[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, all they were doing is an autoland; with GPS instead of ILS. I'm sorry that it offends you, but that's all they did. If you believe otherwise, you'll have provide some hard evidence......short of that, we're done here. You are wasting my time.

Note to participants and lurkers, last time I asked Malcolm for evidence of remote control, he provided me with three examples, two of which relied on - you guessed it - autopilot! The other was the Nasa 707 remote controlled flight testing, which we already knew about. 1 outta 3 ain't bad with Malkie..

Where was the fellow who was holding the GPS on board or not?
Was there any big deal about remotely controlling a 757 or a 767 in 2001?
 
I'm glad you finally got round to looking at an un-edited version of that image that i provided you with earlier

Problem is Malcolm is that when you look at the rest of that report it does not state that the fuselage struck at column 11

it states it struck at 14 in their own diagrams and words later in the report

from that report you can see the fence would still be standing as it is too far to the left
I hope Taffer and the 'lurkers' on here are reading this post. They will remember me saying, that once I say the plane hit at 10 or 11, someone will say 17 and when I say 17, someone will say 10 or 11.
 
you have no idea what you are talking about malcolm

from the same article



Also from the same page



as for the rest of your post, there is a thread already here regading this and it has been shown that there is no proof that the phone were disabled prior to 911, what is certain is that they were not removed

there are photos on 911myths of aircraft with phones still in seats

try harder malkie
You're off again, you're unbelievable. I have produced a letter from Boeing. The person who signed that letter acknowledges that he works for Boeing and altough he can't remember the specific letter, he agrees that it's his and he stands by the content.
As he represents Boeing, then Boeing says their seat back phones were deactivated, if not also torn out on 9/11.
Respond to that. Spare me the baloney about some other backslappers thread, respond to the points in this post.
 
1. I have no idea. I'm not an engineer. I can say two thing: such a function would not be called "intuitive tone control", it would be "automatic pitch correction". And, for myself at least (and anyone who isn't totally tone-deaf (and I suspect even them)) it would be terribly disconcerting to have a radically different pitch coming out of the speakers than what's coming out of my mouth.
2. Then why have we been talking about this for six pages?
I quote you,
"I have no idea".
If you have no idea, then what are you doing pontificating on the subject?
 
How did the conspirators know passenger Linda Gronlunds safe combination for her sister to retrieve her last will and testament? did they morph that too?
Not so fast Smith. You have already squirmed around the Olson questions by trying to change the topic to light poles, now you are off on another tack with other passengers.
If you are so knowledgeable about the passengers then why do you avoid saying what type of phone Olson used and how many calls she made?
I will address the topic of other passengers when I have finished with the Olsons. Who is trying to move the goalposts now?
 
Ow :(

This should put Malcolm in a pickle, but I'd guess he'll say that the sister was "got at " by the CIA. Or maybe the sister invented the story to cover the fact she knew it all along and was routinely stealing from the safe.

Y'know. Something totally crass.
How's this for crass? I've got the truth on my side. Can you remember what that is? if not, stay tuned. I'll show you how far lies, deceit and trickery get you, when somebody shines the light of truth on you.
 
Idiots wrote that article you posted. Just lies.

"As well as fully autonomous flight capability, the 767 and 757 are the ONLY COMMUTER PLANES MADE BY BOEING THAT CAN BE FLOWN VIA REMOTE CONTROL. It is a feature that is standard to all of them, all 757's and 767's can do it. The purpose for this is if there is a problem with the pilots, Norad can fly the planes to safe destinations via remote. Only in this flight mode can those craft exceed their software limits and perform to their actual physical limits because a pre existing emergency situation is assumed if this mode of flight is used."
http://www.viewzone.com/911revisited.html
Edited by Katana: 
Edited out personal insult prior to approval.
It is hard to get something as wrong as they did.

Edited by Katana: 
Edited out personal insult prior to approval.
I am a retired Airline Captain, currently flying Business Jets. I have an Airline Transport Pilot Rating qualifying me to fly Captain on Boeing 707/720/727/747-400/757/767/777, Lockheed 382 and L-1011, and Dassault 20 and 2000 Aircraft. I have over 28,000 hours, several thousand of which were in command of 757/767's.
There is no provision for a 757/767 to be flown remotely. It can't be done. Period. Nothing disables the Flight or Voice Recorders, etc., except for the pulling of circuit breakers in the cockpit.
The 1.5 G limit built into the flight control system isn't there. The 757/767 does not have electronic flight controls- "fly by wire" and I don't know of any way to design these limits into the system without fly by wire. Some fly by wire aircraft- the Airbus 319/320/330/340 series and some military aircraft, for example- do have these artificial limits. The limits on the 'Busses is about 2.5 G's. Since the airplane is pulling 1 G in straight and level flight there would only be 1/2 G left for manuvering- not much.
The 757/767 cannot- repeat cannot be "programmed" to fly without a Pilot. It has a very good autopilot, capable of manipulating the controls as directed by the ON BOARD Crew in climb, cruise, descent, and- in some cases- landing. It must be disconnected for takeoff.
The 757/767 is hardly a Commuter aircraft. These are the small jets such as the Canadair and Embraer Jets and Turboprops used by Regional Airlines. Herb Fischer

As an avionics engineer, I also would like to stress out that there are NO provisions on 757/767 aircraft to have it remote controlled. Also, the CVR itself only can be erased by having the parking brake set and the erase button actuated. Not something you can do in flight. You can before start and pull the CVR CB though.
Regarding turn control: there is a banklimiter but when flown by hand, it won't work. The automatic pilot is similar to the 747-400. It cannot do a complete start. It is able to engage lateral navigation and vertical navigation _after you have reached the radio altitude of 100 and 400 ft if I recall correct. So the AP functions are armed but will NOT be able to control the aircraft at the time you select Take-OFF.

"Planes of 911 Exceeded Their Software Limits" in this case, is just BS. [email protected]
Too bad sane people can see the lies.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Here is a web page and here is a quote from it.
...
"As well as fully autonomous flight capability, the 767 and 757 are the ONLY COMMUTER PLANES MADE BY BOEING THAT CAN BE FLOWN VIA REMOTE CONTROL. It is a feature that is standard to all of them, all 757's and 767's can do it. The purpose for this is if there is a problem with the pilots, Norad can fly the planes to safe destinations via remote. Only in this flight mode can those craft exceed their software limits and perform to their actual physical limits because a pre existing emergency situation is assumed if this mode of flight is used."
http://www.viewzone.com/911revisited.html


My word, Malcolm. So, Gravy posted several articles and you posted an article that disagrees with him.

Gravy's article was written by Elizabeth Bretz, Senior Associate Editor of IEEE Spectrum. IEEE Spectrum magazine is the flagship publication of the IEEE, the world's largest professional technology association. IEEE Spectrum is read by over 385,000 technology professionals and senior executives worldwide in the high technology sectors of industry, government, and academia. IEEE stands for the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers.

Elizabeth Bretz was a Senior Associate Editor when she wrote the article but she's been promoted to Managing Editor since then. She's been at Spectrum since at least 2001. Before that, she was senior editor of Power, Electric Power International, Electric World, and Information Technologies for Utilities/IT. She earned a B.S. degree in mechanical engineering from Tulane University.

Your article was written by Jim Heikkila and published at Viewzone.Com. Viewzone has the following articles linked from its homepage right now: Did JESUS visit Tibet?: Nicholas Notovitch and the "Jesus Thangka" - new images found!; Chemtrails: What's going on?; The BioMusic Conspiracy: Secrets of the Rainbow Serpent Flute Goddess; The Truth About Jonestown: Was this part of a CIA mind control program; and Was Jesus Just A Man? New scientific evidence suggests that the bones of Jesus have been found.

Jim Heikkila is ... well, I don't know who he is. What I do know is that he seems to have pasted this article everywhere he could. It's just been dropped on forums all over the place. The only clue I found to his qualifications is this message on some sort of construction safety listserve where a "Jim Heikkila" comments on how to build a wood shelf. That individual's email address is [email protected] and I suppose you could write him to ask if he's the same guy and how he knows what he wrote in the article to be true. Incidentally, tdi.net is just Corecomm, an internet access company, so no help from his email address.

Sources

How well sourced are the articles? Gravy's article quoted: Bruce Solomon, a Raytheon programn manager in air traffic control systems and Steve Kuhar, senior technical advisor in FedEx's flight department. You can contact Raytheon here: Corporate Communications, Raytheon Company, 870 Winter Street, Waltham, MA 02451-1449, Waltham main switchboard: 781.522.3000.

Your article cites the following sources: None.

Really. None whatsoever.

Actually, that's not entirely true. People left comments on the bottom of the article that you yourself linked to in order to support your point.

Here's one: I am a retired Airline Captain, currently flying Business Jets. I have an Airline Transport Pilot Rating qualifying me to fly Captain on Boeing 707/720/727/747-400/757/767/777, Lockheed 382 and L-1011, and Dassault 20 and 2000 Aircraft. I have over 28,000 hours, several thousand of which were in command of 757/767's. There is no provision for a 757/767 to be flown remotely. It can't be done. Period. ... The 757/767 cannot- repeat cannot be "programmed" to fly without a Pilot.

Herb Fischer


And here's another one where the guy actually believes there's a conspiracy but still disagrees with the article: As an avionics engineer, I also would like to stress out that there are NO provisions on 757/767 aircraft to have it remote controlled. ... I am pretty sure that there are big question marks about that the Govt of the USA showed and told us and I am pretty sure quite a bit is staged, just like some other past disasters. However, technically, the story "Planes of 911 Exceeded Their Software Limits" in this case, is just BS. [email protected]

He leaves his email address so you can write to him with questions.

The essay you linked to is worthless in every way imaginable. It is written by no one, cited no sources and published in nothing. Gravy's article was written by a seasoned and educated reporter, cited actual humans who were involved in the tests and was published in a professional journal. The two are not comparable. The fact that you think that the essay you linked to is evidence of anything is a sadder commentary on your personal discernment than it is on the events of 9/11.
 
Not so fast Smith. You have already squirmed around the Olson questions by trying to change the topic to light poles, now you are off on another tack with other passengers.
If you are so knowledgeable about the passengers then why do you avoid saying what type of phone Olson used and how many calls she made?
I will address the topic of other passengers when I have finished with the Olsons. Who is trying to move the goalposts now?


the olson calls are a red herring

Red herring This fallacy is committed when someone introduces irrelevant material to the issue being discussed, so that everyone's attention is diverted away from the points made, towards a different conclusion.

it is YOU who changed the subject. Because this thread is moderated I brought up facts contesting your assertions that had been previously posted in this very thread.

Try and squirm away. But all here know I have proven you wrong. Just your not man enough to admit you are wrong.
 
Squirming again, In other words, "all they were really doing is an auto land".
Stop wriggling, I'm tired of it. Are you frightened the truth will set you on fire or what?
WAS THERE ANY BIG DEAL ABOUT FLYING AN UNMANNED LARGE PLANE BY REMOTE CONTROL IN 2001 ?



Malcolm, an experienced avionics tech is attempting to explain the matter so that even you are capable of comprehending it. Stop babbling long enough to have someone read you Apathoid's posts. You really are not getting any of this. Fun is fun, but you're overdoing it.
 
That's you all over isn't it. Skip when the going gets anywhere near the nitty gritty. Come out with words a mile high when you're obfuscating and then dodge the main question when is put up in bold right to you.
There was no big deal at all albout flying large planes by remote control in 2001 and well you know it. It's just that you thought you'd cloud the issue coming out with a sidetrack of what is and is not auto pilot etc. I told you all some time ago, that your squirming wouldn't last the course. Now you're bailing out, having dodged remote control and the Olson phone call questions.
You're all smoke and mirrors pal, all smoke and mirrors.


Malcolm,, listen closely: Boeing 767s and 757s cannot be flown by remote control. No remote-controlled planes were involved in the jihadist attacks of 9/11/01. The voice-morphing technology necessary to allow conversations does not exist today and certainly did not exist six years ago. Barbara Olson died when the plane she was on, AA Flight 77, was hijacked and flown into the Pentagon.

Your act,
Edited by Katana: 
Edited out personal insult prior to approval.
, was highly amusing for quite some time, but we've done over a HUNDRED pages, Malcolm. Enough, already.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
One thing at a time shiner. You said column 17, so what happened to the port side engine. You know the one I mean, the underslung one that had to dig into the earth?

Learn to read malkie, i said 14

You tell me where the engine is, I have seen photos of engine parts but how they entered the building or if they did, I do not know

I suggest you read the rest of the report you posted the link to again (but obviously did not read properly) and try to work it out yourself

now on with the remote planes fantasy please
 
I hope Taffer and the 'lurkers' on here are reading this post. They will remember me saying, that once I say the plane hit at 10 or 11, someone will say 17 and when I say 17, someone will say 10 or 11.

No malkie, we will look at the Building Performance report and see what it says, if you disagree with it then we will correct you, in the diagrams the fuselage initial entry is at 14

You have already accused me of saying 17 when in fact i said 14, so who is the liar malkie?
 
You're off again, you're unbelievable. I have produced a letter from Boeing. The person who signed that letter acknowledges that he works for Boeing and altough he can't remember the specific letter, he agrees that it's his and he stands by the content.
As he represents Boeing, then Boeing says their seat back phones were deactivated, if not also torn out on 9/11.
Respond to that. Spare me the baloney about some other backslappers thread, respond to the points in this post.

No you have not shown this malcolm

you showed an letter from someone at American Airlines, not Boeing

even if the phones were de-activated they had not been removed

What I'm saying is that the Claircom system was not deactivated until 2002 by AA M&E. The "order" for M&E to deactivate the system did not hit the shop floor until March 2002 in the form of ECO F0871XX. The decision was made in late 2001 by the higher ups at HQ, after 9-11.

form of ECO F0871 which is dated March 2002. ECO F0878AX/XX orders the removal of the major components of the system. F0871XX is the "order" to turn off the system and collar the associated circuit breakers.

Even DRG and the PFT say that the phones were still physically fitted to the seats at this time, you may want to check with them

Try contacting John Hotard at AA to see what he says?
 
No you have not shown this malcolm

you showed an letter from someone at American Airlines, not Boeing

even if the phones were de-activated they had not been removed





Even DRG and the PFT say that the phones were still physically fitted to the seats at this time, you may want to check with them

Try contacting John Hotard at AA to see what he says?
Thank you for correcting my grammar.
AA say that their Boeing 757's had DEACTIVATED seat back phones.
They also say that any calls made by passengers on 9/11 from the plane that supposedly hit the Pentagon had to have been made by cell phones.
Hat this not been the case, then the neocons would most certainly have gotten AA to publish a retraction.
You ask me to tell you what happened to the port engine. It went up Rumsfeld's sleeve together with the starboard engine, the wings, the tail, all the seats, luggage, fuel and of course, all those passengers who either worked for Raytheon or Boeing. That's what you call a sleeve. Let's see David Copperfield do that.
 
My word, Malcolm. So, Gravy posted several articles and you posted an article that disagrees with him.

Gravy's article was written by Elizabeth Bretz, Senior Associate Editor of IEEE Spectrum. IEEE Spectrum magazine is the flagship publication of the IEEE, the world's largest professional technology association. IEEE Spectrum is read by over 385,000 technology professionals and senior executives worldwide in the high technology sectors of industry, government, and academia. IEEE stands for the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers.

Elizabeth Bretz was a Senior Associate Editor when she wrote the article but she's been promoted to Managing Editor since then. She's been at Spectrum since at least 2001. Before that, she was senior editor of Power, Electric Power International, Electric World, and Information Technologies for Utilities/IT. She earned a B.S. degree in mechanical engineering from Tulane University.

Your article was written by Jim Heikkila and published at Viewzone.Com. Viewzone has the following articles linked from its homepage right now: Did JESUS visit Tibet?: Nicholas Notovitch and the "Jesus Thangka" - new images found!; Chemtrails: What's going on?; The BioMusic Conspiracy: Secrets of the Rainbow Serpent Flute Goddess; The Truth About Jonestown: Was this part of a CIA mind control program; and Was Jesus Just A Man? New scientific evidence suggests that the bones of Jesus have been found.

Jim Heikkila is ... well, I don't know who he is. What I do know is that he seems to have pasted this article everywhere he could. It's just been dropped on forums all over the place. The only clue I found to his qualifications is this message on some sort of construction safety listserve where a "Jim Heikkila" comments on how to build a wood shelf. That individual's email address is [email protected] and I suppose you could write him to ask if he's the same guy and how he knows what he wrote in the article to be true. Incidentally, tdi.net is just Corecomm, an internet access company, so no help from his email address.

Sources

How well sourced are the articles? Gravy's article quoted: Bruce Solomon, a Raytheon programn manager in air traffic control systems and Steve Kuhar, senior technical advisor in FedEx's flight department. You can contact Raytheon here: Corporate Communications, Raytheon Company, 870 Winter Street, Waltham, MA 02451-1449, Waltham main switchboard: 781.522.3000.

Your article cites the following sources: None.

Really. None whatsoever.

Actually, that's not entirely true. People left comments on the bottom of the article that you yourself linked to in order to support your point.

Here's one: I am a retired Airline Captain, currently flying Business Jets. I have an Airline Transport Pilot Rating qualifying me to fly Captain on Boeing 707/720/727/747-400/757/767/777, Lockheed 382 and L-1011, and Dassault 20 and 2000 Aircraft. I have over 28,000 hours, several thousand of which were in command of 757/767's. There is no provision for a 757/767 to be flown remotely. It can't be done. Period. ... The 757/767 cannot- repeat cannot be "programmed" to fly without a Pilot.

Herb Fischer


And here's another one where the guy actually believes there's a conspiracy but still disagrees with the article: As an avionics engineer, I also would like to stress out that there are NO provisions on 757/767 aircraft to have it remote controlled. ... I am pretty sure that there are big question marks about that the Govt of the USA showed and told us and I am pretty sure quite a bit is staged, just like some other past disasters. However, technically, the story "Planes of 911 Exceeded Their Software Limits" in this case, is just BS. [email protected]

He leaves his email address so you can write to him with questions.

The essay you linked to is worthless in every way imaginable. It is written by no one, cited no sources and published in nothing. Gravy's article was written by a seasoned and educated reporter, cited actual humans who were involved in the tests and was published in a professional journal. The two are not comparable. The fact that you think that the essay you linked to is evidence of anything is a sadder commentary on your personal discernment than it is on the events of 9/11.
Do you never get fed up of getting beat up?
We'll do this by the numbers. Was there any problem with flying a large passenger plane by remote control in 2001?
 
I quote you,
"I have no idea".
If you have no idea, then what are you doing pontificating on the subject?
Excuse me while I bang my head on the wall...

My contribution to this "discussion" was to point out the semantic difference between tone control and pitch correction. Not "pontificate" on the various capabilities of sound equipment. See the difference there?
 
Do you never get fed up of getting beat up?
We'll do this by the numbers. Was there any problem with flying a large passenger plane by remote control in 2001?

Yes, there was, this post that you made is false, it is all rubbish and lies

As well as fully autonomous flight capability, the 767 and 757 are the ONLY COMMUTER PLANES MADE BY BOEING THAT CAN BE FLOWN VIA REMOTE CONTROL. It is a feature that is standard to all of them, all 757's and 767's can do it. The purpose for this is if there is a problem with the pilots, Norad can fly the planes to safe destinations via remote. Only in this flight mode can those craft exceed their software limits and perform to their actual physical limits because a pre existing emergency situation is assumed if this mode of flight is used."

Are you going to retract the statement you made about me that I claimed it was column 17? Just say sorry, it wont hurt
 
Thank you for correcting my grammar.

AA say that their Boeing 757's had DEACTIVATED seat back phones.

They also say that any calls made by passengers on 9/11 from the plane that supposedly hit the Pentagon had to have been made by cell phones.
Hat this not been the case, then the neocons would most certainly have gotten AA to publish a retraction.
.

It was not grammar it was a false claim

One employee sent a letter saying they had been deactivated but not removed

You said they had been removed, they had not, another false claim

You do know that even if they did get the deactivation started and in place by sept 2001, that they would not have done all the planes at the same time, this has been shown in the other thread that I quoted for you, you happily ignore this

John Hotard is from AA he will put you right on whtether the phones were deactivated

I bet you do not ask him
 
In that case, I'll put you back on the payroll.
I'm sure you can answer the Olson questions, in particular what type of phone she made the calls on. Seeing as it's weekend, here's a vid I would, in all seriousness, appreciate your opinion of,
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-1656880303867390173


Well, several other people have answered the Olson question; however, as stated, she made at least two calls that connected, and possibly one or two additional calls that didn't connect, from air phones on American 77.

As for the film you linked, I watched the first ten minutes or so, which should be enough to dispose of the entire argument presented. The short version: despite the contentions of various tax protesters, the Sixteenth Amendment to the US Constitution was properly ratified, and the law creating the Federal Reserve is not unconstitutional.

On the Sixteenth Amendment, the issue of its ratification was settled by court decision, in United States v. Thomas, in 1986:

Benson and Beckman did not discover anything; they rediscovered something that Secretary Knox considered in 1913. Thirty-eight states ratified the sixteenth amendment, and thirty-seven sent formal instruments of ratification to the Secretary of State. (Minnesota notified the Secretary orally, and additional states ratified later; we consider only those Secretary Knox considered.) Only four instruments repeat the language of the sixteenth amendment exactly as Congress approved it. The others contain errors of diction, capitalization, punctuation, and spelling. The text Congress transmitted to the states was: "The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration." Many of the instruments neglected to capitalize "States," and some capitalized other words instead. The instrument from Illinois had "remuneration" in place of "enumeration"; the instrument from Missouri substituted "levy" for "lay"; the instrument from Washington had "income" not "incomes"; others made similar blunders.

Thomas insists that because the states did not approve exactly the same test, the amendment did not go into effect. Secretary Knox considered this argument. The Solicitor of the Department of State drew up a list of the errors in the instruments and--taking into account both the triviality of the deviations and the treatment of earlier amendments that had experienced more substantial problems--advised the Secretary that he was authorized to declare the amendment adopted. The Secretary did so.

Although Thomas urges us to take the view of several state courts that only agreement on the literal text may make a legal document effective, the Supreme Court follows the "enrolled bill rule." If a legislative document is authenticated in regular form by the appropriate officials, the court treats that document as properly adopted. Field v. Clark, 143 U.S. 649, 36 L. Ed. 294, 12 S. Ct. 495 (1892). The principle is equally applicable to constitutional amendments. See Leser v. Garnett, 258 U.S. 130, 66 L. Ed. 505, 42 S. Ct. 217 (1922), which treats as conclusive the declaration of the Secretary of State that the nineteenth amendment had been adopted. In United States v. Foster, 789 F.2d. 457 (7th Cir. 1986), slip op. 10-12 & n.6, we relied on Leser, as well as the inconsequential nature of the objections in the face of the 73-year acceptance of the effectiveness of the sixteenth amendment, to reject a claim similar to Thomas's. See also Coleman v. Miller, 307 U.S. 433, 83 L. Ed. 1385, 59 S. Ct. 972 (1939) (questions about ratification of amendments may be nonjusticiable). Secretary Knox declared that enough states had ratified the sixteenth amendment. The Secretary's decision is not transparently defective. We need not decide when, if ever, such a decision may be reviewed in order to know that Secretary Knox's decision is now beyond review.[emphasis added]


The US Supreme Court declined to review this decision, thus allowing it to stand without comment.

As for the Federal Reserve, in 1819 the Supreme Court ruled unanimously that the Congress has the power to create a national bank, in McCullough v. State of Maryland:

After the most deliberate consideration, it is the unanimous and decided opinion of this court, that the act to incorporate the Bank of the United States is a law made in pursuance of the constitution, and is a part of the supreme law of the land.


In short, in the United States the power to interpret laws and the US Constitution is "vested in one Supreme Court, and in such inferior courts as the Congress may from time to time ordain and establish" (Article III, US Constitution). It is most assuredly not vested in a few disgruntled citizens who happen to disagree.

Did you have any questions about the rest of the film?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom