Yawn. I think Malcolm wrote the book on "bunker mentality".
Has he figured out yet whether he's trying to show that the "original" karaoke machines had the capacity to alter the pitch or the singer's voice, or whether karaoke machines were indeed invented in 1971, or whether the existence of any system at all which can modify a voice in any way at all (even if it was only invented yesterday) is proof that an ordinary person's voice could be simulated, real time, well enough to convince his mother, in 2001?
Malcolm, sweetie, a wee bit of friendly advice.
Don't get so distracted by trying to prove that every casual word you've typed is incontrovertibly true, that you lose all sense of whether the point you're defending is even remotely related to your actual thesis.
The properties of 1970s karaoke machines are irrelevant. As is whether they were or were not first invented in 1971. The amateurish capabilities of cheap kiddies' toys available in 2007 are also irrelevant. As is the fact that someone messed up a bad pop song even further by mangling the singer's voice.
Either you have evidence that
realistic faking of someone's voice, without any opportunity to take multiple samples from that voice to set up the system, and in real-time conversation, well enough to convince a mother, was possible in 2001, or you don't.
If you have such evidence, produce it. If you don't, quit trying to lead the argument down irrelevant back alleys. We
will notice.
I'm getting awfully tired waiting for this alleged great revelation to appear. But while I'm waiting, I'd still like to hear why it could ever be a good idea for a conspirator, trying for realism and believability, to include in the scenario fakes of demonstrably impossible telephone conversations.
Digression now. I was watching TV this evening (good programme called
Before Scotland), and the mountain Schiehallion was mentioned (the real "magic mountain", eat your heart out Schildhorn). Anyway, that reminded me of the famous
Schiehallion experiment of 1774, in which the then Astronomer Royal measured a good approximation to the mass of the earth.
Basically, as Schiehallion is fairly regular and symmetrical in shape, it is possible to make a good estimate of its mass. Then, by measuring the exact angle a plumb line was deflected from true vertical by the mass of the mountain, the ratio of its mass to the mass of the Earth could be calculated. It really was the
neatest experiment.
Now, Malcolm, you didn't seem to understand how the equally famous "guinea and feather" experiment showed that there is gravity in a vacuum. Is it possible that you might be able to think about the Schiehallion experiment and realise how gravity works, and that it has nothing to do with "air pressure"?
[Oops, just noticed that this experiment also proved that the Earth wasn't hollow. That's going to be a bit of a blow to some people!]
Rolfe.