[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

So, you admit to not having evidence of your assertion.

Blind faith is not skeptical. I choose not to subscribe to this sort of information consumption.

I admit only to thinking you ought to get off your backside and do a little work of your own. I know this stuff and feel no need to forcefeed you, or to cater to those who prefer not to do research or think. If you prefer to express silly ideas, and wallow in a slough of received ignorance, be my guest.
 
You find it logical that there were death squads running around murdering civilians in the middle of a "hot" war zone?

This transcends silly. What's logic got to do with it? It happened. If you have a complaint about Ober-Ost's failure to apply logic (the German high command in the "wild east"), I suggest you take it up with them. Yoo hoo, boys, JdG thinks you fell short in your application of logic! Why not stop by the old "Wolf's Lair" (Hitler's eastern hq/ personal refuge) and explain?

Ech, he's just trolling. The method of asking pointless, obviously rhetorical questions indicates that. Why not tell us what you think, besides the implication that the German policies in the east failed in the logic area?

Gotta go, youngster. I've finished the Clifton Chenier CD.
 
Last edited:
You find it logical that there were death squads running around murdering civilians in the middle of a "hot" war zone?



No, I find it consistent.


One would have to travel quite a long distance to find anybody who believes Hitler's behavior was in any way logical.
 
Glory unto the divine being of your choosing! That's correct. The killing squads followed the armies. (Actually, it's becoming better and better known that the army did a lot of its own killing of civilians.) Many have commented that the German focus on eliminating Jews was a waste of war material and forces, and may have been a major factor in German failure in the east -- the "wild East," they called it. The general German policy of repression and violence directed against the civilian populations in general in the east also had a lot to do with this. Many welcomed the German armies in 1941, because they hated the Sovs. It didn't take long for the Germans to waste most of this support. (Though they continued to have some.)

So, do you have evidence that German death squads were "following" the army in the middle of the dispute for the Crimea.
 
Do you have evidence that the Germans used Hitler Youth in the death camps?


Nobody ever said they did. SDC's oiginal quote only said very young adults worked in the death camps and that the Hitler Youth were drafted into many roles at the end of the war. Here is his original statement:

They certainly used very young adults, as staff. The Hitlerjugend (Hitler Youth) were drafted late in the war into all sorts of stuff.


Yet you misread the statement and ask for evidence of something SDC never said:

Do you have evidence that the Germans used Hitler Youth in the death camps?


And then you insist on demanding evidence for something that nobody ever argued:


So, you admit to not having evidence of your assertion.


And then you demand evidence again despite the fact that nobody ever made the claim you are demanding evidence of:


I do want evidence for your assertions.


You mischaracterized the original argument in such a way as to make evidence impossible. Perhaps you knew that you were doing so. Perhaps you just misread the original post. In any event, you may stop demanding evidence of this now.
 
Last edited:
I am not asking for evidence of something that was not asserted.


Here's a woman who started killing in the death camps at the age of 20. By the age of 25, she was the female supervisor at Majdanek.

Do you honestly believe that a country whose youngest soldiers were about 18 for much of the war (and younger at the end), didn't have young adults working as guards in the death camps?

Exactly whom do you believe was working there? The Keebler Elves?
 
Amazing that the Germans sent death squads into the Crimea during the battles with the Russians.

Crimea was a war zone into 1944.

I guess winning the war was less important than killing non-combatants.

Jerome,

Stop embarassing yourself. Get a map. Then get a timeline of the events of WWII. Check out 1941. Particularly check Sep/Oct/Nov. See anything relevant?

I assume you also recall that the Russians mounted a counter-offensive after Germany had controlled extensive Russian territories (including the Crimea) for several years.

Okay, now let's see.
Census is 1939, as I surmised and as the always well-documented Spitfire X confirmed.
Germany took the Crimea in the autumn of '41.
German communique says many of the Jews were effectively wiped out before December of '41.
Russian counter-offensive in Crimea - '44!

Get it, yet?

You still owe the guy an apology. In so many words, you called him a liar... a fabricator of evidence. The only evidence I see is that you're trolling for a scrap, and as usual, you're armed with no facts, just headlines and opinions.
 
I am just joining this thread. Due to the length and number of post, what I have to offer may be redundant, but I would like to offer it none the less. One of the best sources for information about the holocaust online is the US Holocaust Memorial Museum website.
While none of my relatives were holocaust survivors (or victims), I have met several WW2 veterans who were there for the liberation of at least one of the camps: the Landsberg subcamp of Dachau. My father was in the 10th Armored Division, and at a reunion of that outfit last year, I learned of their part in the liberation of that camp. When I got home, I looked it up, and they are recognized as liberators by the museum, (though according to the vets, Band of Brothers presented the story differently than it really happenned...it was the 10thAD that arrived at and liberated Landsberg. They handed it over to the 101st Airborne.) Even though my dad was not with the outfit when they liberated Landsberg (he was sitting in a POW camp in Muhlberg, captured during the Ardennes Offensive), he was a witness to some of the camps after he was liberated from Stalag 4B. He never liked to talk about it, other than to say he had never immagined there could be such evil perpetrated by men.
Where was I going with this, you ask? To deny the holocaust or to attempt to revise history to shift blame not only dishonors the memory of the victims...it dishonors the memory and the actions off the people who fought the Nazis and ultimately brought the holocaust to an end.
 
J
Germany took the Crimea in the autumn of '41.
German communique says many of the Jews were effectively wiped out before December of '41.

This argument is falling apart by the post.

In just two months the Germans secured the Crimea and "wiped out" the majority of Jews?

Have you thought about the logistics here?

Please keep posting your thoughts; this is great!
 
In 1929 there were 18 million Jews on Earth. After WW2, and till today, there are about 13-14 million Jews. Where did the missing Jews go...Mars?
 
I'll sum up the truth about holocaust deniers. If you don't believe the Holocaust happened, you're in an idiot. There. Time to go to bed CT's.
 
Here's a woman who started killing in the death camps at the age of 20. By the age of 25, she was the female supervisor at Majdanek.

Do you honestly believe that a country whose youngest soldiers were about 18 for much of the war (and younger at the end), didn't have young adults working as guards in the death camps?

Exactly whom do you believe was working there? The Keebler Elves?

I would love to see the transcripts of this trial.

She was convicted in 1980 of stamping old women to death in 1939.
 
In 1929 there were 18 million Jews on Earth. After WW2, and till today, there are about 13-14 million Jews. Where did the missing Jews go...Mars?

The Jews have had a static population for 60 years?

So, in 1930 Jews were 9% of the world population, 6% of the world population in 1950, and today Jews are 2% of the world population.

What is your explanation for the decrease in percentage of Jews between 1950 and 2005?

Did they go to Mars?
 
I'll sum up the truth about holocaust deniers. If you don't believe the Holocaust happened, you're in an idiot. There. Time to go to bed CT's.

Ohh, I think the holocaust happened. I just find it interesting that people would be jailed for researching history. A very interesting topic concerning freedom of thought and speech. I also have a hard time allowing people to state silly claims only backed by insults and name-calling if evidence is asked of the assertion. This is regardless of the subject at hand.
 
I guess winning the war was less important than killing non-combatants.
The leadership of the Third Reich made all kinds of errors which contributed to their downfall. Not converting the German economy to a total war footing until well into 1943 would be one. Not focusing on the production of fighters for air defence would be another. Squandering huge amounts of resources on the militarily useless V-1 and V-2 programs would be yet another. And that's just three which quickly come to mind.

Given this, that they would commit another mistake by pouring resources into mass killing of undesired populations rather than in useful military affairs would seem to be fully in keeping with their ability to make unwise choices in regards to winning the war.
 
Last edited:
The Jews have had a static population for 60 years?

So, in 1930 Jews were 9% of the world population, 6% of the world population in 1950, and today Jews are 2% of the world population.

What is your explanation for the decrease in percentage of Jews between 1950 and 2005?

Did they go to Mars?

I think I can answer this. According to Jewish Law, when a Jewish man marries a non-Jew, offspring are not Jews. Based on a 54 percent figure
http://judaism.about.com/od/jewishhumor/f/jewry_usa.htm
at least one quarter of the population growth vanishes, based on using Jewish Law to determine who is Jewish.

Because of this weird definition of who is considered Jewish, there are no half Jews, quarter Jews, whatever. Even if a Jewish man has a dozen kids, if his wife is non-Jew, none of them count as Jews.

I'm pretty sure this is the only situation in the entire world where people can reproduce, a population can grow, but the statistics show no growth, or negative growth, because the "race" is based only on the Mother, and it is all or nothing.

I could be wrong, and I'm sure if that is the case, someone will explain why. The Jewish women who marry non-Jews don't balance the numbers because the addition of one non-Jew (even if they convert) doesn't equal the loss of all children from the Jew men who marry out.

I never thought about it before, but it is really strange.

Not just the population statistics being skewed, but the whole way of counting heads based on religion, not race.

Every time a Jew man marries out, all of his children, grandchildren, great grandchildren, none are counted as Jews. The numbers add up quick. There may be 20 million people living right now, who had a Jewish parent, that are not considered Jews.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom