[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Is the same true for a TV tube?
There's gravity inside a TV tube. There is no air in a TV tube.

TV tubes are sealed to prevent air getting in, not to keep gravity out.

Malcolm, I really think you need to stop. Every word you write makes your position worse.
 
Alright Jock, I'm a Macdonald myself.
Before we move off the topic. Tell me, if you were buying IV drips for the military.
Would you buy the ones that needed to be held up in the air or the ones that you could lay on the ground?
You will I'm sure, appreciate that you would take into account battlefield conditions.

*Sigh*

The military buys standard, gravity-fed IV bags.

Hell, I hold the EFMB (Expert Field Medical Badge) in the Army, one of the hardest badges to get. I know about the IVs the Army uses. They buy the regular, gravity-fed bags. I did have a pressure infusion pump in the aid bag (it's the thing that looks like a BP cuff). You slip the gravity-fed IV bag into the pump, squeeze the bulb to blow it up with air to the desired pressure (it has a pressure guage). BUt generally, you use gravity.

Heck, you can even verify my credentials. Look up the phone number for the 90th Reserve Readiness Command, North Little Rock, Arkansas. I say look up the number so you can be sure it's the right one. When you get ahold of them, ask them if they have a soldier named SGT Brister working in their G-6 shop. Then ask if he's got a secondary MOS as a medic. Heck, for that matter you can call the 489th Engineer Battalion (same base) and ask if a medic named SGT Brister went to Iraq with them in 2003.

For that matter, go to http://www.army.mil/usapa/doctrine/8_Series_Collection_1.html. This is the Army publications site, where you can download military training manuals. Look for STP 8-91W15-SM-TG, title SOLDIER'S MANUAL AND TRAINER'S GUIDE, MOS 91W, HEALTH CARE SPECIALIST, SKILL LEVELS 1/2/3/4/5. This is the training manual for military medics (basically the Army's EMTs and field medics, as well as filling roles of nurses aids, surgical assistants, lab techs, and others). You'll need to have someone who is actually in the military download the manual for you (it requires an AKO account). Look for Subject Area 5: Venipuncture and IV Therapy under Chapter 3 (MOS/Skill Level Tasks). Specifically, you're looking for task 081-833-0033: Initiate an Intravenous Infusion and 081-833-0034, manage a patient with an intravenous infusion. A few relevant quotes:

3. Prepare the equipment.
a. Clamp the tubing 6 to 8 inches below the drip chamber.
b. Remove the protective covers from the spike and from the outlet of the IV container.​
[FONT=Arial,Bold]
CAUTION:​
​
​
Do not touch the spike or the outlet of the IV container.
c. Insert the spike into the container.
(1) If using a bag, push the spike firmly into the container's outlet tube.
(2) If using a bottle, push the spike firmly through the container's diaphragm.
​

[FONT=Arial,Bold]
CAUTION:​
​
[/FONT]If no vacuum release sound is heard when puncturing bottled solution, discard the
solution. Bagged solution makes no vacuum release sound.
d. Hang the container at least 2 feet above the level of the patient's heart, if possible.
​

NOTE:​
​
​
An IV bag container may be placed under the patient's body if there is no way to hang
it.
e. Squeeze the drip chamber until it is half full of the IV fluid.
f. Prime the tubing.
​

NOTE:​
​
​
Ensure that all air is expelled from the tubing.
(1) Hold the tubing above the level of the bottom of the container.
(2) Loosen the protective cover from the needle adapter to allow the air to escape.
(3) Release the clamp on the tubing.
​

(4) Gradually lower the tubing until the solution reaches the end of the needle
adapter.
(5) Clamp the tubing.
(6) Retighten the needle adapter's protective cover.
(7) Loop the tubing over the IV stand or holder.​


[FONT=Arial,Bold]
CAUTION:
The old tubing is still connected to the catheter or needle. Use care to maintain
sterility. To prevent backflow of blood, keep the spike and tubing elevated.


You still haven't produced anything except your opinion to show that IV bags are not gravity fed, or need a "hole" for gravity to act.

Air pressure works against gravity. When you have a rigid container, it's the pressure of the air coming up through the bottom of the container that holds the contents in place against gravity. IV bags, however, are flexible. This means the air pressure around the IV bag can push the IV bag sides in with the same pressure as any air pushing up from the bottem, thus equalizing the internal and external air pressure. This leaves gravity as the only force acting on the bag, so the fluid falls.

If it's necesary for your thick-headedness, I'll make a video and/or picture sequence of me opening an IV bag, spiking it, and draining the fluid, with a bit to show how the gravity feed works. Heck, I can even give myself the IV and show you what happens when it's hung vs. when it's lowered.

You are wrong. VERY little research and a few google searches would have shown that. Unfortunately, you're too biased to even make the five-minute research required to show your claim is wrong. That's pathetic. Here you're trying to spread "truth" about what you believe to be a very dangerous, evil conspiracy to decieve the American public, something you claim is vitally important to know, yet you can't spend five minutes of your time researching to make sure you have the facts?

You are the same type of person who would still be imprisoning scientists for saying the Earth revolves around the Sun.
​

[/FONT][/FONT]
 
What on earth is a 'stundie'?

These are the Stundies. Named for a CTer who had a way with stupidity.

Your nominations start here.

These are awarded monthly. The July nominations close on 1 August, voting will run until the beginning of September. The winner of the July Stundie will be announced shortly thereafter.
 
Firstly, you have to agree that there is no technical difficulty in a remote controlled flight from Offutt hitting the twins.
There's quite a bit of technical difficulty. Engineering a system to do that would require the work of dozens, if not hundreds, of engineers, and more technicians to implement it.


Let me get this straight: Instead of acknowledging he was totally wrong about the IV bag and getting on with the subject at hand, malcolm continues insist he is right about the IV bag.
Just like he has done with so many other points that he's been proven wrong on. Remember how he stuck to the claim that "verb transitive" is correct?
 
I haven't finished with IV's, I've barely started. Kindly cast your considerable intellect upon the following;
1. Different types of IV bags.
Well, personally, the vast majority of IVs in use are the flexible plastic bag types. If you need a precise or forced flow, you either squeeze the bag (manually or with a pump) or hook that flexible bag to a pump. In rare occassions, glass bottles are used. This is only done if the medication, for whatever reason, would react with plastic. IIRC this is true of some chemotherapy drugs, but not a lot else.
2. The type the military would prefer.
The flexibla plastic kind. Glass would take up more room and is much more prone to breakage. The plastic bags are easier to store and carry, lighter than glass bottles, less likely to break, and can be pressurized (with a pump or simply by placing it under the patient's head) in those rare instances when it's needed. Otherwise, gravity fed is fine. You aren't going to be giving an IV while under direct fire...you ALWAYS get your patient to cover or a secure area before starting work. The bag only has to be a couple feet above the patient: a tree, bush, person holding it, or the butt of the M-16 driven bayonet first into the ground (Sorry MortFurd :) ) are all easily available battlefield options.
3. The type of establishment that is the Pentagon.
A military administrative headquarters, far from enemy frontlines.
4. The photos.
I see nothing wrong with them, can you be more specific?
5. No onebeingableto deny having seen the photos.
Um, okay.
6. The barrier that isn't.
No idea what this is about.
That should be enough to oil your wheels.
I can see a few of the brighter posters already heading for the hills.
I'm suprised you can see at all with that blindfold you're wearing.
 
Last edited:
I have told you before. Show me where the 'full' photo is and I will post it.
You cannot post photos from the NIST report.
Just give me the page No.


fig 3.8 on page 16 of the of the NIST pentagon building report

you posted a cropped version of this, you did not post the whole photograph

why was that?
 
Now that you are back, perhaps you will consider pole No.2?

Oh I was only away for a short holiday, and I caught up on the thread.

The reason I haven't posted much is that I don't comment on things I know bugger all about.

So as I haven't studied "pole No. 2" I'll leave that to those better qualified to put you right (because if your past record is anything to go by you will be wrong).

Dave
 
Tell me, if you were buying IV drips for the military.
Would you buy the ones that needed to be held up in the air or the ones that you could lay on the ground?


I heard about this but I didn't believe it.

Pressure-infusion IVs are of two types: 1) large battery-powered machines that look like this; or 2) smaller hand-pumped cuffs like this.

The large machine is more reliable. It's also more expensive and needs a power source. Also, and this is the fun part, the IV bag must still be hung above it because the pump is still fed by gravity.

The hand-pumped cuffs are less expensive but they are also less accurate and, in any case, are still far, far more expensive than just a plain plastic bag that works fine when held above the patient. An IV bag filled with 500 ml of dextrose solution is about seven bucks and probably a lot less when ordered in massive quantity. A pressure infusion cuff is eighty-five dollars. You are literally spending money for something the earth gives you for free.

Now, we could make jokes about the military paying twelve times too much for equipment, but let's not. If I were in military procurement, I'd probably want the most reliable equipment at the cheapest price. Plastic bags held above the patient are cheap and they work. I'm already paying the medic so I might as well have him hold the bag up as well. Once he's inside the ambulance, a small hook on the ceiling can take over the duties of holding the bag. Once at the hospital, an aluminum pole could probably do the job.

But there's another reason not to use pressure cuffs and lay the IV on the ground: it's dirty on the ground. With any traumatic wound, infection is a major worry. The ground is where all sorts of bacteria and bugs and nasty things live. Putting the bag in the air makes it just that much harder for infection to take hold.

Honestly - I have had five open-heart surgeries and plenty of other procedures to go with them. I've been taken by ambulance several times. I have never had anything but a gravity-fed IV in the ambulance. In the hospital, it has been gravity-fed eight times our of ten.

There has to be a local ambulance corps near you. Why don't you wander over on your lunch break and ask them?
 
At maximum flow, [I can't post URLs yet]these guys say a full 500mL bag will empty in from 2 to 2.5 minutes. A 1000mL bag will empty in 3.5 to 11.5 minutes. The actual maximum flow rate depends on the size of the tubing and the size of the needle inserted into the vein....
Bad example, Mort. They are discussing a pressure-fed IV in this abstract. Malcom seized on that:
Thanks for the term 'Pressure Infusion Devices'...
thinking he had scored a point. Unhappily for him, the rest of the abstract does not support his claim that gravity-fed IVs have gone the way of the dodo:
Rapid fluid resuscitation of hypovolemic casualties is necessary to prevent organ failure and death. Greater flow rates than can be achieved with gravity flow using conventional IV sets and large catheters is obtainable by two methods: use of large bore, multiple spike, rapid infusion sets, and use of pressure infusion devices. The latter are more desirable for the field because of their lack of dependence on gravity for operation. Ten commercially available pressure infusers were evaluated for their field applicability. Results (using lactated Ringer's) indicated a problem with pressure decay for inflatable bladder type infusers, which when used with a 14 gauge catheter emptied in 2-3.5 minutes (500 cc size) and 3.5-11.5 minutes (1000 cc size).
In other words, they are talking about using pressure-fed IVs instead of gravity-fed IVs, presumably because when you are moving someone on the battlefield you want to stay low and move real fast before you get shot. A pressure-fed IV you can just lay down on the patient is the ticket for that.

In the civilian EMS world, though, that's not generally a consideration. In urban, suburban, and most of the rural calls, there is no need to stay close to the ground and there is sufficient manpower for someone to hold up the IV when you move a patient. So it's much simpler and cheaper to take advantage of gravity feed, and you don't have to worry about a pump breaking or a pressure bladder leaking.

In other words, while the passage above was inapplicable for Mort's reply, it not only didn't support Malcolm's claim, it actually subverted it by explicitly acknowledging the existence of gravity-fed IVs. I've seen this sort of thing a lot when conspiracists and Apollo hoax-believers try to do a bit of quick quote-mining. Hint: malcolm, next time be sure to read all the passage and consider the context as well.

Why does a 'pressure infusion' bag need to be higher than the patient?

It doesn't. That's the point of using one in a combat EMS situation. An example of the modern U.S. military using an IV in a non-combat situation is at www (dot) army (dot) mil/calltoduty/508/slideshow/slide24.html. Gravity-fed.

I haven't finished with IV's, I've barely started. Kindly cast your considerable intellect upon the following;
1. Different types of IV bags.


Asked and answered.

2. The type the military would prefer.
3. The type of establishment that is the Pentagon.


An office building on steroids. Not an active combat zone, but rather a crash site with extensive collapse and fire involvement. Furthermore, the vast bulk of the fire/rescue/EMS response was from civil (non-military government) and civilian agencies.

4. The photos.
5. No onebeingableto deny having seen the photos.


The photo of some random guy holding up an IV bag? This demonstrates nothing, except he thought he was supposed to hold it up. Even if you were right about IV bags, this wouldn't constitute proof of a hoax - merely that this guy believed what most people believe about IV bags.

But in any case, you have had extensive testimony from actual medical providers (myself included), you have had direct photographic evidence presented to you, and you have had the physical and operational principles explained to you in great detail. Why, given your belief that you have so much going for your claim, are you unable to concede such a simple error of fact? Is your faith in your claim that brittle? Are you afraid you'll be ridiculed for admitting an error? Quite the contrary - being able to admit a mistake is a mark of maturity, and you would get credit for it.
 
Meanwhile...

Let's just cut to the chase. I think we all can agree that the fact that someone is holding up an IV bag in a photo does not mean the photo was staged or faked.

Moving on...


I'm afraid not.

I haven't finished with IV's, I've barely started. Kindly cast your considerable intellect upon the following;
1. Different types of IV bags.
2. The type the military would prefer.
3. The type of establishment that is the Pentagon....


Malcolm, you don't know anything about "different types of Roman Four i/v bags."

There are different makes, and different sizes, some are just polythene bags while others are very flimsy and collapsible shaped bottles (you can see both sorts in Spitfire's photo gallery), but they're all much the same. Just soft plastic containers of fluid with a port you spike the giving set into. And none of them has a BIG hole in the top.

What has mostly been discussed here are different types of delivery mechanism. There is quite a wide range of different sorts, designed for different purposes. Most of the bells and whistles are intended for use when there is a drug of some sort in the infusion, when you need more precision in rate of flow than you can get just by counting the drips in the drip chamber of an ordinary giving set. These are pumps that you can attach to the tubing and calibrate. They offer no advantage for simple fluid replacement and I'd take a very large bet you'll not find any emergency response kit stocked with that sort of thing.

There are also, as has been described by other posters, mechanisms for forcing the fluid into a very hyopvolaemic patient at pressures greater than simple gravity feed. These might be appropriate for an emergency response team to carry, but they would not be used on every casualty even if they were there - only on someone for whom very fast restoration of circulating volume was a life-or-death matter. The reason for this is that you can potentially do harm by forcing fluid into someone at that sort of rate, and so you'd avoid the risk whenever possible. (I'm not familiar with using these things, so I'll let Huntsman be the arbiter here, but I suspect you still probably want to have the bag above the patient even if you have a pressure cuff on it.)

Now let's just recall your original claims.

Those bags are mildly pressurised and will work equally well above or below the patient. Holding high such bags was for films and TV only. That was twenty five years ago. What do you think I thought when I first saw the bagman?

What do you think every doctor, nurse, medic, paramedic etc in the world will also think when they see that?


Nothing here about any special system that the military would prefer, just that every doctor, nurse, medic or paramedic in the world would know that bags weren't held up in real scenarios these days.

No one remotely connected to medical work, would hold up such a bag.


Again, nothing about any special system, just that "no one remotely connected to medical work" would hold up a bag.

Emergency teams don't use infusion pumps on casualties on stretchers. Infusion pumps are for infusions that have drugs in them that need to be delivered at a more precise rate than an ordinary giving set will provide. An ordinary giving set is absolutely adequate for simple fluid replacement in casualty situations. And has the advantage of being simple, non-powered, and easy to store.

If forced fluid administration is required one might use some sort of pressure system, if it was available, but one would only use that if the casualty was dangerously hypovolaemic, not as a routine.

So, Malcolm, there's no mileage in trying to elicit the existence of "pressurised systems" and then claim that the military would always use these because they're better. That's complete nonsense. The military will treat a routine casualty the same as an ambulance crew would treat a routine casualty. And fluid replacement would be by ordinary giving set. This is so standard that, while variations might possibly be encountered in particular circumstances, it's the variations that would excite remark and possibly questioning among medically-knowledgeable people, not the standard method.

Which is what these photos show. The standard procedure. In that case apparently showing a passer-by (in civvies) having been asked to "hold that up there for a moment, will you?" by a paramedic who was running out of hands.

You were even claiming a minute ago that such a system couldn't work, because it didn't have a BIG hole in it to let gravity in. Now where are you? Are you agreeing that this is the standard system, but just deciding that you think the military would have used something different? Or are you still taking the position that the fluid won't flow out of a soft plastic bag because it hasn't got a BIG hole in it?

Rolfe.
 
This IV discussion is ridiculous. Just tonight, my father had chest pains and I called an ambulence. In our town, the EMTs are firefighters too and they were a little shorthanded because of a bad accident on the local freeway. I held up the freaken' bag myself until they got the pole thing set up. The bag is always elevated, whether by hand or on a hook. Hasn't pretty much everybody witnessed this at one time or another in a hospital or vets office?




How would this alleged Offutt option be "proven and trouble free" when it had never been done before and if done this way, would open up an enormous amount of holes in the supposed "cover story" and add significant numbers to the legion of accomplices that would need to be kept quiet?

You're only presuming Offutt to be some easy answer because you have chosen who you want the prime suspects to be and are now scrambling to make a theory fit with that. It doesn't work that way. You have to follow the evidence and the evidence will lead to your suspects and theories.

The mass of evidence tells us that Al Qaeda has been plotting against US interests as an entity since 1989, with them merging with Egyptian Islamic Jihad and the hybrid organization declaring war on the US and Israel in 1996. They have engineered dozens of attacks over the last nearly two decades. The September 11 attacks bear all the hallmarks of an Al Qaeda attack, including: meticulous planning (provided perhaps most prominantly by Ramzi Yousef and Khalid Sheik Mohammad), coordinated hits on at least two targets within minutes of each other, the choosing of highly symbolic targets to attack, and suicide attackers who spent time training in Afghanistan and left behind mission statements and/or "martyr" videos intending the whole world to see them. Oh yeah, and they also confessed once they got busted.
KSM (Khalid Sheik Mohammad) has admitted to everything from kidnapping Lindburgh's baby to shooting JFK. So would you if you'd been waterboarded a couple of times.
Yours is a serious case of misinformation. You are in need of an immediate intensive course of THE TRUTH.
I will include a number of sites to show I'm telling you the truth. If there is anything you need further and better details on, then I'll post them.
People say 9/11 wa an inside job. It's another name for a false flag operation.
For example Hitler set fire to the german parliament building so that he could declare himself a dictator. There are many examples, I will post the Gulf of Tonkin and the USS Liberty.
Bankers first and foremost are moneylenders. They love war. They land both sides money for bullets, then when the war is over, they lend both sides money for bricks to rebuild. Britain has just finished paying off the debts incurred in the Crimean War 1853 -1856.
On the eve of WW1, Mimi Rothschilde said,
"If my sons don't want war, then there'll be no war". Her sons being the major bankers.
This is but an intro. I recommend that you listen to Alex Jones on a daily basis, in order to get yourself brought up to speed.
You can tune in to his three hour rollover anytime, you'll find it here,
press either 'mainstream' or 'low bandwidth', you'll get it on either channel.
http://www.infowars.com/
The Gulf of Tonkin here,
http://www.fair.org/index.php?page=2261
The USS Liberty here,
http://www.whatreallyhappened.com/ussliberty.html
There's no shortage of stuff where these came from.
 
I'm not even going to ask you what a "pressure infusion Roman Four i/v" is. I'm going to concentrate on your actual claim. First time you said:




You followed this up with:




In relation to this claim it is entirely irrelevant whether or not some nifty bit of kit exists that might eliminate the need to elevate the bag. Your claim is that the whole idea of elevating the bags is so out of date, so 1950s, that nobody would even dream of doing it in 2001. You state that nobody with any medical knowledge would do such a thing, and anyone with medical knowledge would peg the photo as a fake because of that.

Now what do people with actual medical knowledge say?




You called that doctor's explanation "24 carat nonsense" (then spouted an example of same yourself).




And another medical professional replied to that:




Your only response was that I was "throwing my qualifications about", and "attempting to win an argument by demanding respect from a position of elitism."




Your response was


This definitely persuades me that we shouldn't let this one go until Malcolm has acknowledged his error (like with Bush and the photoshoots with primary school children), or actually digs so far he emerges to join Zep in Sydney.




I can't yet find an answer to this other than "Join the rest of the drip feeds."

How many people with medical knowledge do you need to tell you you're wrong?

How about a few people with recent experience as patients or patients' relatives?




And another:




And that's just on this thread.

Over in the parts of the forum you never visit, there's another thread just laughing its socks off at you, Malcolm.

A few selected excerpts:










There's also SpitfireIX's gallery of seven photographs of patients on stretchers receiving i/v fluids, and in every single case someone is holding the bag up.




Malcolm, it matters not if there is in existence, somewhere, some sort of mechanism that may allow the administration of i/v fluids without any necessity for the fluid reservoir to be held or secured above the patient. The fact is that common standard practice does it that way, no medically knowledgeable person finds such a scenario in the least bit unusual, and you have been shown plenty examples.

It has also been explained to you how the damn things work, and why there is no need either for any BIG hole to let the gravity in.

:crazy:

Now will you agree that you made a mistake, and that the picture of the casualty is plausible, and move on?

Rolfe.
Does common standard practise hold sway on a battlefield.
A straightforward yes or no will suffice.
 
Malcolm, I've had you on ignore since shortly after we first met, but I just wanted to pipe in here and say that your continuing argument about IV bags and gravity is the single most unusual argument that I've come across on the internet. Please click this Google image search and see many pages of images of IV bags and holders. In every case the bag is held above the patient. In every case a source of gravity is provided: the universe. That's all. Best wishes.

http://images.google.com/images?q=iv+bag
You keep coming and going. Maybe that's the butterfly in you.
Stick around, watch a spider at work.
 
The plastic bag experiment is a perfect model of a normal IV bag. IV bags are nothing more than sterile plastic bags with a hole on one end where stuff runs out.
Allow me to introduce you to Rolfe, you two will get along like a house on fire.
 
OK, I said I'd leave Huntsman to be the arbiter of this.

Well, personally, the vast majority of IVs in [military] use are the flexible plastic bag types. .... The plastic bags are easier to store and carry, lighter than glass bottles, less likely to break, and can be pressurized (with a pump or simply by placing it under the patient's head) in those rare instances when it's needed. Otherwise, gravity fed is fine. You aren't going to be giving an IV while under direct fire...you ALWAYS get your patient to cover or a secure area before starting work. The bag only has to be a couple feet above the patient: a tree, bush, person holding it, or the butt of the M-16 driven bayonet first into the ground (Sorry MortFurd ) are all easily available battlefield options.


He even posts a quote from the military training manual explaining how to set the damn thing up.

By the way, there's a bit of that which might give you a small clue about holes in bags (or the absence of them), Malcolm.

If no vacuum release sound is heard when puncturing bottled solution, discard the solution. Bagged solution makes no vacuum release sound.


However, as sts60 noted, the publication MortFurd linked to was actually talking about something different.

Rapid fluid resuscitation of hypovolemic casualties is necessary to prevent organ failure and death. Greater flow rates than can be achieved with gravity flow using conventional IV sets and large catheters is obtainable by two methods: use of large bore, multiple spike, rapid infusion sets, and use of pressure infusion devices. The latter are more desirable for the field because of their lack of dependence on gravity for operation. Ten commercially available pressure infusers were evaluated for their field applicability. Results (using lactated Ringer's) indicated a problem with pressure decay for inflatable bladder type infusers, which when used with a 14 gauge catheter emptied in 2-3.5 minutes (500 cc size) and 3.5-11.5 minutes (1000 cc size).


Interesting, now I've read it all, this does seem to be advocating the use of a pressurised system as standard in military field conditions. (I thought the bag emptying rates quoted were awfully fast!) They are making a case. However, have they persuaded the top brass to their point of view? Clearly not, from what Huntsman has told us.

That publication is dated 1989, but it's perfectly clear that the equipment being evaluated is not standard issue for the military even now, and it's certainly not standard issue for civilian ambulances. The existence of such a system, and even its having had a positive recommendation in 1989, does not immediately prove that the chance of a gravity-feed i/v being used in 2001 is so remote that any picture purporting to show such a thing must be a fake. Ordinary gravity-fed giving sets are still standard, and it is any variation from these that would be regarded as comment-worthy by people with medical knowledge, not their use. Sorry.

And since it's appeared, I'll just tag this one on.

Does common standard practise hold sway on a battlefield.
A straightforward yes or no will suffice.


What battlefield? Were you on a battlefield 25 years ago when you said you were told not to hold up a drip bag? (Assuming you were even born 25 years ago, which I have some doubts about.) Was the grass next to the Pentagon in 2001 a place that was likely to be equipped as a battlefield? (Other posters have pointed out that it's just a big office building. A bit like the way the BMA headquarters wasn't equipped with anything at all when the 7/7 terrorists blew up a bus right outside the door, and the specialists in there at a meeting had to wait for the ambulance crews to arrive to get the gear they needed.)

MortFurd unknowingly pointed to an old recommendation that pressure-fed devices should be considered for military use in the field. However, Huntsman has demonstrated that this recommendation wasn't implemented, or at least not universally.

You have claimed that gravity-fed systems are so obsolete that scenes of their use are all staged for dramatic or publicity purposes, and that anyone with any medical knowledge would realise this. This claim has been blown out of the water so often by now it's unrecognisable.

The existence of something that doesn't need elevation, which doesn't seem to have achieved widespread use, really doesn't change a thing Malcolm.

Rolfe.
 
Meanwhile...

Let's just cut to the chase. I think we all can agree that the fact that someone is holding up an IV bag in a photo does not mean the photo was staged or faked.

Moving on...
Regarding the IV bag.The row would end in a stalemate. I would be contending that the military buy in bulk. That they would only buy IV bags that didn't have to be held up in the air, because medics in the field would get shot, to say nothing of the bag getting ripped to shreds.
I didn'texpect the wholesale attack from all sides, but there you go, the pack mentality at work when it smells blood. I tried to shorten the matter by collecting all the 'drip feeds' in one lot, but that hasn't worked and I can see the matter rolling on interminably.
Next would come an admission that all had to have seen the photos and something that no one could argue about, namely the grass barrier being painted out.
Would you care to address the grass and the barrier.
It's here,
kindly forego any comments about Jack White. These are govt photos.
http://www.911studies.com/911photostudies5.htm
 
Yes, indeed, and the terrorists would have worked to minimise the risks.



Begging the question. You're AGAIN assuming that those terrorists are government controlled.

These so called 'terrorists' were part of the cover story. Don't pretend you don't know all about them going to Officer's Clubs etc.
 
There's gravity inside a TV tube. There is no air in a TV tube.

TV tubes are sealed to prevent air getting in, not to keep gravity out.

Malcolm, I really think you need to stop. Every word you write makes your position worse.
Your first sentence is incorrect.
 
*Sigh*

The military buys standard, gravity-fed IV bags.

Hell, I hold the EFMB (Expert Field Medical Badge) in the Army, one of the hardest badges to get. I know about the IVs the Army uses. They buy the regular, gravity-fed bags. I did have a pressure infusion pump in the aid bag (it's the thing that looks like a BP cuff). You slip the gravity-fed IV bag into the pump, squeeze the bulb to blow it up with air to the desired pressure (it has a pressure guage). BUt generally, you use gravity.

Heck, you can even verify my credentials. Look up the phone number for the 90th Reserve Readiness Command, North Little Rock, Arkansas. I say look up the number so you can be sure it's the right one. When you get ahold of them, ask them if they have a soldier named SGT Brister working in their G-6 shop. Then ask if he's got a secondary MOS as a medic. Heck, for that matter you can call the 489th Engineer Battalion (same base) and ask if a medic named SGT Brister went to Iraq with them in 2003.

For that matter, go to http://www.army.mil/usapa/doctrine/8_Series_Collection_1.html. This is the Army publications site, where you can download military training manuals. Look for STP 8-91W15-SM-TG, title SOLDIER'S MANUAL AND TRAINER'S GUIDE, MOS 91W, HEALTH CARE SPECIALIST, SKILL LEVELS 1/2/3/4/5. This is the training manual for military medics (basically the Army's EMTs and field medics, as well as filling roles of nurses aids, surgical assistants, lab techs, and others). You'll need to have someone who is actually in the military download the manual for you (it requires an AKO account). Look for Subject Area 5: Venipuncture and IV Therapy under Chapter 3 (MOS/Skill Level Tasks). Specifically, you're looking for task 081-833-0033: Initiate an Intravenous Infusion and 081-833-0034, manage a patient with an intravenous infusion. A few relevant quotes:




You still haven't produced anything except your opinion to show that IV bags are not gravity fed, or need a "hole" for gravity to act.

Air pressure works against gravity. When you have a rigid container, it's the pressure of the air coming up through the bottom of the container that holds the contents in place against gravity. IV bags, however, are flexible. This means the air pressure around the IV bag can push the IV bag sides in with the same pressure as any air pushing up from the bottem, thus equalizing the internal and external air pressure. This leaves gravity as the only force acting on the bag, so the fluid falls.

If it's necesary for your thick-headedness, I'll make a video and/or picture sequence of me opening an IV bag, spiking it, and draining the fluid, with a bit to show how the gravity feed works. Heck, I can even give myself the IV and show you what happens when it's hung vs. when it's lowered.

You are wrong. VERY little research and a few google searches would have shown that. Unfortunately, you're too biased to even make the five-minute research required to show your claim is wrong. That's pathetic. Here you're trying to spread "truth" about what you believe to be a very dangerous, evil conspiracy to decieve the American public, something you claim is vitally important to know, yet you can't spend five minutes of your time researching to make sure you have the facts?

You are the same type of person who would still be imprisoning scientists for saying the Earth revolves around the Sun.[/LEFT]
[/SIZE]
[/SIZE][/FONT][/SIZE][/FONT][/FONT]
A most comprehensive reply and I will concede the point to your greater knowledge.
Would you now kindly consider the point I was leading to, which is to consider the question of the grass and the barrier,
http://www.911studies.com/911photostudies5.htm
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom