[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
[qimg]http://members.shaw.ca/freedomsix/pics/pentagon_debris_logo.jpg[/qimg]

i was staying out but you have posted the site with the letter "n" photoshopped picture again

i could not let that lie, that is a travesty of an attempt at disproving something, wrong colour and rivets, its not even put together so it looks remotely like an "n"

please tell me you have more than this gravity boy?

then again look at that whole page you linked, i think you do not, its a joke

What are you trying to say?
 
. . . I'm sure you will agree that any part of either plane, from wingtip to wingtip would most certainly have broken a window. I know it sounds a ridiculous thing to say. It's just plain silly to say otherwise. oOf course, any part would have broken a window. I hope you will agree. . . .


No, Malcolm; you're simply making ignorant assumptions again based on the way you think things ought to work. The fact that every window you've ever seen struck by a heavy object has broken does not mean that windows that wouldn't necessarily break in such circumstances can't be manufactured.

From the Pentagon Building Performance Report, created by the American Society of Civil Engineers:

As the Pentagon approached its 50th (sic) anniversary in service, an extensive renovation was planned. . . . The actual construction began in 1999, and by September 11, 2001, one-fifth of the renovation was essentially complete. . . . the exterior walls and windows were upgraded to provide a measure of resistance to extreme lateral pressures. . . . (p. 3)

The BPS team also noted the performance of windows and exterior wall reinforcements that had been installed to enhance blast resistance in Wedge 1 prior to the attack. (p. 24)

The structural upgrades of the exterior wall performed reasonably well, considering that they were not specifically designed for aircraft impact.The only window frames removed by the impact were those struck directly by the wings or the fuselage. On the second floor, immediately adjacent to where the fuselage entered the building, upgraded windows remained in their frames even though the surrounding masonry facade was completely removed. Upgraded glass was generally not broken immediately after the impact or after the ensuing fire had been extinguished. By contrast, most of the original windows in a vast area of Wedge 2 were broken after the fire was extinguished. It is probable that some of these windows were broken by the fire or by firefighting efforts rather than by the effects of the impact. (p. 44) [emphasis added]
 
Your words,
"The plane is what's scattered all over the lawn and throughout the interior of the impact area".
Would you like to point out where on the lawn are the wings, the tailplane, the shoulders, the engines, the seats, the luggage and the dead passengers.
Bob Pugh's video is here and is filmed less than five minutes after the moment of impact.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fYWIT9TSJPE
Like I said, "Where's de plane boss?"
http://www.samliquidation.com/da_plane.htm
http://www.asile.org/citoyens/numero13/pentagone/erreurs_en.htm
Also, I quote again,
"You have a large object that is very, very fragile (planes are just thin aluminum skins with a bit of reinforcement added) hitting a large, immoble, reinforced object that is not-so-fragile (reinforced concrete)".

It is now safe to assume than the nose of the plane would also be in bits.
So what cause this hole?
pentagon-punchout.gif

The nose.

Eventually it fell apart, yes. It fell apart as it travelled through the building. As it hit interior columns, additional walls, and other parts of the structure. Besides, even a grouping of small pieces can make a large hole.

IN fact, I'd expect the fuselage to make a hole far deeper than anything the wings might do. Primarily because there's a heck of a lot more material in the fuselage. The wings would be stopped fairly quickly, and the fuselage and it's parts would travel farther, as it would take longer to disintegrate completely.

By your "logic", a shotgun shouldn't leave a single hole, right? It should always leave a pattern of small holes?

Seriously, do you research at all? Do you stop to think about what you say, or is it simply instinct to contradict?

Do you have any science education at all? Any understanding of physics or forensics?
 
...
Okay, first of all let me calm down. I'm being sociable. So, I'll agree with you that if you stood on a line perpendiclar to the wall of the Pentagon and shined a really bright spotlight on the Pentagon so the rays all hit the wall at 90 degree angles, flight 77 would cast a shadow 170 feet long.

But I hope you are not arguing that 170 feet of the Pentagon should have been affected.

Flight 77 was about 125 feet long. It was traveling straight ahead from its perspective. It did damage as it flew straight. So, the absolute longest you would expect that area of damage to be is about 125 feet.

In order for the area of damage to be larger than the width of the plane, the plane would have to have been thrown sideways into the building. At the moment that the plane is making your hypothetical triangle, it would have to be pushed at an angle perpendicular to the face of the Pentagon into the building. If it just flew straight, it would only do damage up to about its width....

Loss Leader,
I think this graphic illustrates what kirkman is trying to say about the width of the damage. Line AB is the width of the plane, from wing tip to wing tip. I believe kirkman is saying that because of the angle of approach, the expected damage to the Pentagon wall would be wider than that, as represented by line CD (hmmm...should have labeled that differently so as to not imply "controlled demolition".)
I want to be clear, however, that I do NOT agree with kirkman's "Saturday morning cartoons" assessment of the damage.
 

Attachments

  • plane.gif
    plane.gif
    3 KB · Views: 3
Your words,
Like I said, "Where's de plane boss?"
http://www.samliquidation.com/da_plane.htm
You do have such wonderful taste in finding source material, Malcolm. I particularly like how he has the Protocols of the Illuminated Elders of Tzion on his site and attempts to tie it all together as a massive end-of-days Jewish Satanic conspiracy. True, if he had any evidence it should stand on its own despite being a raging nutjob, but it is an interesting addition to your prior data set.
It is now safe to assume than the nose of the plane would also be in bits.
So what cause this hole?
One of the reinforcing bits. There are parts of the engine, landing gear, etc that are designed to be quite strong and would have had tough enough to survive the trip through the contents of the outer ring of the Pentagon.

This argument takes me back... to 2002.. when it was brought up the first time. Ah, memories.
 
"The width of the severe damage to the west facade of the Pentagon was approximately 120 ft (from column lines 8 to 20)."

ASCE Pentagon Building Performance Report, pg. 35


Here's a picture from that page that shows the damage aligned approximately with the aircraft's centerline.

@Loss Leader, Malcolm is correct that the damage would cover a larger area of the facade because of the aircraft's high angle of incidence. However, I believe it was also Malcolm who claimed that any object striking a surface with an angle of incidence greater that 45 degrees would bounce off. This is wrong, of course, but it does show that he should grasp the concept that objects impacting at high angles of incidence are less likely to penetrate than those impacting with low angles of incidence. In other words, we would expect the plane not to penetrate the wall of the building as well as if it had struck perpendicularly, and some of the lighter parts could well fail to penetrate at all.

Also, Malcolm, look underneath the right wing. Those three openings at ground level are doors.
 

Attachments

  • Aircraft aligned.jpg
    Aircraft aligned.jpg
    54.5 KB · Views: 8
Malcolm has a problem with the concept that when two objects collide, both may suffer some damage. In his world, when a car collision happens, only one car is damaged.

Rolfe.
 
Like I said, "Where's de plane boss?"
http://www.samliquidation.com/da_plane.htm


What an incredibly knowledgeable, accurate, lucid, and cogently argued web page you've discovered, Malcolm. :rolleyes: I'm willing to give you the benefit of the doubt and assume that you don't buy into the anti-Semitic garbage. That aside, this has got to be one of the most absurdly asinine conspiracist sites I've ever seen, and that's saying a lot.


premiers-secours2.jpg


The above photo appears with the caption "This plane should have been full of fuel, why water sprayed upon a fuel fire?"

And a bit farther down the page we have, "The local fire departments were turned away. The fuel fires were sprayed with water. Water is not effective on fuel fire. Foam is what is used on fuel fires."

:dl: :dl: :dl:

(The yellow-green vehicle and its obscured twin are foam trucks that arrived within a few minutes from nearby National Airport; the the white stuff all over the place is, amazingly enough, foam. :rolleyes:)

Then we have this gem, lifted from another conspiracist web site, re-hashing the "no Arab passengers" canard.

Meanwhile, back at the ranch, the Armed Forces Institute of Pathology (AFIP), does a miraculous job and identified nearly all the bodies on November 16th 2001. . . .

The AFIP suggest these numbers:189 killed, 125 worked at the Pentagon and 64 were passengers on the plane. . . . They did not explain how they were able to tell victims bodies from hijacker bodies. In fact, from the beginning NO explanation has been given for the extra five suggested in news reports except that the FBI showed us the pictures to make up the difference, and that makes it so.

Now, being the trusting sort, I figured that the government would want to quickly dispel any rumors . . . So, I sent a FOIA request to the AFIP . . .

No Arabs wound up on the morgue slab. . . .

The AFIP claims that the only passenger body that they were not able to identify is the toddler, Dana Falkenberg, whose parents and young sister are on the list of those identified.

The satanic masterminds behind this caper may be feeling pretty smug about the perfect crime, but they have left a raft of clues tying these unfortunates together. [emphasis original]


From a CBSNews.com article dated August 17, 2002:

Four sets of remains in Pennsylvania and five at the Pentagon were grouped together as the hijackers - but not identified by name - through a process of elimination.

Families of the airplanes' passengers and crews and those who died within the Pentagon provided DNA samples, typically on toothbrushes or hairbrushes, to aid with identification. The remains that didn't match any of the samples were ruled to be the terrorists, said Chris Kelly, spokesman for the Armed Forces Institute of Pathology, which did the DNA work. The nine sets of remains matched the number of hijackers believed to be on the two planes.

Without reference samples from the hijackers' personal effects or from their immediate families to compare with the recovered DNA, the remains could not be matched to individuals.


I could go on and on, but I'm sure everyone gets the idea.

Congratulations, Malcolm; I'm sure that web site will open the eyes of nearly everyone who sees it to The TruthTM.
 
He challenged numerous people to compare a picture of a piece of debris with a video. Several people (including Rolfe and Gravy) did so. Then, without answering any of those posts, he just moved on.

When he moves on like that, should we assume that he is once again offering to call a piece of evidence "inconclusive"? Or will we be circling around to it again? I'm confused on the whole issue.


It might help to understand that Malcolm has had me on ignore for a few days now. I'm not sure if this was because I kept asking him to agree that you don't need a BIG hole in the top of the polythene bag of Hartmann's solution in order for a giving set to work as illustrated, and that there is indeed gravity inside a TV tube. (When I suggested that if we could agree on that, I'd take a look at the photos, he replied, "don't bother, I'm not that desperate.") Or alternatively, it might be because I mentioned once or twice - OK, maybe three times - that he had been conclusively proven to have told a pack of jawdropping lies about his finances, his qualifications and his personal circumstances, earlier in this thread. And by the way, I intend to keep mentioning it every time he says how dedicated he is to the Truth.

I think it's not unlikely that he has Gravy on ignore too.

Having cleared that up, I hope we can finally get to the reall truth about 9/11 and especially about just exactly where the British can stick their precious aluminium.


Exactly the same place you can stick your "thimerosal" (the other ingrained misspelling that drives me rule8-ing nuts).

This is almost a Stundie.


Heck, it's pretty weak compared to his usual standard and I'm sure he'll do better later in the month, but let's go for it as his starter for 10.

Rolfe.
 
Here's a picture from that page that shows the damage aligned approximately with the aircraft's centerline.

@Loss Leader, Malcolm is correct that the damage would cover a larger area of the facade because of the aircraft's high angle of incidence. However, I believe it was also Malcolm who claimed that any object striking a surface with an angle of incidence greater that 45 degrees would bounce off. This is wrong, of course, but it does show that he should grasp the concept that objects impacting at high angles of incidence are less likely to penetrate than those impacting with low angles of incidence. In other words, we would expect the plane not to penetrate the wall of the building as well as if it had struck perpendicularly, and some of the lighter parts could well fail to penetrate at all.

Also, Malcolm, look underneath the right wing. Those three openings at ground level are doors.
You're worth your weight in gold to me. You stick up a NIST image showing that even they can't get a head on 757 to fit, without vapourising one of the engines and forgetting half of each wing. You do all that to mention three doors? What's the big deal with the three doors?
What happened with that probability stuff, I'll make good use of that. Then there'a the Bob Pugh video. Are you sure that you're not on my side?
 
Just to be sociable, I'll agree without looking it up.





I'm still being sociable so I'll still agree.





Sociable. Agree.





What? What?

Okay, first of all let me calm down. I'm being sociable. So, I'll agree with you that if you stood on a line perpendiclar to the wall of the Pentagon and shined a really bright spotlight on the Pentagon so the rays all hit the wall at 90 degree angles, flight 77 would cast a shadow 170 feet long.

But I hope you are not arguing that 170 feet of the Pentagon should have been affected.

Flight 77 was about 125 feet long. It was traveling straight ahead from its perspective. It did damage as it flew straight. So, the absolute longest you would expect that area of damage to be is about 125 feet.

In order for the area of damage to be larger than the width of the plane, the plane would have to have been thrown sideways into the building. At the moment that the plane is making your hypothetical triangle, it would have to be pushed at an angle perpendicular to the face of the Pentagon into the building. If it just flew straight, it would only do damage up to about its width.

Let me give you an example. It's the one I just did to make sure I was right. Take a white piece of paper, a sewing needle and a bright lamp. Sit with the needle between the lamp and the paper. Hold the needle at whatever angle you want. It casts a shadow of varying length on the paper. The smallest shadow would be its width but the shadow could grow as long as the length of the needle (or longer if you don't line everything up).

Now, fly the needle like an airplane towards the paper. Fly it straight on point first. No matter how large the shadow is or was, when that needle hits the paper, it is going to make a hole just about as large as its width. And it will go right through that small hole. It doesn't matter how oblique you make the angle, if you fly the needle point-first, it's only going to make a hole about size of its width.

Flight 77 was flying nose first. The damage it did to the Pentagon (at least just from the collision aspect) could only be about the size of its width.

I hope this isn't where you were going with this because damn.
Let me see if I've got this right. In spite of me mentioning the sine and cosine rules etc. You steam in with needles, paper and bright lights to exhibit to all and sundry that you have absolutely no knowledge of the properties of a right angled triangle.
Yet, just a couple of posts before, you pontificated at length about perspective etc, mentioning The Leaning Tower of Pisa and all kinds of weird and wonderful stuff.
Tell me, how did you manage to leapfrog the right angled triangle bit on your way to all this advanced knowledge on perspective?
 
Loss Leader,
I think this graphic illustrates what kirkman is trying to say about the width of the damage. Line AB is the width of the plane, from wing tip to wing tip. I believe kirkman is saying that because of the angle of approach, the expected damage to the Pentagon wall would be wider than that, as represented by line CD (hmmm...should have labeled that differently so as to not imply "controlled demolition".)
I want to be clear, however, that I do NOT agree with kirkman's "Saturday morning cartoons" assessment of the damage.



Okay, I think I'm with you. I called my ninth grade math teacher and she explained the whole thing. I now agree that the side of a triangle with one side 125 feet and three angles of 47, 43 and 90 would be 170 feet.

I have, however, a new complaint:

It would seem to me to be the height of stupidity to assume that just because the Plane could affect a maximum of 170 feet of the Pentagon's face, that it must be so.

For one thing, the moment the right wingtip and then the nose touch the Pentagon, they're going to stop moving perfectly straight. To my way of thinking, this should pull the plane in to the right. The left side of the plane should be pulled right by the impact of the right side. If I'm speeding down the highway and I strike a large metal post with the front right side of my car, the left side of the car does not continue straight; the left side makes a somewhat violent right turn, spinning the car so that it is facing right.

Tell me if any of this makes sense because I just did trigonometry for the first time in twenty-one years and I'm feeling a little lightheaded.
 
What an incredibly knowledgeable, accurate, lucid, and cogently argued web page you've discovered, Malcolm. :rolleyes: I'm willing to give you the benefit of the doubt and assume that you don't buy into the anti-Semitic garbage. That aside, this has got to be one of the most absurdly asinine conspiracist sites I've ever seen, and that's saying a lot.


[qimg]http://www.samliquidation.com/images/premiers-secours2.jpg[/qimg]

The above photo appears with the caption "This plane should have been full of fuel, why water sprayed upon a fuel fire?"

And a bit farther down the page we have, "The local fire departments were turned away. The fuel fires were sprayed with water. Water is not effective on fuel fire. Foam is what is used on fuel fires."

:dl: :dl: :dl:

(The yellow-green vehicle and its obscured twin are foam trucks that arrived within a few minutes from nearby National Airport; the the white stuff all over the place is, amazingly enough, foam. :rolleyes:)

Then we have this gem, lifted from another conspiracist web site, re-hashing the "no Arab passengers" canard.




From a CBSNews.com article dated August 17, 2002:




I could go on and on, but I'm sure everyone gets the idea.

Congratulations, Malcolm; I'm sure that web site will open the eyes of nearly everyone who sees it to The TruthTM.
I didn't bother reading the web page. I saw the photo of Dr No and his assistant superimposed on the lawn and thought the reader might realise how easy it was to fake photos.
There's good and bad in all. I'm not anti semitic, although I've got a couple of old girlfriends who might argue that point.
Tel me how you got that image from the NIST report up. You might as well, you've done more for me than anyone else on here.
 
SpitfireIX said:
Also, Malcolm, look underneath the right wing. Those three openings at ground level are doors.
You're worth your weight in gold to me. You stick up a NIST image showing that even they can't get a head on 757 to fit, without vapourising one of the engines and forgetting half of each wing. You do all that to mention three doors? What's the big deal with the three doors?


I'm pretty sure Spitfire wonders what the big deal with the three doors is, too. But you are the one who insisted that there were no doors there. Repeatedly. Here are some of your own words, Malcolm. I've bolded the part where you make a big deal out of the absense of doors into the Pentagon at that exact spot:


Also, how can it be a path when it goes from a wall to nowhere. Who would tread such a 'path' and why do you fail to address that point?
How did this path get worn? People walked through a wall and then jumped the last ten or so feet?
2. The impact point is a wall.
3. There is no possible way it can been a short cut footpath. Apart from it running from a wall to an on ramp, it is not complete.
I thinks it's better than a path from a wall to an on ramp.
It is not a path, because it goes from a motorway barrier, to a wall. The part of the wall it goes to, is the impact point.
What part of the path do I not get?
The part that goes through a wall for a start.
I can't type for laughing. A path, I cannot believe it. A path from a wall to a motorway. Whst happened when the pedestrian got to the road. Over fast moving roads, central reservations, fences, then a cloverleaf to what? Oh of course, how silly of me. To the Citgo station for a mars bar. Then retrace the route back, roads, cloverleaf, fences, motorway etc etc. Then for the last few yards a sprint to get high enough up the wall to get to the window ledge and thus through the window. Let's hope nobody closed the window in the life threatening 40 or so minutes it took to get the mars bar. Why do you come out with this nonsense?
There was no door in the wall at that spot for any unofficial 'path' to originate. Who would walk up to a wall and why?


As you can see, you were the one who turned the question of whether there were doors at the impact point into a "big deal." You did it because you thought it helped your "missile cart" theory.

But as you can also see, your old arguments do not fade away. We do not forget an issue just because you would like to move on. And we certainly do not forget that you never once withdrew your "missile cart" contention no matter what evidence was presented to you.

And the next time you try to dance away from an issue on which you've lost your bearings, we'll remember that as well.
 
I didn't bother reading the web page. I saw the photo of Dr No and his assistant superimposed on the lawn and thought the reader might realise how easy it was to fake photos.
There's good and bad in all. I'm not anti semitic, although I've got a couple of old girlfriends who might argue that point.
Tel me how you got that image from the NIST report up. You might as well, you've done more for me than anyone else on here.


I posted the following as a separate thread, but it certainly belongs here:

Last night I viewed, for the third or fourth time, the Discovery-Times documentary "Flight 175: As the World Watched."

I can't begin to describe how intensely moving I found the experience. It's one of the main reasons I got into the debunking business. If you haven't already seen this extraordinary short film, please make every possible effort to do so.

I hear ignoramuses and charlatans babbling their contemptible nonsense about "video fakery" and "thermite" all the time on this forum and others. The best corrective is to hear the words of Louise Sweeney:

When I watch that plane go in, I'm watching my son die."

Call her a liar, Ace and Malcolm.
 
Here's a picture from that page that shows the damage aligned approximately with the aircraft's centerline.

@Loss Leader, Malcolm is correct that the damage would cover a larger area of the facade because of the aircraft's high angle of incidence. However, I believe it was also Malcolm who claimed that any object striking a surface with an angle of incidence greater that 45 degrees would bounce off. This is wrong, of course, but it does show that he should grasp the concept that objects impacting at high angles of incidence are less likely to penetrate than those impacting with low angles of incidence. In other words, we would expect the plane not to penetrate the wall of the building as well as if it had struck perpendicularly, and some of the lighter parts could well fail to penetrate at all.

Also, Malcolm, look underneath the right wing. Those three openings at ground level are doors.
Nearly, an angle of incidence LESS than 45 degrees.
Ricochette is a better word than bounce.
Remember that pack attack on the following sentence,
"corrugated" for want of a better word.
 
So, Malcolm, your contention about the 9/11 attacks is that all of the witnesses and investigators are wrong, and all of the evidence is faked? Is that correct?
 
Okay, I think I'm with you. I called my ninth grade math teacher and she explained the whole thing. I now agree that the side of a triangle with one side 125 feet and three angles of 47, 43 and 90 would be 170 feet.

I have, however, a new complaint:

It would seem to me to be the height of stupidity to assume that just because the Plane could affect a maximum of 170 feet of the Pentagon's face, that it must be so.

For one thing, the moment the right wingtip and then the nose touch the Pentagon, they're going to stop moving perfectly straight. To my way of thinking, this should pull the plane in to the right. The left side of the plane should be pulled right by the impact of the right side. If I'm speeding down the highway and I strike a large metal post with the front right side of my car, the left side of the car does not continue straight; the left side makes a somewhat violent right turn, spinning the car so that it is facing right.

Tell me if any of this makes sense because I just did trigonometry for the first time in twenty-one years and I'm feeling a little lightheaded.
A couple of corrections,
1. At 450 mph, how much turning to the right is gonna go on in a millionth of a second.
2. You've just done trig for the first time.
 
Loss Leader,
I think this graphic illustrates what kirkman is trying to say about the width of the damage. Line AB is the width of the plane, from wing tip to wing tip. I believe kirkman is saying that because of the angle of approach, the expected damage to the Pentagon wall would be wider than that, as represented by line CD (hmmm...should have labeled that differently so as to not imply "controlled demolition".)
I want to be clear, however, that I do NOT agree with kirkman's "Saturday morning cartoons" assessment of the damage.
Is there anything you do agree with?
 
The nose.

Eventually it fell apart, yes. It fell apart as it travelled through the building. As it hit interior columns, additional walls, and other parts of the structure. Besides, even a grouping of small pieces can make a large hole.

IN fact, I'd expect the fuselage to make a hole far deeper than anything the wings might do. Primarily because there's a heck of a lot more material in the fuselage. The wings would be stopped fairly quickly, and the fuselage and it's parts would travel farther, as it would take longer to disintegrate completely.

By your "logic", a shotgun shouldn't leave a single hole, right? It should always leave a pattern of small holes?

Seriously, do you research at all? Do you stop to think about what you say, or is it simply instinct to contradict?

Do you have any science education at all? Any understanding of physics or forensics?
You mean a fusilage like this at 37 secs,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l38oEJwAb1Q&mode=related&search=
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom