[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

I also have a hard time allowing people to state silly claims only backed by insults and name-calling if evidence is asked of the assertion.


And yet when I provide you evidence, you react with incredulity. So, if you want evidence, why do you mock it when it is presented?


I would love to see the transcripts of this trial. She was convicted in 1980 of stamping old women to death in 1939.


Do you have any evidence that she wasn't guilty of this? Do you have any reason to believe that this woman who was identified by numerous victims was not a Nazi murderer in her early twenties?


And here again, you just mock the evidence presented:

The Jews have had a static population for 60 years?

So, in 1930 Jews were 9% of the world population, 6% of the world population in 1950, and today Jews are 2% of the world population.

What is your explanation for the decrease in percentage of Jews between 1950 and 2005?

Did they go to Mars?


I actually have an explanation for the decrease in percentage. I found it after twelve seconds of research. If you read here, you'll see that the world population of Jews is stagnating and even declining. The two main reasons are low birthrate and intermarriage.

As personal wealth increases, birthrate decreases. Jews are victims of this cold sociological fact. We just aren't reproducing like poorer quarters of the world. That makes our real numbers stagnate and our population percentage decline.

Sadly, intermarriage reduces our numbers. As Jews assimilate into Western society, we marry non-Jews and raise our children outside of the faith. Two generations of that and people hardly remember they had a Jewish ancestor, let alone practice any of the religion.

Do you have any facts that dispute this? Or do you just have your mocking incredulity based on ignorance?
 
I actually have an explanation for the decrease in percentage. I found it after twelve seconds of research. If you read here, you'll see that the world population of Jews is stagnating and even declining. The two main reasons are low birthrate and intermarriage.

Ha! I figured it out and I didn't even do any research.

Maybe people of Jewish descent aren't really stagnating, maybe they are doing what so many other people have done. Joined the melting pot and become Americans. While the numbers might show Jews decreasing, in reality they are doing quite well, just not called Jews anymore.
 
Based on your link the numbers for outmarriage in Britain are 50% for married men under 30. Obviously this makes it look like Jews are not reproducing, when in fact they may be breeding like rabbits, just not counted as Jews.

How strange. There may be a huge population of people who have Jewish fathers, but they are not considered of Jewish descent. In fact, based on statistics, that is actually the case.

Does anyone else find that odd?
 
Ohh, I think the holocaust happened. I just find it interesting that people would be jailed for researching history. A very interesting topic concerning freedom of thought and speech. I also have a hard time allowing people to state silly claims only backed by insults and name-calling if evidence is asked of the assertion. This is regardless of the subject at hand.


I wasn't referring to you. I was replying to the General Topic of the post. I'm making a general statement that if someone refuses to believe a historical fact, they are idiots. I would say the same thing about someone who didn't believe that Gen. Custer committed mass murder of a tribe or that the Rwandan Genocide didn't happen. And I would also say they are quite sociopathic in their reasoning. As far I have seen everyone here has not resorted to name calling and they have provided the keyword dun dun dun FACTS. And also regarding freedom of speech. Just a general statement. Life is not carte blanche. With that right there also has to be responisbility. If you are irresponsible then there are consequences. It is my right to yell "FIRE!" in a crowded theater but as the Supreme Court has said, I have to face the consequences of abusing that right. Now I'm not one of those people who believes that in America someone should be jailed for denying the Holocaust. But if Austria wants to do it, let them. That's their perogative. This is America. And as far as I see given Austria's involvement with the Holocaust I understand why they fear Holocaust denial. It isn't a freedom of speech issue there. It's because they don't want a second Hitler to emerge.
 
I think I can answer this. According to Jewish Law, when a Jewish man marries a non-Jew, offspring are not Jews. Based on a 54 percent figure
http://judaism.about.com/od/jewishhumor/f/jewry_usa.htm
at least one quarter of the population growth vanishes, based on using Jewish Law to determine who is Jewish.

Because of this weird definition of who is considered Jewish, there are no half Jews, quarter Jews, whatever. Even if a Jewish man has a dozen kids, if his wife is non-Jew, none of them count as Jews.

I'm pretty sure this is the only situation in the entire world where people can reproduce, a population can grow, but the statistics show no growth, or negative growth, because the "race" is based only on the Mother, and it is all or nothing.

I could be wrong, and I'm sure if that is the case, someone will explain why. The Jewish women who marry non-Jews don't balance the numbers because the addition of one non-Jew (even if they convert) doesn't equal the loss of all children from the Jew men who marry out.

I never thought about it before, but it is really strange.

Not just the population statistics being skewed, but the whole way of counting heads based on religion, not race.

Every time a Jew man marries out, all of his children, grandchildren, great grandchildren, none are counted as Jews. The numbers add up quick. There may be 20 million people living right now, who had a Jewish parent, that are not considered Jews.

Well done! Great reasoning. I did know of this quirk but never thought of it in this instance.
 
And yet when I provide you evidence, you react with incredulity. So, if you want evidence, why do you mock it when it is presented?

I think you may be talking to a ghost here.

Do you have any evidence that she wasn't guilty of this? Do you have any reason to believe that this woman who was identified by numerous victims was not a Nazi murderer in her early twenties?

No and No. I just stated that I would love to read the transcript of the trial.


And here again, you just mock the evidence presented:

You are jumping to conclusions here. I was trying to determine if the figures were accurate, and if so, why the static population growth.

The Mars comment was a direct mock of the exact comment directed toward me.


I actually have an explanation for the decrease in percentage. I found it after twelve seconds of research.

Opps, Robinson beat you to the info. See, this is a forum that is used for conversation and exchange of ideas. You seem to think it is a place "mock" any with which you perceive a disagreement.

Do you have any facts that dispute this? Or do you just have your mocking incredulity based on ignorance?

Nope and Nope.

Our conversations are falling apart here. I would suggest that we read the meanings of the words written and not presume their meaning. If unclear we could ask one another what our meaning is.

:)
 
It is my right to yell "FIRE!" in a crowded theater but as the Supreme Court has said, I have to face the consequences of abusing that right.

Well written post.

I must comment on the above part.

You can only be punished for yelling fire in a crowded theater IF your yelling is taken as serious and there is actual harm done as a direct result of your yelling.
 
Last edited:
This argument is falling apart by the post.

Only due to your total ignorance of the history of WWII in the Crimea. If you knew anything about the topic, you might be able to keep up. You're flopping around like a bass on the beach. Maybe you read somewhere about the battle in the Crimea continuing through the early years of the war. Maybe you should read a little more. The Germans took the vast majority of the Crimea in one fell swoop. (See below for specfics.)

In just two months the Germans secured the Crimea and "wiped out" the majority of Jews?

Argument from incredulity? Do you have a library card. There are numerous books on WWII readily available, and you wouldn't have to do so much guesswork.

The majority of the "available" 65000. You do know that the Germans could not take Kerch and Sevastopol, right? You do, don't you? Tell me you know something about the topic under discussion, please.

So, if 40% lived in the large cities, let's say 10% lived in those bigger, unoccupied (by Germans) cities. So,....? 50,000 +/- deaths/murders/executions in 60 +/- days? Why do you find that so difficult to believe? 850 deaths a day? Heck the Germans could handle that many before the morning coffee and streudel was ready!


Have you thought about the logistics here?

Why no, Jerome. I'd never think of the logistics of the situation, having merely spent my entire business career (41 years) in the field of, well, .... Logistics. :spjimlad:
Please keep posting your thoughts; this is great!

Oh, I will, Jerome. You can rely on that. So many trolls; so few rye crisps to serve 'em on! Where's Paulhoff with that barbecue sauce?
 
Would you consider thought crimes part of a free society?

I also have a hard time allowing people to state silly claims only backed by insults and name-calling if evidence is asked of the assertion. This is regardless of the subject at hand.

And if those silly claims, unbacked by any substantial evidence, are capable of fueling hatred and violence or cause innocent people to be accused of crimes, does this 'hard time' of yours ever translate into a desire for justice?

Once again, I can only point out to you that the countries in which holocaust denial is considered a crime are democratic countries whose laws should be followed by all of those within their borders. If a denier is stupid enough to flout such a law, then they suffer the consequences.

Likewise, if an individual is sued in a civil action in a country where holocaust denial is not illegal, but the court finds against the denier, then the law says that person must pay the prescribed award or suffer the consequences of being in breach of the law.

Let's say a woman does accuse you of rape, and you go through the whole process of being investigated and stigmatised by the accusation only to be found completely innocent. Has she committed a 'thought crime' and, if so, should she go unpunished?
 
What exactly are you asking me? If non-Jews were gassed?

I do not believe anyone was ever killed in any so called "gas chambers" The "gas chambers" were used for delousing prisoners and clothing. When the prisoners arrived at the camps they were told to disrobe and go into the gas chambers to kill the lice.

The only book worth reading on the "Holocaust" is The Hoax of the Twentieth Century by Butz.

Fortunately we still have a few guards and the last of the Zonda men to dispell your belief
 
And if those silly claims, unbacked by any substantial evidence, are capable of fueling hatred and violence or cause innocent people to be accused of crimes, does this 'hard time' of yours ever translate into a desire for justice?

Once again, I can only point out to you that the countries in which holocaust denial is considered a crime are democratic countries whose laws should be followed by all of those within their borders. If a denier is stupid enough to flout such a law, then they suffer the consequences.

Likewise, if an individual is sued in a civil action in a country where holocaust denial is not illegal, but the court finds against the denier, then the law says that person must pay the prescribed award or suffer the consequences of being in breach of the law.

Let's say a woman does accuse you of rape, and you go through the whole process of being investigated and stigmatised by the accusation only to be found completely innocent. Has she committed a 'thought crime' and, if so, should she go unpunished?

Just to endorse this point, the law in most European countries ensures freedom of speech. What it does not do it allow others to maliciously usethat freedom to encourage racial or religious hatred.

In some countries, notably Germany, the law prevents silly and unsubstantiated claims such as those that the Holocaust never took place. In others, such as the UK, you can be sued for libel or slander if you seek to attack those who highlight the errors in your reasoning.

Of course if you could prove that the Holocaust didn't take place then a court would have no real scope to act. Europe is not a police state, and the courts are usually quite happy to intervene where laws are inappropriate.

As with David Irving, your problem is that (a) the Holocaust did take place - although there may be discussion regarding the exact numbers - and (b) you can't put together a compelling case, supported by evidence, that proves otherwise.

Really, you're just using this to support your crazy anti-semetic ideology. Get a grip.
 
In some countries, notably Germany, the law prevents silly and unsubstantiated claims such as those that the Holocaust never took place.

AFAIK, the law (in Germany and certain other countries) doesn't forbid silly and unsubstantiated claims such as those that the Holocaust never took place. It forbids the silly and unsubstantiated claim that the Holocaust never took place.

I'm not going to shed any tears for the scumbags that get prosecuted and convicted because of it, but I'm still not totally comfortable with that law.
 
AFAIK, the law (in Germany and certain other countries) doesn't forbid silly and unsubstantiated claims such as those that the Holocaust never took place. It forbids the silly and unsubstantiated claim that the Holocaust never took
place.

Agreed. I was just giving myself some leeway in case it covered any other Nazi war crimes. Incidentally, you would think that if it was all jsut a big "hoax" then the Germans more than anybody would be keen to expose it. Funny that they don't, eh?

Anyway, the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) ensures freedom of speech saving for where the deliberate intention is to encourage criminal acts. I really don't have a problem with that. Jail 'em.
 
Last edited:
Agreed. I was just giving myself some leeway in case it covered any other Nazi war crimes. Incidentally, you would think that if it was all jsut a big "hoax" then the Germans more than anybody would be keen to expose it. Funny that they don't, eh?

Yeah, well, it has been a criminal offense there (or in West Germany, anyway) after WWII. At least this particular law was AFAIK pretty directly dictated by the Allies. While what you say makes sense, I don't see it as that strong an argument.

And then there's of course the fact that there's still a significant number of Germans who were alive back then and who have memories of the Nazi era. "None of that happened" doesn't necessarily go down well with people who were there (or even people who remember stories from ma and pa who were there). Plus, there's something deeply absurd about a theory that requires that the Soviet Bloc (which has its own history of anti-semitism) who went trough quite a bit of trouble to fake gas chambers, concentration camps and stuff, seemingly to emphasize their 'communist martyrs' who died there while downplaying the Jewish (and Roma) massacre, was really doing all that to further some Zionist agenda.

Anyway, the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) ensures freedom of speech saving for where the deliberate intention is to encourage criminal acts. I really don't have a problem with that. Jail 'em.

The 'deliberate intention to encourage criminal acts' part is, IMO, crucial. That's what separates the crank from the demagogue. The guy who stands on a soapbox in the middle of the downtown market square yelling "All blue-eyed Finns should be crucified!" to the masses who ignore him, is exercising his right to free speech. The guy who yells the same words under my balcony to a frenzied crowd waving planks, nails, and hammers is doing something different. I'd be interested in knowing whether the German law differentiates between the two.
 
Last edited:
Do you have any evidence that she wasn't guilty of this? Do you have any reason to believe that this woman who was identified by numerous victims was not a Nazi murderer in her early twenties?

I've a degree of scepticism wrt very late convictions of individuals based on eye witness testimony many years later. I don't know this particular case, so I can't comment directly. It might be that there was other evidence which was critical.

Which doesn't effect the main point, as to the fact that those acts were committed.
 
I won't argue. Some of his early work was well-regarded, as well.

Irving said:
The Nazis did murder millions of Jews. ... I am absolutely without doubt that the Holocaust took place.

Which is not to say that he hasn't twisted the truth, and provided support for the Nazis. His peculiar contention is that the massive enterprise of extermination went on without Hitler's knowlege. Still, anyone who asserts that there wasn't a mass extermination of Jews by Nazis is contradicting Irving.
 
The nazis was actually pretty good at creating jews. Here's a parable:

You have five apples and five pears. You want to eat all the apples.

You eat two apples, one pear that you think is an apple and nibble at one pear that you also think is an apple.

The pear that got nibbled does, for some reason, turn into an apple.

After this we have four apples (one nibbled) and three pears, even though your journal claims that you ate three apples and nibbled at one apple.
 
Last edited:
Just for the sake of historical accuracy, it may not matter to them but it does to me, the Nazi attitude towards Jews was not unique in Europe. There were several Nationalist (Volkisch) parties in the politics of Germany prior to the Nazis gaining control. A common thread was hatred of the Jews, most often as the villains in the loss of World War I (to the delight of the real villains, the German General Staff). Most of the other nations had similar movements. The notorious Dreyfus affair in France (which these 3 would no doubt believe was true) is an excellent example

It's certainly true that the Nazis would have found it much more difficult to round up Jews without cooperation from locals in many jurisdictions, willing or otherwise. How would they know who the Jews were if nobody told them? This happened on Jersey and Guernsey - local officials reporting to the Germans where the Jews were to be found.
 
No, I find it consistent.


One would have to travel quite a long distance to find anybody who believes Hitler's behavior was in any way logical.

In any case, the Einsatzgruppen didn't operate in hot war zones. They moved in when the territory was occupied.

It's hardly surprising that there was an organisation set up to administed captured territories. The allies had their own arrangements when Germany was conquered. It just so happens that the Einsatzgruppen had a mandate to round up, detain, deport or execute Jews, en masse.

As to the population question - naturally switching the context from absolute numbers to percentages is at best disingenuous, at worst the tactic of a scoundrel. The fact that the absolute numbers of Jews fell drastically in Europe cannot be explained by anything other than a deliberate plan.

The idea that millions of Jews decided to run off and hide just to make the Germans look bad, out of sheer badness, is obviously ridiculous.
 
Plus, there's something deeply absurd about a theory that requires that the Soviet Bloc (which has its own history of anti-semitism) who went trough quite a bit of trouble to fake gas chambers, concentration camps and stuff, seemingly to emphasize their 'communist martyrs' who died there while downplaying the Jewish (and Roma) massacre, was really doing all that to further some Zionist agenda.

The Soviets and their satellites in fact suppressed Holocaust memorials. There's a synagogue in Prague which had the names of all the Jews killed by the Nazis. During the 6-day war, the authorities closed the place for "repairs" and painted over all the names.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom