[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Is the same true for a TV tube?

Did you mean IV tube?

At any rate, if you've found something that blocks gravity, patent it quickly. That stuff would be so useful you'd be rich beyond your wildest dreams.


I keep waiting for Allen Funt to pop out from behind a curtain somewhere and holler "Smile, you're on Candid Camera!"
 
Excellent example (once again) of one-dimensional thinking, Malcolm. It's indicative of the basic problem with your entire argument: you cannot conceive of there being more than one reason for...well, much of anything, really.


I've siphoned gas from my own car, to put in my lawnmower.
(That's a machine that one uses to cut grass.)

I've siphoned gas from my own car to put in our other car, in a pinch.
I've siphoned gas from my own car to prime a carburetor.
I've siphoned gas from my own car to kill fire ants. They hate that.

Aside from all that, however, is the fact that your reply doesn't address the point being made. In fact, your reply missed the mark completely. Try again.
Quick to insult people when you think you're on a roll eh.
Stick around, just a few more posts from me will see you heading for the hills.
 
Let me get this straight: Instead of acknowledging he was totally wrong about the IV bag and getting on with the subject at hand, malcolm continues insist he is right about the IV bag.

malcolm, please for the sanity of the thread admit you are wrong about something.
 
To all the drip feeds.
Is all you say true for pressure infusion IV's.


I'm not even going to ask you what a "pressure infusion Roman Four i/v" is. I'm going to concentrate on your actual claim. First time you said:

Those bags are mildly pressurised and will work equally well above or below the patient. Holding high such bags was for films and TV only. That was twenty five years ago. What do you think I thought when I first saw the bagman?

What do you think every doctor, nurse, medic, paramedic etc in the world will also think when they see that?


You followed this up with:

There is no necessity to hold up such a bag, they are not gravity fed. No one remotely connected to medical work, would hold up such a bag. Ergo, the pictures are staged.


In relation to this claim it is entirely irrelevant whether or not some nifty bit of kit exists that might eliminate the need to elevate the bag. Your claim is that the whole idea of elevating the bags is so out of date, so 1950s, that nobody would even dream of doing it in 2001. You state that nobody with any medical knowledge would do such a thing, and anyone with medical knowledge would peg the photo as a fake because of that.

Now what do people with actual medical knowledge say?

I am a physician with tons of experience using IV's. The IV fluid depends upon pressure to go into the vein in order to overcome the pressure of the blood within. Pumps can be used, but in the field, gravity (i.e. elevation) or external pressure on the bag is used to create that pressure. It is usual and expected to hold up the IV bag. In fact, I might suspect the scene was staged if I didn't see the iv bag held up, as it would be the automatic response.


You called that doctor's explanation "24 carat nonsense" (then spouted an example of same yourself).

I'm a vet. And have extensive experience using these i/v infusions Malcolm has such difficulty understanding. ....

Face it, Malcolm, ordinary gravity feed via an ordinary drip-regulated giving set is still the commonest way to administer i/v fluids, and certainly the most likely thing you'll find at an accident scene. These bags have to be held up in order to work properly. While there may be other ways to do it, and someone mentioned putting the bag under the patient's head temporarily to keep a bit of pressure on during transit, it's more lilkely than not that someone would simply hold the bag up.

That's why not a single medic or vet or paramedic or firstaider on this forum or anywhere else thinks there's anything even slightly strange about the scene.


And another medical professional replied to that:

As a first responder, I concur.


Your only response was that I was "throwing my qualifications about", and "attempting to win an argument by demanding respect from a position of elitism."

The VAST MAJORITY of IVs given outside of a hospital are gravity fed. Period. Even most of those in hospitals are gravity fed through a pump. ....

I've given IVs to others under varying conditions, including combat situations, emergency situations, field situations, and in a hospital setting. My brother works as a Physician's Assistant, specializing in ortho- and neuro-surgical procedures. He also uses gravity-fed IV bags, without holes in the top. A simple look at one of the major suppliers (Baxter, for example) will show the ignorance of your claim. ....

If you'd like, I can get pictures of all the equipment (I have a fully-stocked aid bag at home), and even video of a gravity-fed IV in action. Of course, you could get a clue and just walk through a hospital...you'll see plenty of gravity-fed IVs.


Your response was
You won't mind joining forces with the vet then will you and we'll see who is ignorant and uneducated.

I refer you to my previous post and look forward to cleaning your clock along with the many others who slide away, either permanently or until they think the subject matter has changed sufficiently for them to have another go.


This definitely persuades me that we shouldn't let this one go until Malcolm has acknowledged his error (like with Bush and the photoshoots with primary school children), or actually digs so far he emerges to join Zep in Sydney.

Good, because IV bags are not pressurized. In fact, the bag slowly collapses as the fluid is drained out....

IV bags are absolutely gravity-fed.

5-1/2 years as a volunteer firefighter/EMT. I've spiked many an IV bag for the paramedics, including for a fair number of trauma patients. We hold up bags because they are gravity-fed. The ambulances have little flip-down hangers on the ceilings to hold the bags up above the patient. The drip sets have long tubes in part so that you can place them up above the patient.

Your claim is flatly at odds with reality.

.... they are gravity-fed.

I'm .... someone who is trained in and practices emergency medicine. ....

We take the bag down and can lay it on the patient for a short time during transfers, but as soon as the opportunity presents itself, the bag goes back up. ....

Now that you have heard from current medical types, do you concede this point?


I can't yet find an answer to this other than "Join the rest of the drip feeds."

How many people with medical knowledge do you need to tell you you're wrong?

How about a few people with recent experience as patients or patients' relatives?

[In reply to "No one remotely connected to medical work, would hold up such a bag."]

I'll tell that to the nurse, next time I've got an IV plugged into me.

Last time was in November, by the way.


And another:

This IV discussion is ridiculous. Just tonight, my father had chest pains and I called an ambulence. In our town, the EMTs are firefighters too and they were a little shorthanded because of a bad accident on the local freeway. I held up the freaken' bag myself until they got the pole thing set up. The bag is always elevated, whether by hand or on a hook. Hasn't pretty much everybody witnessed this at one time or another in a hospital or vets office?


And that's just on this thread.

Over in the parts of the forum you never visit, there's another thread just laughing its socks off at you, Malcolm.

A few selected excerpts:

He's wrong.
I'm a trauma nurse and work with IV's every day. If not run through an IV pump, IV's actually are "gravity run". The higher you hold the bag, the faster the fluid runs into the patient. If the bag is at the same level as the patient, the fluids don't run and there is often a backup of blood into the IV tubing. ....

Trauma victims often require large volumes of fluid following injury in order to maintain adequate blood pressure. Having someone hold the bag up above the patient is an effective and easy way to help administer the volume of fluid needed by the victim.


Same as jens. We get ours from a company called BAXTER. They supply gravity only lines and lines that do both. The cannulae go into viens(hopefully) so it's not like it is fighting against arterial blood pressure. All the lines I have seen have a thumbwheel to regulate flow when not in a pump.


Has this guy never been near a hospital? I see people outside every day, pushing IV stands along the sidewalk outside a hospital. Even with pumps, they're elevated.

Doesn't pretty much everyone go into a hospital from time to time, either for care, or to visit someone? How can you avoid seeing IV bags elevated on stands in the hallways and rooms?


There's also SpitfireIX's gallery of seven photographs of patients on stretchers receiving i/v fluids, and in every single case someone is holding the bag up.



Malcolm, it matters not if there is in existence, somewhere, some sort of mechanism that may allow the administration of i/v fluids without any necessity for the fluid reservoir to be held or secured above the patient. The fact is that common standard practice does it that way, no medically knowledgeable person finds such a scenario in the least bit unusual, and you have been shown plenty examples.

It has also been explained to you how the damn things work, and why there is no need either for any BIG hole to let the gravity in.

:crazy:

Now will you agree that you made a mistake, and that the picture of the casualty is plausible, and move on?

Rolfe.
 
Malcolm, in an astonishing reversal of roles, you are the only person here who is qualified to answer that question.

You mean to say that I am the only person on this forum who is interested in telling the truth?
 
Malcolm, I've had you on ignore since shortly after we first met, but I just wanted to pipe in here and say that your continuing argument about IV bags and gravity is the single most unusual argument that I've come across on the internet. Please click this Google image search and see many pages of images of IV bags and holders. In every case the bag is held above the patient. In every case a source of gravity is provided: the universe. That's all. Best wishes.

http://images.google.com/images?q=iv+bag
 
Did you mean IV tube?

At any rate, if you've found something that blocks gravity, patent it quickly. That stuff would be so useful you'd be rich beyond your wildest dreams.


I keep waiting for Allen Funt to pop out from behind a curtain somewhere and holler "Smile, you're on Candid Camera!"
No, I meant a TV tube, a television tube,
 
Alright Jock, I'm a Macdonald myself.
Before we move off the topic. Tell me, if you were buying IV drips for the military.
Would you buy the ones that needed to be held up in the air or the ones that you could lay on the ground?
You will I'm sure, appreciate that you would take into account battlefield conditions.
Well, there's Huntsman who knows. 14 Years as a military medic.

You don't "pressurize" an IV bottle by pumping air in behind the fluid. You sure as hell don't make pre-pressurized bottles with compressed air in them. Doing that is a good way to guarantee that the patient get an air bubble in his veins.

The pump systems either a) squeeze the bag or b) use a mechanical cam to squeeze the tube and force the flow. Both systems are used. The "squeeze the bottle" type gives a very high flow rate. The "squeeze the tube" type gives precise flow rates.

As for battlefield conditions, would you like to be responsible for keeping the batteries for portable pumps charged? Battlefield equipment is designed for simplicity and robustness. If a pump goes bust, you are SOL. Gravity feed just needs a hook to hang the bag from - and that could be a stick from a tree or hung on the tip of a bayonet on a rifle stuck butt first in the ground.

Malcolm, you are digging yourself in a very deep hole.
 
Let me get this straight: Instead of acknowledging he was totally wrong about the IV bag and getting on with the subject at hand, malcolm continues insist he is right about the IV bag.

malcolm, please for the sanity of the thread admit you are wrong about something.
I haven't finished with IV's, I've barely started. Kindly cast your considerable intellect upon the following;
1. Different types of IV bags.
2. The type the military would prefer.
3. The type of establishment that is the Pentagon.
4. The photos.
5. No onebeingableto deny having seen the photos.
6. The barrier that isn't.
That should be enough to oil your wheels.
I can see a few of the brighter posters already heading for the hills.
 
:hb:

I think that says it all, really. And no, you can't brush off that lot by claiming that the photos were "staged".




Not necessarily. But if that wasn't a perfect analogy, then what about the other one. Ever used an ordinary rubber hot water bottle, Malcolm? Ever emptied it? Just take such a hot water bottle, the morning after the night before, unscrew the cap, and invert. Does the water magically stay there if you don't put any pressure on it?




The only way sealing a container will prevent it from emptying is if the container is rigid. (Like, for example, a toilet stack if the outlet pipe is blocked.) You can use this property to measure atmospheric pressure, and surely you did this at school. Atmospheric pressure is measured as how high a column of mercury can be supported under a vacuum. Mercury is used because it is heavy, but water behaves the same way - it's just less practical as you'd need a column many feet high.

But this DEPENDS ON THE CONTAINER NOT BEING ABLE TO COLLAPSE.

If the container is flexible, like a hot water bottle or a plastic bag, no vacuum can form above the departing liquid, because the air pressure on the outside simply allows the bag to collapse leaving no dead space. This is why flexible bags or thin polythene bottles are used when one wants the contents to flow freely out.

[You can use a rigid bottle, and they used to use rigid bottles back in the dim and distant past - think MASH - but these required some way of letting AIR in, to prevent the vacuum forming and allow the fluid to flow. I've used such bottles for administering chloral hydrate anaesthetic intravenously, and the solution there was to incorporate a flutter valve. The snag with that is that you have to be quick to stop the flow once the bottle is empty, ot the air might go right on flowing into the veins, which is universally agreed to be a Bad Thing. The advantage of using a flexible container which collapses down is that no air is allowed in, and so once the bag is empty the flow will stop of its own accord. It's not GRAVITY you need to let in, Malcolm, it's AIR. But only if the container is rigid enough to allow a vacuum to form.]




No, Malcolm, most would call it explaining that I'm in a position to know what I'm talking about. Because, unlike you (but in common with a good dozen or so other posters here who are medics, nurses, paramedics, ambulance crew and so on, and who are all telling you the same thing), I have been trained to use the damn things, know how they work, and am experienced in actually using them.




Oh, Malcolm, don't try to move the goalposts. You said "no one remotely connected to medical work would hold up such a bag." We are telling you (and in SpitfireIX's case, eloquently showing you) that yes, they would. That the normal, usual, standard way of administering i/v fluids requires the bag to be elevated. Whether or not special add-ons are available that eliminate this necessity is not the point. The routine method requires the bag to be held up.




How long is a piece of string? Specifically, how long do you want it to take? Bags come in 500ml and 1000ml sizes, as standard. They're just bags of salty water, with a port where you can shove the sharp bit at the end of the giving set. It's the giving set that controls the rate. These things incorporate a "drip chamber" which you can see in several of Spitfire's pictures. This is a chamber with a little bit of air through which the fluid has to drip to get down the tube. (Another reason for not laying down the whole thing is it can mess up the operation of the drip chamber, which has to be more or less vertical to work properly.) The purpose of the drip chamber is to allow the flow rate of the fluid to be directly observed. You just count the number of drips falling in, say, 30 seconds or a minute, and that tells you how fast the fluid is flowing into the patient.

The flow rate is regulated by a little thumbwheel or similar device that is fitted to the tube below the drip chamber, and squeezes the tube more or less depending on how you adjust it. More squeeze, more resistance to flow, slower administration. Less squeeze, less resistance, faster flow. Just adjust to requirements, and count the rate the drops are falling to ensure you've got it right.

The size of the drop is determined by the diameter of the tubing entering the drip chamber. Most giving sets are rated at approximately 10 drops/ml. So, if you have a 500ml bag, that's 5000 drops. If you set the drip rate at a drop a second, that would be 5000 seconds, or an hour and 23 minutes. In hospitals, where the drip is often being used just as maintenance for patients on nil by mouth, you'll often see it a lot slower than that, maybe only a drop every three or four seconds. In that case it would take three or four times as long to empty the bag. But on the other hand in an emergency when fast replacement is required, you may set it much higher, even open the thumbwheel entirely, in which case the flow rate will depend on the resistance of the rest of the system - the tubing and the actual i/v catheter being used. MortFurd already explained it.




You can speed it up a bit in this situation by getting the bag as high as possible to increase the "head of water" so that this gravity thing you're having such trouble with will produce a faster flow.

Just LOOK AT SPITFIRE'S PICTURES. You can see the giving sets. You can see the drip chambers. The very name demonstrates that these things need to be approximately vertical to work as designed. The fluid is dripping DOWN into the patient by gravity.



:dl:

Malcolm, you just slay me. You had to want a Stundie awful bad to make this much of a fool of yourself.

Rolfe.

What on earth is a 'stundie'?
 
Ivor the Engineer: What are viable sources of gravity?
malcolm kirkman: Air pressure.

No, of course not. Such a statement would flunk you out of an elementary-school physics class. In fact, you have it almost exactly backwards. Air pressure, roughly 15 psi at sea level, is caused by the Earth's gravity, which pulls down on the air molecules - just like it attracts you or birds or your toast (buttered side down, of course). The result is that between you and space is a column of air that weighs about 15 lbs over every horizontal square inch at sea level.

That same air pressure squeezes on IV bags and squishes them down as they empty, preventing a vacuum from forming inside. (The vacuum would inhibit the flow of liquid because the air pressure (or patient's blood pressure) pushes back against the flow.) Rigid tanks like the water tanks you see on many buildings are vented to keep a vacuum from forming inside the tank for the same reason. The squishing in the first case, and the vents in the second case, don't "let gravity in"; if this was the case, things in a vacuum chamber would float (funk de fino already picked up on this) . If this was the case, you couldn't water your plants with a watering can, becuse the air pressure is the same around the can and the plants. Simple everyday observations refute this idea of yours.

Conversely, water must be pressurized to flow up. This water pressure can be supplied by pumps, by placing the water source high up (gravity feed again), or by using pressurized air as in a conventional water fire extinguisher. An IV can be supplied by any of these methods, but in the civilian world at least field IVs are almost always gravity-fed because gravity is available everywhere and never leaks or breaks. We've told you this from direct personal experience. Why can you not admit such a simple error of fact?

How many of those photos are staged?

Several of them are clearly publicity photos or public demos. The LA one is marked as a real incident, and the PG County photo is definitely from a real incident (trench collapse). Please don't attempt to handwave away visual evidence directly refuting your erroneous claim; much more can be supplied.

It would be mature of you to simply admit your error and defend the rest of your claims; no one would think less of you for it - actually, your stock would go up. In fact, since you seem quite sure you have so many ironclad arguments in your favor, why would it harm you to admit that you're wrong about such a minor one?
 
Here's another one. Gravity feed. 4.775mL per second. That's 1.75 minutes for 500mL.

Whether the toilet backs up when I block the air vent depends on whether there's another way for air to get into the system. Since there's more than one drain on the same down pipe, they'd suck air from some where else.

With an IV bag, the bag collapses as the liquid flows out. Great freaking crap, man. Your preconceptions are blinding you to reality.

Well with nothing to break the siphon you would pull the water out of the u-bend and get sewer gasses. It might cause a clog as you would not have water in the bowl when it would be used, so nothing in suspension
 
Meanwhile...

Let's just cut to the chase. I think we all can agree that the fact that someone is holding up an IV bag in a photo does not mean the photo was staged or faked.

Moving on...
 
These possibilities that you mention. You would have to take these into consideration before the event.

Yes, indeed, and the terrorists would have worked to minimise the risks.

Why take a chance when you have a proven trouble free option ready and waiting?

Begging the question. You're AGAIN assuming that those terrorists are government controlled.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom