[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
The government tells us that a number of things happened on 9/11, I'm going to refer to that as the OCT (Official Conspiracy Theory).
The OCT tells us that a regular commercial jetliner, a Boeing 767 crashed into the North tower and then a 767 crashed into the South tower.
On this page you will see a photo of the impact damage to the North tower and further down the page a graphic which superimposes the outline of a 767.
Will you please notice that the wings cut their way through steel.
http://911research.com/essays/reynolds/index.html#nt_holesize
Here is the same thing done to the South tower,
http://www.serendipity.li/wot/spencer06.htm
All I am asking here, is for you to agree that in New York city on 9/11, according to the OCT, the wings of Boeing passengers jets cut cleanly through 'corrugated' steel.
I use the word 'corrugated' because the outside wall of each twin was not made up of sheets of flat steel. Rather for strength, the steel was 'corrugated', for want of a better word.
Here are a couple of construction photo to show what I mean,
http://www.sharpprintinginc.com/911/Photo archives/WTC construction/normal_trident16.jpg
http://www.sharpprintinginc.com/911/Photo archives/WTC construction/knuckles_above_deck.jpg

No, I wouldn't agree with that. The first link you provide shows that the last 20' or so of the wings did not cut cleanly through the steel.

It is true that steel perimeter columns were not severed under the impact profile of the outermost 20 or so feet of each wing -- as would be expected in the contest between the very lightweight aluminum-structured wing-tips and the far stronger steel box columns.

As to the second link you provide, I would need a better photo of the actual damage to be sure, but it looks as if here, too, the outermost portions of the wings did not sever the steel, but rather badly buckled it.
 
SOMERLED:

You are wrong. The outer cladding of the WTC towers was made of aluminum, not steel. This was primarily because no one wanted their building to rust.

Additionally, the WTC towers were office buildings. The Pentagon (at least the part hit, which had undergone renovations) is a hardened structure. Reinforced concrete (high-density concrete with steel supports), bomb-proof glass, and similar features that would all provide more resisitence than a traditional office-building outer facade.
 
Wrong again. That piece of wreckage appears at the far right of the screen.


I'm not totally seeing what you're indicating, Gravy. How big is the actual piece of plane? I thought it was quite big from the size of the rivets, but then thinking about the position of the shot, low down near the grass, I thought it might be a lot smaller than it looks.

What I absolutely can't say is that this piece of wreckage definitely isn't there in the video.
  • The resolution of the video is much poorer than the photograph, making identification of individual bits of wreckage almost impossible
  • We don't know exactly how large a piece we're looking for, it might be smaller than it looks in the photograph
  • Since the position of the photographer and the position of the cameraman are different, it's extremely difficult to say exactly where on the video one should be looking for that exact piece
  • As the wreckage is twisted and very irregularly shaped, it's impossible to tell what it might look like from a different angle - the outline could be quite different
I'd have to walk across that lawn looking closely at each bit of wreckage one at a time before I could even begin to speculate that the piece in the photo wasn't there.

What was this supposed to prove, again? That the photo was a fake?

:dl:

We had the elevated i/v bag, supposed to make every medically trained person in the world sit up and declare the scene to be a set-up. Except when some medically-trained people actually looked, they declared the scene to be exactly as they would expect.

We had the "scorch mark", which wasn't the colour of a scorch mark, but which a boy scout with a plastic badge could tell you was caused by a trolley being wheeled onto the lawn and a missile fired from the trolley. And in spite of trying to hide this evidence, the NWO had botched it again. Except, other pictures showed the "scorch mark" to be probably the line of a utility tunnel with access hatches.

Now we've got the photogenic piece of wreckage which absolutely isn't there in the video. Except the photographer was deliberately using the wreckage to provide a foreground for his shot, while the video camaraman was just panning the scene. There's no way to tell whether or not that piece, of unknown size and uncertain position and very irregular shape, is one of the umpteen bits of random debris seen in the video. (Unless Gravy can be a bit more specific - I'm just not seeing it.)

Next case?

Rolfe.
 
There's a lot of debris in the foreground of those videos. The largest piece I saw was maybe two by three feet, and it was crumpled. I believe that is the piece that everybody sees, with a blue stripe...well it had red paint on it, a red logo.


Sorry, moderation is sometimes interfering with the sense of the thread, I hadn't seen that when I asked about the size. That's a decent assessment, from somebody who saw the thing. Two feet by three feet.... eyes up desk.... not very big. Certainly impossible to tell whether a crumpled piece of aluminium of that size, with an outline which might be very different from different angles, does or does not appear in that low-resolution video, filmed from a greater distance.

Malcolm is perhaps thinking of this piece of wreckage, which has been shown innumerable times on UK TV, and which was indeed very large, and assuming he should be seeing something that big in the video. No.

lockerbie.gif


(I've now seen the argument about the red bits being part of the "n" of "American". All I can say is, well, maybe. And then again, maybe not. Right under there is a comment asking why the piece of wreckage is undamaged. This is clearly some new and unique definition of "undamaged" I have not previously encountered.)

Next case?

Rolfe.
 
The government tells us that a number of things happened on 9/11, I'm going to refer to that as the OCT (Official Conspiracy Theory).
The OCT tells us that a regular commercial jetliner, a Boeing 767 crashed into the North tower and then a 767 crashed into the South tower.
On this page you will see a photo of the impact damage to the North tower and further down the page a graphic which superimposes the outline of a 767.
Will you please notice that the wings cut their way through steel.
http://911research.com/essays/reynolds/index.html#nt_holesize
Here is the same thing done to the South tower,
http://www.serendipity.li/wot/spencer06.htm
All I am asking here, is for you to agree that in New York city on 9/11, according to the OCT, the wings of Boeing passengers jets cut cleanly through 'corrugated' steel.
I use the word 'corrugated' because the outside wall of each twin was not made up of sheets of flat steel. Rather for strength, the steel was 'corrugated', for want of a better word.
Here are a couple of construction photo to show what I mean,
http://www.sharpprintinginc.com/911/Photo archives/WTC construction/normal_trident16.jpg
http://www.sharpprintinginc.com/911/Photo archives/WTC construction/knuckles_above_deck.jpg

OK, now please for a start understand that I am not attempting to argue the question of what hit what, or who did what, or why. I am addressing one point, and one point only, based on a reasonable amount of experience working with the materials of construction.

Steel (or any other sheet metal) is corrugated to provide lateral stiffness, in other words, to prevent it from wrinkling, denting or bending, especially in a direction perpendicular to the corrugations, and also to provide some ability to withstand thermal changes without wrinkling. It is a very effective way of making relatively thin metal stiffer. But there is a difference between stiffness and strength.

Anybody who has actually worked with sheet metal could tell you that corrugation has no appreciable effect on the ability to cut through it. If it is possible for an object or tool to slice through a sheet of flat steel, the same object could slice through the same sort of steel in corrugated form. In fact, if the corrugations provide stiffness and prevent the steel from being dented inward, this could promote slicing rather than preventing it. It's really that simple.

I express no opinion here whether or not an airplane wing can slice through a steel panel, or whether it did at the WTC, though I see no reason why it could not have. I've seen tree branches slice through a metal roof. I only point out that corrugation is a red herring.

And I hope, by the way, that you also realize by now that there is gravity inside a vacuum tube! Really.
 
All I am asking here, is for you to agree that in New York city on 9/11, according to the OCT, the wings of Boeing passengers jets cut cleanly through 'corrugated' steel.
I use the word 'corrugated' because the outside wall of each twin was not made up of sheets of flat steel. Rather for strength, the steel was 'corrugated', for want of a better word.


Oh no not again. Was it on this thread or another that the idea that the Twin Towers were "corrugated" was trashed? "Corrugated" describes what we're all familiar with in shed and garage roofs and that sort of thing. Weren't Anderson shelters made of corrugated iron?

inside-andersonlarge.jpg


The Twin Towers, seen from a much greater distance, may have had a visual appearance similar to the striping of the corrugations seen in this picture, but they were not "corrugated", as in being made of sheets of metal, each sheet being formed into a ripple pattern for strength, with a wavelength of a few inches.

The visual appearance of the twin Towers was created by a design detail which placed the windows set back a bit from the level of the facade, and used sheets of metal of alternating depths, as much for aesthetic effect as anything. This picture has no corrugated metal in it.

normal_trident16.jpg


This one shows it even better. These are flat sheets of metal.

knuckles_above_deck.jpg


I'm not saying the design wasn't intended to be strong. It was. It was probably a hell of a lot stronger than an Anderson shelter. However, the use of corrugated metal, or even "corrugated" metal, wasn't part of it.

How much of the facade was steel and how much was aluminium I don't know. I'm sure structural components were steel, but the cladding was probably aluminium. None of it was corrugated, though.

Rolfe.
 
Rolfe:

Just to clarify myself and answer your question:

You are correct. The structural columns were steel beams crossed with steel plates for support (I believe this is what is shown in the picture you posted on post 3487). These were part of the exterior wall, but were not visible from outside. The outside of the structure was covered in aluminum cladding. Aluminum is used for these types of applications because it's lightweight, strong for it's weight, rust and tarnish resistant, ans less costly than steel. I suppose you could make a steel outer cladding, but you'd end up with a brown building within a year :)

IN any case, breaking through some steel beam designed to resist a vertical load is quite a bit different from breaking through reinforced concreate designed to resist both vertical and horizontal loads. Remember, the Pentagon renovation was intended to make the structure more bomb-resistent. In regards to the resistence of steel vs. concrete to explosive impulse, there is a reason bomb shelters tend to be made of concrete and earth rather than steel. Since we're talking of "cutting", imaginge trying to cut through a steel mesh with an axe blade. Now imagine cuting through a steel mesh that's imbedded in concrete.

That gives a bit of an idea of the diffferences between the buildings.
 
First of all, where are we on this thread? We were talking about lines in the grass, then Malcolm wanted to move on to a specific piece of debris and then, without concluding that topic, he moved on to the construction of the towers.

He challenged numerous people to compare a picture of a piece of debris with a video. Several people (including Rolfe and Gravy) did so. Then, without answering any of those posts, he just moved on.

When he moves on like that, should we assume that he is once again offering to call a piece of evidence "inconclusive"? Or will we be circling around to it again? I'm confused on the whole issue.



How much of the facade was steel and how much was aluminium I don't know. I'm sure structural components were steel, but the cladding was probably aluminium.


I can say with 100% confidence (and I'm sure Gravy will agree) that there was absolutely no aluminium in the facade of the Twin Towers whatsoever. Zero. It was utterly devoid of aluminium. Having been built in the United States, the towers may have contained aluminum but would never have been built with aluminium. Aluminum is the preferred metal in such a circumstance.

Having cleared that up, I hope we can finally get to the reall truth about 9/11 and especially about just exactly where the British can stick their precious aluminium.
 
Rolfe:

Just to clarify myself and answer your question:

You are correct. The structural columns were steel beams crossed with steel plates for support (I believe this is what is shown in the picture you posted on post 3487). These were part of the exterior wall, but were not visible from outside. The outside of the structure was covered in aluminum cladding. Aluminum is used for these types of applications because it's lightweight, strong for it's weight, rust and tarnish resistant, ans less costly than steel. I suppose you could make a steel outer cladding, but you'd end up with a brown building within a year :)

IN any case, breaking through some steel beam designed to resist a vertical load is quite a bit different from breaking through reinforced concreate designed to resist both vertical and horizontal loads. Remember, the Pentagon renovation was intended to make the structure more bomb-resistent. In regards to the resistence of steel vs. concrete to explosive impulse, there is a reason bomb shelters tend to be made of concrete and earth rather than steel. Since we're talking of "cutting", imaginge trying to cut through a steel mesh with an axe blade. Now imagine cuting through a steel mesh that's imbedded in concrete.

That gives a bit of an idea of the diffferences between the buildings.

You are saying that the concrete wall of the Pentagon would have resisted the plane better than the twins?
If that's the case, where's de plane boss?
 
No, I wouldn't agree with that. The first link you provide shows that the last 20' or so of the wings did not cut cleanly through the steel.



As to the second link you provide, I would need a better photo of the actual damage to be sure, but it looks as if here, too, the outermost portions of the wings did not sever the steel, but rather badly buckled it.

Thank you for that.
I'm sure you will agree that any part of either plane, from wingtip to wingtip would most certainly have broken a window.
I know it sounds a ridiculous thing to say. It's just plain silly to say otherwise. oOf course, any part would have broken a window. I hope you will agree?
However, believe it or not, that is what the OCT tells us.
The width of a 757-223 is 124 ft 10 inches.
That is here,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_757
If there is any part of the following that you want further explanation on, then please feel free to tell me.
I have to do this, so that you and I can agree on the numberring of the pillars
across the front of the Pentagon and the area supposedly affected.
The approach angle was 47 degrees. If you want to alter that, I don't mind.
At the moment the right wingtip touched the face of the building. If you projected forward a line from the LEFT wingtip at 90 degrees. You would have a right angled triangle of 47, 43 and 90 degrees. With one side 124 ft 10ins long.
Using the sine/ cosine rule, I get the hypotenuse to be over 170 ft.
It now follows that the 757 should cover at least 170 ft across the face of the Pentagon.
Finally for now, I seek a simple agreement so that we can identify the pillars, which I will do as soon as you are satisfied that we are together on these points.
If you can imagine a soccer goal. You have two uprights and a cross bar.
In a building like the Pentagon, you have a series of uprights - crossbar - upright - crossbar etc.
Above every upright, there is a column of bricks and above every crossbar, there is a column of windows.
Please don't proceed until you are happy with all I have written,
thank you.
Here are a couple of illustrations of the front of the Pentagon, to highlight the columns of bricks - windows - bricks etc.
http://www.freedomfiles.org/war/pentagon.htm
 
The width of a 757-223 is 124 ft 10 inches.


Just to be sociable, I'll agree without looking it up.


The approach angle was 47 degrees. If you want to alter that, I don't mind.


I'm still being sociable so I'll still agree.


At the moment the right wingtip touched the face of the building. If you projected forward a line from the LEFT wingtip at 90 degrees. You would have a right angled triangle of 47, 43 and 90 degrees. With one side 124 ft 10ins long.


Sociable. Agree.


Using the sine/ cosine rule, I get the hypotenuse to be over 170 ft.
It now follows that the 757 should cover at least 170 ft across the face of the Pentagon.


What? What?

Okay, first of all let me calm down. I'm being sociable. So, I'll agree with you that if you stood on a line perpendiclar to the wall of the Pentagon and shined a really bright spotlight on the Pentagon so the rays all hit the wall at 90 degree angles, flight 77 would cast a shadow 170 feet long.

But I hope you are not arguing that 170 feet of the Pentagon should have been affected.

Flight 77 was about 125 feet long. It was traveling straight ahead from its perspective. It did damage as it flew straight. So, the absolute longest you would expect that area of damage to be is about 125 feet.

In order for the area of damage to be larger than the width of the plane, the plane would have to have been thrown sideways into the building. At the moment that the plane is making your hypothetical triangle, it would have to be pushed at an angle perpendicular to the face of the Pentagon into the building. If it just flew straight, it would only do damage up to about its width.

Let me give you an example. It's the one I just did to make sure I was right. Take a white piece of paper, a sewing needle and a bright lamp. Sit with the needle between the lamp and the paper. Hold the needle at whatever angle you want. It casts a shadow of varying length on the paper. The smallest shadow would be its width but the shadow could grow as long as the length of the needle (or longer if you don't line everything up).

Now, fly the needle like an airplane towards the paper. Fly it straight on point first. No matter how large the shadow is or was, when that needle hits the paper, it is going to make a hole just about as large as its width. And it will go right through that small hole. It doesn't matter how oblique you make the angle, if you fly the needle point-first, it's only going to make a hole about size of its width.

Flight 77 was flying nose first. The damage it did to the Pentagon (at least just from the collision aspect) could only be about the size of its width.

I hope this isn't where you were going with this because damn.
 
You are saying that the concrete wall of the Pentagon would have resisted the plane better than the twins?
If that's the case, where's de plane boss?

Yes to the first question.

To the second, thought experiment time. Take a pea. Set it on a post outside, in an area with a good backstop (or nothing behind it for miles). Shoot the pea with a .45 caliber "ball" type lead bullet. You need to make sure it impacts dead center of the peafor this to be a valid test.

Now, where's the pea?

That's what happened to the plane. The plane impacted at a speed almost equal to that of a bullet fired from a 45 automatic (the plane was ~ 800 ft/sec, the bullet is about 900 ft/sec). As anyone who knows physics will agree, the plane impacting the building at that speed its comparable to the building impacting the plane at that speed. Thus, a .45 caliber bullet, representing the building, impacting the pea, representing the plane, is a good analogy to demonstrate the effects. You have a large object that is very, very fragile (planes are just thin aluminum skins with a bit of reinforcement added) hitting a large, immoble, reinforced object that is not-so-fragile (reinforced concrete).

The plane is what's scattered all over the lawn and throughout the interior of the impact area.
 
I have a question...Since it was a same day videotape that had an airliner "faked" into the video hitting the TC, why is it after nearly 6 years, they haven't been able to come up with a "faked" Pentagon video?

I'm flattered by your signature, thank you.
I'm not aware of such a same day videotape. However, with over 100 cctv videos yet to surface, who knows what boloney they'll try to serve up next?
 
Yes to the first question.

To the second, thought experiment time. Take a pea. Set it on a post outside, in an area with a good backstop (or nothing behind it for miles). Shoot the pea with a .45 caliber "ball" type lead bullet. You need to make sure it impacts dead center of the peafor this to be a valid test.

Now, where's the pea?

That's what happened to the plane. The plane impacted at a speed almost equal to that of a bullet fired from a 45 automatic (the plane was ~ 800 ft/sec, the bullet is about 900 ft/sec). As anyone who knows physics will agree, the plane impacting the building at that speed its comparable to the building impacting the plane at that speed. Thus, a .45 caliber bullet, representing the building, impacting the pea, representing the plane, is a good analogy to demonstrate the effects. You have a large object that is very, very fragile (planes are just thin aluminum skins with a bit of reinforcement added) hitting a large, immoble, reinforced object that is not-so-fragile (reinforced concrete).

The plane is what's scattered all over the lawn and throughout the interior of the impact area.
Your words,
"The plane is what's scattered all over the lawn and throughout the interior of the impact area".
Would you like to point out where on the lawn are the wings, the tailplane, the shoulders, the engines, the seats, the luggage and the dead passengers.
Bob Pugh's video is here and is filmed less than five minutes after the moment of impact.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fYWIT9TSJPE
Like I said, "Where's de plane boss?"
http://www.samliquidation.com/da_plane.htm
http://www.asile.org/citoyens/numero13/pentagone/erreurs_en.htm
Also, I quote again,
"You have a large object that is very, very fragile (planes are just thin aluminum skins with a bit of reinforcement added) hitting a large, immoble, reinforced object that is not-so-fragile (reinforced concrete)".

It is now safe to assume than the nose of the plane would also be in bits.
So what cause this hole?
pentagon-punchout.gif
 
pentagon_debris_logo.jpg


i was staying out but you have posted the site with the letter "n" photoshopped picture again

i could not let that lie, that is a travesty of an attempt at disproving something, wrong colour and rivets, its not even put together so it looks remotely like an "n"

please tell me you have more than this gravity boy?

then again look at that whole page you linked, i think you do not, its a joke
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom