[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
See that big round thing the building your room is in is sitting on? No, the bigger one. No, no, the really, really, really big one. Next, take out the inverse squared law of universal gravitation. Lastly, take the values for the mass and radius of that really, really, really big round thing and, tada, 9.822 m/s2
9.8 m/s2 is acceleration due to gravity, ta ta.
 
Ok malcolm, this may be difficult to follow, but I want you to look down. Underneath your feet, there is a giant, and I mean truly massive, thing called Planet Earth.

It's so big that it generates a gravitational field capable of doing all sorts of amazing things such as holding you in the chair you are most likely sitting while you post here.

That gravitational field is even strong enough to power an IV drip.
Does that include a pressure infusion IV?
 
ignoring my posts regarding photos is not backing me into a corner

i will not argue with any man who says you need a "source of gravity"

if you were in a vacum sealed room would you float off and hit the roof because the source of gravity cannot get to you?

have you ever siphoned petrol from a car malcolm

why do you have to suck the petrol through the hose to start with?

if you go underneath your car and make a hole in the bottom of it would it spill out?

gravity is always there malcolm it does not come and go depending on holes

i am speechless at your ignorance of gravity

in fact you are 100% a plant and you are truly a genius one at that

hats off gravity boy
I pay for my petrol.
 
Thanks for the term 'Pressure Infusion Devices'.
I suggest that you conduct the experiment that I outlined in post 3063.
I suggest that you stay inside.
Here's another one. Gravity feed. 4.775mL per second. That's 1.75 minutes for 500mL.

Whether the toilet backs up when I block the air vent depends on whether there's another way for air to get into the system. Since there's more than one drain on the same down pipe, they'd suck air from some where else.

With an IV bag, the bag collapses as the liquid flows out. Great freaking crap, man. Your preconceptions are blinding you to reality.
 
No one remotely connected to medical work, would hold up such a bag.



:hb:

I think that says it all, really. And no, you can't brush off that lot by claiming that the photos were "staged".

Talking about having a pee, pressure is applied.


Not necessarily. But if that wasn't a perfect analogy, then what about the other one. Ever used an ordinary rubber hot water bottle, Malcolm? Ever emptied it? Just take such a hot water bottle, the morning after the night before, unscrew the cap, and invert. Does the water magically stay there if you don't put any pressure on it?

Where is that pressure applied on a sealed bag?

The bag is sealed. Air pressure won't empty it any different three feet from the ground or six feet from the ground.


The only way sealing a container will prevent it from emptying is if the container is rigid. (Like, for example, a toilet stack if the outlet pipe is blocked.) You can use this property to measure atmospheric pressure, and surely you did this at school. Atmospheric pressure is measured as how high a column of mercury can be supported under a vacuum. Mercury is used because it is heavy, but water behaves the same way - it's just less practical as you'd need a column many feet high.

But this DEPENDS ON THE CONTAINER NOT BEING ABLE TO COLLAPSE.

If the container is flexible, like a hot water bottle or a plastic bag, no vacuum can form above the departing liquid, because the air pressure on the outside simply allows the bag to collapse leaving no dead space. This is why flexible bags or thin polythene bottles are used when one wants the contents to flow freely out.

[You can use a rigid bottle, and they used to use rigid bottles back in the dim and distant past - think MASH - but these required some way of letting AIR in, to prevent the vacuum forming and allow the fluid to flow. I've used such bottles for administering chloral hydrate anaesthetic intravenously, and the solution there was to incorporate a flutter valve. The snag with that is that you have to be quick to stop the flow once the bottle is empty, ot the air might go right on flowing into the veins, which is universally agreed to be a Bad Thing. The advantage of using a flexible container which collapses down is that no air is allowed in, and so once the bag is empty the flow will stop of its own accord. It's not GRAVITY you need to let in, Malcolm, it's AIR. But only if the container is rigid enough to allow a vacuum to form.]

You're throwing your 'qualifications' about. I daresay some one here would call it an 'argument from authority'.

I call it attempting to win an arguement by demanding respect from a position of elitism.

Now you knowwhat I think of elitists.


No, Malcolm, most would call it explaining that I'm in a position to know what I'm talking about. Because, unlike you (but in common with a good dozen or so other posters here who are medics, nurses, paramedics, ambulance crew and so on, and who are all telling you the same thing), I have been trained to use the damn things, know how they work, and am experienced in actually using them.

So you and I will hammer this one out between us.

1. Are all IV bags gravity fed?


Oh, Malcolm, don't try to move the goalposts. You said "no one remotely connected to medical work would hold up such a bag." We are telling you (and in SpitfireIX's case, eloquently showing you) that yes, they would. That the normal, usual, standard way of administering i/v fluids requires the bag to be elevated. Whether or not special add-ons are available that eliminate this necessity is not the point. The routine method requires the bag to be held up.

2. How long does it take to empty such a bag. Bearing in mind the varying rates of drip. What would be the average time for such a bag to empty?


How long is a piece of string? Specifically, how long do you want it to take? Bags come in 500ml and 1000ml sizes, as standard. They're just bags of salty water, with a port where you can shove the sharp bit at the end of the giving set. It's the giving set that controls the rate. These things incorporate a "drip chamber" which you can see in several of Spitfire's pictures. This is a chamber with a little bit of air through which the fluid has to drip to get down the tube. (Another reason for not laying down the whole thing is it can mess up the operation of the drip chamber, which has to be more or less vertical to work properly.) The purpose of the drip chamber is to allow the flow rate of the fluid to be directly observed. You just count the number of drips falling in, say, 30 seconds or a minute, and that tells you how fast the fluid is flowing into the patient.

The flow rate is regulated by a little thumbwheel or similar device that is fitted to the tube below the drip chamber, and squeezes the tube more or less depending on how you adjust it. More squeeze, more resistance to flow, slower administration. Less squeeze, less resistance, faster flow. Just adjust to requirements, and count the rate the drops are falling to ensure you've got it right.

The size of the drop is determined by the diameter of the tubing entering the drip chamber. Most giving sets are rated at approximately 10 drops/ml. So, if you have a 500ml bag, that's 5000 drops. If you set the drip rate at a drop a second, that would be 5000 seconds, or an hour and 23 minutes. In hospitals, where the drip is often being used just as maintenance for patients on nil by mouth, you'll often see it a lot slower than that, maybe only a drop every three or four seconds. In that case it would take three or four times as long to empty the bag. But on the other hand in an emergency when fast replacement is required, you may set it much higher, even open the thumbwheel entirely, in which case the flow rate will depend on the resistance of the rest of the system - the tubing and the actual i/v catheter being used. MortFurd already explained it.

At maximum flow, these guys say a full 500mL bag will empty in from 2 to 2.5 minutes. A 1000mL bag will empty in 3.5 to 11.5 minutes. The actual maximum flow rate depends on the size of the tubing and the size of the needle inserted into the vein.


You can speed it up a bit in this situation by getting the bag as high as possible to increase the "head of water" so that this gravity thing you're having such trouble with will produce a faster flow.

Just LOOK AT SPITFIRE'S PICTURES. You can see the giving sets. You can see the drip chambers. The very name demonstrates that these things need to be approximately vertical to work as designed. The fluid is dripping DOWN into the patient by gravity.

Or are you all bark and no bite.

:dl:

Malcolm, you just slay me. You had to want a Stundie awful bad to make this much of a fool of yourself.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
.....About 25 years ago, I picked up an IV bag and held it high, to be immediately ordered to put it back on the stretcher. I mentioned the need to hold the bag higher that the patient and was laughed at. Gravity feed had gone out years before. Those bags are mildly pressurised and will work equally well above or below the patient. Holding high such bags was for films and TV only. That was twenty five years ago. What do you think I thought when I first saw the bagman?
.....
I think you are an idiot or so burdened by your prejudices towards anything related to 9/11 that you can not think straight.

A collapsible IV bag only needs to be elevated above the vein and have the pinch clamp open to flow into the vein. That is all there is to it, very simple. No vent into the top of the bag is needed because the bag is very flexible and collapses as it empties into the vein. A bag of IV fluid can be run into the patient within less than ten minutes, but his/her arm may feel chilled, and some medications can actually cause pain or injury going in that fast. To stop flow, all you need to do is close the clamp or lower the bag. If the bag is lowered, then blood may run back into the tube and clot, so it is best to keep the drip running slowly in.

Sometimes medications are run in using a small pump that meters the flow, you may have heard of morphine pumps that a patient can use to regulate the amount of pain reliever they receive.

How do I know this? I am not a doctor or any kind of medical professional. I have been a patient several times at hospitals and required these kinds of IV's several times in the past.

You should try getting out into the world someday, or at least try to learn something before making a fool of yourself online. Good luck.

Ranb
 
I'm..I'm speechless. this...this isn't even...dangit man WHAT WERE YOU THINKING WHEN YOU TYPED THIS?!? sorry...sorry. I mean, all caps, bad form, I know but, seeing this typed out. just...wow.

I mean, is it in your mind set that gravity is somehow not effecting the IV bag? Like that line about there needing to be a hole in the bag TO LET THE GRAVITY IN? (That quote, for those of you just tuning in, was )

But none the less, I'm gonna help you. My guess is you're confused about Air Pressure, not gravity. It's moot in the case of IV bags, because they collapse as the liquid drains out. Also, it's not how high above the ground the IV bag is - it only has to be higher than the patient.

Anyway, that was not pole number 2 in the previously referenced photographs, and you can't seal gravity out of a bag by closing it.
Is the same true for a TV tube?
 
I pay for my petrol.

Excellent example (once again) of one-dimensional thinking, Malcolm. It's indicative of the basic problem with your entire argument: you cannot conceive of there being more than one reason for...well, much of anything, really.


I've siphoned gas from my own car, to put in my lawnmower.
(That's a machine that one uses to cut grass.)

I've siphoned gas from my own car to put in our other car, in a pinch.
I've siphoned gas from my own car to prime a carburetor.
I've siphoned gas from my own car to kill fire ants. They hate that.

Aside from all that, however, is the fact that your reply doesn't address the point being made. In fact, your reply missed the mark completely. Try again.
 
24 carat nonsense. In order for gravity to work, you need a source of GRAVITY.

Yes, and we call it the Earth, Malcolm.

If you guys were really 'cool' sceptics, taking a pride in taking apart all claims. How come you're all so avidly pro the OCT or is it the Banksters you really support?

Begging the question of whether those evil bankers exist.

The plane cut across the Reagan approach paths, safe in the knowledge that all other planes were on the ground. Did a lazy left up the Potoman, safe in the knowledge that you don't get a lot of people on the Potomac on a cold september tuesday morning when everybody is at work. In any event should someone surface with such a claim. How long would it take to rub that person out. As Trentadue's brother was rubbed out whilst in custody.
My fingers are tingling.

Malcolm. You're not very good at this. I asked you where the plane went. You have an explosion at the Pengaton and a plane that's almost at ground level. At the speed it's going, thousands of people are going to have a VERY close look at a 757 on its way back up. So WHERE did it go that nobody saw it leave the area ?

Then you're landing at Dulles. Where Mrs Booth will be added to the list of 'passengers' for putting two and two together.

Speculation.

Now, how about you answer my other points ?
 
Dear Malcolm Kirkman,

Can you not clearly see that we actually get paid by the Bush administration to refute your claim?

Kind regards,

Bruce Jongejans
If I was paying you I would want my money back.
 
Talking about having a pee, pressure is applied.
Where is that pressure applied on a sealed bag?
The bag is sealed. Air pressure won't empty it any different three feet from the ground or six feet from the ground.
You're throwing your 'qualifications' about. I daresay some one here would call it an 'argument from authority'.
I call it attempting to win an arguement by demanding respect from a position of elitism.
Now you knowwhat I think of elitists.
So you and I will hammer this one out between us.
1. Are all IV bags gravity fed?
2. How long does it take to empty such a bag. Bearing in mind the varying rates of drip. What would be the average time for such a bag to empty?
Or are you all bark and no bite.

Malcolm, GO TO A DAMN HOSPITAL and ask them.

Why do you keep having beliefs that fly in the face of reality ? What is it with you ?
 
this is the one that you avoided my question on about the molten metal and then referenced your cropped photo

you were never pinned down you wriggled out and ignored

post the full photograph and we can all look at it again
I have told you before. Show me where the 'full' photo is and I will post it.
You cannot post photos from the NIST report.
Just give me the page No.
 
Here's another one. Gravity feed. 4.775mL per second. That's 1.75 minutes for 500mL.

Whether the toilet backs up when I block the air vent depends on whether there's another way for air to get into the system. Since there's more than one drain on the same down pipe, they'd suck air from some where else.

With an IV bag, the bag collapses as the liquid flows out. Great freaking crap, man. Your preconceptions are blinding you to reality.
Don't go away.
 
Psst... Malcolm... I'd drop the IV angle... that grave is already deep enough to take your entire family crypt. Move discussion to something that doesn't make you look like a 3-year-old? Hmm?
Alright Jock, I'm a Macdonald myself.
Before we move off the topic. Tell me, if you were buying IV drips for the military.
Would you buy the ones that needed to be held up in the air or the ones that you could lay on the ground?
You will I'm sure, appreciate that you would take into account battlefield conditions.
 
:hb:

I think that says it all, really. And no, you can't brush off that lot by cliaming that the photos were "staged".




Not necessarily. But if that wasn't a perfect analogy, then what about the other one. Ever used an ordinary rubber hot water bottle, Malcolm? Ever emptied it? Just take such a hot water bottle, the morning after the night before, unscrew the cap, and invert. Does the water magically stay there if you don't put any pressure on it?




The only way sealing a container will prevent it from emptying is if the container is rigid. (Like, for example, a toilet stack if the outlet pipe is blocked.) You can use this property to measure atmospheric pressure, and surely you did this at school. Atmospheric pressure is measured as how high a column of mercury can be supported under a vacuum. Mercury is used because it is heavy, but water behaves the same way - it's just less practical as you'd need a column many feet high.

But this DEPENDS ON THE CONTAINER NOT BEING ABLE TO COLLAPSE.

If the container is flexible, like a hot water bottle or a plastic bag, no vacuum can form above the departing liquid, because the air pressure on the outside simply allows the bag to collapse leaving no dead space. This is why flexible bags or thin polythene bottles are used when one wants the contents to flow freely out.

[You can use a rigid bottle, and they used to use rigid bottles back in the dim and distant past - think MASH - but these required some way of letting AIR in, to prevent the vacuum forming and allow the fluid to flow. I've used such bottles for administering chloral hydrate anaesthetic intravenously, and the solution there was to incorporate a flutter valve. The snag with that is that you have to be quick to stop the flow once the bottle is empty, ot the air might go right on flowing into the veins, which is universally agreed to be a Bad Thing. The advantage of using a flexible container which collapses down is that no air is allowed in, and so once the bag is empty the flow will stop of its own accord. It's not GRAVITY you need to let in, Malcolm, it's AIR. But only if the container is rigid enough to allow a vacuum to form.]




No, Malcolm, most would call it explaining that I'm in a position to know what I'm talking about. Because, unlike you (but in common with a good dozen or so other posters here who are medics, nurses, paramedics, ambulance crew and so on, and who are all telling you the same thing), I have been trained to use the damn things, know how they work, and am experienced in actually using them.




Oh, Malcolm, don't try to move the goalposts. You said "no one remotely connected to medical work would hold up such a bag." We are telling you (and in SpitfireIX's case, eloquently showing you) that yes, they would. That the normal, usual, standard way of administering i/v fluids requires the bag to be elevated. Whether or not special add-ons are available that eliminate this necessity is not the point. The routine method requires the bag to be held up.




How long is a piece of string? Specifically, how long do you want it to take? Bags come in 500ml and 1000ml sizes, as standard. They're just bags of salty water, with a port where you can shove the sharp bit at the end of the giving set. It's the giving set that controls the rate. These things incorporate a "drip chamber" which you can see in several of Spitfire's pictures. This is a chamber with a little bit of air through which the fluid has to drip to get down the tube. (Another reason for not laying down the whole thing is it can mess up the operation of the drip chamber, which has to be vertical to work properly.) The purpose of the drip chamber is to allow the flow rate of the fluid to be directly observed. You just count the number of drips falling in, say, 30 seconds or a minute, and that tells you how fast the fluid is flowing into the patient.

The flow rate is regulated by a little thumbwheel or similar device that is fitted to the tube below the drip chamber, and squeezes the tube more or less depending on how you adjust it. More squeeze, more resistance to flow, slower administration. Less squeeze, less resistance, faster flow. Just adjust to requirements, and count the rate the drops are falling to ensure you've got it right.

The size of the drop is determined by the diameter of the tubing entering the drip chamber. Most giving sets are rated at approximately 10 drops/ml. So, if you have a 500ml bag, that's 5000 drops. If you set the drip rate at a drop a second, that would be 5000 seconds, or an hour and 23 minutes. In hospitals, where the drip is often being used just as maintenance for patients on nil by mouth, you'll often see it a lot slower than that, maybe only a drop every three or four seconds. In that case it would take three or four times as long to empty the bag. But on the other hand in an emergency when fast replacement is required, you may set it much higher, even open the thumbwheel entirely, in which case the flow rate will depend on the resistance of the rest of the system - the tubing and the actual i/v catheter being used. MortFurd already explained it.




You can speed it up a bit in this situation by getting the bag as high as possible to increase the "head of water" so that this gravity thing you're having such trouble with will produce a faster flow.

Just LOOK AT SPITFIRE'S PICTURES. You can see the giving sets. You can see the drip chambers. The very name demonstrates that these things need to be approximately vertical to work as designed. The fluid is dripping DOWN into the patient by gravity.



:dl:

Malcolm, you just slay me. You had to want a Stundie awful bad to make this much of a fool of yourself.

Rolfe.
Allow me to refer you to my previous post (to Floyt).
 
I think you are an idiot or so burdened by your prejudices towards anything related to 9/11 that you can not think straight.

A collapsible IV bag only needs to be elevated above the vein and have the pinch clamp open to flow into the vein. That is all there is to it, very simple. No vent into the top of the bag is needed because the bag is very flexible and collapses as it empties into the vein. A bag of IV fluid can be run into the patient within less than ten minutes, but his/her arm may feel chilled, and some medications can actually cause pain or injury going in that fast. To stop flow, all you need to do is close the clamp or lower the bag. If the bag is lowered, then blood may run back into the tube and clot, so it is best to keep the drip running slowly in.

Sometimes medications are run in using a small pump that meters the flow, you may have heard of morphine pumps that a patient can use to regulate the amount of pain reliever they receive.

How do I know this? I am not a doctor or any kind of medical professional. I have been a patient several times at hospitals and required these kinds of IV's several times in the past.

You should try getting out into the world someday, or at least try to learn something before making a fool of yourself online. Good luck.

Ranb

Don't go away and we will see who is the idiot.
For now, let me refer you to my previous post (to Floyt).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom