[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Walk into your local cop shop with a vague idea that because you haven't seen your next door neighbours wife for a few days and the last time you did see her, she was having a row with her husband. Now you think he's done the dirty deed and thrown her in some river. Then, without further and better details, the police are not obliged to investigate.

If you stated that you almost always saw her every few days and now, after a loud row between her and her husband, you have not seen any sign of her they indeed will follow up. Not to do so would be egregious.

If you walk in and say that she is missing and her husband was seen by you argueing with short , large eyed, grey beings they may not act upon that information.


As for gravity and air pressure, let it be perfectly clear Malcolm. Air pressure is a function of gravity keeping the atmosphere of this planet, on this planet. No gravity, no atmosphere and therefore no air pressure.

However that does not work in reverse. Gravity is in no way shape or form affected by the presence of an atmosphere. Remove the atmosphere from this planet and the force due to gravity will remain the same.
(other than the fact that the atmosphere itself has some mass and in that way contributes ever so slightly to the overall gravitational attraction experienced by objects on the hard surface of the planet. This effect is miniscule.
 
Let's see who is being "bloody ridiculous". Give us the benefit of your reasoning skills on this piece. Let's see just how jaundiced you are.
ps,
Try to read it all before firing off. I will be marking you on it.
http://pilotsfor911truth.org/amrarticle.html


A day late and a dollar short again, Malcolm?

What Gravy is referring to is the thread entitled "On Again Off Again Airfones", which was started on 26th June and has run (so far) for 431 posts, the current last post being made just under 2 days ago. Your obsessive concentration on this one thread is blinding you to the wider discussion on the forum. Here was a thread on something you now reveal as a major plank of your own thesis, running concurrently with this one, and you didn't participate at all. Well, not too late!

Gravy is right, and he's made it easy for you. The earlier part of the thread included a lot of discussion on what turned out to be red herrings (such as a typo that was probably just a printer glitch, and the oddity of two revision dates being the same date several years apart and both being Sundays, simply being explained by an automated revision programme). The real meat starts well into the thread, indeed at post 378.

Why should we repeat everything for you, when you can't be bothered to participate in other relevant threads? I keep telling you you should get out more.

Rolfe.
 
Is malcolm really trying to say that intuitive tone control means the same as automatic tone control?
this state off the art machine, that was not available in 2001, can make me sound enough like Mark to fool his mum?

Malcolm, maybe it can make you sound like Willie Nelson

Please god, no more
Nope. It's worse. He's trying to claim that "intuitive tone control" means "automatic pitch shifting to fix vocals by singers who couldn't hit a tone with a shotgun."

Somerled is convinced that fake phone calls were made using voice morphing technology. As proof of this, he has offered the following:
1. The "original karaoke machines" had this pitch shift that automatically shifted the singer's voice to the proper key. Busted, as the original machines from 1971 had tapes and no pitch changin on either playback or vocals. Later machines do have pitch change for the playback, but that's to match the music to singers who know their range.
2. Relatively recent toy that does pitch shifting of voices. All processing done in the (over sized) microphone housing. Busted, 'cause it sounds like $%#@#$%, which pitch shifting tends to do.
3. A pitch shifted video on YouTube of an Avril Lavigne song. Sounds like $#%^$%, 'cause pitch shifting tends to do that. Busted, both technically and 'cause the song sucks.
4. This latest piece of idiocy involving a microphone pre-amp with compressor and selection of common DSP effects, like echo and chorus. Busted, 'cause it don't even do pitch shifting.

Pitch shifting has inherent limits. Those limitations come from the limits of the FFT used to do the shifting.

FFTs are done in blocks. The time length of those blocks depends on the sampling rate and the number of samples you use in the FFT. As an example, CD audio is sampled at 44100 samples per second per channel. The FFT might be done on 1024 samples, giving a time length of 23 milliseconds.

An FFT done in those conditions gives you a pitch shift accuracy of 43 Hertz. That is, the smallest pitch change you can make (without resorting to god awful tricks that fark things up even more) is 43 Hertz. That's not real good when you consider that the difference between an A 440Hz and the B above that (466Hz) is 26 Hertz.

You can improve the frequency resolution by using a longer FFT. 2048 points in the FFT gets you down to 22 Hz resolution, and 4096 would get you down to around 11 Hz resolution.

BUT, you can't just do that. The longer FFT also means a longer time length. At 4096 samples, that'd be 93 milliseconds. That's 1 tenth of a second to you pedestrians, and that's longer than most phonemes. So, you've going to end up squishing together at least two phonemes into one.

More likely, since the FFT won't be aligned to the edge of your spoken (or sung) phonemes, you'll end up with pieces of a couple of phonemes mashed together with a transition where it doesn't belong.

Translation: It'll sound like **** and be hard to understand.

The shorter the FFT the less it farks up the intelligibility, but the less precise you can be in your shifting.


This leaves out entirely all of the fun involved in doing an inverse FFT on an FFT that has been manipulated. Suffice to say that there's problems there that make the situation even worse than I've described.




In case anybody is wondering:
I've written FFTs, and discrete JTF analysis code. I've written filtering software for DSPs, and done FFT based filtering using hand written assembler code. No wimpy DSP C code for me - the DSPs I was using didn't have enough ooomph to handle the overhead and still get the job done.
 
Last edited:
How can you electronically alter somebody's voice to match 'exactly' another persons voice so his own mother wouldn't know the difference?

And, how come people believe silly things?
 
Take gravity away and then talk to me about air pressure.
Your words, 'gravity has nothing to do with air pressure'.
WRONG.


Malcolm, hold on a minute. We all know that ambient air pressure is caused by the weight of the air column over any given area of the Earth's surface.

But are you claiming that gravity is affected by air pressure? Yes or no.

Or, more specifically, where there is no air pressure there is no gravity? Yes or no.
 
Walk into your local cop shop with a vague idea that because you haven't seen your next door neighbours wife for a few days and the last time you did see her, she was having a row with her husband. Now you think he's done the dirty deed and thrown her in some river. Then, without further and better details, the police are not obliged to investigate.
However, if you could present enough evidence for probable cause, then it would be a different matter. Is that a bit better?


You are dead wrong. You are wrong in every detail (except one which I'll get to). What you just said is not true.

If you go to the police with what you just wrote, they will investigate. They investigate everything. That's what they do. And I linked to an article that explained that police take every call they get seriously. They assume the person is telling the truth.

You can test this by doing exactly what you just said. Go into the police station and say you haven't seen your next door neighbours wife for a few days and the last time you did see her, she was having a row with her husband. Now you think he's done the dirty deed and thrown her in some river. See what they do.

Once again, you will not do this. You will not do it because you know that you are lying. You know the police will react and investigate and then they will charge you with filing a false report. You know this just the way you know Reverand Grogan's congregation will not be happy to hear that there is no evidence his flight even took off.

You are once again wrong when you say, "if you could present enough evidence for probable cause, then it would be a different matter." As I told you before, "probable cause" has nothing to do with the level of proof required to cause police to investigate a crime. They investigate all reports of crime no matter how ridiculously unlikely. And as I told you before, lay citizens are not expected to amass "probable cause" because they are not expected to know what evidence is or is not necessary, sufficient or even admissible. Only prosecutors and police are expected to be able to manipulate the concept of "probable cause." They are trained in so doing.

So you are still wrong, wrong, wrong. Police get involved at a level of suspicion far, far less than probable cause. It's so much less that it doesn't even have a name. And complainants do not have to advocate for their case by marshalling evidence - that's the job of the police and prosecutors when they bring charges or petition the court for a warrant.

Now, I did say that you got one thing sort of right. It is this statement: "the police are not obliged to investigate." You meant that police are not obliged to investigate a complaint without evidence but somehow if you give them "probable cause," they are. In that way, you are wrong. In reality, police are not obliged to investigate anything. They have discretion over what they will and will not investigate, which laws they will and will not enforce and how much protection they will and will not give the public. Police discretion exists to allow police to be flexible and to do their jobs without having to worry about lawsuits every time someone gets punched and a cop wasn't nearby.

However, balancing this discretion is the fact that the police are public employees ultimately led by elected officials. If the police don't protect and serve well enough, the populace gets angry and the politicians lose their jobs.

So, for all practical purposes, you are absolutely wrong. In one small, qualified way, you sort of said something that barely verged on almost being right. Good for you and your poor reasoning and decoding skills.
 
How can you electronically alter somebody's voice to match 'exactly' another persons voice so his own mother wouldn't know the difference?

And, how come people believe silly things?
If I had to try it, I'd have the target read several thousand words, then use one of the available speech synthesis toolkits to build a speech synthesizer libray from that. Then, I'd just feed it text by typing it. You'd be more certain to get the correct words. If you just HAD to make it work on-line as you speak, I'd want a voice recognition program that I'd trained very heavily to my voice. Then, I'd feed the recognized text to the synthesizer.

It'd sound sort of flat (no excitement, etc) but it be no worse quality wise than a GSM cell phone.


Then all I'd need is to be able match the target's word choice and know everything about him just in case the person on the other end of the conversation asked me some off the wall question.

We're not talking about automatic anything here, though. Building the synthesizer dictionary is a huge pile of work for a skilled person. That's more people to bump off after the event so they don't spill the beans.

You'll need a blazingly fast machine to do the voice recognition in real time, and another one to do the synthesis in real time - and you'll still end up with skips and gaps and delayed responses to questions. The recognizer can't tell what you've said until it hits a pause between words, and the synthesizer won't be able to do anything until it gets the next word. Continuous speech would be a problem.

People believe that there's some sort of magic machine that can do all of that because it is necessary for their make believe conspiracy to function. Somerled is convinced there were no passengers in the planes because the planes were remote controlled "military bad boys" specially beefed up to do a number on the towers so they'd fall. No passengers, no calls. Since there are recordings of the calls (with voices identified as belonging to the passengers that Somerled says don't exist,) the calls must be fake. So that the fakes match the real people (who didn't really exist, right Somerled?) they had to make fake recordings that sounded real - enter Morph-O-Mat 2000, stage right.

Ignoring, of course, that Somerled also claims such calls were impossible to begin with. He says there were no airphones on the planes and that cell phones wouldn't work in an airplane.


Did I leave out anything important? Well, the fake photos of first responders that are obviously fake because nobody holds an I/V up like that adn there's no holes in the I/V bag to let in gravity. And probably lots of other stuff so stupid it would burn out my brain to think of.
 
Just as soon as you translate your signature.

Just once, Malcom, why don't you just act like a grown up ?

I'd like to repeat what Rolfe said:

Your big problem is that you've got this weird idea that it was impossible to make such calls, therefore they must have been faked. However, if it were indeed true that it was impossible to make such calls, then the very last thing anyone conspiring to set up something like this would do, is to fake such calls.

Which came first, karaoke or disco?

 
That's where you're wrong. I don't have to show anything like what you claim.
Stick around, as I'm sure you will and see how very quickly your thinking turns into the 'bunker' mentality.

So... are you saying you don't have to prove anything that you say ?

How juvenile.

You are very exacting. You give me no space for brevity. I'll take that into consideration in future. I think I've said something like this to you before.
I'll take responsibility for being too brief.
What I should have said was, words to the following effect.
Walk into your local cop shop with a vague idea that because you haven't seen your next door neighbours wife for a few days and the last time you did see her, she was having a row with her husband. Now you think he's done the dirty deed and thrown her in some river. Then, without further and better details, the police are not obliged to investigate.

"Uh oh, he called me on that. Gotta think of a reason why my example was right, after all. Oh, I'll just add more detail."

You're failed, Malcolm. Your example was flawed, and you were wrong, and SHOWN to be wrong, yet again. And once more, instead of admitting it, you CHANGE de rules of the game in order to stay "right" in your mind.

Pathetic.
 
It'd sound sort of flat (no excitement, etc) but it be no worse quality wise than a GSM cell phone.

Thats the closest thing to making sense of approximately what could concievably do this. It leaves two flaws for the conspiracy theorists.

1) You cannot add stress strain or excitement to the voice. It will be in the same tone as the prerecorded version.

2) The subject has to be aware and active part of the conspiracy, and help with the making of the database. This is no "Hi my name is Werner Braun, my voice is my passport"* deal, thousands of words are required. Which beggers the question if they were part of the Impossibly Large Conspiracy
(TM) why didn't they just make the calls themselves.


*Bonus points for someone to name the Robert Redford movie this was from.
 
You show me one site I've been "run out of" and I'll give up.
This tactic of talking to an imaginary audience, of sounding off for the sake of one post, carries no weight with 'lurkers' on here. They've seen your ilk come and go.
How do I know you just haven't altered your handle after already having been banjaxed on this thread?


h t t p ://64.233.169.104/search?q=cache:th4IDRS5L6wJ:z9.invisionfree.com/Pilots_For_Truth/index.php%3Fshowtopic%3D8190%26view%3Dold

Obsess much? Trying to rally up people to come over here just to support your alien pods crackpot theory?

Altered my handle? Like when I started reading this thread and you were Malcolm Kirman and now you're Somerled? Hiding your real name perhaps? Hiding what people can find out about you after you tarnished your real name with lunacy for the entire web to see. For your sake, I hope your future employers google your name
Edited by chillzero: 
Edited for civility

.

I've never been on this board before. But I can't prove that any more than you can prove that I've been banned before. Of course for you to come right out and accuse that shows just how paranoid you are.

I don't care if my one post carries weight with the "lurkers". If you think your crazy "Nothing can penetrate without a tip, no matter the mass and velocity" alien pods + pedo remote control pilots is convincing lurkers to believe your crackpot world view...
Edited by chillzero: 
Edited for civility

.

Personally I'm very interested in the psychological and psychiatric aspect of those who believe in conspiracy theories. A majority of the people who start the CTs are paranoid schizophrenics who believe that something is after them or after everyone and they believe they must warn the world! See those guys wandering the streets mumbling to themselves holding a sign about how Mossad kidnapped his family from his Brooklyn home and killed them for kicks? That's not too far off from someone believing "The government, using pedos and remote controlled planes and escape hatches and pods and thousands of police, first responders, CIA, etc etc etc killed 3000 people and incurred a trillion dollars in economic losses to save $5 billion." They're not far off from the guy wandering the street, off his meds.

The Conspiracy Fanatics are a different bird. They are identical to cultists. For whatever personal reasons, they have a need for acceptance. They have a need to feel smarter or more knowledgeable than the rest of the population. Being a part of a group that claims it's "Smarter" than everyone else because they "See through the lies" fits that bill. Whether you're a scientologist, branch davidian, one of those guys in the orange jumpsuit with the Baghwan Rajneesh, or a truther... You're in a group that feeds into that inner need to be better than everyone else, while in many aspects of your personal life are most likely lacking.

Edited by chillzero: 
Edited for civility
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Pilots were on board - yes. Did they take their hands off the controls - yes.
That adds up to remote control.



Are you just not getting what autopilot is? I have explained it many times in this very thread and it just seems to go right over your head. Maybe I'm using the wrong approach here. So instead of explaining it in words, I'll do it in pictures and video - notice where the pilots hands are(or better, aren't):

http://www.airliners.net/open.file/0753967/L/
http://www.airliners.net/open.file/1147833/L/
http://www.airliners.net/open.file/1215769/L/
http://www.airliners.net/open.file/0885702/L/
http://www.airliners.net/open.file/1143478/L/
http://www.airliners.net/open.file/0488157/L/
http://www.airliners.net/open.file/1038308/L/
http://www.airliners.net/open.file/1005960/L/
http://www.airliners.net/open.file/0685357/L/
http://www.airliners.net/open.file/0283857/L/



Autolands:


The autopilot disconnect comes at :33, the only thing the pilot does here deploy and stow the thrust reversers, since the 747-400 has rollout guidance, the A/P disconnect happens well down the runway after landing.




Airbus. The autopilot disconnect comes at the 1:39 mark, just after main gear touchdown.




MD-11. A/P disconnect happens at :56, well into rollout. Like the 747-400, the MD-11 has rollout guidance which automatically steers the airplane to the centerline.




737NG. A/P disengaged at 2:53 in the first landing and :11 in the second. Since the NG doesn't have rudder servos for rollout guidance, the A/P disconnects just after main gear touchdown.



Since the pilots are not flying these airplanes in the examples above - how are they being flown Malcolm?
 
People believe that there's some sort of magic machine that can do all of that because it is necessary for their make believe conspiracy to function.

Well, and because they saw it being done by some bad guy in a movie.

Somerled is convinced there were no passengers in the planes because the planes were remote controlled "military bad boys" specially beefed up to do a number on the towers so they'd fall. No passengers, no calls. Since there are recordings of the calls (with voices identified as belonging to the passengers that Somerled says don't exist,) the calls must be fake. So that the fakes match the real people (who didn't really exist, right Somerled?) they had to make fake recordings that sounded real - enter Morph-O-Mat 2000, stage right.

Ignoring, of course, that Somerled also claims such calls were impossible to begin with. He says there were no airphones on the planes and that cell phones wouldn't work in an airplane.


Did I leave out anything important?

That Offut was closed to military traffic but open to only private jets?

Well, the fake photos of first responders that are obviously fake because nobody holds an I/V up like that and there's no holes in the I/V bag to let in gravity. And probably lots of other stuff so stupid it would burn out my brain to think of.

"let in gravity " oh, stop I have a cold and laughing that hard just makes me cough more.:D

Perhaps someone should introduce Malcolm to the writings on one Issac Newton concerning gravity and once he has grasped that he could move on to those of Albert Einstein. Actually all he need do is go to the nearest university bookstore and obtain a copy of the text book for first year physics.
 
Well, and because they saw it being done by some bad guy in a movie.



That Offut was closed to military traffic but open to only private jets?



"let in gravity " oh, stop I have a cold and laughing that hard just makes me cough more.:D
Perhaps someone should introduce Malcolm to the writings on one Issac Newton concerning gravity and once he has grasped that he could move on to those of Albert Einstein. Actually all he need do is go to the nearest university bookstore and obtain a copy of the text book for first year physics.
I'm not making this up. I can't think at that level of stupid. Read all about it here. Somerled really has (had?) a problem with gravity, air pressure, and vacuum.
 
*Bonus points for someone to name the Robert Redford movie this was from.


Sneakers (1982). The line was said by character actor Stephen Tobolowsky who, despite being on every TV show ever made, is probably best known as insurance salesman Ned Ryerson from Groundhog Day.
 
Thats the closest thing to making sense of approximately what could concievably do this. It leaves two flaws for the conspiracy theorists.

1) You cannot add stress strain or excitement to the voice. It will be in the same tone as the prerecorded version.

2) The subject has to be aware and active part of the conspiracy, and help with the making of the database. This is no "Hi my name is Werner Braun, my voice is my passport"* deal, thousands of words are required. Which beggers the question if they were part of the Impossibly Large Conspiracy
(TM) why didn't they just make the calls themselves.


*Bonus points for someone to name the Robert Redford movie this was from.

Well, given BlackOps(tm), you could just tap the target's phone and record a couple of months worth of calls. The quality would suffer, though, since the words would be spoken in varying circumstances. And the guy building the library would be unhappy becuase he'd have to hunt and fish for words.


I'm thinking "Sneakers" on the Robert Redford movie, but I haven't seen it in several years.
 
Leave it out. Pilots were on board - yes. Did they take their hands off the controls - yes.
That adds up to remote control.

is cruise control in your car remote control?

remote -

Located far away; distant in space.
Hidden away; secluded: a remote hamlet.
Distant in time: the remote past.
Faint; slight: a remote possibility; had not the remotest interest.
Far removed in connection or relevance: a cause remote from everyday concerns.
Distantly related by blood or marriage: a remote cousin.
Distant in manner; aloof.
Operating or controlled from a distance: remote sensors.
Computer Science. Located at a distance from another computer that is accessible by cables or other communications links: a remote terminal.

autopilot is onboard control malcolm, done by systems onboard not remotely
 
<snip>

*Bonus points for someone to name the Robert Redford movie this was from.


Sneakers. Very funny, if not overly realistic in some of the computer/communications technology portrayed (for the time, at least).

Funniest line in the movie, IMO (Ben Kingsley referring to Robert Redford's character):

Cosmo: I cannot kill my friend.
[to his henchmen]
Cosmo: Kill my friend.


ETA: Loss Leader beat me to it. :(
 
Last edited:
Sneakers (1982). The line was said by character actor Stephen Tobolowsky who, despite being on every TV show ever made, is probably best known as insurance salesman Ned Ryerson from Groundhog Day.

Ding! Sorry Mort Loss Leader was faster of the buzzer, and goes into the lightening round with 3 more points.

In Sneakers Dan Aykroyd played Darryl 'Mother' Roskow, a conspiracy theorist and electronics expert, which given the level of expertise usually shown by actual conspiracy theorists makes this the most implausible character in modern cinema until they cast J-Lo as a criminal psychologist.

Anywho Mort you're right they could do it that way we'll call it random word bingo into phones. But some of the passengers on the flight didn't book their tickets months in advance. Lets put our NWO black Ops thinking caps on and figure this pickle of a puzzle out for Malcolm.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom