[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have a question...Since it was a same day videotape that had an airliner "faked" into the video hitting the TC, why is it after nearly 6 years, they haven't been able to come up with a "faked" Pentagon video?
 
I'm sorry, Malcolm, but I'm having a really hard time reading this as anything other than your muttering to yourself in the mirror.

I'm just utterly bewildered by your response to twinstead's post. How is the mention of the evidence available "obfuscation"?
Below I have copied the post I wrote.
It asks one specific question about one specific piece of wreckage.
It is an invitation to compare a photo and pass judgement.
It is an invitation to an answer, not a question. A question that would lead me around the houses, whilst the original point got lost in the shuffle, (if you'll forgive my choice of simile). This is a practise that I have encountered time and again, it is obfuscation.
This is the dictionary definition of obfuscate,
"To make obscure or unclear".
Are you still bewildered?

Here's a bit of research for you.
Here's a video that pans across the whole of the relevant area of the Pentagon lawn. Around about 7.30 or so, you see a priest backing up, the whole relevant area of lawn is covered.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fYWIT9TSJPE
You will not find the piece of wreckage pictured here,
http://www.rense.com/general31/CONFIRM.htm
I do have things to do, other than play silly word games with people whose only desire is to obfuscate.
A serious response from you will get a similar response from me.
What's it to be, the choice is yours, puerile or grown up?
 
Obfuscation and now duplicity = the ignore list.
I've better things to do that try to talk with some people.

There is none so blind as one who will not see, and none who will not see like one who makes other people vanish.


So, Malcolm, when are you going to get your evidence to court and nail these bastards ?
 
My pleasure Glenn,
Plenty of debris available as you so rightly point out.
Guess what, there is one piece of debris you won't see.
Here it is,
http://www.rense.com/1.imagesD/hullpart.jpg


And from the angles of the yellow fire-trucks it's blindingly obvious that the "priest" is many yards to the right of that particular piece of wreckage .
Do you have any more points?
 
I'm just utterly bewildered by your response to twinstead's post. How is the mention of the evidence available "obfuscation"?

I assume it means that mention of CONTRARY evidence to his was what he considered 'obfuscation'.

Par for the course.
 
You will find no trickery of any kind with me. I have no need to play word games or anything else, I have the truth on my side. What you see is what you get.
I am not asking you to say, "Yes, Bob Pugh did say that. Therefore 9/11 was an inside job".
You will find no tricks at all.
All I'm asking you to do, is agree that Pugh said those things about the hole, that's all.
You did use the words "Frank and Earnest" and I understand you are busy.
That is why I asked you just to look at the last minute os so of the video.
I asked from 9 minutes 45 secs to the end of the video.
The answer is a clear "Yes, Bob Pugh did say those things".
That's all I was asking for.
Thsi is how evidence would be presented to you if were you on a jury. One thing at a time. Then at the end, there is no telling you how to think. You make up your own mind.
There is quite a way to go. If you give me the opportunity, I will present a case to you that I think is compelling. You don't have to agree that I have presented a compelling case. All I am asking you to do is give a frank and earnest consideration of the evidence I present.

Ah, I see.

Yes, he does indeed say that the hole was rather small.
 
I apologize in advance but I had to do it

I am sorry but after 87 pages of this. I must admit that this quote from the movie Billy Madison goes through my mind whenever I read a missive from "the artist formally know as Malcolm."

Principal: Mr. Madison, what you've just said is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul.
 
Just this,
stop the video at 5.04, then again at 5.12 and it becomes blindingly obvious that the piece of wreckage in question aint on the lawn.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fYWIT9TSJPE
If you took two pictures of my desk from an identical vantage point today, one would show a sandwich, and the other would show a clear desk where the sandwich should be. I must have photoshopped the sandwich in.

This is dumb.
 
My pleasure Glenn,
Plenty of debris available as you so rightly point out.
Guess what, there is one piece of debris you won't see.
Here it is, http://www.rense.com/1.imagesD/hullpart.jpg


Here's my problem with this picture, Malcolm: forced perspective. Basically, a camera had no depth perception. Any depth in a still picture is actually a trick of the mind - our brains know what size different objects are and so we put them in the right context subconsciously. Here's a good example of forced perspective: [ing]http://www.travellerspoint.com/photos/51219/thumb_IMGP6461.jpg[/img]

It's a very common tourist photo of a guy appearing to hold up the Leaning Tower of Pisa. And for a moment we might be confused. But our brains quickly sort out that the guy is only 6 feet tall and the tower is, um, 182 feet tall so he must be much closer to us than the tower. And, indeed, the tiny people in the background give it away.

But look at this example: http://www.snopes.com/photos/animals/wcgator.asp

In the picture on this page, it looks as though they've caught an enormous alligator. It's just a photography trick, though. The deputy is far behind the alligator and the gator's head is turned towards the camera. The alligator is large but only about 2/3 the size it seems. The problem is that, unlike in Pisa, most of us have no real reference for how large an alligator should be. If we don't know how large the thing should be, our brains cannot adjust the monoscopic image for us. So, for example, good luck figuring out how big this thing really is. There is nothing in this picture to give us the least reference to how large the sculpture is or how it would look from a different angle.

So, my problem with your picture of a particular piece of debris is that it suffers from the same forced perspective. The piece of debris looks huge but it is much, much closer to the camera than anything else. It should look huge. And since we do not encounter airplane debris in our normal lives (well, you and I don't in any case), our brains cannot help us decipher the image. We do not really know how big it is.

You show a video and say that the single piece is not visible. I'm not sure that's true. You may be looking for a very large piece when, in reality, it is much smaller.

And I think there's reason to believe this particular piece is fairly small. In the photo near the piece, you can make out individual blades of grass. Behind it where other debris is scattered, the grass is more indistinct.

I think, from another perspective like the video you posted, the piece would fade into anonymity.

Please consider that you have once again misinterpreted a photograph.
 
Ah, here I come to ask Malcolm what size the bit of wreckage in the foreground is, so that I know what I'm supposed to be looking for, and Loss Leader beat me to it again. It could be fairly small. And the video is not a closeup. It could be any one of many bits of debris seen at a greater distance in the video. Somebody took a picture in closeup of an interesting bit of wreckage. You can't identify that particular little bit for sure in a rather grainy video of the whole scene. Fancy that.

Malcolm, did you ever see the French and Saunders sketch of the making of Lord of the Rings? It was hilarious. One bit was also instructive, where they demonstrated how most of the weird sizing of the characters was achieved by forced perspective rather than by special effects. Dawn French was Frodo and Jennifer Saunders was Gandalf, and they were in a set made to look like Bag End. The table, when first seen, was obviously quite a long rectangle. Dawn French sat at the far end, by the window, while Jennifer Saunders sat at the end closest to the camera, on the other side of the table. Each talked not to the other but directly in front of her. Still it looked like a long table, with two women behaving rather strangely.

Then they moved the camera so that the table was foreshortened, and looked almost square. Getting there, but not there yet. It was the teacups that did it. They had a big argument about who should have the big cup and who got the little one. Dawn kept saying that as she was the little person she should have the little cup, and while she held the little cup and Jennifer had the big one, the illusion still wasn't there. Then Jennifer persuaded Dawn to switch cups.

The illusion was perfect, from that moment, with no other manipulation. It was like suddenly seeing a Magic Eye picture. Suddenly it wasn't two normal-sized women at either end of a long table, and two identical but differently-sized cups, it was one very big woman and one tiny and tubby one, sitting facing each other over a square table, holding identical cups. (Of course in the film they went to a lot more trouble, building over-sized furniture for the hobbits, and trompe l'oeil foreshortened sets, and both a pony and a horse cast as Bill, and so on, but that little sketch got the basics over.)

The brain makes a best guess from the information it has. Since the piece of wreckage is filling a lot of the frame of the picture, and seems a lot bigger than other objects in the picture, the brain assumes it's large.

It ain't necessarily so.

Rolfe.

PS. Yup, the more I look at it the surer I am. It's the grass that gives it away. To make a dramatic picture, the cameraman has hunkered down in front of the piece of wreckage, possibly with the camera only two feet or so from the lawn. Look at the way the grass rolls back towards the building, with very little vertical gain in the picture for a long horizontal distance. This is characteristic of a camera held a lot lower than the 5' 6" of so one would assume it would be held by someone standing normally. You can also see it in the clarity and size of the grass blades in the foreground.

The same scene can look very different at different times of day, and in different lighting, and from different camera angles. An unusual and unexpected camera angle used to get a dramatic picture can give quite a false impression without being manipulated in any way. In this case, the false impression that something quite small is much bigger than it really is.

Try it, Malcolm. Try photographing an object on your lawn from a standing position, and try to get that perspective (as in the "hullpart" picture) on the lawn itself. You won't be able to do it. Then hunker down to just above the grass, and see what the perspective is like then. And you'll see how something maybe less than a foot long can appear very large when it's in the foreground of such a shot. Something you wouldn't even be able to identify if you took a panned video shot of your whole lawn from a standing position.

(On second thoughts, try it in the public park. You need to be able to get a fair bit of distance in to make the exercise comparable.)
 
Last edited:
Malcolm, did you ever see the French and Saunders sketch of the making of Lord of the Rings? It was hilarious. (snipped)

Rolfe.

Dear kitty-friend Rolfe, could you point me to that sketch/explanation? As a long-time fan of LOTR the books and then of the flicks, I'd love to see it...

(oh shucks, I thought the kitty that someone else used as a smiley was available here, but it's not [sigh])
 
Dear kitty-friend Rolfe, could you point me to that sketch/explanation? As a long-time fan of LOTR the books and then of the flicks, I'd love to see it... )


I'm on a slow-ish dial-up here (haven't sorted out broadband for the New House yet), so I can't search easily. I can try tomorrow at work. But it was on the BBC, possibly BBC2, and in fact I think it was shown in the April following the release of the first film. The name of the show is simply French and Saunders, so if you search the bbc.co.uk web site for that, you may find it.

Rolfe.
 
That's what I think.

I've got no opinion about the "slug line" theory, I can see why it might be reasonable, and indeed both might be true. However that trail doesn't just connect two manhole covers, there appear to be two more square structures, less prominent but also possibly manhole covers, along the length of the line. Another photo posted has actually shown the manhole nearest the building open, with someone working inside.

It looks to me as if the line is an area of poor grass growth either because it has been recently excavated along its length, or because the utility tunnel is so superficial that the grass over it has poor roots and is liable to scorching in times of drought. Or perhaps because people regularly walk between the manholes, perhaps performing inspections.

In the garden of the flats where I used to live in the 1980s there was a large circular area which scorched pale brown whenever there was a spell without rain. It was quite large and almost perfectly circular, and when I first saw it I thought someone had been putting weedkiller on the grass. Woo-woos might have postulated a fairy ring. However, it was in fact a circular structure connected to the drainage system of the flats (not a septic tank though, we were on mains sewage), which was so near the surface that the grass above it had shallow roots and survived drought less well than the rest of the lawn. This could only be ascertained for certain by inspecting the area on foot. Any speculation about the cause of the circle based simply on aerial photographs would have been just that - speculation.

Nobody can say for sure what that track on the grass is without going there and taking a look, close up, on foot. All else is speculation. The "slug line" idea seems plausible. However, based on the appearance of the regular squares which seem to be connected by the line, and the fact that we have a picture of one of the squares which shows it to be a manhole cover, my speculation is firmly in the "utility tunnel" camp.

Speculations centering on the concept of someone wheeling a trolley there and letting off a missile seem to me to be in the realms of paranoid fantasy.

But just supposing for a moment that they did, why not just erase the evidence of that from the picture, if they're so good at tampering? And why is the line so consistent over so many pictures? A mark caused by a single event would surely be completely absent, appear suddenly, then gradually fade away. That doesn't seem to be the case with this mark.

Maybe Malcolm could actually produce this Boy Scout, copmplete with plastic badge, who can support his theory? Because clearly nobody else here is seeing it, including lots of people with good degrees in all sorts of things, PhDs, and Mensa-level IQs.

Rolfe.

don't forget the pentagon was in the process of a huge renovation project which included upgrading all the utility cables. workmen would be walking on the grass between the manhole covers to pull new cable. You do remember the huge cable spools next to the building? where the manhole closest to the building was?
 
My pleasure Glenn,
Plenty of debris available as you so rightly point out.
Guess what, there is one piece of debris you won't see.
Here it is,
http://www.rense.com/1.imagesD/hullpart.jpg

Just curious, Malcolm: why did you choose to crop out the debris in the foreground? It would have been just as easy to crop out the Pentagon and claim that it wasn't there, and then you'd have a new theory to promote that was your very own. How did you choose between the two?

879046b03dd91e8b6.jpg



Just this,
stop the video at 5.04, then again at 5.12 and it becomes blindingly obvious that the piece of wreckage in question aint on the lawn.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fYWIT9TSJPE

Wrong again. That piece of wreckage appears at the far right of the screen.
 
don't forget the pentagon was in the process of a huge renovation project which included upgrading all the utility cables. workmen would be walking on the grass between the manhole covers to pull new cable. You do remember the huge cable spools next to the building? where the manhole closest to the building was?


That makes a lot of sense. In the picture with the manhole cover open, it actually looks as if there's been recent excavation all along the line. If it were a general utility tunnel, they would put regular access hatches in so that cables could be threaded along a bit at a time, from one hatch to the next. (I've seen an electrician doing something similar when installing an extra telephone point in my new house.) It looks as if that's what the smaller, intermediate squares are. And of course if you're putting in cables, you walk between the hatches.

However, we can only ever be speculating from the pictures. If this were really a case in a court of law, and you said, well your Honour, I've just looked at the pictures and I'm certain it's a utility tunnel, you'd just get laughed at. What, you haven't been to the site, looked to see what is actually there, and come back with a series of close-up photos so that we can all know for certain? Next case.

Even worse with the trolley-and-missile theory though. What, you haven't been to the site to see if there's any structure there such as a utility tunnel which might explain the uneven grass growth? Next case.

I'm not saying what we're doing is futile, but it's inevitably limited.

Rolfe.
 
I assume it means that mention of CONTRARY evidence to his was what he considered 'obfuscation'.

Par for the course.
No, I asked a question. Instead of answering that question you responded by asking a question of your own.
If you want to avoid obfuscating an issue, you need to first answer the question set and then ask your own question, if you have one.
 
Ah, I see.

Yes, he does indeed say that the hole was rather small.
The government tells us that a number of things happened on 9/11, I'm going to refer to that as the OCT (Official Conspiracy Theory).
The OCT tells us that a regular commercial jetliner, a Boeing 767 crashed into the North tower and then a 767 crashed into the South tower.
On this page you will see a photo of the impact damage to the North tower and further down the page a graphic which superimposes the outline of a 767.
Will you please notice that the wings cut their way through steel.
http://911research.com/essays/reynolds/index.html#nt_holesize
Here is the same thing done to the South tower,
http://www.serendipity.li/wot/spencer06.htm
All I am asking here, is for you to agree that in New York city on 9/11, according to the OCT, the wings of Boeing passengers jets cut cleanly through 'corrugated' steel.
I use the word 'corrugated' because the outside wall of each twin was not made up of sheets of flat steel. Rather for strength, the steel was 'corrugated', for want of a better word.
Here are a couple of construction photo to show what I mean,
http://www.sharpprintinginc.com/911/Photo archives/WTC construction/normal_trident16.jpg
http://www.sharpprintinginc.com/911/Photo archives/WTC construction/knuckles_above_deck.jpg
 
Correction to my post # 3476: Malcolm's photo hadn't fully loaded when I posted, and I thought he was claiming that the large debris wasn't in that view! I apologize to Malcolm for thinking that he was misrepresenting that scene.

However, that debris does appear in many other photos and in videos, and Bob Pugh, who shot the video that Malcolm is referring to, even has this to say:

There's a lot of debris in the foreground of those videos. The largest piece I saw was maybe two by three feet, and it was crumpled. I believe that is the piece that everybody sees, with a blue stripe...well it had red paint on it, a red logo.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom