[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

So, if 40% lived in the large cities, let's say 10% lived in those bigger, unoccupied (by Germans) cities. So,....? 50,000 +/- deaths/murders/executions in 60 +/- days? Why do you find that so difficult to believe? 850 deaths a day?

By your math that is a murder every 1 minute and 36 seconds 24 hours a day for 60 days straight.

With your logistics experience are you testifying this is logistically possible under the circumstances of the Crimea during war?

Oh, I will, Jerome. You can rely on that. So many trolls; so few rye crisps to serve 'em on! Where's Paulhoff with that barbecue sauce?

Name-calling?
 
In any case, the Einsatzgruppen didn't operate in hot war zones. They moved in when the territory was occupied.

It's hardly surprising that there was an organisation set up to administed captured territories. The allies had their own arrangements when Germany was conquered. It just so happens that the Einsatzgruppen had a mandate to round up, detain, deport or execute Jews, en masse.

As to the population question - naturally switching the context from absolute numbers to percentages is at best disingenuous, at worst the tactic of a scoundrel. The fact that the absolute numbers of Jews fell drastically in Europe cannot be explained by anything other than a deliberate plan.

The idea that millions of Jews decided to run off and hide just to make the Germans look bad, out of sheer badness, is obviously ridiculous.

Was every single Jew that was no longer in Europe murdered?

According to the American Jewish Yearbook, the Jewish population of Europe was about 9.5 million in 1933. In 1950, the Jewish population of Europe was about 3.5 million.
http://www.ushmm.org/wlc/article.php?lang=en&ModuleId=10005687
 
Was every single Jew that was no longer in Europe murdered?

No, I don't believe they were. A proportion of Jews relocated to the USA, the UK, Palestine and other places. However, that leaves a significant shortfall.


According to which, about two out of every three died. I suppose that a proportion of those didn't die because they were directly (e.g. shot, gassed) or indirectly (e.g. starved in Warsaw ghetto) targetted for extermination by the Nazis. But that two out of three statistic is fairly telling. That number of people don't die Europe-wide without it being made happen.
 
By your math that is a murder every 1 minute and 36 seconds 24 hours a day for 60 days straight.

With your logistics experience are you testifying this is logistically possible under the circumstances of the Crimea during war?

A unit of a thousand men could kill one person each per day and maintain that rate. I don't know how many einsatzgruppen were operating in the Crimea, but that's not logistically unlikely. Clearly they'd need to be identified and rounded up, but it's not so unlikely. The Crimea is almost perfect as a killing ground. There's nowhere for runaways to go.

However, if they didn't die, where did they go?
 
By your math that is a murder every 1 minute and 36 seconds 24 hours a day for 60 days straight.

With your logistics experience are you testifying this is logistically possible under the circumstances of the Crimea during war?

Why is that so hard to believe - If you accept a figure of 55 million for casualties in the war - Over six years thats works out a 17.5 people killed per minute during the conflict
 
Is it a common tactic of discussion for you when you lack the ability to evidence your assertions to claim Troll?

You are pretending that there is no significant evidence, and then engaging in weaselly statements. You should go to the library and start looking. Yes, you're trolling. My "ability" is that I send you to the library. Try to learn, heavens to betsy.
 
Last edited:
I am not asking for evidence of something that was not asserted.

Then prove it -- let's see your quote, young whippersnapper. Granted, that was yesterday, after I went to bed. Who can remember that far back?

Edit: wait a minute... what in heck does JdG's sentence mean when it is parsed? Is that a double negative I see before my eyes/ Its point ... oh, whatever that quote is.

Let's put it this way: you give an excellent impression of someone who is misinterpreting, perhaps deliberately, others' assertions; and thereby yes, you are asking other people to provide evidence for things they didn't say. Don't try that at home...
 
Last edited:
Why is that so hard to believe - If you accept a figure of 55 million for casualties in the war - Over six years thats works out a 17.5 people killed per minute during the conflict

You are equating death tolls in battles in which parties know the location of large groupings of people in which to fire large amounts of munitions to a death squad searching for specific people to murder.

The logistics are vastly different.
 
No, I don't believe they were. A proportion of Jews relocated to the USA, the UK, Palestine and other places. However, that leaves a significant shortfall.

That is the crux. If the European population of Jews dropped by 6 million and not all 6 million were murdered than the 6 million figure is incorrect.
 
My father was in the 10th Armored Division, and at a reunion of that outfit last year, I learned of their part in the liberation of that camp. When I got home, I looked it up, and they are recognized as liberators by the museum, (though according to the vets, Band of Brothers presented the story differently than it really happenned...it was the 10thAD that arrived at and liberated Landsberg. They handed it over to the 101st Airborne.) Even though my dad was not with the outfit when they liberated Landsberg (he was sitting in a POW camp in Muhlberg, captured during the Ardennes Offensive), he was a witness to some of the camps after he was liberated from Stalag 4B. He never liked to talk about it, other than to say he had never immagined there could be such evil perpetrated by men.

This seems to be a common theme among defenders of the Holocaust legend. "My dad/grandpa/neighbor was there, and he saw it..." Being related to or meeting someone who was there gives us a personal bond to the Legend, and we become emotionally attached to the official story, defending it to the death.

It reminds me of one person I debated who defended the official story of 9/11-- on the basis of the fact that his brother had been working in a nearby office building. "He was there, it happened," I was told.

There is no denying that British and American soldiers liberated several camps. No doubt they saw horrifying conditions and many dead bodies. The camps had been ravaged by typhus and other diseases compounded by malnutrition as the German nation collapsed under relentless Allied bombing and the demand for unconditional surrender.

How come we never hear about any American soldiers describing the carnage they witnessed in the wake of the firebombing of Dresden in February, 1945?
"When Germany collapsed in the spring of 1945 it was after a long Allied propaganda campaign which had repeatedly claimed that people, mainly Jews, were being systematically killed in German "camps." When the British captured the camp at Bergen-Belsen in northern Germany they found a large number of unburied bodies lying around the camp. Photographs such as Fig. 10 and pictures of guards with unfortunate facial expressions, such as Fig. 12, were accordingly reproduced all over the world. It is, I believe, Belsen which has always constituted the effective, mass propaganda "proof" of exterminations, and even today you will find such scenes occasionally waved around as "proof."

In fact these scenes, repeated in varying degrees at other German camps, e.g. Dachau and Buchenwald, were much less related to "extermination" than the scenes at Dresden after the British-American raids of February, 1945, when many, many times as many bodies were found lying around. The deaths at Belsen were the result of a total loss of control, not a deliberate policy. Equivalent scenes could easily have existed in any country invaded on all sides by enemy armies, crippled by powerful "strategic" bombings which had caused all sorts of shortages and chaotic conditions.

The major cause of the deaths at Belsen was a typhus epidemic. Everybody agrees that typhus was a constant menace in all German camp and eastern military operations; for this reason there was a real fear of typhus spreading throughout Germany and vigorous countermeasures were applied. The typhus problem will play a most significant role in our story because it was not merely at the end of the war that it manifested itself; the scenes at the end of the war were due to the total collapse of all measures against a disease that had plagued the German concentration camps since early in the war. The typhus was of the sort carried by the body louse and consequently defensive measures consisted in killing the lice, whose spread was due mainly to the constant rail traffic with the East. Thus all "survivor literature," sincere or inventive, and regardlesss of the type of camp involved, report the same basic procedure involved in entering a German camp: disrobe, shave hair, shower, dress in new clothes or in old clothes after disinfection..."

Arthur Butz, The Hoax of the Twentieth Century pp.34
 
You are equating death tolls in battles in which parties know the location of large groupings of people in which to fire large amounts of munitions to a death squad searching for specific people to murder.

The logistics are vastly different.

Oh, bazz fazz. Do a little research. It was easy to find "large groupings." They typically lived in the same parts of the towns and cities (historic or self-segregation); the local police and authorities often helped; and they put one hell of a lot of work into this. These were dangerous subhumans, remember (the Jews). It was very difficult to hide and stay alive for an extended period; most people were too frightened to help, or simply unwilling or hostile; and if you find a market town with a few hundred or a few thousand Jews per day or two or three, it isn't hard. Remember machine guns?

Ach, like I said, a troll. He's / she's (I shouldn't presume) just baiting.

You are giving an excellent impression of someone either who is trying to undermine the extraordinarily detailed and comprehensive evidence for the Holocaust, by means of silly and ill-informed objections; or else someone who is not necessarily trying to undermine that, but somehow gets a kick out of saying silly and ill-informed things. Your choice.
 
That is the crux. If the European population of Jews dropped by 6 million and not all 6 million were murdered than the 6 million figure is incorrect.

Eh? I gather that you have now become the greatest Holocaust scholar of the age? Able to leap over the best estimates of those far better qualified than you at a single bound?
 
This seems to be a common theme among defenders of the Holocaust legend. "My dad/grandpa/neighbor was there, and he saw it..." Being related to or meeting someone who was there gives us a personal bond to the Legend, and we become emotionally attached to the official story, defending it to the death.

It reminds me of one person I debated who defended the official story of 9/11-- on the basis of the fact that his brother had been working in a nearby office building. "He was there, it happened," I was told.

There is no denying that British and American soldiers liberated several camps. No doubt they saw horrifying conditions and many dead bodies. The camps had been ravaged by typhus and other diseases compounded by malnutrition as the German nation collapsed under relentless Allied bombing and the demand for unconditional surrender.

How come we never hear about any American soldiers describing the carnage they witnessed in the wake of the firebombing of Dresden in February, 1945?

Hey, you're back, Pumpkin! Happy t'giving. Kisses to the family.

American soldiers... You mean besides Kurt Vonnegut? He was there, captured at the Battle of the Bulge. The Dresden bombings are well known. What's your point? Heck, it's even in a movie made from the book, though a lousy one. (The movie.)

This is a standard Holocaust denier tactic; "Oh yeah?? Well, what about the poor defenseless Nazis [that's A-Train's phrase, remember] here or there or elsewhere?"

Note that he can't say "your grandfather lied to you, since he must have been in the pay of the Jews!" And so we see -- now class, pay attention -- the Holocaust denier's version of moving goalposts: most of those who died after liberation in the camps in Germany, like Belsen, died of disease, exhaustion, starvation, and overwork. True. (Though who exposed them to disease, exhaustion, starvation, and overwork? The Nazis. Do we detect a hint of culpability?) However, the camps in Germany proper were not extermination/ death camps. The massive killing fields were further east, on Polish territory (see Y.Arad, "Belzec, Sobibor, Treblinka: The Operation Reinhard Death Camps"), and in the mass shootings which JdG regards as logistically illogical elsewhere in Poland, Yugoslavia, Romania, and the Soviet Union.

Whillikers, A-train, before you sit down for your kosher-certified turkey (whoops! sorry to let that out of the bag), try and find something more interesting.
 
How come we never hear about any American soldiers describing the carnage they witnessed in the wake of the firebombing of Dresden in February, 1945?

Because the Russians took Dresden.

Yes, Dresden's been covered up really effectively, and practically nobody ever discusses it. Now if, say, some leading sci-fi author had made it the centrepiece of his greatest work, maybe some of us would have heard of it.

Dave

ETA: SDC beat me to it. Oh well, maybe I can say something about Len Deighton's "Bomber"...
 
Last edited:
This seems to be a common theme among defenders of the Holocaust legend. "My dad/grandpa/neighbor was there, and he saw it..." Being related to or meeting someone who was there gives us a personal bond to the Legend, and we become emotionally attached to the official story, defending it to the death.

Right. With all those eyewitnesses, it can't be anything but a hoax.

:hb:
 
There is no denying that British and American soldiers liberated several camps. No doubt they saw horrifying conditions and many dead bodies. The camps had been ravaged by typhus and other diseases compounded by malnutrition as the German nation collapsed under relentless Allied bombing and the demand for unconditional surrender.

How come we never hear about any American soldiers describing the carnage they witnessed in the wake of the firebombing of Dresden in February, 1945?

I will happily be proved wrong, but I am certain that Dresden never came under the US armies control, if memory served, it remained, like Cologne, firmly under Soviet control
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom