[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
My pleasure,
Allow me to start by attempting to gain your agreement, that Bob Pugh, the freelance who made this video. Describes the hole in the Pentagon as 16 ft x 16 ft, 20 ft wide max. He also uses the term 'garage door'.
Do you agree,
9 mins 45 secs to close.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fYWIT9TSJPE

Ok, well, I watched most of the video (I don't have time to watch the full thing right now, I need to review a couple of papers for tomorrow).

I have to admit I'm a little confused what you're asking me to agree with. I agree that the guy in the video has his doubts, and says he saw something other then what is given to us by the official video. Now, not to say anything against the witness, but generally this kind of thing isn't considered evidence. It may be enough for you or I, but for those who are more scientific in their investigations will request physical evidence, rather then testimony.

Or is there something in ~ the last third that you wanted me to see?
 
Um, Gravy, I hate to disagree with you but I think you linked to the September 7, 2001 photo. I think the website misdated it. I've been looking at them pretty closely and I think they're the same.

I could well be wrong.
Now a WEBSITE can MISDATE a photo and you talk about it like a simple everyday occcurence,
"I think the website misdated it". Just like that, wallop - done - misdated.
How can you mess about with the date of something by accident?
Any form of MISDATING has to be DELIBERATE.
I think there's a whole lotta misdating going on.
 
They are different photos. The Sept 7 is a satellite photo, and mine is by aircraft (the stray boat in the harbor is a giveaway in mine). However the date is wrong. It's labeled November, 2000, but the text on the page says it was taken July, 2001.
http://www.directionsmag.com/gisresponse/maps-dc.php
Yet another MISDATED photo. You yourself say that the date is WRONG that is is not Nov 2000.
You now say that the text says July 2001.
In your post 3405, you not only said 2000, but you underlined these words,
"The Pentagon was hit by a missile before 2000".
You then went on with a sarcastic,
"That's bad. Somebody should tell somebody about that".
I will only converse with you if the need arises. In other words, when and if I get desperate in order to keep this thread going.
I believe Lyte Trip has been cleaning your clock on another thread.
You will get no respite here.
 
Um, Malcolm, I answered your seven questions. I even provided a link to learn more about "slug lines" and a picture of the Capitol Building showing a similar "scorch mark." I admit it got burried in a lot of posts about your real identity, but I worked hard on it.





What is the source of your path-wear knowledge? What information do you have about how the Pentagon grounds were kept?

I believe I remember someone posting pictures showing that sewr lines were installed in the middle of the Pentagon lawn on that side of the building. If that were the case, people walking on the freshly dug up and then refilled earth would impede grass regrowth. The part of the lawn that was not dug up would just have people trodding on grass as it grows.

I admit that I haven't the first clue as to whether this actually happened. But you must admit that my explanation for why the path would be more bare in some spots than in others is at least as good as your reasoning as to why the path would be uniformly worn.





Great. Just to be sociable, I'll agree that based on physical evidence your theory is as likely as mine. Do you have any eyewitnesses that saw the cart with the missiles on it? It was close to rush hour right next to a busy highway. The cart had to have been there for at least a little while. Please list the individuals who saw it.

Now my theory that a damn plane hit the Pentagon is supported by witnesses. Here's a whole page of them.

Actually, there is one piece of physical evidence you keep forgetting. To the left of your "scorch mark," starting from the edge of the parking lot and extending across the grass of one of the clover leaves is another "scorch mark." How do you explain it? I think it's a foot path people took to get to the onramp for cars going the other way on the highway. What do you think it is?





No, it doesn't. It goes from some outbuildings and a helipad to an on ramp. I think there were one-way exits from the Pentagon located near the helipad. Did you write the DoD to ask?






I addressed the point several times. The path goes from the helipad and some outbuildings to an on ramp. The people who would tread such a path are people who have finished work for the day and want to catch a ride with a Pentagon worker going right (Or maybe East. I have no idea which direction the photo was taken from.) .





Are you deliberately ignoring my posts?

You didn't answer one of my questions - not one.
What you did do was put up a totally implausable alternative.
Here's a part of it,
"The path goes from the helipad and some outbuildings to an on ramp. The people who would tread such a path are people who have finished work for the day and want to catch a ride with a Pentagon worker going right (Or maybe East. I have no idea which direction the photo was taken from.)"
I am speechless.
Not only have you avoided answering my post and referring to the photo I put up. You actually put up photos from another source and talked about them.
How is that referring to the photo I put up?
You are right about a genuine short cut over to the left. It is clear that the genuine short cut is an unbroken line and it is clear where it goes from, where it goes to and why it is there. It is there to clearly cut a corner off. It is evidence of what a genuine path looks like and that bare earth at that location shows up 'white' from the air. You maintain that the scar that points directly to the impact spot, is a path to an on ramp.
A path to an on ramp? I can just imagine a line of cars all queued up patiently, waiting for people. Your path to the on ramp, isn't complete. Did people leap the last 20 ft or so to the road?
http://www.geoeye.com/gallery/9-11/Pentagon/Pentagon_9_7_01.jpg
 
Thank you for asking. As I noted, you seem dismissive, or just not interested, and your phrasing this time is just plain rude. But I'll go ahead and give you this to start with:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metadata

See, that wasn't so hard, could have done that yourself I think. ;)
Most people forget its there, and it may contain valuable info as support. Please peruse that link and feel free to ask for help if any of that doesn't make sense.

You have claimed this photo has been edited, made bold statments of what the edited photo is supposed to be hiding, and at no time substantiated those statements with evidence. Any points you pose about what this photo is supposed to show are really moot until you show some evidence backing your initial statment that this photo has been edited.

You have also ignored posters which have replied to answer your points, especially those who do have supporting evidence.

The evidence in this particular case seems against you. You may want to focus your efforts on those issues which you think you can better support.
You present quite a reasoned argument. I hope you continue in this vein.
Before we let the scar go. Thereis much supporting evidence.
1. It points directly to the impact point.
2. The impact point is a wall.
3. There is no possible way it can been a short cut footpath. Apart from it running from a wall to an on ramp, it is not complete. It has gaps along its course that a genuine trodden path would not have.
4. It is in line with the line of approach as stated by two police officers in this video,
http://www.jonhs.net/911/pentacon.htm
I will agree that this scar can be seen as inconclusive, especially to a newcomer to the truth. I will argue that to someone who knows the truth about 9/11, it is further evidence.
I accept your point about moving on and would ask you for some indication as to your candid opinion as to 9/11. I'm not asking you to agree that 9/11 was an inside job, I am asking you, for example, if you would agree that a new investigation might be a good idea in order to put this matter to rest.
Alternatively, just tipping up the 100 or so cctv tapes that the govt snatched from the area around the Pentagon. Can you think of any reason why they don't tip up those tapes for example?
I'm just trying to loosely gauge whereabouts you are on this issue.
 
Kirkman thats an obvious utility tunnel http://www.directionsmag.com/gisresponse/images/maps/dc/airphotousa_pentagon.jpg

Just connect the two square manhole covers.


That's what I think.

I've got no opinion about the "slug line" theory, I can see why it might be reasonable, and indeed both might be true. However that trail doesn't just connect two manhole covers, there appear to be two more square structures, less prominent but also possibly manhole covers, along the length of the line. Another photo posted has actually shown the manhole nearest the building open, with someone working inside.

It looks to me as if the line is an area of poor grass growth either because it has been recently excavated along its length, or because the utility tunnel is so superficial that the grass over it has poor roots and is liable to scorching in times of drought. Or perhaps because people regularly walk between the manholes, perhaps performing inspections.

In the garden of the flats where I used to live in the 1980s there was a large circular area which scorched pale brown whenever there was a spell without rain. It was quite large and almost perfectly circular, and when I first saw it I thought someone had been putting weedkiller on the grass. Woo-woos might have postulated a fairy ring. However, it was in fact a circular structure connected to the drainage system of the flats (not a septic tank though, we were on mains sewage), which was so near the surface that the grass above it had shallow roots and survived drought less well than the rest of the lawn. This could only be ascertained for certain by inspecting the area on foot. Any speculation about the cause of the circle based simply on aerial photographs would have been just that - speculation.

Nobody can say for sure what that track on the grass is without going there and taking a look, close up, on foot. All else is speculation. The "slug line" idea seems plausible. However, based on the appearance of the regular squares which seem to be connected by the line, and the fact that we have a picture of one of the squares which shows it to be a manhole cover, my speculation is firmly in the "utility tunnel" camp.

Speculations centering on the concept of someone wheeling a trolley there and letting off a missile seem to me to be in the realms of paranoid fantasy.

But just supposing for a moment that they did, why not just erase the evidence of that from the picture, if they're so good at tampering? And why is the line so consistent over so many pictures? A mark caused by a single event would surely be completely absent, appear suddenly, then gradually fade away. That doesn't seem to be the case with this mark.

Maybe Malcolm could actually produce this Boy Scout, copmplete with plastic badge, who can support his theory? Because clearly nobody else here is seeing it, including lots of people with good degrees in all sorts of things, PhDs, and Mensa-level IQs.

Rolfe.
 
Kirkman thats an obvious utility tunnel http://www.directionsmag.com/gisresponse/images/maps/dc/airphotousa_pentagon.jpg

Just connect the two square manhole covers.
I think you deserve some marks for originality. A service tunnel from one manhole cover to another - not bad.
There are indeed flags (paving squares) in some later photos. Unfortunately not in this photo,
http://www.jonhs.net/911/pentacon.htm
However, yours is highly original. I thinks it's better than a path from a wall to an on ramp. Better than a path alongside a ditch and a lot better than a path from a helicopter on the grass to a car waiting on the on ramp.
All in all, yours is the best so far.
Except, of course, for the real reason.
 
My pleasure,
Allow me to start by attempting to gain your agreement, that Bob Pugh, the freelance who made this video. Describes the hole in the Pentagon as 16 ft x 16 ft, 20 ft wide max. He also uses the term 'garage door'.
Do you agree,
9 mins 45 secs to close.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fYWIT9TSJPE


Cherry picking. You uncritically accept witness Bob Pugh's description of the size of the hole, because it fits your conspiracy theory, but you reject out of hand all the witnesses' accounts that state a 757-sized airliner hit the Pentagon, because they don't fit your conspiracy theory. Malcolm, please explain why anyone whom you are trying to convince would accept that as reasonable evidence.
 
You are right about a genuine short cut over to the left. It is clear that the genuine short cut is an unbroken line and it is clear where it goes from, where it goes to and why it is there. It is there to clearly cut a corner off. It is evidence of what a genuine path looks like and that bare earth at that location shows up 'white' from the air. You maintain that the scar that points directly to the impact spot, is a path to an on ramp.
A path to an on ramp? I can just imagine a line of cars all queued up patiently, waiting for people. Your path to the on ramp, isn't complete. Did people leap the last 20 ft or so to the road?
http://www.geoeye.com/gallery/9-11/Pentagon/Pentagon_9_7_01.jpg


The reason the two paths look different is simple: they are each maintained by different authorities. The path from the Pentagon to the on ramp (or between the manhole covers) was maintained by the Department of Defense. The path over one of the cloverleaves wasn't. It was maintained by whomever is responsible for the highway - the State of Virginia or the City of Arlington or the highway authority. There is no reason to believe they would care for the grass in the same way.

In any case, you can stop claiming the path led to a wall. In this picture, you can see a door just to the left of the plane. And this picture appears on a truther website. That door is where people left from after a hard day of doing whatever people did in the Pentagon.

Also, you are quite wrong about the fact that Gravy or I conceded that a picture's date could be changed. In the cases we were talking about, we were discussing the date the website owner wrote that the picture was taken and the date the owner used in the name of the picture. Neither of us were talking about the metadata hidden within the picture file itself. When you were informed that the picture you use was taken on September 7, that information came from the metadata. In fact, a screen shot of the metadata was provided for you.

And you have yet to produce a single witness who agrees with your missile cart theory.
 
You present quite a reasoned argument. I hope you continue in this vein.
Before we let the scar go. There is much supporting evidence.
<snip>
I'm just trying to loosely gauge whereabouts you are on this issue.

I'm sorry, but I believe I have made my thoughts on this issuse fairly clear.
I am addressing a very specific point about your belief that a photo was edited. Without your evidence that the photo has been manipulated and is not authentic, any claims you make about what that photo is supposed to show really are moot.

I will be happy to continue, but really, I feel at this point, until you add some piece of evidence (I don't believe it would be that difficult for you, you've said there is such), any thing about scars and walls is irrelevant.

Who would tread such a 'path' and why do you fail to address that point?

You don't have to take such a tone with me. Your question goes both ways too:
Who would make such a 'scar' and why do you fail to address that point?
But to be perfectly honest, such a question is really unnecessary until the question of the photo is answered.
 
Last edited:
Don't make me laugh too much please, my lips are cracked.
The grass was scorched away and the ground was scorched WHITE.

Simply repeating something doesn't make it true, Malcolm.

It is not a path, because it goes from a motorway barrier, to a wall.

So why was it there before 9/11 ??

This evidence would persuade any unbiased jury in a New York minute.

EXCELLENT! Then get to it, Malcolm. Get this evidence to court and nail these bastards.

Will you ?
 
Now a WEBSITE can MISDATE a photo and you talk about it like a simple everyday occcurence,
"I think the website misdated it". Just like that, wallop - done - misdated.
How can you mess about with the date of something by accident?
Any form of MISDATING has to be DELIBERATE.
I think there's a whole lotta misdating going on.

Actually the copyright of that photo has been shown its date to be correct, even though it's the page that shows the wrong date. This has been addressed upthread. Even Gravy spotted and clarified the sites mistake, without jumping to any conclusion of deliberate manipulation.
See, that wasn't so hard to accept.
 
Ok, well, I watched most of the video (I don't have time to watch the full thing right now, I need to review a couple of papers for tomorrow).

I have to admit I'm a little confused what you're asking me to agree with. I agree that the guy in the video has his doubts, and says he saw something other then what is given to us by the official video. Now, not to say anything against the witness, but generally this kind of thing isn't considered evidence. It may be enough for you or I, but for those who are more scientific in their investigations will request physical evidence, rather then testimony.

Or is there something in ~ the last third that you wanted me to see?
You will find no trickery of any kind with me. I have no need to play word games or anything else, I have the truth on my side. What you see is what you get.
I am not asking you to say, "Yes, Bob Pugh did say that. Therefore 9/11 was an inside job".
You will find no tricks at all.
All I'm asking you to do, is agree that Pugh said those things about the hole, that's all.
You did use the words "Frank and Earnest" and I understand you are busy.
That is why I asked you just to look at the last minute os so of the video.
I asked from 9 minutes 45 secs to the end of the video.
The answer is a clear "Yes, Bob Pugh did say those things".
That's all I was asking for.
Thsi is how evidence would be presented to you if were you on a jury. One thing at a time. Then at the end, there is no telling you how to think. You make up your own mind.
There is quite a way to go. If you give me the opportunity, I will present a case to you that I think is compelling. You don't have to agree that I have presented a compelling case. All I am asking you to do is give a frank and earnest consideration of the evidence I present.
 
You present quite a reasoned argument. I hope you continue in this vein.
<lots o' snipping>
I will agree that this scar can be seen as inconclusive, especially to a newcomer to the truth. I will argue that to someone who knows the truth about 9/11, it is further evidence.
I accept your point about moving on and would ask you for some indication as to your candid opinion as to 9/11. I'm not asking you to agree that 9/11 was an inside job, I am asking you, for example, if you would agree that a new investigation might be a good idea in order to put this matter to rest.
<extra snipping>
I'm just trying to loosely gauge whereabouts you are on this issue.

Thank you for your comments, but I don't feel you are qualified to decide if I am a "newcomer to the truth", though I do admit to lurking. You really know nothing about me, and as such ignorantly dismiss me.

To be perfectly honest, I'm not sure I want to engage you about my opinins. I have been happy to focus on a specific point, with clear evidence, and am relieved that you agree at least it is inconclusive, and I do so without regard as to what ever level knowlege each of us has.

I will not ask you to accept that you may have made a mistake about the dating and possible manipulation of this photo. I think that is best left to readers to make their own decision.
 
The reason the two paths look different is simple: they are each maintained by different authorities. The path from the Pentagon to the on ramp (or between the manhole covers) was maintained by the Department of Defense. The path over one of the cloverleaves wasn't. It was maintained by whomever is responsible for the highway - the State of Virginia or the City of Arlington or the highway authority. There is no reason to believe they would care for the grass in the same way.

In any case, you can stop claiming the path led to a wall. In this picture, you can see a door just to the left of the plane. And this picture appears on a truther website. That door is where people left from after a hard day of doing whatever people did in the Pentagon.

Also, you are quite wrong about the fact that Gravy or I conceded that a picture's date could be changed. In the cases we were talking about, we were discussing the date the website owner wrote that the picture was taken and the date the owner used in the name of the picture. Neither of us were talking about the metadata hidden within the picture file itself. When you were informed that the picture you use was taken on September 7, that information came from the metadata. In fact, a screen shot of the metadata was provided for you.

And you have yet to produce a single witness who agrees with your missile cart theory.
I must remember not to read your posts with my mouth full, one day I'll surely choke myself. Different paths because every couple of months or so the lawns are mowed by different people. I suppose you deserve something for using your imagination.
You posted a full website. Don't worry about it. There was no door there. The door to which you refer is fifty or more yards away and leads to the heliport.
You go on to state categorically and I quote,
"Also, you are quite wrong about the fact that Gravy or I conceded that a picture's date could be changed. In the cases we were talking about, we were discussing the date the website owner wrote that the picture was taken and the date the owner used in the name of the picture".
You then went on to write,
"I think the website misdated it".
Furthermore you have still not answered one question I asked you.
Don't bother writing a post back to me along the lines of trying to argue the toss that a photo hasn't been misdated with some boloney about meta data.
Obfuscation and now duplicity = the ignore list.
I've better things to do that try to talk with some people.
Go and wheel your barrow somewhere else.
 
Actually the copyright of that photo has been shown its date to be correct, even though it's the page that shows the wrong date. This has been addressed upthread. Even Gravy spotted and clarified the sites mistake, without jumping to any conclusion of deliberate manipulation.
See, that wasn't so hard to accept.

It was by me. You stick up misdated material and laugh it off as just one of those things.
I don't, I say it's like a lot of what you see when you look at 9/11.
A lot of smoke and mirrors and now a lot of people argueing against the truth for all they are worth.
Now I wonder why that is?
Deliberate lies, trickery, all the tools of the fakir or faker to you.
Anything but face the truth.
 
I'm sorry, but I believe I have made my thoughts on this issuse fairly clear.
I am addressing a very specific point about your belief that a photo was edited. Without your evidence that the photo has been manipulated and is not authentic, any claims you make about what that photo is supposed to show really are moot.

I will be happy to continue, but really, I feel at this point, until you add some piece of evidence (I don't believe it would be that difficult for you, you've said there is such), any thing about scars and walls is irrelevant.



You don't have to take such a tone with me. Your question goes both ways too:
Who would make such a 'scar' and why do you fail to address that point?
But to be perfectly honest, such a question is really unnecessary until the question of the photo is answered.


Let me clarify things.
I was asking for your general attitude at this moment in time with regard to 9/11 itself.
Specifically, are you happy with the current state of affairs where so many people are crying "inside job", when the govt could silence all dissent by tipping up a few videos. Do you see such a request as unreasonable?
 
You will find no trickery of any kind with me. I have no need to play word games or anything else, I have the truth on my side. What you see is what you get.

:id:

Sorry, bust another irony meter. Better start ordering them in bulk, Hector.

What we "saw" (i.e. what Malcolm said) was:
  • He is a successful businessman
  • He has a honours degree in Law
  • He is very rich
  • He has a very expensive car
  • He is a member of Mensa
  • He has lived in the USA for a considerable period
What we "got", on the other hand, was - well, let's just say a rather sad tale. None of the above is true, as we have conclusively seen. Malcolm has given up responding to posts pointing this out, and probably has me and others on ignore now.

There's probably more - for example he claimed to have a girlfriend, or was it a new wife, then posted about going out to "score". He implied he was living with his mother (yes, a fifty-something retired businessman, OK), when we know he doesn't. And so on.

Now I don't mind arguing on the points raised, but when he comes out with ludicrous statements like the above, then he's going to get called on it.

Rolfe.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom