[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted by jaydeehess
Once again illustrating that what malcolm dearly wants is an opressive dictatorship and do do away with the rule of law.

Shall I list the people in charge of such systems past and present , malcolm?

Feel free, you will of course, be starting with George W Bush.


Ok, do you feel warm and satisfied sharing the desire for such oppression with the likes of GWB(though it is still quite a stretch to include him), Idi Amin, Pol Pot, Stalin, or Mugawbe, just to list a few?

Are these the people you wish to emulate malcolm?
 
The innocents in this matter are the office workers who were allowed to go to work that morning, allowed to go to their deaths, inside a waiting to explode, giant bomb.

Appeal to emotion. You still have no evidence that 175 did NOT hit the tower. The airlines has a missing plane, we (and many more, some live) saw the airplane crash into the towers, and we have debris from 175.

The burden's on you. So far, zilch.

Then there are the firemen and police who were also allowed to go to their deaths in guaranteed to fail rescue attempts.

Only in retrospect. No one knew the tower would collapse until it was too late.

The guilty are megalomaniacs on steroids such as Rumsfeld who predicted the attack on the twins before it happened and then predicted the attack on the Pentagon moments before that happened.

And you who apparently have predicted what happened in his head.

He even, the day before 9/11, clearly knowing what was coming off, announced that the Pentagon had lost $2.3 trillion.

They didn't "lose" it. This has been pointed out so many times, I can't possibly understand how you could not know this.

People keep asking me for references. Prove this, prove that.

Yes, if you take your "evidence" to court you might want to get used to that.

At the moment, you have the luxury of constant denial without facing accusations of being an accessory after the fact.

And you have the luxury of not being sued for saying that.

As a denier, do the following 250 facts raise any doubts whatsoever in your mind?

You tell us. You're the denier.
 
Are you totally discounting, simply brushing off, the evidence of two Pentagon police officers?

I'm not interested in your one-liner responses. Please adress my points:

I told you before, Malcolm. We're familiar with this. Lyte Trip asked a few leading questions to people years after a traumatic event. You'd think that a few of them might get the exact heading wrong.

Besides, eyewitness reports aren't particularily reliable, and they're trumped not only by a larger number of witnesses, but by PHYSICAL evidence that the plane crashed into the building.

How does that relate to my post ? Did you even read the posts I was responding to ?

Why do you think civilian planes are so weak ? You DO know that the wings have to carry the entire craft, don't you ?

Stop using common sense; you might eventually start to believe that the Earth is flat.

Yes, there is, and the difference is that you believe in one and not the other.

Why the hell would he ?


Kindly consider this photo, do you see material going UP.
If so, can you kindly explain to me how material goes UP, without being BLOWN UP ?

Malcolm, you might want to consider researching this stuff before simply asking a question out of credulity. The answer is so easy to find that just asking it in the condescending tone you're known for doesn't make you look good at all.
 
Ok, do you feel warm and satisfied sharing the desire for such oppression with the likes of GWB(though it is still quite a stretch to include him), Idi Amin, Pol Pot, Stalin, or Mugawbe, just to list a few?

Are these the people you wish to emulate malcolm?
All promoted and funded by the same people who are pulling GWB's strings.
 
Now you agree (in part), perhaps you can point out the 163 or so ft scar along the face of the Pentagon?

Well, see...like I said, the Physics are hellish in those first few seconds of the impact. from here:

http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/build03/PDF/b03017.pdf

Page 23 of the pdf, It discusses the issue, actually talking about your question of the damage to the facade of the building.

"The Width of severe damage to the West facade of the building was approximatly 120 ft. (From columns 8 through 20)."

"An examination of the area encompassed by extending the line of travel of the aircraft to the face of the building shows that there are no discrete marks on the building corresponding to the outer third of the right wing"

They conjecture that part of the right wing impacted at the 2nd floor slab, which, of course, would be substantially stronger then the rest of the facade struck.

"In any event, the evidence suggests that the tips of both wings DID NOT (my emphasis) make direct contact with the facade of the building and that portions of the wings might have been separated from the fuselage before the aircraft struc the building. This is consistant with eyewitness statements that the right wing struck a large generator before the aircraft struck the building and that the left wing struck a ground-level, external vent structure."

(hope that's not too much to get it modded out...it seems the important part of the few paragraphs).

In conclusion, Nope. you're not going to get pictures of 160' long marks on the building, since the damage was less then that. The researchers were just as curious about that as you were, and upon investigating, discovered just why there wasn't the width of the damage marks on the building.

hope that answers it for you.
 
You contradict yourself. You have just agreed that the planes will be given power to spare and then some.
It now follows that the internal space available within the plane dictates the number of troops to carry. The weight of those troops is not relevant, neither is the weight of the plane. Ergo, no reason not to reinforce and every reason so to do.
Didn't see this till today. Oh well. You should really so some research before you post. There are no aircraft that are only troop carriers. They also carry things like tanks, helicopters, supplies, etc. So they are built to carry loads considerably heavier than troops. So google C-5, C-17, C-141 and C-130. Guess what you won't find. Armor. Transport helicopters are the same way. Go the the next military air show and walk through the ones they have on display and you will see. Ask them about your so-called bad boys and report back what their answer is.
 
Corsair said:
Weight is an even more critical factor for aircraft than for ships.

We will have to agree to differ on this.

It's like talking to a brick wall.

Malcolm, Corsair brought up some very important points concerning craft armour. How can you "agree to differ" when he's correct ?

Do any of the 250 points raise any questions in your mind or not ?

So far, nothing that warrants the expenditure of so many ressources in order to fund a new, "independent" investigation. No serious suspicion comes up.

Myriad said:
Wisdom (unlike intelligence quotient) is neither defined nor measured by tests.

Nor are the tests for measuring intelligence particularily reliable, I might ad
d.
 
You say a video might suffice. Here's a couple,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m-n3XOb3uAQ&mode=related&search=
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xq1gpC7QqeM&mode=related&search=
There's plenty more where where these came from.

You dug up the videos, but forgot to take a look at them and answer Myriad's question:

"Can materials move against the pull of gravity without having been propelled by explosions, and if so, what are some of the mechanisms that can cause it to happen?"
 
Would you also kindly confirm the following two facts,
Here in this photo, you can clearly see the outline of the wings where they have cut through steel. All the posters on here have spent much time insisting that aluminium wings can go through most anything when travelling at 500mph.
Now show me the scar caused by the wings across the face of the Pentagon in the seventh photo on this webpage.

You might be aware of what happened when the plane crashed into the Pentagon.

Of course you are. No honest researcher wouldn't. Silly question. Sorry.
 
If you want to liken your heart and your mind to stony ground, I won't dispute you, but I think you're being unnecessarily hard on yourself. The entire world was once stony ground, and no one is born wise. The fertile soil that nourishes civilized thought does not appear overnight. Give it some time.

In any case, I'm not speaking to you alone. You know only a tiny fraction of the ground my words are falling upon.




Yes, they are innocents. But they are not "the innocents" to the exclusion of everyone else. That is a false choice fallacy. Their innocence doesn't make everyone else guilty.

Whenever someone makes false accusations (even if they believe them to be true), they create new innocent victims and they aid the real perpetrators and their cause.

That's one reason why older wiser people are very cautious making accusations. They know the terrible harm done by false accusations and they do not want such painful consequences to be inflicted on innocent people. This is known as compassion. They also don't want to live with having been responsible for such harm. This is known as conscience. People sometimes develop these characteristics (as with other aspects of wisdom) with age and experience.




I'm not asking you to prove anyone. I'm just reminding you that if you fail to prove it, you do not, and should not, get your wish for retribution.




This list has not convinced older, wiser people of your case. Possibly because some of the items on the list directly contradict people's own personal experience, so they know they're false.

So what, you say? That can only be the case for a few items on the list, leaving plenty of smoking guns remaining?

No. A responsible prosecutor does not get to lie about ANY of the evidence. Making mistakes is inevitable and excusable, but making no effort to correct mistakes is fatal to credibility. Prosecutor caught lying = case dismissed. Truthers lose all credibility when, like the metaphorical monkey with its hand caught in the jar of nuts, they will not let go of any accusation no matter how worthless.




I agree that my loyalty should be (and is) to the Constitution, first and foremost. Funny you should point this out though, considering your subsequent statements.




Yes, this privilege is known as my Constitutional right to free speech. I treasure it highly.




Thank you for warning me that evil people are planning to attempt to revoke my right to free speech. Can you be more specific about who these reprehensible Constitution-hating thugs might be?




Please be more specific regarding the danger you believe he's in. Who is plotting to take away his right to be uncertain about what happened on 9/11? The U.S. government? Or perhaps the same evil bullying wannabe-thought-police who are plotting "moves afoot" to take away my right to free speech?




I cannot answer any question "as a denier" because I do not regard myself as any sort of denier. I accept whatever conclusions the evidence leads to.

Respectfully,
Myriad
I quote,
"Whenever someone makes false accusations (even if they believe them to be true), they create new innocent victims and they aid the real perpetrators and their cause."
Do you mean like blaming moslems for the inside job that was 9/11 ?
 
Please, before further discussion of the collapse videos, I need you to address this point:

At the moment, you have the luxury of constant denial without facing accusations of being an accessory after the fact. You should know that there are moves afoot to alter that state of affairs. This clean up won't necessarily begin at the top. It can equally begin at the bottom.
Only recently a newspaper reporter said to me,
"Does anyone really know what happened on 9/11"? He said it in a bored manner. I couldn't be bothered to tell him, that he was skating on thin ice.
What's it matter to me, whether or not his ice breaks.


It sounds very much like you have knowledge of plans ("moves afoot") to coerce or silence news reporters as well as Internet correspondents like myself (whom you were addressing in the post). Now, you might be talking about completely legal measures like a lawsuit or a publicity campaign, which I have no objection to in principle (though if the target of a frivolous suit or of libel, I would of course defend myself with all legal means available). However, it seems equally likely, from what you said (especially the part about starting from the bottom), that the plans might instead involve coercion by intimidation and/or violent means.

Therefore, I must request that you explain more specifically what you were talking about in the quote above. In this era of truck bombs, anthrax by mail, and school shootings, ignoring possible veiled threats is not an option for a responsible citizen. If you won't explain what you meant, I can't rule out a significant possiblity that you were talking about violent measures being planned on a large scale, which would give me the responsibility to bring the matter to the attention of the appropriate authorities.

You say a video might suffice. Here's a couple,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m-n3XOb3uAQ&mode=related&search=
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xq1gpC7QqeM&mode=related&search=
There's plenty more where where these came from.


It's a good thing there are plenty more, because those two are useless. Motion of objects in these videos cannot be evaluated, even casually by eye, because the images frequently intercut between different viewpoints, zoom in and out (making it impossible to compensate visually for camera tracking as it follows the collapse downward and for the effects of the zooming on apparent motion), and freeze the action to draw speculative claims on the screen.

In watching unedited video of the collapse, I've seen nothing moving upward except for smoke and billowing dust, the latter moving in all directions including upward due to the turbulence of the air around the collapse. However, it a violent chaotic collapse, it would not be surprising if some pieces of debris were in fact thrown upward. (Just as if you drop a glass on the floor -- nothing but gravity, note -- pieces scatter outward and sometimes a few pieces are launched upward.)

Note also that debris (other than, again, billowing dust after the collapse is well underway) does not blast upward in controlled demolitions either, at least not in the many I've watched video of, so if there were upward-moving debris in the tower collapses it would not be evidence of demolition explosions.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
All promoted and funded by the same people who are pulling GWB's strings.

I asked you if you wish to emmulate their actions malcolm and you refuse to answer the question.

I assume, from what you have posted, that such extra-judicial punishments are OK by you as long as it is you, or someone you trust, who is doing it. In that way, once again you emulate most of the people on my short list above. (actually all of them since that is the reason they all gave for their actions)

So malcolm, do you or do you not like the company you emmulate in calling for extra-judicial punishment(up to and including Capital punishment)?
The question has nothing at all to do with who you think was instructing those other people. It has to do with your own beliefs!
 
Well, see...like I said, the Physics are hellish in those first few seconds of the impact. from here:

http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/build03/PDF/b03017.pdf

Page 23 of the pdf, It discusses the issue, actually talking about your question of the damage to the facade of the building.

"The Width of severe damage to the West facade of the building was approximatly 120 ft. (From columns 8 through 20)."

"An examination of the area encompassed by extending the line of travel of the aircraft to the face of the building shows that there are no discrete marks on the building corresponding to the outer third of the right wing"

They conjecture that part of the right wing impacted at the 2nd floor slab, which, of course, would be substantially stronger then the rest of the facade struck.

"In any event, the evidence suggests that the tips of both wings DID NOT (my emphasis) make direct contact with the facade of the building and that portions of the wings might have been separated from the fuselage before the aircraft struc the building. This is consistant with eyewitness statements that the right wing struck a large generator before the aircraft struck the building and that the left wing struck a ground-level, external vent structure."

(hope that's not too much to get it modded out...it seems the important part of the few paragraphs).

In conclusion, Nope. you're not going to get pictures of 160' long marks on the building, since the damage was less then that. The researchers were just as curious about that as you were, and upon investigating, discovered just why there wasn't the width of the damage marks on the building.

hope that answers it for you.
Here's a couple of photos, where is your 120 ft scar ?

car911.JPG

car-whitep.JPG
 
You dug up the videos, but forgot to take a look at them and answer Myriad's question:

"Can materials move against the pull of gravity without having been propelled by explosions, and if so, what are some of the mechanisms that can cause it to happen?"

Do you see material being blown up ?
 
Appeal to emotion. You still have no evidence that 175 did NOT hit the tower. The airlines has a missing plane, we (and many more, some live) saw the airplane crash into the towers, and we have debris from 175.

The burden's on you. So far, zilch.



Only in retrospect. No one knew the tower would collapse until it was too late.



And you who apparently have predicted what happened in his head.



They didn't "lose" it. This has been pointed out so many times, I can't possibly understand how you could not know this.



Yes, if you take your "evidence" to court you might want to get used to that.



And you have the luxury of not being sued for saying that.



You tell us. You're the denier.
You call a description of the murder of over three thousand people "an appeal to emotion".
Do you or do you not accept the evidence of two Pentagon police officers ?
 
Didn't see this till today. Oh well. You should really so some research before you post. There are no aircraft that are only troop carriers. They also carry things like tanks, helicopters, supplies, etc. So they are built to carry loads considerably heavier than troops. So google C-5, C-17, C-141 and C-130. Guess what you won't find. Armor. Transport helicopters are the same way. Go the the next military air show and walk through the ones they have on display and you will see. Ask them about your so-called bad boys and report back what their answer is.

I refer you to my previous posts on the matter.
 
You dug up the videos, but forgot to take a look at them and answer Myriad's question:

"Can materials move against the pull of gravity without having been propelled by explosions, and if so, what are some of the mechanisms that can cause it to happen?"
Have you any questions of your own ?
I'm sure Myriad can fight his own corner.
 
Does it now follow, that you yourself have done your own research and concluded that the govt version is correct?

How do I know that UA175 crashed into the south tower of the WTC? My brother-in-law told me. He was a fire fighter with the FDNY. He was there. There's my proof, no Internet required.
 
Malcolm said:
"Whenever someone makes false accusations (even if they believe them to be true), they create new innocent victims and they aid the real perpetrators and their cause."
Do you mean like blaming moslems for the inside job that was 9/11 ?

This is the quintessential example of trolling, Malcolm. You know very well what he meant. And it works both ways, and it's true whether or not your "theory" is correct.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom