[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

Why would those who ran the camps bother to tattoo the inmates if the plan was to kill them?

If they didn't keep track of what they were doing, they could end up losing thousands of Jews.
 
Why should I believe any of this is true?

I wouldn't necessarily believe documents purely from Soviet sources. They had entire departments producing forgeries.

However - the reason for believing that the Germans in Russia were rounding up and killing Jews is that everybody involved with what went on in Russia knows that after the Germans passed through, the Jews were gone, and they didn't come back.
 
The Jews in the Crimea.
.
.
Already in 1939, out of 65,000 Jews in the Crimea, 44,000 (that
is almost 70 percent) live in the cities of Simferopol, Sevastopol,
Kertch, Jewpatoria, Yalta, and Feodosia alone...

If you are going to make up stuff to make your point, try to have the falsehood at least match with historical facts.

Germany fought the Russians in the Crimea in 1941.
:jaw-dropp
 
Let's face it, an impossibly vast conspiracy involving academics and professionals from all over the world to discredit the tenets of national socialism is a lot less likely than a bunch of bitter and twisted pseudo intellectuals with an axe to grind and a willing audience of skinheads and right wing religious bigots peddling their 'revisionism' despite being proven wrong at every turn

I tend to be skeptical when academics are jailed for their ideas.
 
I tend to be skeptical when academics are jailed for their ideas.

I tend to believe that people who spread pernicious lies masquerading as historical fact and in so doing fuel the hatred of one race for another, should suffer the consequences, even when those consequences tend to be more restrained than those meted out by the ideologies the faux historian idealises.
 
Last edited:
I tend to believe that people who spread pernicious lies masquerading as historical fact and in so doing fuel the hatred of one race for another, should suffer the consequences, even when those consequences tend to be more restrained than those meted out by the ideologies the faux historian idealises.

So, if an academic wrote the the British empire did not rape and pillage the world they should be jailed?
 
So, if an academic wrote the the British empire did not rape and pillage the world they should be jailed?
The world was asking for it. You should have seen what she was wearing.
colbert.gif
 
If you are going to make up stuff to make your point, try to have the falsehood at least match with historical facts.

Germany fought the Russians in the Crimea in 1941.
:jaw-dropp

Good catch, Sherlock!

Now read it again, please and then apologize!

The German(translated) gives a little history of the population of the area. I'd suspect that the last census was maybe in 1939.

But the report is dated 1942 (see the header?), and refers to numbers having been executed BEFORE Dec of '41. Since the war in the Crimea, I'm sure you know, was in the autumn and early winter of '41, there's not a thing wrong with the information, historically.

There is, however, something wrong with accusing someone of fabricating evidence without even reading the document.
 
So, if an academic wrote the the British empire did not rape and pillage the world they should be jailed?

If it was an excuse for accusing someone else of the rape and pillage, or in order to claim that "the world was asking for it, you should have seen what she was wearing"?

You abide by the laws in democratic countries. If the law of a particular country makes holocaust denial illegal then you abide by this or suffer the consequences.
 
If it was an excuse for accusing someone else of the rape and pillage, or in order to claim that "the world was asking for it, you should have seen what she was wearing"?
Rattling cages before 10 am. Yes, Thanksgiving has come early this year. :cool:
 
I wouldn't necessarily believe documents purely from Soviet sources. They had entire departments producing forgeries.

However - the reason for believing that the Germans in Russia were rounding up and killing Jews is that everybody involved with what went on in Russia knows that after the Germans passed through, the Jews were gone, and they didn't come back.

The evidence is far from just "negative," in that sense. There were plenty of witnesses, not just the German soldiers who did the killing, but local people who were drafted for the labor involved. And a few survivors. And then there are the tons of evidence by the Germans themselves. Just one example would be the records of the many trials and investigations in West Germany.

Read anything by Christopher Browning, but especially "Ordinary Men." It's a detailed study of a single reserve unit made up of ordinary German policemen who were assigned to mass shootings in Poland. One of the best and most terrifying books on the topic. (Goldhagen isn't ranked so highly as a scholar, by any means, even though -- because? -- he gained a kind of celebrity status in Germany.)

Another excellent book of recent years, a kind of micro-study: Jan Gross, "Neighbors." About massacres in northeastern Poland at the time of the German sweep-through in the summer of 1941. The point is the active participation of parts of the local Polish community in the slaughter of their Jewish neighbors, in a town called Jedwabne. (That's Yed-VAHB-ne.) An excellent book for depressing thoughts about human nature.
 
The Germans used children in the death camps?

They certainly used very young adults, as staff. The Hitlerjugend (Hitler Youth) were drafted late in the war into all sorts of stuff.

Come on, JDG, do a little homework. Read Michael Kater's recent book, "Hitler Youth." It's short.
 
I tend to be skeptical when academics are jailed for their ideas.

Name the academic(s), please. Not Irving, he's not an academic, not as normally defined. (A person holding a university or other educational position).

As for the laws against Holocaust denial, or against promotion of anti-Semitism in many European countries... well, I understand it from their history.
 
Good catch, Sherlock!

Now read it again, please and then apologize!

The German(translated) gives a little history of the population of the area. I'd suspect that the last census was maybe in 1939.

But the report is dated 1942 (see the header?), and refers to numbers having been executed BEFORE Dec of '41. Since the war in the Crimea, I'm sure you know, was in the autumn and early winter of '41, there's not a thing wrong with the information, historically.

There is, however, something wrong with accusing someone of fabricating evidence without even reading the document.

Follow-up: yes, the last pre-war census of the Soviet Union was in 1939. ("Jewpatoria" is the German spelling of a city known in English as "Yevpatoria" or "Evpatoriia," depending on transliteration schemes.)

Further, the killing squads (Einsatzgruppen, essentially "special assignment teams") followed the German armies into the Soviet Union in the summer of 1941. Their assignment included primarily rounding up and eliminating the Jewish communities, which were especially large and widespread in the western Sov Un, including Belarus (White Russia) and Ukraine, plus Crimea. The most famous case was outside Kiev, at Babi Yar (= "Old Woman Gulch," if you must know) where some tens of thousands were shot and buried. The death camps, of which Auschwitz was most famous, were only one piece of the Holocaust. There were other "pure" death camps (Operation Reinhard, with Treblinka, Sobibor, Belzec...), plus hard labor camps where hundreds of thousands died, including many non-Jews (much of the Auschwitz site consisted of labor, not only death camps). I think the most recent estimate is 5,000 KL (Concentration Camp) sites throughout Europe.

Edit: Whoops! I forgot the ghetto sites which were established, chiefly in Poland. Best known of course was the Warsaw ghetto, where half a million were kept. Hundreds of thousands died in the official ghettos due to disease and starvation as well as actual "Aktions", i.e., send in the killing squads and turn them loose for a day.

But heck, Atrain and Magz, you know all this.
 
Last edited:
I had avoided investigating the Holocaust for, well, squeamish pathetic reasons for many years. Then I visited Terezin in 1993 and got interested in the subject as a background historical project, and then the David Irving trial and the book written by one of the expert witnesses, Richard Evans, was a really gripping account, both of the reality of a systematic genocidal campaign against mainly Jews, and of the mindset of the Holocaust revisionists.

I've no doubt, therefore, that to deny the Holocaust is to have a mindset that any evidence presented must be tainted or fraudulent and that the first impression that the Holocaust cannot have happened must be defended at all costs.

As quite a few people on this thread have already mentioned, the documentary evidence is overwhelming that there was indeed a program by the Nazi regime to annihilate all Jews that were under its sphere of military dominance.

But everyone who encounters this evidence must weigh it up in his or her own mind - it is not an ideological position, a faith position, or a consensus position.

The thing you do learn from studying this is that David Irving, Arthur Butz, Paul Rassanier and others are irrelevant, a legend in their own lunchtimes and no-one else's.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom