Rolfe
Adult human female
I'm not making this up. I can't think at that level of stupid. Read all about it here. Somerled really has (had?) a problem with gravity, air pressure, and vacuum.
Malcolm seems to have sort of grasped the glimmer of an idea that atmospheric pressure depends on gravity acting on the air molecules. However, my best take on how he has developed that thought is that he therefore thinks that this is all "gravity" is - the weight of air molecules holding us all down. (Er, so what's holding down the air molecules again, Malcolm?)
The concept that gravity has nothing to do with air pressure, nevertheless air pressure has everything to do with gravity, seems to be a bit much for him.
He continued to protest that where there was no air (i.e. in a vacuum), there was also no gravity. Repeated links to descriptions of the "guinea and feather" experiment didn't cause even a penny to drop, never mind a guinea.
He then chose to use as his killer example that it was obvious there was no gravity in the middle of an (evacuated) TV tube, because how else could the electrons make it all the way across to the screen.

Although he finally bowed to the overwhelming weight of informed opinion and accepted that i/v infusion sets are indeed normally held up, as depicted in all these pictures, he flatly refused to agree that the polythene bags of saline really would empty as advertised without a BIG hole in the top to let gravity in, or that gravity was unaffected by the presence or absence of a vacuum.
He's currently polling just over 50% of the total votes in the July Stundies for that one, despite being only one of 14 entrants.
Malcolm, if you take the air away, does gravity still act? How do either the guinea or the feather fall inside the evacuated tubes? How did the lunar astronauts stay feet-down on the (airless) moon? How come gravity is different near a mountain like Schiehallion, although there is no change in the atmospheric pressure?
Rolfe.
Last edited:
