[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

And the bombings of Hamburg and Dresden is exaggregated. The only victims was old ladies that got heart attacks when the RAF conducted recon missions. Typical of the crybaby jerries to claim that at least 100 thousand people was killed in the so-called "firestorm". (And where are the at least 100 thousand corpses? Burned to ash? How convenient.)

Well, I don't know how serious you are, but these were among the most horrifying of the firebombings. There is the case that bombing the active enemy's civilians is a different act from killing the civilians under your (the conqueror's) control who have effectively surrendered. And one should remember that the Germans started the terrorization/ massacre of civilians as a conscious policy process in Poland in 1939. Terrible nonetheless. (And the most recent serious estimates from Dresden are rather lower, but still in the tens of thousands.)

Read W.G. Sebald, "Luftkrieg und Literatur" (Air War and Literature) for one approach to the topic, from the perspective of how little it has been discussed in German literature, which is fascinating. It's been translated into English -- Sebald was a professor in Norfolk, though German-born -- though I don't recall the English title. The German is murderously hard, at least for me, which may be appropriate to the topic.

Edit: they seem to have translated the title as "On the Natural History of Destruction."
 
Last edited:
Name the academic(s), please. Not Irving, he's not an academic, not as normally defined. (A person holding a university or other educational position).
Eh, he's an academic. Wrote lots of books, and is well-studied in the history of the time.

He just also happens to be a fraud and a Nazi apologist/sympathizer.
 
Last edited:
Eh, he's an academic. Wrote lots of books, and is well-studied in the history of the time.

He just also happens to be a fraud and a Nazi apologist/sympathizer.

I won't argue. Some of his early work was well-regarded, as well.
 
Holocaust revisionism is so eerily similar to 911 trutherism.

Amazing.

It is indeed. There ought to be some serious writing, out there in the world, on the general topic... Hofstadter's approach to the "Paranoid Style in American Politics" (that's the title) often gets cited. Offhand I don't know what else there is. Scholars tend to concentrate on single countries or movements/ events rather than the general topic of conspiratorial writings/ theories. I'd be glad to hear of a wider work on the "theory and practice" of conspiracies.
 
It is indeed. There ought to be some serious writing, out there in the world, on the general topic... Hofstadter's approach to the "Paranoid Style in American Politics" (that's the title) often gets cited. Offhand I don't know what else there is. Scholars tend to concentrate on single countries or movements/ events rather than the general topic of conspiratorial writings/ theories. I'd be glad to hear of a wider work on the "theory and practice" of conspiracies.
It's appalling how much overlap there is between the two groups as well.
 
It is indeed. There ought to be some serious writing, out there in the world, on the general topic... Hofstadter's approach to the "Paranoid Style in American Politics" (that's the title) often gets cited. Offhand I don't know what else there is. Scholars tend to concentrate on single countries or movements/ events rather than the general topic of conspiratorial writings/ theories. I'd be glad to hear of a wider work on the "theory and practice" of conspiracies.
Shermer's "Why People Believe Weird Things" spends a great deal of time on the Revisionist movement. It's sad it was written prior to 9/11 but almost every single thing he touches on seems to run exactly parallel to twoofers.
 
One thing I don't understand. If most Holocaust-deniers are anti-semites, themselves, why are they denying the Holocaust's existence ? I mean, they should be happy (GRRRr... I need to restrain myself) that it happened.
 
One thing I don't understand. If most Holocaust-deniers are anti-semites, themselves, why are they denying the Holocaust's existence ? I mean, they should be happy (GRRRr... I need to restrain myself) that it happened.

They're trying to rehabilitate national socialism...... so that they can have another.
 
One thing I don't understand. If most Holocaust-deniers are anti-semites, themselves, why are they denying the Holocaust's existence ? I mean, they should be happy (GRRRr... I need to restrain myself) that it happened.
If it had worked and the Nazis ran a Jew-free world it'd be cause to celebrate for them. But since it didn't it's more productive to deny its existence and blame Jews for inventing it as a sympathy ploy.
 
If it had worked and the Nazis ran a Jew-free world it'd be cause to celebrate for them. But since it didn't it's more productive to deny its existence and blame Jews for inventing it as a sympathy ploy.

Plus, if the Holocaust (and a few assorted other crimes) are gone, they can "spin" all the rest to make the Nazis look like blameless victims of the evil jews/communists/capitalists/whatever.

Next stop after that: The Fourth Reich.
 
Just for the sake of historical accuracy, it may not matter to them but it does to me, the Nazi attitude towards Jews was not unique in Europe. There were several Nationalist (Volkisch) parties in the politics of Germany prior to the Nazis gaining control. A common thread was hatred of the Jews, most often as the villains in the loss of World War I (to the delight of the real villains, the German General Staff). Most of the other nations had similar movements. The notorious Dreyfus affair in France (which these 3 would no doubt believe was true) is an excellent example
 
Well, I don't know how serious you are, but these were among the most horrifying of the firebombings.
Yes, but that was only because of the freak occurrence of a large firestorm. Had conditions been just a little bit different, there would have been no firestorm.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom