300,000 left. Most of them moved to Israel. Where did the missing Jews go?

Do we know how many Poles died from their population in the same period? It would put things in perspective. I would assume that they suffered massive casualties, but still enormously less in percentage terms than the Jews.

Nazis can never answer this question.

They'd rather quibble about the paint on the gas chamber walls.
 
Eh? I gather that you have now become the greatest Holocaust scholar of the age? Able to leap over the best estimates of those far better qualified than you at a single bound?

I am sorry that simple math disturbs you so much.
 
Once again, you are completely wrong about a matter of law. Your statement is false. Don't ask me for evidence, do your own research before just blithering ignorantly.

In response too:

Originally Posted by JEROME DA GNOME
You can only be punished for yelling fire in a crowded theater IF your yelling is taken as serious and there is actual harm done as a direct result of your yelling.


Oliver Wendell Holmes:
The most stringent protection of free speech would not protect a man falsely shouting fire in a theater and causing a panic.

I guess Oliver Wendell Holmes is wrong as well, esquire.


Each time you name-call it shows your inability to have a rational talk at an adult level.
 
Okay, so now I see your disgusting little jog around logic. All you want to prove is that less than six million Jews were murdered by the Nazis. You think that knocking down that fact somehow brings all claims about the Holocaust tumbling to the ground.

You're a filthy, ignorant fool. Read a book.

You are not rational or speaking as an adult. I would suggest you take a break and calm down a bit.
 
Of course the figure is incorrect. Does anyone think exactly six million were killed? It would be a surprisingly round number. That's yet another strawman. Suppose that close analysis reveals that "only" five million Jews were killed, the rest being due to natural wastage. How does that change our attitude to the event?

However, all else being equal, populations remain static. Deaths are balanced by births. It should also be possible to allow for the death rates suffered by the non-Jewish civilian populations. When this is done, it turns out that vast numbers of Jews must have been deliberately disposed of.

Agreed. Thank you for your rational response.
 
Perhaps I'm wrong in the assumption that JdG is a Yank of some variety. If he is, I can only assume that he/she didn't get invited to any nice T'givings today. (And if he's/she's Canadian, then he/she didn't like the event last month.)

Between JdG and LastChild, this place is a total grump-o-rama.

Anyhow, JdG, I now depart. The little bits you provide are as content- and value-free as any I've ever seen. My advice is to renew your library card, and try to use it.
 
I understand that this is often a very emotive subject to discuss however please keep in mind your Membership Agreement and if you can't post something civil and on topic don't post until you can.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Darat
 
Perhaps I'm wrong in the assumption that JdG is a Yank of some variety. If he is, I can only assume that he/she didn't get invited to any nice T'givings today. (And if he's/she's Canadian, then he/she didn't like the event last month.)

Between JdG and LastChild, this place is a total grump-o-rama.

Anyhow, JdG, I now depart. The little bits you provide are as content- and value-free as any I've ever seen. My advice is to renew your library card, and try to use it.

Why even write this insult full post?

I am amused that one of your insults concerns others posts lacking content.

Your post here is the definition of irony.
:boxedin:
 
I understand that this is often a very emotive subject to discuss however please keep in mind your Membership Agreement and if you can't post something civil and on topic don't post until you can.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Darat

OK, I know this is a very emotive subject, but it is still possible to discuss it without resorting to personal attacks and rudeness. Please refrain from the use of words such as 'filthy', and 'disgusting', particularly directed at individual members. Stay calm, and adress your comments to the issues, not members. Thanks.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: chillzero

Now, if we could get a third mod to chime in, maybe it'll work, but I doubt it! ;)
 
Do you think there were any "dangerous subhuman Jews" in the Nazi party and serving in Hitlers' war machine?


Another strawman parading as a question. What exactly would your argument be if the answer were yes? Let me guess, you're not making an argument, you're "just asking questions." Do your own research.


I guess Oliver Wendell Holmes is wrong as well, esquire.


And yet, even with OWH's quote, you're still completely wrong. That is to be expected coming from a position of willful ignorance such as your own.

Here's what you wrote:
You can only be punished for yelling fire in a crowded theater IF your yelling is taken as serious and there is actual harm done as a direct result of your yelling.

And here, as just one example out of fifty, is the California Penal Code Section 403:

403. Every person who, without authority of law, willfully disturbs
or breaks up any assembly or meeting that is not unlawful in its
character, other than an assembly or meeting referred to in Section
302 of the Penal Code or Section 18340 of the Elections Code, is
guilty of a misdemeanor.


See? There is no requirement that the threat of "fire" be taken seriously. There is no requirement of actual harm.

You are wrong.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom