Drudgewire
Critical Doofus
- Joined
- Feb 27, 2006
- Messages
- 9,421
Hehe, nice one.Wouldn't they clash horribly with his brown shirts?![]()
Hehe, nice one.Wouldn't they clash horribly with his brown shirts?![]()
So people who were actually there don't count?
Hope you are not a neoNAZI nut case like MaGzee.If you are going to make up stuff to make your point, try to have the falsehood at least match with historical facts.
Germany fought the Russians in the Crimea in 1941.
![]()

Another excellent book of recent years, a kind of micro-study: Jan Gross, "Neighbors." About massacres in northeastern Poland at the time of the German sweep-through in the summer of 1941. The point is the active participation of parts of the local Polish community in the slaughter of their Jewish neighbors, in a town called Jedwabne. (That's Yed-VAHB-ne.) An excellent book for depressing thoughts about human nature.
I'm always dead serious, only that I sometimes uses humor and hyperbole to make a point.Well, I don't know how serious you are, but these were among the most horrifying of the firebombings. There is the case that bombing the active enemy's civilians is a different act from killing the civilians under your (the conqueror's) control who have effectively surrendered. And one should remember that the Germans started the terrorization/ massacre of civilians as a conscious policy process in Poland in 1939. Terrible nonetheless. (And the most recent serious estimates from Dresden are rather lower, but still in the tens of thousands.)
Read W.G. Sebald, "Luftkrieg und Literatur" (Air War and Literature) for one approach to the topic, from the perspective of how little it has been discussed in German literature, which is fascinating. It's been translated into English -- Sebald was a professor in Norfolk, though German-born -- though I don't recall the English title. The German is murderously hard, at least for me, which may be appropriate to the topic.
Edit: they seem to have translated the title as "On the Natural History of Destruction."
If the above is enough to convince you Poles participated in the holocaust, then you'll just love researching the massacres of Naliboki and Koniuchy, where Jews murdered civilian Poles, though forsome reason these massacres are not so popular in the circles that promote books like Neighbors.
Can this really be labelled a "holocaust" if the Poles were only taking out revenge on specific individuals based on their actions during the preceding Soviet occupation?
I think this is a common thread throughout Holocaust mythology: the real killings of a handful of Jewish spies, saboteurs, partisans, etc. are linked to the deportation of large parts of the Jewish communities, to falsely suggest that those being evacuated were sent to be exterminated.
An alternate look at the Jedwabne controversy:
http://judicial-inc.biz/jedwabne.htm
Can this really be labelled a "holocaust" if the Poles were only taking out revenge on specific individuals based on their actions during the preceding Soviet occupation?
I think this is a common thread throughout Holocaust mythology: the real killings of a handful of Jewish spies, saboteurs, partisans, etc. are linked to the deportation of large parts of the Jewish communities, to falsely suggest that those being evacuated were sent to be exterminated.
An alternate look at the Jedwabne controversy:
Well the whole issue of Polish-Jewish relations isnt really being looked at objectively by most people. Despite Poland having the fewest collaborators of any occupied country and the largest numbers of Jews saved, while being the only country where helping Jews was punished by death, its easier to shift blame on Poland and drive a mercedes, guilt free, esspecially if you live in the US. Other countries such as France and Scandinavia also like to blame Poles to cover up their own Nazi collaboration. They will talk about a few fishermen ferrying a few thousand Jews 5km to Sweden, while risking not much, but will forget about their goverments giving lists of Jews to the SS and the Nordic SS divisions, for example. Witold Pilecki had himself captured ON PURPOSE and sent to Auschwitz, set up a resistance on the inside, only to be sentenced to death after the war by a Jewish judge and ridicoulous testimony from Jews that hes lying and is an american spy. Jan Karski smuggled himself into ghettoes and documented the holocaust first had only to be called a liar by zionists in the UK and US when he came to them to present the plight of Jews and ask for aid.
Two Polish women set up the Zegota with funding from the Polish goverment in exile with the task of saving Jewish children. 2500 were saved by Irena Sendlerowa alone.
Of course they will make movies about 'good' german slave owners before making fimls about the above. Its quite sad really.
They certainly used very young adults, as staff. The Hitlerjugend (Hitler Youth) were drafted late in the war into all sorts of stuff.
Come on, JDG, do a little homework. Read Michael Kater's recent book, "Hitler Youth." It's short.
If it was an excuse for accusing someone else of the rape and pillage, or in order to claim that "the world was asking for it, you should have seen what she was wearing"?
You abide by the laws in democratic countries. If the law of a particular country makes holocaust denial illegal then you abide by this or suffer the consequences.
Follow-up: yes, the last pre-war census of the Soviet Union was in 1939. ("Jewpatoria" is the German spelling of a city known in English as "Yevpatoria" or "Evpatoriia," depending on transliteration schemes.)
Further, the killing squads (Einsatzgruppen, essentially "special assignment teams") followed the German armies into the Soviet Union in the summer of 1941. Their assignment included primarily rounding up and eliminating the Jewish communities, which were especially large and widespread in the western Sov Un, including Belarus (White Russia) and Ukraine, plus Crimea. The most famous case was outside Kiev, at Babi Yar (= "Old Woman Gulch," if you must know) where some tens of thousands were shot and buried. The death camps, of which Auschwitz was most famous, were only one piece of the Holocaust. There were other "pure" death camps (Operation Reinhard, with Treblinka, Sobibor, Belzec...), plus hard labor camps where hundreds of thousands died, including many non-Jews (much of the Auschwitz site consisted of labor, not only death camps). I think the most recent estimate is 5,000 KL (Concentration Camp) sites throughout Europe.
Edit: Whoops! I forgot the ghetto sites which were established, chiefly in Poland. Best known of course was the Warsaw ghetto, where half a million were kept. Hundreds of thousands died in the official ghettos due to disease and starvation as well as actual "Aktions", i.e., send in the killing squads and turn them loose for a day.
But heck, Atrain and Magz, you know all this.
Do you have evidence that the Germans used Hitler Youth in the death camps?
Amazing that the Germans sent death squads into the Crimea during the battles with the Russians.
Crimea was a war zone into 1944.
I guess winning the war was less important than killing non-combatants.
Amazing that the Germans sent death squads into the Crimea during the battles with the Russians.
Crimea was a war zone into 1944.
I guess winning the war was less important than killing non-combatants.
This from the fellow who had to be chastised per Foolmewunz (? I think) for gross misreading of the Crimean information?
First, I'm not here to do your homework. Is your belief that no Hitlerjugend served in the SS extermination program? That is silly beyond belief. The Hitlerjugend was meant to be an omnipresent force in German society. It went well beyond any reasonable definition of adolescence; millions of young men and women participated. It was compulsory, or next thing to. Again, read Kater's "Hitler youth" if you want to know more. It's recent, it's in English (though there is a German edition, too), and it's only 300 pp. or so.
Besides, you evidently misread Unsecured Coin's original statement. He referred to, I think, his grandmother as a German witness to the Holocaust. The actual death camps were only one piece, albeit by the latter part of the war the biggest and most effective part, of the Holocaust. The most recent scholarly estimates refer to several thousand KL (concentration camps) of many different sorts throughout Europe. The big death camps, Operation Reinhard, were set in Poland. Auschwitz was a complex of labor camps plus a death camp, which is why so many survived; it was huge. A number of camps -- but not big death camps -- were in Germany and Austria; most notorious were Dachau, Belsen, Matthausen... but many small ones were scattered across the landscape. Adult Germans as a whole may have tried not to see, but it was under their noses. Also, perhaps UC's grandmother saw something like the death marches, when those who still survived (in early 1945) were marched or truck from camp to camp to get them out of the way of the Red Army, and save them for proper Nazi murder. (It is remarkable how many resources and how many troops the Germans wasted in this effort, which they could have used against either the western Allies or the Sovs.) So ask him what he meant. He could have meant, or his grandmother could have, any number of things.
Go and read. Try to learn. Learning is Good.
Your not kidding. If Hitler had taken two seconds to think out a coherent plan for Germany that actually had a shot at working, he would have realized that the scientific knowledge, professional skills and money of the Jewish upper class in Germany were necessary to win a war.
Also, he might have done some math and realized it was impossible to kill every single Russian no matter how much he hated them.