[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

Wouldn't they clash horribly with his brown shirts? ;)
Hehe, nice one.
hfive.gif
 
Another excellent book of recent years, a kind of micro-study: Jan Gross, "Neighbors." About massacres in northeastern Poland at the time of the German sweep-through in the summer of 1941. The point is the active participation of parts of the local Polish community in the slaughter of their Jewish neighbors, in a town called Jedwabne. (That's Yed-VAHB-ne.) An excellent book for depressing thoughts about human nature.


Jan Gross' book, Neighbors, presents a very innaccurate account of the Jedwabne massacre- he never went into the local archives and his chief witness was in siberia at the time. A much better book is "The Massacre at Jedwabne: Before, During and After," by Marek Jan Chodakiewicz, which takes into account the findings of the IPN (Institute of National Rememberance). Actually, Gross earlier works are alot more accurate and its almost hard to believe that such different conclusions were written by the same guy (its as if he convieniently forgot things he had written about extensively in prior works....)


(1) "1,600 (Jewish) men, women and children" were murdered (this statement in Gross' `Neighbors' has been repeated many times). In fact, Jedwabne in 1941 did not have 1,600 Jewish inhabitants. An IPN historian, Jan Jerzy Milewski, found a 1940 Soviet NKVD document in the archive in Grodno showing that in Jedwabne in 1940 there were about 560 Jews. Thus a year before the massacre, a Soviet census found the Jewish population of Jedwabne to be approximately one-third the number given by Jan T. Gross in `Neighbors'.

IPN's exhumation of the Jedwabne victims was interrupted at the request of the invited supervising Jewish rabbi that the remains of the victims not be further disturbed. The best estimate of IPN's chief forensic investigator, Prof. Andrzej Kola, was that there were between 300 and 400 victims. IPN concluded: `The figure of 1,600 victims or so seems highly unlikely, and it was not confirmed in the course of the investigation.'

(2) `The Germans' direct participation in the mass murder.....was limited, pretty much, to their taking pictures' (Gross, `Neighbors'). This is false. In reality, IPN found, the day began "with the herding of Poles to the town square, which was done, according to witnesses, jointly by the German gendarmes, i.e. policemen and the people from the collaborating administration. In the testimonials there is mention of the fact that German policemen hit some of the Jedwabne Poles in the face with rifle butts or their hands, which is evidence that some of them did not want to go to the town square." The Germans then distributed bats and clubs to the Poles, to use as weapons against the Jews. At the Jedwabne town square, the Germans were in charge.

The Germans were not in Jedwabne just as photographers, as Gross would have readers believe. The Germans were in Jedwabne as organizers.

(3) "Half of the Polish town" murdered the other half: This is not accurate. IPN, after interviewing 98 persons of whom about one-third were first-hand witnesses, concluded that "approximately at least forty men" were Polish perpetrators in the murder (but not "one half of the town" as stated on the fly-leaf of `Neighbors', which would have required over one thousand participants; Gross himself, in `Neighbors,' claims to have ninety-two names of Polish participants). Whether ninety-two according to Gross or "at least forty" in IPN's findings, the number of Polish participants in the Jedwabne massacre was not one-half of the village, but closer to one-twentieth.

An ACCURATE English-language version of IPN's principal findings, about 3 pages long, can be found on the Internet by going to `The Jedwabne Tragedy' at Buffalo University's `info-Poland' website, and then to `Jedwabne, July 10th, 1941: an interview with Prof. Pawel Machcewicz.

If the above is enough to convince you Poles participated in the holocaust, then you'll just love researching the massacres of Naliboki and Koniuchy, where Jews murdered civilian Poles, though forsome reason these massacres are not so popular in the circles that promote books like Neighbors.
 
Well, I don't know how serious you are, but these were among the most horrifying of the firebombings. There is the case that bombing the active enemy's civilians is a different act from killing the civilians under your (the conqueror's) control who have effectively surrendered. And one should remember that the Germans started the terrorization/ massacre of civilians as a conscious policy process in Poland in 1939. Terrible nonetheless. (And the most recent serious estimates from Dresden are rather lower, but still in the tens of thousands.)

Read W.G. Sebald, "Luftkrieg und Literatur" (Air War and Literature) for one approach to the topic, from the perspective of how little it has been discussed in German literature, which is fascinating. It's been translated into English -- Sebald was a professor in Norfolk, though German-born -- though I don't recall the English title. The German is murderously hard, at least for me, which may be appropriate to the topic.

Edit: they seem to have translated the title as "On the Natural History of Destruction."
I'm always dead serious, only that I sometimes uses humor and hyperbole to make a point.
 
If the above is enough to convince you Poles participated in the holocaust, then you'll just love researching the massacres of Naliboki and Koniuchy, where Jews murdered civilian Poles, though forsome reason these massacres are not so popular in the circles that promote books like Neighbors.

Can this really be labelled a "holocaust" if the Poles were only taking out revenge on specific individuals based on their actions during the preceding Soviet occupation?

I think this is a common thread throughout Holocaust mythology: the real killings of a handful of Jewish spies, saboteurs, partisans, etc. are linked to the deportation of large parts of the Jewish communities, to falsely suggest that those being evacuated were sent to be exterminated.

An alternate look at the Jedwabne controversy:

http://judicial-inc.biz/jedwabne.htm
 
The irony here is that it doesn't really matter what A-Train and his fellow Nazi apologists think; the Holocaust is accepted as fact throughout the West, and taught in schools as such. You can shout until you're blue in the face, lads, but you'll always be a tiny minority....and one which, if you spouted this rubbish in many European countries, would be swiftly escorted to either gaol or the airport.

I think the phrase is "peeing into the wind".......
 
Can this really be labelled a "holocaust" if the Poles were only taking out revenge on specific individuals based on their actions during the preceding Soviet occupation?

I think this is a common thread throughout Holocaust mythology: the real killings of a handful of Jewish spies, saboteurs, partisans, etc. are linked to the deportation of large parts of the Jewish communities, to falsely suggest that those being evacuated were sent to be exterminated.

An alternate look at the Jedwabne controversy:

http://judicial-inc.biz/jedwabne.htm

Nuts. Those deported whether to camps, official ghettos, or simple killing fields like Babi Yar, were killed, and the evidence is overwhelming. Witnesses, and documents, and the physical materials, and a few survivors. No one in their right mind can get around that fact. Your argument is silly in the extreme. But I understand that the mods are very much opposed to how people in Jref often address the Holocaust deniers, so I won't go beyond that statement.

And A, if you want to talk Jedwabne, I'm not going to argue with danceswithganja (sounds like a bad idea, but it's been a long time), but I assume he (?) doesn't question that some hundreds of Jews were killed there (10 July 1941, I think, though I'd have to look it up), with the energetic participation of some of the Polish community. I note he refers to "collaborating authorities" (like the mayor, if memory serves), and not-exactly-the-leading-lights of the town, town thugs in other words. Some of the few Jedwabne Jews who survived the war were protected and hidden by local Poles, which was extraordinarily dangerous -- in Poland the protectors and their families were killed as well as any Jews discovered by the Germans and their allies, which wasn't the case in western Europe.

I know about the disagreements. I'm not a spokesman for Gross. It is a very controversial topic and dwj rightly refers to the IPN, Instytut Pamieci Narodowej, Institute of National Memory. One interesting point is that the Germans early on did have an idea of using local populations to do some of the killing, but quickly gave it up; 1/ it was chaotic, which the German army didn't care for, and 2/ wait a minute... giving Poles or other civilian populations weapons... well, the Germans decided it wasn't a great idea. They moved on from these "wild actions" to the much more organized business of Einsatzgruppen and camps.

Obviously there is a lot on the Jedwabne issue not translated, but you can find "Thou Shalt Not Kill: Poles on Jedwabne" (published by Wiez, an important liberal Catholic publisher), and "The Neighbors Respond: The Controversy... [etc.]" published by Princeton U Press (as was Gross' book). These both are collections of the controversy.

On a more general theme, I recommend Michael Steinlauf, "Bondage to the Dead: Poland and the Memory of the Holocaust." The essential theme is the extraordinarily traumatic memory of the Holocaust in Poland, on whose soil over half of the total Jewish deaths were done. I used it as the basis for a paper once; very, very interesting.

Dwj, no need to be sarcastic. We can talk about this. I am well aware who started, organized, directed, and carried out the Holocaust. If you've read this list (and not just my post mentioning Gross' book) you will see that I've been asking A and M why they and their ilk never, ever mention the Polish and other Eastern European (Russian, Ukrainian, etc.) testimonies about the Holocaust; and that, moreover, the Holocaust in the wider sense of the organized mass killing of civilians by the Germans in WW2, included (est.) a couple of million Polish Christians, half a million Roma/ Gypsies, and well one could go on.

I've been lecturing too much on this. I should step back and get out of the way. Except when A or M try to pop up and repeat one of the silly comments. A or M, if you have nothing new to say other than the tired old silly bilge of the professional anti-semites, well, I don't know why you bother.
 
Last edited:
Can this really be labelled a "holocaust" if the Poles were only taking out revenge on specific individuals based on their actions during the preceding Soviet occupation?

I think this is a common thread throughout Holocaust mythology: the real killings of a handful of Jewish spies, saboteurs, partisans, etc. are linked to the deportation of large parts of the Jewish communities, to falsely suggest that those being evacuated were sent to be exterminated.

An alternate look at the Jedwabne controversy:

Well the whole issue of Polish-Jewish relations isnt really being looked at objectively by most people. Despite Poland having the fewest collaborators of any occupied country and the largest numbers of Jews saved, while being the only country where helping Jews was punished by death, its easier to shift blame on Poland and drive a mercedes, guilt free, esspecially if you live in the US. Other countries such as France and Scandinavia also like to blame Poles to cover up their own Nazi collaboration. They will talk about a few fishermen ferrying a few thousand Jews 5km to Sweden, while risking not much, but will forget about their goverments giving lists of Jews to the SS and the Nordic SS divisions, for example. Witold Pilecki had himself captured ON PURPOSE and sent to Auschwitz, set up a resistance on the inside, only to be sentenced to death after the war by a Jewish judge and ridicoulous testimony from Jews that hes lying and is an american spy. Jan Karski smuggled himself into ghettoes and documented the holocaust first had only to be called a liar by zionists in the UK and US when he came to them to present the plight of Jews and ask for aid.
Two Polish women set up the Zegota with funding from the Polish goverment in exile with the task of saving Jewish children. 2500 were saved by Irena Sendlerowa alone.
Of course they will make movies about 'good' german slave owners before making fimls about the above. Its quite sad really.
 
Well the whole issue of Polish-Jewish relations isnt really being looked at objectively by most people. Despite Poland having the fewest collaborators of any occupied country and the largest numbers of Jews saved, while being the only country where helping Jews was punished by death, its easier to shift blame on Poland and drive a mercedes, guilt free, esspecially if you live in the US. Other countries such as France and Scandinavia also like to blame Poles to cover up their own Nazi collaboration. They will talk about a few fishermen ferrying a few thousand Jews 5km to Sweden, while risking not much, but will forget about their goverments giving lists of Jews to the SS and the Nordic SS divisions, for example. Witold Pilecki had himself captured ON PURPOSE and sent to Auschwitz, set up a resistance on the inside, only to be sentenced to death after the war by a Jewish judge and ridicoulous testimony from Jews that hes lying and is an american spy. Jan Karski smuggled himself into ghettoes and documented the holocaust first had only to be called a liar by zionists in the UK and US when he came to them to present the plight of Jews and ask for aid.
Two Polish women set up the Zegota with funding from the Polish goverment in exile with the task of saving Jewish children. 2500 were saved by Irena Sendlerowa alone.
Of course they will make movies about 'good' german slave owners before making fimls about the above. Its quite sad really.

Well you are largely right except for the sarcasm and the allegation that "zionists" were behind the rejection of Karski's testimony. The Anglo-American governments didn't want to hear about it. The Polish government-in-exile (in London) took a while, but finally started promoting the evidence of the massacres; there was enough information pre-Karski, but hardly anyone wanted to act on it, or believe it. More than "zionists," it was foreign service/ state department anti-semites who were opposed to letting Jewish refugees in (whether the US, Canada, or British Mandate Palestine), and also non-Zionist Jews such as, shamefully, the owners of the NY Times.

As for a "Jewish judge" and Jews testifying (Pilecki case), I don't know the case offhand, but in postwar Poland the communists took over -- including communists of both Jewish and Christian origin. That's how they identified themselves; as servants of the communist state.

As for Karski, don't forget that the prize given in his name has been for the promotion of Polish-Jewish conciliation and cooperation. That memory should be honored.
 
They certainly used very young adults, as staff. The Hitlerjugend (Hitler Youth) were drafted late in the war into all sorts of stuff.

Come on, JDG, do a little homework. Read Michael Kater's recent book, "Hitler Youth." It's short.

Do you have evidence that the Germans used Hitler Youth in the death camps?
 
If it was an excuse for accusing someone else of the rape and pillage, or in order to claim that "the world was asking for it, you should have seen what she was wearing"?

You abide by the laws in democratic countries. If the law of a particular country makes holocaust denial illegal then you abide by this or suffer the consequences.

Would you consider thought crimes part of a free society?
 
SDC,

Well, zionists or not they were Jewish leaders and I wish sometimes people will remember that Ben Gurion didnt send any weapons to the ghettoes when they criticize others for sending to few of theirs when they were significantly underarmed.

btw, Revolution from Abroad is an excellent book by Gross, clearly from his pre-BS days as it, in contrast to Neighbors, didnt include a chapter entitled 'a new approach to sources' which states that we should treat "...what we read in a particular account as fact, until we find persuasive arguments to the contrary, we would avoid more mistakes than we are likely to commit by adopting the opposite approach, which calls for cautious skepticism toward any testimony until independent confirmation of it's content has been found".
 
Follow-up: yes, the last pre-war census of the Soviet Union was in 1939. ("Jewpatoria" is the German spelling of a city known in English as "Yevpatoria" or "Evpatoriia," depending on transliteration schemes.)

Further, the killing squads (Einsatzgruppen, essentially "special assignment teams") followed the German armies into the Soviet Union in the summer of 1941. Their assignment included primarily rounding up and eliminating the Jewish communities, which were especially large and widespread in the western Sov Un, including Belarus (White Russia) and Ukraine, plus Crimea. The most famous case was outside Kiev, at Babi Yar (= "Old Woman Gulch," if you must know) where some tens of thousands were shot and buried. The death camps, of which Auschwitz was most famous, were only one piece of the Holocaust. There were other "pure" death camps (Operation Reinhard, with Treblinka, Sobibor, Belzec...), plus hard labor camps where hundreds of thousands died, including many non-Jews (much of the Auschwitz site consisted of labor, not only death camps). I think the most recent estimate is 5,000 KL (Concentration Camp) sites throughout Europe.

Edit: Whoops! I forgot the ghetto sites which were established, chiefly in Poland. Best known of course was the Warsaw ghetto, where half a million were kept. Hundreds of thousands died in the official ghettos due to disease and starvation as well as actual "Aktions", i.e., send in the killing squads and turn them loose for a day.

But heck, Atrain and Magz, you know all this.


Amazing that the Germans sent death squads into the Crimea during the battles with the Russians.

Crimea was a war zone into 1944.

I guess winning the war was less important than killing non-combatants.
 
Do you have evidence that the Germans used Hitler Youth in the death camps?

This from the fellow who had to be chastised per Foolmewunz (? I think) for gross misreading of the Crimean information?

First, I'm not here to do your homework. Is your belief that no Hitlerjugend served in the SS extermination program? That is silly beyond belief. The Hitlerjugend was meant to be an omnipresent force in German society. It went well beyond any reasonable definition of adolescence; millions of young men and women participated. It was compulsory, or next thing to. Again, read Kater's "Hitler youth" if you want to know more. It's recent, it's in English (though there is a German edition, too), and it's only 300 pp. or so.

Besides, you evidently misread Unsecured Coin's original statement. He referred to, I think, his grandmother as a German witness to the Holocaust. The actual death camps were only one piece, albeit by the latter part of the war the biggest and most effective part, of the Holocaust. The most recent scholarly estimates refer to several thousand KL (concentration camps) of many different sorts throughout Europe. The big death camps, Operation Reinhard, were set in Poland. Auschwitz was a complex of labor camps plus a death camp, which is why so many survived; it was huge. A number of camps -- but not big death camps -- were in Germany and Austria; most notorious were Dachau, Belsen, Matthausen... but many small ones were scattered across the landscape. Adult Germans as a whole may have tried not to see, but it was under their noses. Also, perhaps UC's grandmother saw something like the death marches, when those who still survived (in early 1945) were marched or truck from camp to camp to get them out of the way of the Red Army, and save them for proper Nazi murder. (It is remarkable how many resources and how many troops the Germans wasted in this effort, which they could have used against either the western Allies or the Sovs.) So ask him what he meant. He could have meant, or his grandmother could have, any number of things.

Go and read. Try to learn. Learning is Good.
 
Amazing that the Germans sent death squads into the Crimea during the battles with the Russians.

Crimea was a war zone into 1944.

I guess winning the war was less important than killing non-combatants.


Your not kidding. If Hitler had taken two seconds to think out a coherent plan for Germany that actually had a shot at working, he would have realized that the scientific knowledge, professional skills and money of the Jewish upper class in Germany were necessary to win a war.

Also, he might have done some math and realized it was impossible to kill every single Russian no matter how much he hated them.
 
Amazing that the Germans sent death squads into the Crimea during the battles with the Russians.

Crimea was a war zone into 1944.

I guess winning the war was less important than killing non-combatants.

Glory unto the divine being of your choosing! That's correct. The killing squads followed the armies. (Actually, it's becoming better and better known that the army did a lot of its own killing of civilians.) Many have commented that the German focus on eliminating Jews was a waste of war material and forces, and may have been a major factor in German failure in the east -- the "wild East," they called it. The general German policy of repression and violence directed against the civilian populations in general in the east also had a lot to do with this. Many welcomed the German armies in 1941, because they hated the Sovs. It didn't take long for the Germans to waste most of this support. (Though they continued to have some.)
 
This from the fellow who had to be chastised per Foolmewunz (? I think) for gross misreading of the Crimean information?

First, I'm not here to do your homework. Is your belief that no Hitlerjugend served in the SS extermination program? That is silly beyond belief. The Hitlerjugend was meant to be an omnipresent force in German society. It went well beyond any reasonable definition of adolescence; millions of young men and women participated. It was compulsory, or next thing to. Again, read Kater's "Hitler youth" if you want to know more. It's recent, it's in English (though there is a German edition, too), and it's only 300 pp. or so.

Besides, you evidently misread Unsecured Coin's original statement. He referred to, I think, his grandmother as a German witness to the Holocaust. The actual death camps were only one piece, albeit by the latter part of the war the biggest and most effective part, of the Holocaust. The most recent scholarly estimates refer to several thousand KL (concentration camps) of many different sorts throughout Europe. The big death camps, Operation Reinhard, were set in Poland. Auschwitz was a complex of labor camps plus a death camp, which is why so many survived; it was huge. A number of camps -- but not big death camps -- were in Germany and Austria; most notorious were Dachau, Belsen, Matthausen... but many small ones were scattered across the landscape. Adult Germans as a whole may have tried not to see, but it was under their noses. Also, perhaps UC's grandmother saw something like the death marches, when those who still survived (in early 1945) were marched or truck from camp to camp to get them out of the way of the Red Army, and save them for proper Nazi murder. (It is remarkable how many resources and how many troops the Germans wasted in this effort, which they could have used against either the western Allies or the Sovs.) So ask him what he meant. He could have meant, or his grandmother could have, any number of things.

Go and read. Try to learn. Learning is Good.


So, you admit to not having evidence of your assertion.

Blind faith is not skeptical. I choose not to subscribe to this sort of information consumption.
 
Your not kidding. If Hitler had taken two seconds to think out a coherent plan for Germany that actually had a shot at working, he would have realized that the scientific knowledge, professional skills and money of the Jewish upper class in Germany were necessary to win a war.

Also, he might have done some math and realized it was impossible to kill every single Russian no matter how much he hated them.

You find it logical that there were death squads running around murdering civilians in the middle of a "hot" war zone?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom